--Quarterly per-share earnings falls far short of analyst
expectations
--Company suspends guidance on lower earnings expectations and
arrival of CEO
--No further details of turnaround until new CEO gets up to
speed
(Adds executive comments from conference call, further
details.)
By Joan E. Solsman
Best Buy Co. (BBY) suspended its earnings guidance following a
91% quarterly profit decline Tuesday, providing investors with
scant details about how it and a newly appointed chief executive
will revive the struggling consumer-electronics chain.
The big-box retailer continued to lose sales in key categories
like televisions and notebook computers in the latest period, and
it battled weaker margins than it anticipated because of promotions
and unfavorable changes in its sales mix.
But executives kept mum on further turnaround plans, saying the
company needed to give incoming Chief Executive Hubert Joly time to
digest Best Buy's business and flexibility to make his own
decisions.
The worse-than-expected results sent Best Buy shares down to
nine-year lows at the open, but the stock has since recovered to
$17.97, a 1% decline, in recent trade. The slide follows a 10%
selloff Monday after the naming of Joly as CEO and the continued
blocking of a proposed buyout by its founder and biggest
shareholder.
The choice of Joly baffled some company watchers. A hospitality
executive with experience stabilizing troubled companies, Joly
nevertheless has a resume light on retailing and fending off the
kind online pressures that have increasingly made Best Buy's
big-box model seem obsolete.
Mike Mikan, a Best Buy director who has served as interim chief
since April, said on a conference call Tuesday that Best Buy has
done "a good deal of advance work" on initiatives like expanding
digital services, reducing costs and cutting square footage in
recent months.
The company will share its findings with Joly when he comes on
board next month, but "it would not be fair to him to discuss the
details today," Mikan said.
However, founder and largest shareholder Richard Schulze has
argued the company has no time to waste protecting shareholder
value as he presses for a privatization of Best Buy.
Talks between Mr. Schulze and the company's board stalled this
weekend over the terms of allowing Mr. Schulze access to the
company's books before stepping up his pursuit, leaving their feud
unsettled. Mr. Mikan said Tuesday that Best Buy's proposal still
stands and "it's up to Dick to respond from there."
Granting Joly breathing room was a key factor in Best Buy
suspending both its earnings guidance and share buybacks for the
year, executives said. Best Buy also blamed the suspended view on
lowered expectations for industrywide sales and uncertainty
surrounding several key product launches.
The company doesn't expect the second-quarter trends to extend
into the second half in the same way, executives said, noting that
many of the headwinds weren't unique to Best Buy. Competitors like
HHGregg Inc. (HGG) and RadioShack Corp. (RSH) also have reported
weak product trends recently.
They also touted that Best Buy preserved market share and that
sales at stores, call centers and websites operating for at least
14 months improved sequentially.
Yet same-store sales still fell 3.2% in the latest period. It is
the eighth time in the last nine quarters Best Buy's comparable
sales have dropped.
In the U.S., same-store sales fell 1.6%. Its key consumer
electronics sales kept dwindling, with the latest 9.6% domestic
drop the biggest in more than a year. Its biggest category,
computing and mobile phones, continued steady same-store sales
growth thanks to strength in tablet and mobile phone sales, but the
low-margin profile of smartphones worked against the company's
profitability.
Best Buy was the latest retailer to report international
weakness with an 8.2% drop in same-store sales abroad. It
attributed the decline mostly to China, which is marked by lower
consumer spending, weakness in housing and the absence of
government-sponsored rebate programs for appliances and other
products.
Compounding the sales weakness, gross margin narrowed more than
the company anticipated to 24.3% from 25.4%. Best Buy ramped up
promotions on notebooks as sales volume dropped, presumably ahead
of a new Windows system launching later this year. That helped
revenue and inventory position but hurt margin. A greater mix of
small and mid-size televisions and high-price-point smartphones
further weighed on profitability.
Best Buy has long struggled to keep up with changes in consumer
electronics as the weight of its big-box format inhibits it from
fending off the competitive pressure of online retailers like
Amazon.com Inc. (AMZN). The company has become a particularly acute
example of a phenomenon known as "showrooming," where
bargain-hunting shoppers browse stores then buy the products
cheaper online.
For the quarter ended Aug. 4, Best Buy reported a profit of $12
million, or four cents a share, down from $128 million, or 34 cents
a share, a year earlier. The latest results include a $91 million
restructuring charge, primarily related to store-closure costs.
Stripping out one-time items, the company's per-share profit was 20
cents versus 39 cents a year ago. Revenue fell 2.8% to $10.55
billion.
Analysts polled by Thomson Reuters expected earnings of 31 cents
a share on $10.63 billion in revenue.
--Saabira Chaudhuri contributed to this article.
Write to Joan E. Solsman at joan.solsman@dowjones.com
Subscribe to WSJ: http://online.wsj.com?mod=djnwires