Banks' Retreat On Overdraft Fees Won't Stave Off Legislation
September 23 2009 - 3:04PM
Dow Jones News
The bank industry's signs of retreat on account fees may not
satisfy Washington lawmakers, some of whom say they're pushing
ahead with broad restrictions on fee policies at banks.
Bank of America Corp. (BAC) and JPMorgan Chase & Co. (JPM),
the two largest U.S. by assets, said this week they are reducing
overdraft fees. Some regional banks, including Toronto-Dominion
Bank (TD), PNC Financial Services Group Inc. (PNC) and Fifth Third
Bancorp (FITB), are also planning to change some of the ways they
charge fees.
House Financial Services Committee Chairman Barney Frank
(D-Mass.) said in an interview that he supports the moves by Bank
of America and JPMorgan Chase. But Frank said he will still push
forward with legislation requiring changes in overdraft policies at
banks. The Federal Reserve is also considering strict curbs on
overdraft fees that could be finalized later this year.
The policy change by the two giant banks "confirms that it's
doable," Frank said. "No one else will be able to argue that it's
too burdensome."
A spokeswoman from Senate Banking Committee Chairman Christopher
Dodd's office (D-Conn.) said the senator is still moving forward
with legislation.
Rolling back fees poses a high-stakes dilemma for banks.
The industry earned $39.5 billion from service charges on
deposits last year, according to data from the Federal Deposit
Insurance Corp. Fees for everything from ATM usage to balance
transfers accounted for about 25% of the industry's total revenue,
and are welcome as banks wrestle with losses from the the
nationwide housing depression and severe U.S. recession.
But critics say levying heavy fees to customers is unfair, since
the U.S. government recently allocated more than $700 billion to
support troubled American lenders. Consumer advocates have paraded
examples of consumers who have paid $40 for a cup of coffee because
they unwittingly ran a negative balance in their checking
account.
"A couple of financial institutions taking voluntary steps,"
said Eric Halperin, director of the Center for Responsible Lending,
"doesn't end the need for legislation."
Bank of America and JPMorgan Chase said this week they would
place lower limits on the number of overdraft fees they charge
customers each day. The banks also plan other changes.
Bank of America accelerated and strengthened changes it had been
considering earlier in the year, according to a person familiar
with the situation.
JPMorgan also said it will rescind its policy of re-ordering
customers' debit-card and ATM transactions at the day's end.
Some banks maximize penalties by processing the largest purchase
a customer makes first, draining accounts faster and creating the
potential for multiple fees on smaller purchases. JPMorgan said
it's ending this practice for most transactions.
Later this fall, TD Bank, a unit of Toronto-Dominion Bank, will
also stop this practice, and will instead post most account
transactions chronologically.
"That's much more predictable, fair and transparent," said
Matthew Chevalier, TD Bank's senior vice president of day-to-day
product management.
"We're going to maintain the momentum of the bank through
continued customer retention and staisfaction," Chevalier said. "I
don't have any plans to introduce new fees."
Mike Moebs, founder of Moebs Services Inc., which collects fee
data from nearly every U.S. bank, says banks can actually grow
customer ranks and revenues by lowering fees.
In October, Pittsburgh-based PNC, the fifth-largest U.S. bank by
assets, will lower each customer's first incurred overdraft fee
from $31 to $25 and will also do away with a $15 fee for enrolling
in an overdraft protection product, PNC spokesman Frederick Solomon
said.
Cincinatti-based Fifth Third said Wednesday it's looking at ways
to eliminate what it calls punitive account fees triggered by
certain customer actions. The bank has instead worked to develop
products that charge up-front fees.
But the big regional bank said it won't change its policies
regarding overdraft fees until Congress and bank regulators decide
how to hand down a fresh round of laws and restrictions.
"I think we're going to take more of the wait-and-see approach,"
said Mark Erhardt, Fifth Third's senior vice president for retail
products. Any changes will require the bank to modify its computer
systems, he said.
A spokeswoman for Citigroup Inc. (C) said the announced changes
at Bank of America and Chase bring those banks' policies in line
with Citi's, although Citi still re-orders transactions at the end
of the day.
-By Marshall Eckblad, Dow Jones Newswires; 212-416-2156;
marshall.eckblad@dowjones.com
(Dan Fitzpatrick and Jane J. Kim in New York contributed to this
article.)