CONTENTS
3
Fact Sheet
4
Summary
7
Highlights
9
Chairman's Statement
11
Asset Manager's Report
24
Directors
25
Directors' Report
35
Report of the Audit Committee
38
Statement of Principal Risks and
Uncertainties
41
Statement of Directors'
Responsibilities
43
Independent Auditor's Report to the Members of DP
Aircraft I Limited
49
Consolidated Statement of Comprehensive
Income
50
Consolidated Statement of Financial
Position
51
Consolidated Statement of Cash Flows
52
Consolidated Statement of Changes in
Equity
53
Notes to the Consolidated Financial
Statements
79
Company Information
81
Appendix 1 - Alternative Investment Fund Managers
Directive
FACT SHEET
Ticker
|
DPA
|
Company Number
|
56941
|
ISIN Number
|
GG00BBP6HP33
|
SEDOL Number
|
BBP6HP3
|
Traded
|
Specialist Fund Segment ('SFS') of
the London Stock Exchange
|
SFS Admission Date
|
4-Oct-13
|
Share Price
|
US$ 0.0625 as at 31 December
2023
|
Loss per
Share
|
US$ 0.01047 for the year ended 31
December 2023
|
Country of Incorporation
|
Guernsey
|
Current Ordinary Shares in Issue
|
239,333,333
|
Administrator and Company Secretary
|
Aztec Financial Services
(Guernsey) Limited
|
Asset Manager
|
DS Aviation GmbH & Co.
KG
|
Independent Auditor
|
KPMG Channel Islands
Limited
|
Corporate Broker
|
Investec Bank Plc
|
Aircraft Registration
|
HS-TQD
|
|
HS-TQC
|
Aircraft Serial Number
|
35320
|
|
36110
|
Aircraft Type and Model
|
B787-8
|
Lessees
|
Thai Airways International Public
Company Limited
('Thai Airways')
|
Website
|
www.dpaircraft.com
|
SUMMARY
COMPANY OVERVIEW
DP Aircraft I Limited (the
'Company') was incorporated with limited liability in Guernsey
under the Companies (Guernsey) Law, 2008 on 5 July 2013 with
registered number 56941.
The Company was established to
invest in aircraft. The Company is a holding company, and made its
investment in aircraft held through two wholly owned subsidiary
entities, DP Aircraft Guernsey III Limited and DP Aircraft Guernsey
IV Limited (collectively and hereinafter, the 'Borrowers'), each
being a Guernsey incorporated company limited by shares and one
intermediate lessor company, DP Aircraft UK Limited (the 'Lessor'),
a UK incorporated private limited company. The Company and its
consolidated subsidiaries, DP Aircraft Guernsey III Limited, DP
Aircraft Guernsey IV Limited and DP Aircraft UK Limited comprise
the consolidated Group (the 'Group').
Pursuant to the Company's
Prospectus dated 27 September 2013, the Company offered 113,000,000
ordinary shares of no par value in the capital of the Company at an
issue price of US$ 1.00 per share by means of a Placing. The
Company's shares were admitted to trading on the Specialist Fund
Segment (previously the Specialist Fund Market) of the London Stock
Exchange on 4 October 2013 and the Company was listed on the
Channel Islands Securities Exchange until 27 May 2015.
On 5 June 2015, the Company
offered 96,333,333 ordinary shares (the 'New Shares') of no-par
value in the capital of the Company at an issue price of US$ 1.0589
per share by means of a Placing. The Company's New Shares were
admitted to trading on the Specialist Fund Segment of the London
Stock Exchange on 12 June 2015.
On 13 July 2022 the Company raised
gross proceeds of $750,000 through the issue of 30,000,000 new
ordinary shares in the capital of the Company at a price of
US$0.025 per new ordinary share. The new ordinary shares were
admitted to trading on the Specialist Fund Segment of the London
Stock Exchange on 15 July 2022.
In total there are 239,333,333
Ordinary Shares in issue with voting rights.
In addition to the equity raised
above in 2013, 2015 and 2022, the Group also utilised external debt
to fund the initial acquisition of the aircraft. Further details
are given within this summary section.
INVESTMENT OBJECTIVE & POLICY
The Company and Group's investment
objective is to obtain income and capital returns for its
shareholders by acquiring, leasing and then, when the Board
considers it appropriate, selling aircraft (the 'Asset' or
'Assets').
THE BOARD
The Board comprises of independent
non- executive Directors (the 'Directors' or the 'Board'). The
Directors are responsible for managing the business affairs of the
Company and Group in accordance with the Articles of Incorporation
and have overall responsibility for the Company's and Group's
activities, including portfolio and risk management while the asset
management of the Group is undertaken by DS Aviation GmbH & Co.
KG (the 'Asset Manager'/ 'DS Aviation').
THE ASSET MANAGER
The Asset Manager has undertaken
to provide the asset management services to the Company and Group
under the terms of an asset management agreement but does not
undertake any regulated activities for the purpose of the UK
Financial Services and Markets Act 2000.
SUMMARY (CONTINUED)
ENVIRONMENTAL, SOCIAL AND GOVERNANCE (ESG)
The Group recognises the Paris
Agreement on climate change. The Group operates NTA ('New
Technology Aircraft'); specifically Boeing 787-8's equipped with
Rolls Royce Trent-1000 engines which are 20% more fuel efficient on
a revenue-per-kilometre basis than similar comparable legacy
aircraft. The Board has taken steps to reduce its own
travelling and maximises the use of virtual meetings within the
Board and with all its key service providers.
CORONAVIRUS ('COVID-19')
COVID-19 had a significant impact
on the airline sector, and by extension the aircraft leasing
sector. More information is provided below and in the Asset
Manager's Report.
THAI AIRWAYS INTERNATIONAL PCL ('THAI AIRWAYS' /
'THAI')
The suspension of travel due to
COVID-19 in 2020 resulted in Thai Airways entering into business
rehabilitation. The Central Bankruptcy Court approved Thai's
Business Rehabilitation plan on 15 June 2021. The rehabilitation
process is currently ongoing, please refer to the Asset Manager
Report on pages 11 to 23 for more details regarding the
rehabilitation process.
The Group signed a Letter of
Intent ('LOI') dated 1 March 2021 with Thai Airways under which the
parties agreed to amend the lease terms that existed then. The
actual lease agreement reflecting the terms set out in the LOI was
signed on 1 April 2022. The effective date for the lease
modification was 15 June 2021.
The new lease terms provided for a
power by the hour ('PBH') arrangement until 31 December 2022 (with
rent payable by reference to actual monthly utilisation of the Thai
aircraft and engines), with scaled back monthly fixed lease
payments thereafter until October 2026 for aircraft MSN 36110 and
December 2026 for aircraft MSN 35320 reflecting reduced market
rates in the long-haul market. The lease term can be extended for a
further 3 years to October and December 2029 respectively, with
further scaled back monthly lease payments starting from November
2026 and January 2027. The Extension Period is however subject to
agreement with the Group after consulting the Lenders. Given the
uncertainty around the lease extension, the lease terms are
considered to be the period up to October and December
2026.
A corresponding agreement was
reached with the lenders as detailed below.
DEKABANK DEUTSCHE GIROZENTRALE AND TWO OTHER CONSORTIUM
MEMBERS ('DekaBank')
On 6 May 2021, subsequent to the
LOI being entered into by the Group and Thai as described above,
the Group and DekaBank amended and restated the existing loan
facility agreements in respect of the Thai aircraft to accommodate
the new lease terms, First Amendment and Restatement to the Loan
Agreements. Repayments of principal were deferred until after the
end of the PBH arrangement (31 December 2022), and a new repayment
schedule was to be renegotiated close to the end of the PBH
arrangement.
On 7 February 2023, the Group and
DekaBank entered into a Second Amendment and Restatement to the
Loan Agreement in which the parties agreed on the following main
terms:
·
the total loan amount outstanding was split into
two tranches:
o Facility A loan of US$ 61,144,842 made up of MSN 35320 loan
of US$ 31,099,453 and MSN 36110 loan of
US$ 30,045,389. The Facility A loan amortizes to a combined balloon
of US$ 33,947,878 and represents the scheduled debt.
SUMMARY (CONTINUED)
DEKABANK DEUTSCHE GIROZENTRALE AND THREE OTHER CONSORTIUM
MEMBERS ('DekaBank') (CONTINUED)
o Facility B loan of US$ 35,504,024 (non-amortizing), made up
of MSN 35320 loan of US$ 17,366,650 and
MSN 36110 loan of US$ 18,137,374. The Facility B loan will be
settled as a balloon payment at the end of the loan term in
2026.
·
USD 2.36m of surplus cash generated under the PBH
period was used to immediately repay debt on the amortizing
Facility A loan in February 2023, while an agreed cash reserve of
US$ 500,000 per aircraft will be retained to cover unforeseen costs
going forward.
·
the interest rate swap in place for the scheduled
debt was dissolved at no net gain or loss.
·
the MSN 35320 and MSN 36110 Facility A loans bear
fixed interest rates of 6.61% and 6.89% respectively.
·
the MSN 35320 and MSN 36110 Facility B loans bear
fixed interest rates of 5.26% and 5.42% respectively.
·
from the monthly fixed lease rental of US$
510,000 per aircraft (which denotes the maximum amount the Company
can earn in operations per month), US$ 475,000 is legally
restricted so that those funds are only payable to the lenders, and
US$ 35,000 per aircraft can be retained by the company to
contribute towards ongoing fixed costs of the Company.
Due to the limited liquidity
position of the Group, restructuring fees associated with the
second amendment and restatement will be paid after the eventual
remarketing of the aircraft, subject to surplus sales proceeds
being realised.
IMPAIRMENT
In line with each reporting date
and market capitalisation of US$ 15 million at 31 December 2023, a
detailed impairment assessment of the aircraft was undertaken.
Following this review an impairment of US$ nil (2022: US$ nil) was
booked against the aircraft. See note 3 for further details
regarding the impairment and comments under Highlights on page 7
regarding the difference between net asset value and market
capitalisation.
DISTRIBUTION POLICY
Under normal circumstances, the
Group aimed to provide shareholders with an attractive total return
comprising income, from distributions through the period of the
Company's ownership of the Assets, and capital, upon any sale of
the Assets. The Company originally targeted a quarterly
distribution in February, May, August, and November of each year.
The target distribution was US$ 0.0225 per share per quarter. The
dividends were targets only with no assurance or guarantee of
performance or profit forecast.
Due to the impact of COVID-19 on
the aviation industry and therefore our lessor, the Board suspended
the payment of dividends from 3 April 2020 until further notice.
This suspension remains in place to date. Any lease rental
payments received by the Company in respect of the Thai aircraft
are expected to be applied exclusively towards the running costs of
the Company and its subsidiaries, and as a priority towards
interest and principal repayments to the DekaBank. Given this
backdrop the Company feels that there is no realistic prospect of
the Company's shareholders receiving a dividend or other
distribution during the remaining lease period. The Board and its
advisers will continue to consult with shareholders and its
advisors in the future with a view to determining the best course
of action to take for the future of the Company.
HIGHLIGHTS
RESULTS FOR THE YEAR
Results for the year ended 31
December 2023 is a loss after tax of US$ 2,505,687 (loss per share
US$ 0.01). For the year ended 31 December 2022 there was a profit
after tax of US$ 7,660,823 (profit per share US$ 0.03).
The results for the year ended 31
December 2023 are mainly driven by rental income earned of US$
8,714,249 (2022: US$ 16,462,372) and finance costs incurred of US$
9,551,675 (2022: US$ 4,860,305). The increase of finance costs is a
result of an adjustment required by IFRS to reflect the
modification to the loan terms in February 2023. The adjustment for
the modification to the loans in February 2023 totalled US$
5,042,029 and increased both finance costs and the loans payable at
the point of modification and resulted in an overall loss for the
period. This adjustment essentially recognises a loss now due to
the less favourable terms (primarily interest rate increases) under
the modified terms compared to the original terms. As a result of
this adjustment, interest will be recognised at the lower original
effective interest rate as opposed to the higher modified interest
rate going forward. The decrease in rent was due to the variable
rent earned for the period ended 31 December 2022. For the period
to 31 December 2023, the entity only earned fixed rental
income.
Refer to page 48 for full details
of results for the period.
NET ASSET VALUE ('NAV')
The NAV for the reporting period
was US$ 0.17645 per share at 31 December 2023 (2022: US$ 0.18692).
NAV per share has decreased due to the loss made during the year
(see above). The NAV excluding the financial effects of the
straight-lining lease asset and the loan modification adjustment
was US$ 0.16018 per share at 31 December 2023 ( 2022: US$
0.13662).
The straight-lining lease asset
and the loan modification adjustment will reduce to nil over time.
The adjusted NAV and loan modification adjustment is therefore
presented to provide what the Directors consider to be a more
relevant assessment of the Group's net asset position.
|
As at 31 December
2023,
|
As at 31 December
2022
|
Note
|
US$
|
US$ per
share
|
US$
|
US$ per
share
|
NAV per the financial statements
|
42,230,434
|
0.17645
|
44,736,121
|
0.18692
|
Less: Straight-lining lease
asset
11
|
(10,038,709)
|
(0.04194)
|
(13,525,502)
|
(0.05651)
|
Add: Provision for straight lining
lease asset 11
|
1,103,254
|
0.00461
|
1,486,453
|
0.00621
|
Add: Loan modification
adjustment
6
|
5,042,029
|
0.02107
|
-
|
-
|
|
(3,893,426)
|
(0.01627)
|
(12,039,049)
|
(0.05030)
|
Adjusted NAV
|
38,337,008
|
0.16018
|
32,697,072
|
0.13662
|
As at 31 December 2023 the price
per share was US$ 0.0625 which is significantly lower than the NAV
per share above, excluding the straight-lining lease asset and the
loan modification adjustment. The reason for the difference is due
to the market price per share reflecting other factors such as
market sentiment that cannot be accounted for in a set of annual
financial statements. The main asset in the Group, the aircraft,
has been assessed for impairment (see note 9) - with no resulting
impairment for the period. Other significant assets comprise cash
and receivables whose values are considered to be reflective of
fair value due to their short-term nature. Therefore, the low share
price is not indicative of a need for further impairment to the
assets of the Group.
HIGHLIGHTS (CONTINUED)
DIVIDENDS
As previously outlined, as a
result of the Coronavirus pandemic on global aviation and
particularly on its lessees; the Group suspended dividends on 3
April 2020 until further notice to help preserve liquidity. Further
details on the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic can be found within
the Summary, the Asset Manager's Report, and the Directors' Report.
Furthermore, in accordance with the second amended loan agreement
with DekaBank, the Group will make no dividend payments while loan
deferrals remained outstanding under the amended loan
agreement.
OFFICIAL LISTING
The Company's shares were first
admitted to trading on the Specialist Fund Segment of the London
Stock Exchange on 4 October 2013.
CHAIRMAN'S STATEMENT
I am pleased to present
Shareholders with the Annual Report of the Group for the year ended
31 December 2023.
The loss per share for the period
was US$ 0.01047 compared to a profit per share of US$ 0.03429 for the same period last
year. The net asset value per share at the period end was US$
0.17645 compared to US$ 0.18692 at 31 December 2022.
For the last six months of the year
the Group made a profit of US$ 1.567m.
IFRS requires rental income to be
recognised on a straight-line basis over the remaining lease period
and consequently the accounting treatment has resulted in some
income being recognised earlier than would normally be the case. In
addition, IFRS requires a provision to be made against that lease
income which has been estimated based on recent credit reports on
Thai. Please refer to page 7 which explains the net impact of this
on the profit for the period and the NAV of US$ 0.17645 per
share.
There has been a continued
improvement in the global aviation market following the challenges
resulting from the effects of the Covid-19 (Covid) pandemic.
Recent sentiment on airline and related stocks
has been more optimistic. The Ukraine war
has not had as a significant impact on the industry as was
expected. With Covid restrictions in China being lifted there is
cause for some optimism in tourism numbers from that market going
forward.
It has been encouraging to see how
the airline and the Thai tourist economy has responded and
rebounded from the crippling effect of the Covid years. Thai has
regained profitability and anticipates exiting administration -
currently anticipated in Q4 2024. They have also projected a
potential listing return during 2025.
Both our aircraft, HS-TQC and
HS-TQD have mainly flown in the Asian region during the year. This
has also been true of the other four, Rolls Royce Trent 1000
powered 787-8 aircraft in the Thai fleet. Sector lengths flown
through the year have varied from just under two hours (Singapore
and KL) to approximately six hours (Japanese routes). Other larger
aircraft in the Thai fleet have also been serving Asian routes
which at present represent the largest passenger segment. Under the
terms of industry lease arrangements lessee's have the right to fly
the routes which serve their needs. Shorter sector lengths do not
reduce the airlines responsibility to maintain the aircraft nor in
our case to return the aircraft at the lease term end in full life
condition. Our asset manager is responsible for liaison with Thai
on all operational matters and to regularly inspect our
assets.
The vibrant uptick of the tourist
economy has led to the airline placing both near term orders for
seven larger wide bodied aircraft (both Boeing and Airbus) but also
for bigger order sizes in the medium term. This larger reported
order of 45 Boeing 787-9's is good news as a reinforcement of
Boeing as a core fleet constituent but it has opted for GE engines
rather than Rolls Royce which power the current six 787-8's in
their fleet (including both our aircraft). The positioning of the
smaller 787-8 within Thai's forward fleet plans is not conclusively
known and we, through our asset manager, will be seeking to clarify
greater detail in that regard.
Our aircraft are now operating on
fixed monthly lease payments with Thai until October/December 2026
respectively, reflecting the reduced lease rates negotiated
earlier. As previously noted, the lease term was extended by a
further 3 years to October/December 2029, with further scaled back
monthly lease payments starting from November 2026/January 2027,
and the Group retaining a right of early termination in
October/December 2026 after consultation with the
Lenders.
CHAIRMAN'S STATEMENT
(CONTINUED)
The current finance arrangements
with our Lenders expire at the end of 2026. In this respect the
Group can therefore (i) negotiate to extend the loans with the
existing Lenders, (ii) refinance the loans with new lenders or
(iii) sell the aircraft to an investor within a time frame until
the end of 2026. Any option has to be agreed with the current
Lending group and corresponding discussions will start in October
2024. By April 2025, the Group and Lenders
have to inform Thai whether or not they will execute the early
termination option under the lease. By October 2025 the Group has
to provide the Lenders with information on the steps it is taking
to refinance or to remarket the aircraft followed by a Term sheet
no later than August 2026. As an ongoing obligation, the
Group has to inform the Lenders in relation to any negotiations and
or consultation with Thai regarding any restructuring of the
Operating Lease Agreement.
Whilst there can be no absolute
certainty the preferred option for the Group is the sale of the
aircraft with a lease attached which reflects improved market terms
and conditions. The current leases require the
aircraft to be returned in full life
condition.
The Board and the Asset Manager
remain fully committed to extract the best value for shareholders
in this process and are focussed on actions to improve and preserve
the value of the assets. The forthcoming
months will allow us to consider and review the various options and
to recommend a preferred path. Necessarily this will need to
involve the proactive involvement of our lenders, advisors and our
valued lessee.
The Company believes the Boeing
787 remains an attractive asset and notes recent transactions in
the market though transparency around transaction values is not
currently available. Boeing 787 wide body
production is still behind historic levels and delayed deliveries for new aircraft are further strengthening
this demand.
The Board notes that whilst the
787 aircraft is now key to Thai, the Group's aircraft type are the
smaller 8 series and we note that all new wide bodied aircraft Thai
propose to add to their fleet are the larger 787-9 variant. The
priority of the Group will therefore be commencing discussions with
Thai on how our aircraft fit into the overall Thai fleet strategy
and to what extent existing arrangements can be enhanced for the
mutual benefit of both parties.
As previously noted, there is no
realistic prospect of the Company's shareholders receiving a
dividend or other distribution prior to the end of the lease term.
The key uncertainty remains the outlook for Thai, though the
position of Thai has improved considerably, the impact of inflation
on the travel industry and the knock on effect these factors may
have on aircraft values and lease rentals.
Notwithstanding there has been
some unavoidable cost increases and inflationary pressures, with
respect to ongoing working capital requirements, the Group has been
able to reduce the net cash burn because some service providers and
the directors have deferred some amounts due.
In order to ensure the Group has
sufficient funds to adequately finance the period over which the
Board would like to realise value for shareholders, should an
appropriate opportunity arise, a further fund raise up to $1
million will be required in Q3
2024.
The Board and its advisers will
continue consulting with investors on an ongoing basis. I am
especially grateful to the Board and our key service providers for
their continued significant support over the period and going
forward. Finally I would like to thank our Investors for their
continued support.
Jonathan Bridel
Chairman
25 April 2024
ASSET MANAGER'S REPORT
THE AIRLINE MARKET
Snapshot
"The airline industry has emerged
from the shadows of the pandemic, showing signs of robust recovery
and resilience" says Jeremy Bowen, CEO at Cirium.[1] Global passenger traffic is expected to outperform
pre-Covid levels in 2024 and airline revenues are expected to be
about 7% higher than in 2019.[2] However,
challenges such as rising inflation rates, geopolitical conflicts,
environmental pressure and supply chain issues will continue to
impact the aviation industry in 2024.
Source: IATA December 2023[3]
ASSET MANAGER'S REPORT (CONTINUED)
Source: IATA December 2023; April 2021[4]
Global
·
Current Situation
o All regions benefitted from increasing passenger demand and
the lifting of Covid-19 restrictions[5]
o Sluggish business travel recovery due to increasing cost
management and sustainability strategies but premium travel of
leisure passengers increased[6]
o Aircraft deliveries in 2023 lower than in 2019 due to supply
chain and manufacturer issues still unsolved[7]
o At the end of 2023, 13% of the global fleet was reported as
stored (including aircraft reserved for part-outs) compared to 19%
at the beginning of 2023[8]
·
Outlook
o 60 national elections to take place in 2024 with uncertain
outcome on the political direction[9]
o Unknown impact of increasing geopolitical tensions, acts of
war and warlike operations
o The cargo market might profit from disruption of seaborne
cargo and increasing volumes but is expected to remain
weak[10]
o Boeing predicts that over 42,000 new aircraft (with an
approximate value of USD 8 trillion) will be needed over the next
20 years - an increase of 3.5% compared to Boeing´s last year
outlook[11]
o DBRS Morningstar expects aircraft asset values and lease
rates to be strong in 2024[12]
o Uncertainty regarding costs of sustainability
strategies[13]
ASSET MANAGER'S REPORT (CONTINUED)
Asia
·
Current Situation
o
Recovery
lags
behind other regions such as Europe and
North America[14]
o
An increase of
131% in demand, measured in Revenue Passenger
Kilometers (RPK) and 106% in availability, measured in Available
Seat Kilometers (ASK) on full year international 2023
traffic[15]
o
Break-even load-factor expected for
2023[16]
·
Outlook
o Demand (ASK) expected to grow by over 13% in 2024 compared to
2023[17]
o
Recovery year 2024: passenger traffic expected to
outperform 2019-levels[18]
o AAPA´s (Association of Asia Pacific Airlines) Director
general Subhas Menon expects 2024 to be a successful year for Asian
airlines[19]
Outlook & Conclusion
The aviation industry has made
good progress to completely return globally to pre-Covid-19 levels,
despite ongoing-challenges such as high inflation, supply and
maintenance facility bottlenecks as well as the rising number of
geopolitical conflicts and wars. The current aircraft shortage
results mainly from the still reduced delivery rates and the
grounding of aircraft due to various reasons such as issues with
B737MAX aircraft and Pratt & Whitney GTF engines. This
situation might persist and lead to longer aircraft in service
lives and the reactivation of previously retired
aircraft.
The Asia Pacific market represents
about one third of global demand[20]
although not having completely recovered from the pandemic,
particularly suffering from weak international markets to and from
China. Other emerging markets, such as India, offer a huge
potential for growth. This in turn, might intensify competition as
new market entrants will try to benefit from such
momentum.
ASSET MANAGER'S REPORT (CONTINUED)
Considering the enormous number of
new aircraft orders in 2023 shows that airlines are confident in
the rising numbers of travellers and a positive trend of aviation
transport. Increasing premium travel of leisure passengers
indicates the importance of the freedom to travel after the
pandemic and the importance of holiday trips. The current
development emphasises the resilience of the aviation industry,
although this business sector will always remain fragile to
temporary downturns. One very important and significant challenge
for the aviation industry, not only from a financial perspective,
is to reduce its environmental impact and ultimately to reach zero
CO2 emissions.
Please note that all forecasts are
predicated on historical facts and educated projections. It ought
to be regarded as a potential rule of thumb.
THE LESSEE - THAI AIRWAYS
INTERNATIONAL PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITED
Snapshot
·
Fleet of 69 aircraft in operation and 20
decommissioned aircraft in storage[21]
·
Thai Airways is the market leader within
Thailand´s carriers on international routes (16% market share)
while being the smallest on domestic routes [22]
·
Launch of a daily flight to Istanbul (Turkey) in
December 2023[23]
·
Yields in the third quarter 2023 were up more
than 50% compared to the same quarter 2019[24]
·
Stronger focus on sustainability through
partnerships regarding SAF (Sustainable Aviation Fuel) usage and
commitment to use more eco-friendly material (on-board amenity
kits, new flight attendant uniforms, etc.)[25]
·
The largest number of tourist arrivals at Thai
airports are from Malaysia, China and South Korea[26]
·
Arrivals from China and Japan in 2023 had reached
only 35% and 65% respectively of 2019-levels, while inbound travel
from Vietnam, Taiwan, Indonesia, UAE and the Philippines (nearly)
exceeded pre-pandemic levels[27]
·
Main threats result from lower economic growth in
the Asia Pacific region, a high level of inflation, volatility of
oil prices and the entrance of new market players[28]
ASSET MANAGER'S REPORT (CONTINUED)
Restructuring and Rehabilitation Process since
18th May 2022
·
Debt repayment according to the Business
Rehabilitation Plan on track[29]
·
Sale of six B747-400s, one A340-500, three
additional unused aircraft, five unused engines, two overseas
properties and shares in a pipeline Transportation
company[30]
·
The integration of Thai Smile into Thai had been
completed 31st December 2023 and is expected to increase
the carrier´s efficiency, flight operations and fleet
utilisation[31]
·
The carrier implemented a route expansion and
fleet efficiency improvement plan[32]
·
The Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET) approved to
extend the time limit to 7th March 2025 for Thai to
eliminate the criteria for delisting (negative equity)[33]
·
Thai Airways plans to exit rehabilitation by the
end of 2024[34]
ASSET MANAGER'S REPORT (CONTINUED)
Thai´s Financial & operational performance in brief
(incl. subsidiaries)[35]
[billion THB*]
|
2023
|
2022
|
Change
|
Link
|
Operating Revenues
|
161.07
|
105.04
|
+ 53 %
|
|
- Passenger and Excess
Baggage
|
132.74
|
74.04
|
+ 79
%
|
|
- Freight and Mail
|
15.46
|
23.78
|
- 35
%
|
|
- Other Businesses
|
9.25
|
6.67
|
+
39%
|
a)
|
- Other Income
|
3.62
|
0.55
|
+
562%
|
|
Operating Expenses
|
120.86
|
97.24
|
+ 24 %
|
b)
|
- Fuel and Oil
|
47.77
|
38.38
|
+ 25
%
|
c)
|
- Non-Fuel Operating
Costs
|
73.09
|
58.87
|
+ 24
%
|
d)
|
Operating Result excl. One-Time Items
|
24.60
|
- 4.59
|
|
|
Net Result
|
28.10
|
- 0.27
|
|
e)
|
Capacity - ASK (million)
|
54,280
|
38,526
|
+ 41 %
|
|
Demand - RPK (million)
|
43,268
|
26,163
|
+ 65 %
|
|
Load Factor
|
79.7 %
|
67.9 %
|
+ 11.8 pp
|
|
Passengers (million)
|
13.76
|
9.01
|
+ 53 %
|
|
Passenger Yield [THB/RPK]
|
3.06
|
2.82
|
+ 9 %
|
|
Aircraft Utilisation [block
hours]
|
12.2
|
10.4
|
+ 17 %
|
|
Number of Aircraft
|
77
|
86
|
- 11 %
|
|
Increase in Cash & Cash Equivalents [bn
THB]
|
18.40
|
29.03
|
|
f)
|
Current Ratio (consolidated)
|
2.51
|
2.04
|
|
g)
|
* Exchange rate THB:USD as at
31st December 2023: 1,00 THB : 0,03 USD[36]
Remarks
a) Catering, ground
services, cargo handling, etc.
b) Increase is in-line
with increased operations
c) Average fuel price
in 2023 decreased by 16% compared to 2022
d) Crew expenses,
aircraft maintenance, lease of aircraft, etc
ASSET MANAGER'S REPORT (CONTINUED)
Thai´s Financial & operational performance in brief
(incl. subsidiaries)[37]
(Continued)
Remarks
(continued)
e) Affected by
one-time expenses, particularly due to a gain on debt restructuring
(THB 3.96 billion), the sale of assets (THB 0.47 billion) and a
loss on foreign currency exchange (THB 1.07 billion)
f) Slower
increase than last year but the amount of cash and cash equivalents
further increased
g) Improve in
liquidity and the ability to pay debt services (Current Ratio =
Current Assets/Current Liabilities)
Fleet
Source: Cirium: "Thai Airways
International Fleet Summary"; 2nd February
2024
·
Currently about 70 aircraft in
operation[38]
·
Pre-pandemic fleet comprised approximately 100
aircraft
·
Targeted growth of about ten aircraft annually to
90 aircraft by the end of 2025[39]
·
Agreement to lease four A350-900s, three B787-9s
and ten A321NEOs from AerCap with delivery between 2024 and
2026[40]
·
Signed leases for two used A330-300s with CDB
Aviation[41]
·
Agreement with Air Lease Corporation on leases
for three B787-9s with delivery in 2025[42]
·
Firm order of 45 B787-9s equipped with GE
Aerospace engines and additional 35 B787-9s on option; deliveries
are expected to start in 2027 and Thai has the flexibility to
change the order (partially) to B787-8s or
B787-10s[43]
·
Potential aircraft type phase-out in the
mid-term[44]
§ A330
fleet as the only three aircraft in the current fleet (two used
will join shortly on a lease; lease term unknown) are about 15
years old
§ B777-200ER fleet (five aircraft) being 16 to 17 years of
age
ASSET MANAGER'S REPORT (CONTINUED)
Outlook & Opportunities post-Covid-19
pandemic
·
Additional destinations to be resumed in
spring/summer 2024: Perth, Colombo, Milan and Oslo and frequencies
on popular routes will be increased [45]
·
Thai Airways plans to codeshare with low-cost
airline Nok Air to enlarge its domestic network once Nok Air opens
a base at Bangkok Suvarnabhumi Airport; expected for the second
half of 2024[46]
·
Eight start-up airlines had been granted an AOC
in 2023, including cargo airlines, operators of less than 20-seat
aircraft as well as competing airlines such as Really Cool
Airlines; however, it remains uncertain if all of them will start
operations[47]
·
Passenger numbers at Thailand´s Airports in 2023
only recovered to about 75% of pre-pandemic levels leaving room for
further growth[48]
·
The Airports of Thailand announced to invest THB
97 billion (approx. USD 2.72 billion[49])
in the expansion of six major international Thai Airports,
including Bangkok Suvarnabhumi, within the next six
years[50]
·
The Thai Government decided on a permanent
visa-exemption for Chinese tourists[51]
·
Analysts are not aligned if Thailand´s passenger
numbers will fully recover in 2024 as this strongly depends on
tourism, especially on Chinese tourists' numbers which are
currently impacted by a weak Chinese economy[52]
Comments & conclusions
Thai Airways is dependent on the
tourism sector, particularly on in-bound tourism and contingent on
any decision made by the Government to soften travel restrictions.
Consequently, the visa-exemption for Chinese travellers might be
welcome to support the airline´s growth of passengers, revenues´
and operational income.
The airline`s move to fully
integrate the subsidiary Thai Smile is expected to offer a more
consistent brand identity and to allow Thai Airways to switch more
easily narrow- and widebody aircraft on domestic and regional
routes due to seasonality and overall demand. Therefore, it makes
sense that the Business Class comfort of the former A320 Thai Smile
Fleet will be enhanced to offer a consistent product within its
fleet. However, it will be interesting to see if increased fleet
flexibility and synergy effects will succeed to counterbalance the
parent company`s higher aircraft operating costs.
ASSET MANAGER'S REPORT (CONTINUED)
Outlook & Opportunities post-Covid-19 pandemic
(Continued)
Comments & conclusions (Continued)
Thai´s order of B787s demonstrates
that this aircraft type is of significance in the carrier´s long
term fleet strategy. The decision for engines from GE is not a big
surprise as Thai has publicly mentioned not to be happy with
Rolls-Royce´s pricing strategy[53] and
Rolls-Royce engine shop capacity is limited. It is not completely
uncommon to operate one aircraft family with engines from different
manufacturers. Emirates´ operates its A380 fleet with two
different engine types and LATAM recently ordered B787s equipped
with GE engines despite operating its current B787s fleet with
Rolls-Royce engines. Taking into account that not all aircraft
joining the fleet over the next ten years are dedicated for growth
but also for replacement of older aircraft puts the growth rate
into perspective. Nevertheless, Thai will need to demonstrate that
their aircraft orders are not bringing more seat capacity into the
market than the airline will be able to profitably
utilise.
The 2023 financial results look
promising, and Thai intends to exit Rehabilitation earlier than
originally forecasted. Though, the carrier will have to prove
profitability in the long-term allowing for potential new market
entrants and a flattening passenger growth after pre-pandemic
levels have been reached. The recovery in the Asia Pacific region
could also attract new airline launches aiming to benefit from a
recovering market. Potentially, in times of delivery and aircraft
shortages, the winners will be those who successfully manage to
receive additional aircraft at the time of market need.
THE ASSETS
Update Boeing 787[54]
·
313 Boeing 787s were ordered in 2023; including
14 of the B787-8 variant
·
73 B787s were delivered in 2023, including ten
B787-8s
·
The orderbook showed 797
backlogs of the Dreamliner, including 43 of the B787-8 variant (as
at 27th February 2024)
·
Boeing intends to increase the monthly B787
production rate to ten aircraft in 2025; the current rate was at
five per month as at the end of 2023[55]
·
Seven B787 aircraft, all of them of the B787-8s
variant, were published for remarketing as at March
2024[56]
ASSET MANAGER'S REPORT (CONTINUED)
THE ASSETS (Continued)
Update Boeing 787[57]
(Continued)
Source: Cirium: "Fleet Analyzer";
28th February 2024
·
27% of delivered and ordered B787s are powered by
Rolls-Royce compared to a market share of 33% in 2022[58]
·
Rolls-Royce is going to invest GBP 1 million in
the improvement of existing products, including the Trent 1000
engine (powering B787s)[59]
·
Latest transactions:
o November 2023: Credit Agricole closed a finance lease of one
B787-9 operated by Vistara[60]
o December 2023
§ First
delivery of one B787-9 to a Chinese airline after two
years[61]
§ Order
of five B787s powered with GE-engines by LATAM[62]
§ Air
Europe took delivery of one B787-9 leased from
AerCap[63]
o 2023: Lessor AerCap bought three B787-9s to be hold in their
own portfolio[64]
o January 2024: Air Japan (Low-Cost-Carrier newly launched by
ANA) received its first B787-8 (formerly operated by
ANA)[65]
o February 2024
§ Royal
Brunei ordered four B787-9s with deliveries starting in
2028[66]
§ Thai
Airways ordered 45 B787-9s plus 35 Dreamliner on option[67]
§ Hawaiian´s first Dreamliner (B787-9) will be financed by the
Lessor Jackson Square Aviation[68]
o One B787-9 had been delivered to Turkish Airlines by
AerCap[69]
o March 2024: Oman Air intends to sell its only two B787-8s and
keep its B787-9s a part of their restructuring[70]
ASSET MANAGER'S REPORT (CONTINUED)
Assets & Operations
Overview
Both aircraft, HS-TQC and HS-TQD,
are based at Bangkok International Airport and operated by Thai
Airways. HS-TQC is in regular commercial service.
The utilisation of TQC and TQD as
well as their respective titled engines is shown in the following
tables:
AIRCRAFT OPERATIONS
|
Thai
Airways
|
HS-TQC
|
HS-TQD
|
Cabin Layout
|
24
Business Class Seats
240
Economy Class Seats
|
LAST PHYSICAL
INSPECTION
|
|
Date
|
21st December 2023
|
3rd February 2023
|
Place
|
Bangkok
Airport (BKK)
|
AIRFRAME STATUS (29th
February 2024)
|
|
|
Total Flight Hours
|
24,313
|
22,166
|
Average Monthly Utilisation Since
Delivery [FH]
|
217
|
200
|
Total Flight Cycles
|
5,702
|
5,144
|
Average Monthly Utilisation Since
Delivery [FC]
|
51
|
46
|
Hours/Cycles Ratio Since
Delivery
|
4.26
|
4.31
|
TITLED
ENGINES
(29th February 2024)
|
HS-TQC
|
HS-TQD
|
ESN
10239
|
ESN
10243
|
ESN
10244
|
ESN
10248
|
Total Time [Flight
Hours]
|
22,735
|
16,645
|
18,967
|
21,431
|
Total Flight Cycles
|
5,322
|
3,482
|
4,640
|
4,632
|
Location
|
On-wing
|
In-shop
at SAESL for repair
|
HS-TQE
|
On-wing
|
Engine ESN 10243 was removed due
to IPC Stage 8 blade damage found and inducted into shop at the
SAESL facility in Singapore on 31st January 2024.
Moreover, during replacing engine ESN 10240 with ESN 10243, it was
contractually agreed with Thai Airways that the AD (Airworthiness
Directives)-2019-0286 would be included in the work scope of the
next shop visit of ESN 10243.
On 27th October 2023,
the C3-check of HS-TQC was completed at the maintenance facilities
at Don Muang Airport (Bangkok, Thailand). On 21st
December 2023, the annual inspection of HS-TQC has been performed
at Bangkok Suvarnabhumi Airport. The aircraft was undergoing an
A-check at this time. No major issues had been found. The aircraft
is airworthy and currently in regular commercial operation with
Thai Airways. The C3-Check of HS-TQD was completed on
15th March 2024 at the maintenance facilities at Don
Muang Airport (Bangkok, Thailand)
ASSET MANAGER'S REPORT (CONTINUED)
Snapshot: Destinations of
HS-TQC and HS-TQD in December 2023
Destination
|
Average Flight Time
|
Frequency - TQC
|
Frequency - TQD*
|
Bangalore, India
|
3:18
|
1
|
-
|
Chitose, Japan
|
6:32
|
1
|
1
|
Delhi, India
|
3:38
|
1
|
1
|
Denpasar, Indonesia
|
3:44
|
1
|
1
|
Dhaka, Bangladesh
|
2:06
|
3
|
1
|
Hanoi, Vietnam
|
1:46
|
3
|
2
|
Hyderabad, India
|
3:01
|
8
|
-
|
Islamabad, Pakistan
|
4:26
|
-
|
2
|
Istanbul, Turkey
|
9:18
|
2
|
-
|
Jakarta, Indonesia
|
2:53
|
8
|
3
|
Karachi, Pakistan
|
4:28
|
-
|
1
|
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
|
1:46
|
1
|
1
|
Lahore, Pakistan
|
4:06
|
2
|
1
|
Madras, India
|
2:56
|
-
|
1
|
Manila, Philippines
|
2:55
|
5
|
2
|
Mumbai, India
|
4:12
|
4
|
1
|
Rangoon, Myanmar
|
1:13
|
2
|
1
|
Saigon, Vietnam
|
1:30
|
-
|
1
|
Singapore, Singapore
|
2:00
|
7
|
2
|
*Less frequencies compared to
HS-TQC due to the C3-Check starting 13 December 2023
Source: Flightaware
ASSET MANAGER'S REPORT (CONTINUED)
Asset Manager´s actions
ensure asset value
Regular monitoring is the top
priority for DS Aviation as DP Aircraft's Asset Manager to make
sure that the Lessee is keeping the aircraft in the best condition
per the manufacturer's and Lessor's requirements.
Therefore, both aircraft are
inspected regularly by DS Aviation´s technical staff or on-site
representatives. As previously reported, HS-TQD was lastly
inspected in February 2023 at Bangkok International Airport. The
next annual inspection will be scheduled in due course. Aircraft
HS-TQC was inspected December 2023 at Bangkok International Airport
by DS Aviation's on-site representative.
Considering the past, it is
essential to monitor the Lessee's activities including both
aircraft and its overall activities. Additionally, it is important
to ensure a prompt exchange of updated information. Because of
this, DS Aviation continues to have an "on-demand" contract with
the on-site service provider. Their expertise and workforce are
available whenever the circumstance calls for it, ensuring prompt
and efficient support on the spot.
Comments and Conclusions
The challenges for the
manufacturers and airlines to deal with bottlenecks and quality
issues remain. The procurement of metals
and parts take up to five times longer than in 2019.[71] Airbus´s supply chain management had been
increased by 150% and engineers sent out to critical supplier
facilities.[72] Therefore, many airlines
are not able to grow as quickly as intended. If a carrier is in the
favourable position to extend leases, reactivate stored aircraft or
push back the phase-out of older aircraft, it might overcome the
current bottlenecks. But this might cause new issues as airlines
might then not be able to meet given or self-proclaimed standards
of sustainability. The significance of sustainability is
growing, not only in the population but also in statutory
provisions. And delaying the change to a more environmentally
friendly fleet might result in additional costs.
The latest B787 transactions show
that this aircraft is still a liquid asset and well accepted by
airlines. On the engine side, Rolls-Royce pays for their
reliability issues, particularly with the Trent 1000 engines where
the manufacturer lost market shares. Both Thai and LATAM, operating
their current B787 fleet with Roll-Royce engines, decided on the GE
engine option regarding their latest orders. Rolls-Royce needs to
make huge efforts to regain the airlines´ trust and generate
orders. Nevertheless, the Dreamliner B787 is of the latest
technology and seems to be well-positioned for the near and
mid-term future. However, it remains important to closely watch the
market and monitor the assets' condition.
DIRECTORS
Jonathan (Jon) Bridel, Non-Executive Chairman
(59), appointed 10 July 2013
Jon is a Guernsey resident and is
currently a non-executive director of Fair Oaks Income Fund
Limited. Jon was previously managing director of Royal Bank of
Canada's ('RBC') investment businesses in the Channel Islands and
served as a director on other RBC companies including RBC Regent
Fund Managers Limited. Prior to joining RBC, Jon served in a number
of senior management positions in banking, specialising in credit
and corporate finance and private businesses as Chief Financial
Officer in London, Australia and Guernsey having previously worked
at Price Waterhouse Corporate Finance in London.
Jon graduated from the University
of Durham with a degree of Master of Business Administration, holds
qualifications from the Institute of Chartered Accountants in
England and Wales (1987) where he is a Fellow, the Chartered
Institute of Marketing and the Australian Institute of Company
Directors. Jon is a Chartered
Marketer and a Member of the
Chartered Institute of Marketing, a Chartered Director and Fellow
of the Institute of Directors and a Chartered Fellow of the
Chartered Institute for Securities and Investment.
Jeremy Thompson, Non-Executive Director (68), appointed 10 July
2013
Jeremy Thompson is a Guernsey
resident. He acts as a non-executive director to a number of
businesses which include three private equity funds, an investment
manager serving the listed NextEnergy Solar Fund Limited and London
listed Riverstone Energy Limited. Prior to that he was CEO of four
autonomous global businesses within Cable & Wireless PLC and
earlier held CEO roles within the Dowty Group.
Jeremy currently serves as
chairman of the States of Guernsey Renewable Energy Team and is a
commissioner of the Alderney Gambling Control Commission. He is
also an independent member of the Guernsey Tax Tribunal panel.
Jeremy is an engineering graduate of Brunel (B.Sc) and Cranfield
(MBA) Universities and attended the UK's senior defence course
(Royal College of Defence Studies). He holds the Institute of
Directors (IoD) Certificate and Diploma in Company Direction and is
an associate of the Chartered Institute of Arbitration. He
completed an M.Sc in Corporate Governance in 2016 and qualified as
a Chartered Company Secretary in 2017.
Harald Brauns, Non-Executive Director
(70), appointed 1 November 2019
Harald is a German banker with
extensive experience in the specialised lending sector. He joined
NORD/LB Hannover, Germany in 1977 with a first engagement in the
shipping segment. In 1985 he started the aircraft finance
activities for the bank from scratch. As the Global Head of
Aircraft Finance, he built successively a team of more than 40
dedicated aviation experts located in Hannover, New York and
Singapore. Focused on an asset-based business model with
sophisticated solutions for selected clients, he and his team
advanced to global leaders in commercial aircraft finance with an
exposure of well above US$ 10 billion split over a portfolio of 650
aircraft assets. After more than 35 years in the aviation industry
Harald retired in October 2019. He is resident in Germany and was
appointed as a director of the Company with effect from 1 November
2019.
DIRECTORS' REPORT
The Directors present their Annual
Report and Audited Consolidated Financial Statements for DP
Aircraft I Limited for the year ended 31 December 2023.
Principal Activity and Review of the
Business
The Company's principal activity
is to purchase, lease and then sell two Boeing 787-8 Aircraft (the
'Assets'). The Company wholly owns two subsidiary entities, DP
Aircraft Guernsey III Limited and DP Aircraft Guernsey IV Limited
(collectively and hereinafter, the 'Borrowers'), each being a
Guernsey incorporated company limited by shares and one
intermediate lessor company, DP Aircraft UK Limited (the 'Lessor'),
a UK incorporated private limited company. The Company and its
consolidated subsidiaries, DP Aircraft Guernsey III Limited, DP
Aircraft Guernsey IV Limited and DP Aircraft UK Limited comprise
the consolidated Group (the 'Group').
The investment objective of the
Group is to obtain income and capital returns for the Company's
shareholders by acquiring, leasing and then, when the Board
considers it appropriate, selling the Assets. The Company has made
its investments in the Assets through its subsidiaries. The
Ordinary Shares of the Company are currently trading on the
Specialist Fund Segment of the London Stock Exchange.
Notwithstanding the requirement
for the aircraft to be parked in the past due to Trent 1000 issues
there are no incidents to bring to the attention of Shareholders
concerning the operation of the Thai aircraft. Inspections have
revealed no matters of concern. The
aircraft have been operational for all of 2023 year and are
currently in regular commercial use with the exception of regular
mandated C checks where the aircraft are thoroughly checked. Such
checks are a functions of flight hours flown. It should be noted
that the Company receives full lease payments during such
checks. Rolls Royce are continuing to
address the Trent 1000 engine warranty related issues which have
not impacted the Company. A more detailed review of the business
and prospects is contained in detail in the Asset Manager's Report
on pages 11 to 23.
Results and Dividends
For the year ended 31 December
2023 the Group made a loss of US$ 2,505,687 (2022:US$ 7,660,823).
The results for the year ended 31 December 2023 are mainly driven
by rental income earned of US$ 8,714,249 (2022: US$ 16,462,372) and
finance costs incurred of US$ 9,551,675 (2022: US$ 4,860,305). The
increase of finance costs is a result of an adjustment required by
IFRS to reflect the modification to the loan terms in February
2023. The modification adjustment for the modification to the loans
in February 2023 totalled US$ 5,042,029 and increased both finance
costs and the loans payable at the point of modification and
resulted in an overall loss for the period. This adjustment
essentially recognises a loss now due to the less favourable terms
(primarily interest rate increases) under the modified terms
compared to the original terms. As a result of this adjustment,
interest will be recognised at the lower original effective
interest rate as opposed to the higher modified interest rate going
forward. The decrease in rent was due to the variable rent period
ending on 31 December 2022. For the period to 31 December 2023, the
entity only earned fixed rental income. As a result, the group
reported loss during the period ended 31 December 2023, see page 49
for full results for the year.
Historically, under normal
circumstances, the Company aimed to provide Shareholders with an
attractive total return comprising income, from distributions
through the period of the Company's ownership of the Assets, and
capital, upon any sale of the Assets. The Company targeted a
quarterly distribution in February, May, August and November of
each year. The target distribution was US$ 0.0225 per share per
quarter.
DIRECTORS' REPORT (CONTINUED)
On 3 April 2020, the Company
announced a suspension of dividends until further notice due to the
impact of Covid-19 in global aviation and especially with long haul
operations. The suspension is continuing and as noted in Summary
report on pages 4 to 6, there is no realistic prospect of the
Company's shareholders receiving a dividend or any other
distribution.
Subsequent Events
Refer to note 23 for
further details regarding Subsequent
Events.
Directors
The Independent Directors of the
Company, who served during the year and to date, are as shown
below:
·
Jonathan Bridel;
·
Jeremy Thompson; and
·
Harald Brauns.
Directors' Interests
The Directors interests in the
shares of the Company as at 31 December 2023 are set out below and
there have been no changes in such interests up to the current
date:
|
Number of
ordinary
shares
31 December
2023
|
Number of
ordinary
shares
31 December
2022
|
Connected parties of Jon
Bridel
|
90,000
|
90,000
|
Jeremy Thompson
|
15,000
|
15,000
|
Harald Brauns
|
-
|
-
|
Principal Risks and Uncertainties
The Statement of Principal Risks
and Uncertainties are as described on pages 38 to 40.
Substantial
Shareholdings
The Directors note the following
substantial interests in the Company's share capital as at 31
December 2023 (10% and more shareholding):
o M&G Investments 59,533,421 shares - 24.87 %
o Ironsides Partners 53,082,972 shares - 22.18 %
As at the date of this report
there have been no significant changes in the above list of
substantial shareholdings.
The Board
The Board consists of three
directors, all of whom are non-executive. Mr Bridel and Mr Thompson
satisfy all the criteria for assessing director independence set
out by the Association of Investment Companies ("AIC") and adopted
by the Board. Although they have served on the Board for over ten
years, it is the opinion of the other member of the Board that they
both continue to demonstrate objective and independent thought
processes during Board meetings and in their dealings with the
Asset Manager, and therefore consider them both to be independent,
despite their long service.
Jeremy Thompson was appointed as
Senior Independent Director (the 'SID') on 1 April 2016. During the
year ended 31 December 2023 the Board had a breadth of experience
relevant to the Company and a balance of skills and
experience.
DIRECTORS' REPORT (CONTINUED)
The Board recognises the
importance of diversity and will evaluate applicants to fill any
vacant positions regardless of gender and without prejudice.
Applicants will be assessed on their broad range of skills,
expertise and industry knowledge, and business and other expertise.
In view of the long-term nature of the Company's investments, the
Board believes that a stable board composition is fundamental to
run the Company. The Board has not stipulated a maximum term of any
directorship.
Board Independence and Disclosure
The Board is composed entirely of
independent Directors, who meet as required without the presence of
the Asset Manager or service providers to scrutinise the
achievement of agreed goals, objectives and monitor performance.
Through the Audit Committee and the Management Engagement Committee
they are able to ascertain the integrity of financial information
and confirm that all financial controls and risk management systems
are robust and analyse the performance of the Asset Manager and
other service providers on a regular basis.
The Directors have challenged the
Asset Manager throughout the year under review and for the purposes
of assessing compliance with the AIC Code, the Board as a whole
considers that each Director is independent of the Asset Manager
and free from any business or other relationship that could
materially interfere with the exercise of their independent
judgment. If required, the Board is able to access independent
professional advice. Open communication between the Asset Manager
and the Board is facilitated by regular Board meetings, to which
the Asset Manager is invited to attend and update the Board on the
current status of the Company's aircraft, along with ad hoc
meetings as required.
The Board has been actively
engaged in negotiating revised agreements with its lending group
and Thai. Jon Bridel and Jeremy Thompson have served for ten
years and together with Harald Brauns have acted independently and
in the best interests of the Company. The Board is now focused on
using its experience to work with the Asset Manager to maximise
value for shareholders.
Directors
As the Company is not a FTSE 350
company, Directors were not subject to annual election by the
shareholders nor for the requirement for the external audit
contract to be put out to tender every 10 years. Historically, the
Directors had offered themselves by rotation for re-election at
each annual general meeting ('AGM'). Harald Braun was re-elected at
the AGM on 19 September 2023. Jeremy Thompson is offering himself
for re-election at the forthcoming AGM.
The Directors are on a termination
notice of three months.
Directors' Duties and Responsibilities
The Board of Directors has overall
responsibility for the Company's affairs and is responsible for the
determination of the investment policy of the Company, resolving
conflicts and for monitoring the overall portfolio of investments
of the Company. To assist the Board in the day-to-day operations of
the Company, arrangements have been put in place for the
performance of certain of the day-to-day operations of the Company
to third-party service providers, such as the Asset Manager,
Administrator and Company Secretary, under the supervision of the
Board. The Board receives full details of the Company's assets,
liabilities and other relevant information in advance of Board
meetings.
The Board undertakes an annual
evaluation of its own performance and the performance of its audit
committee and individual Directors. This is to ensure that they
continue to act effectively and efficiently and to fulfil their
respective duties, and to identify any training requirements. The
results of the most recent evaluation have been reviewed by the
Chairman and his fellow Directors. No significant corporate
governance issues arose from this review.
DIRECTORS' REPORT (CONTINUED)
Directors' Duties and Responsibilities
(continued)
The Board also undertakes an
annual review of the effectiveness of the Company's system of
internal controls and the safeguarding of shareholders' investments
and the Company's assets. A Management Engagement Committee,
chaired by Harald Brauns has been established to further this
safeguarding. At each quarterly meeting the Audit and Risk
Committee reviews a risk matrix. Issues identified as a result of
this review are discussed and action plans put in place as is
necessary. There is nothing to highlight from the reviews of these
reports as at the date of this report.
Board Meetings
The Board meets at least four
times a year to consider the business and affairs of the Company
for the previous quarter. Between these quarterly meetings the
Board keeps in regular contact by email and video calls as well as
meeting to consider specific matters of a transactional nature.
There is regular contact with the Secretary and
administrator.
The Directors are kept fully
informed of investment and financial controls and other matters
that are relevant to the business of the Company. The Directors
also have access, where necessary in the furtherance of their
duties, to professional advice at the expense of the
Company.
The Board considers agenda items
laid out in the Notice and Agenda which are formally circulated to
the Board in advance of any meeting as part of the board papers.
Such items include but are not limited to; investment performance,
share price performance, review of marketing and shareholder
communication. The Directors may request any agenda items to be
added that they consider appropriate for Board discussion. In
addition, each Director is required to inform the Board of any
potential or actual conflict of interest prior to Board
discussion.
Board meetings are attended by
representatives of the Asset Manager. The Company's corporate
brokers also attend to assist the Directors in understanding the
views of major shareholders about the Company.
Board Meeting attendance
The table below shows the
attendance at Board meetings and Audit Committee meetings during
the year.
Director
|
No of board meetings
attended
|
No of audit committee
meetings attended
|
Jonathan Bridel
|
5
|
4
|
Jeremy Thompson
|
5
|
4
|
Harald Brauns
|
5
|
4
|
No. of meetings during the year
|
5
|
4
|
The Directors also attended
committee meetings for the Management Engagement Committee meeting
in addition to the regular quarterly meetings as shown in the above
table and the Chairman attended further meetings with various
stakeholders and on management related matters.
DIRECTORS' REPORT (CONTINUED)
Directors' Remuneration
The remuneration of the
non-executive Directors is reviewed on an annual basis and compared
with the level of remuneration for directorships of funds with
similar responsibilities and commitments.
Base annual fees are as
follows:
Annual Fees
|
Jan 23 to Dec
23
|
Oct
22 to Dec 22
|
Jan 22 to Sept
22
|
Jonathan Bridel
|
£61,750
|
£61,750
|
£66,000
|
Jeremy Thompson
|
£49,450
|
£49,450
|
£53,700
|
Harald Brauns
|
£49,450
|
£49,450
|
£53,800
|
In 2021, in recognition of the
extra services performed by the Directors and the significant
increase of committed time during 2021 due to the Group's
circumstances, the Board had earned extra fees of £65,000 which
were not paid in cash but deferred to be possibly settled by the
issue of shares. This is included in note 13 as part of the
Directors fees payable. No additional fees were earned by the Board
during the 2023 financial period.
On 1 October 2022, the Director
fees were reduced by 10% which was the portion being deferred and
possibly payable in shares.
During the current and prior year
each Director received the following remuneration in the form of
Directors' fees from Group companies:
|
Year ended
|
Year ended
|
|
31 December
2023
|
31 December
2022
|
|
£
|
US$
equivalent
|
£
|
US$
equivalent
|
Jonathan Bridel
(Chairman)
|
61,750
|
78,608
|
64,937
|
80,701
|
Jeremy Thompson (Audit Committee
Chairman)
|
49,450
|
62,950
|
52,637
|
65,503
|
Harald Brauns (Management
Engagement Committee Chairman)
|
49,450
|
62,950
|
48,229
|
60,064
|
|
160,650
|
204,508
|
165,803
|
206,268
|
Up to 30 September 2022, 10% of
base fees and all extra fees were not paid by way of cash payments
but were deferred to be settled in the future or to be paid by way
of equity. There has been no settlement of director remuneration
via the issue of equity in the current year (2022: nil) and the
deferred fees remain outstanding as at 31 December 2023 (see note
13).
There are no executive director
service contracts in issue.
DIRECTORS' REPORT (CONTINUED)
Remuneration Policy
All Directors of the Company are
non-executive and therefore there are no incentive or performance
schemes. Each director's appointment is subject to an appointment
letter and article 24 of the Company's articles of association.
Base remuneration is paid monthly in arrears and reflects the
experience, responsibility, time, commitment and position on the
main board as well as responsibility for sitting on subsidiary
boards when required. The Chairman, Audit Chairman (SID) and other
committee Chairman may receive additional remuneration to reflect
the increased level of responsibility and accountability. The
maximum amount of directors' fees payable by the Company in any one
year is currently set at £200,000 in accordance with article 24.
Remuneration may if deemed appropriate also be payable for special
or extra services if required in accordance with article 24.
This is defined as work undertaken in connection
with a corporate transaction including a new prospectus to acquire,
finance and lease an aircraft and/or engines, managing a default,
refinancing, sale or re-lease of aircraft and for defending a
takeover bid. This may include reasonable travel time if
applicable. The Board may appoint an
independent consultant to review fees if it is considered an above
inflation rise may be appropriate.
Internal Controls and Risk Management
Review
The Board is responsible for the
Company's system of internal control and for reviewing its
effectiveness. The Board confirms that there is an ongoing process
for identifying, evaluating and monitoring the significant risks
faced by the Company.
The Board carries out an annual
review of internal controls including those of the administrator.
The internal control systems are designed to meet the Company's
particular needs and the risks to which it is exposed. Accordingly,
the internal control systems are designed to manage rather than
eliminate the risk of failure to achieve business objectives and by
their nature can only provide reasonable and not absolute assurance
against misstatement and loss.
The Directors of the Company
clearly define the duties and responsibilities of their agents and
advisors. The appointment of agents and advisers is conducted by
the Board after consideration of the quality of the parties
involved and the Board monitors their ongoing performance and
contractual arrangements. Each service provider is reviewed
annually, and key risks and operating matters are addressed as part
of that review.
Dialogue with Shareholders
All holders of shares in the
Company have the right to receive notice of, and attend, all
general meetings of the Company, during which the Directors are
available to discuss issues affecting the Company. The Directors
are available to enter into dialogue with shareholders and make
themselves available for such purpose when reasonably required. The
Company believes such communications to be important. Reports are
provided to the Board of Directors on shareholders' views about the
Company and any issues or concerns they might have.
Board Policy on Tenure and Independence
The Board has not yet formed a
policy on tenure. However, it does consider the independence of
each director on an annual basis during the performance evaluation
process. All Directors are considered independent.
Auditor
In order to align the Company's
auditing arrangements with the location of its business, the Board
have changed the KPMG entity which undertakes the Company's audit
during the year. As a consequence, KPMG Channel Islands Limited has
assumed the role of independent auditor for the year ended 31
December 2023 and has replaced KPMG Ireland.
KPMG Channel Islands Limited have
indicated their willingness to continue in office.
DIRECTORS' REPORT (CONTINUED)
Going Concern
The Directors believe that it is
appropriate to prepare these consolidated financial statements on a
going concern basis as the current cash flow forecasts demonstrate
that the Group, with continued deferral of fees, as outlined below,
from some service providers, has sufficient cash to cover operating
costs for a period of at least twelve months from the signing of
the consolidated financial statements (the "going concern
period").
Should a plausible downside
scenario occur additional finance will be required to provide
sufficient funding to fund the Group's activities to cover any
negotiations with the lenders as further detailed below. In this
respect the Company believes it is therefore prudent to raise
additional capital in Q3 2024. The Board will consult with its
broker regarding a proposed capital raise and its uptake. However,
the outcome is currently uncertain.
The Board therefore concludes that
to sufficiently cover off all going concern scenarios, there is a
material uncertainty, however it remains appropriate to prepare the
financial statements on a going concern basis.
In making this conclusion, the
Board have taken into consideration:
·
that Thai Airways have made monthly fixed lease
rental payments on time and in full from the start of the revised
fixed rental period commencing in January 2023. Further that Thai
have reported a consistent return to profitability and have
projected that they will exit their formal rehabilitation Period in
Q4 2024;
·
that given Thai Airways improved performance the
Company will continue to receive US$ 35,000 per aircraft per month
as a contribution towards its operating costs with the rest going
towards the pay down of the Group's outstanding loan
arrangements;
·
the continued deferral of some fees by the Board,
the Asset Manager and the Broker as noted in note 13;
·
successfully raising up to US$ 1m in Q3 2024 to
allow the Group to trade beyond the going concern period to
facilitate negotiating (i) an extension to the current loan
maturities beyond the expiring loan terms in Q4 2026 with the
Lenders, and (ii) an enhancement of the terms and conditions of the
leases with Thai Airways, noting that negotiations with the lenders
will commence in late 2024;and
·
as a matter of prudence, the Company will need to
consider costs associated with the winding up of the Group should
it be required.
Viability Statement
As with previous reports the
Directors regularly assess the viability of the Group with respect
to the impact of potential risks the Group faces and the Group's
current position.
In February 2023, the Group and
DekaBank entered into Second Amendment and Restatement to the Loan
Agreements in which the parties agreed to new repayment schedules
for the loans in place. Under the revised repayment schedules,
monthly payments of fixed interest and principal will be limited to
net lease rental monies available for application towards the loans
of US$475,000 per loan and the final balloon repayments will be
settled out of proceeds from sale of the aircraft at the end of the
lease term. These new repayment terms are aligned with the lease
agreements in place.
The PBH period on the Thai Airways
leases expired on 31 December 2022 and now the Group is receiving
fixed monthly rental payments of US$510,000 per aircraft.
This is in line with the amended lease agreements finalised and
signed on 1 April 2022. US$35,000 per aircraft of the fixed monthly
rental payments will be retained by the Group to contribute to
ongoing fixed costs, the remainder will be used to cover principal
and fixed interest payable on the DekaBank loans per
above.
DIRECTORS' REPORT
(CONTINUED)
Viability Statement (continued)
Both aircraft have been
operational for the 2023 year and are currently in regular
commercial use. With both aircraft operational, this not only means
the aircraft are earning revenue, but it also means that if Thai
were to default, the aircraft are in flightworthy
condition.
Thai Airways, at the end of the
lease term, have an obligation to return the aircraft in full life
condition. This is either by undertaking all the work themselves to
do this or provide the lessor with the equivalent cash to undertake
the work required. The viability and therefore continuation
of the Group looks positive save any major, likely force majeure,
scenarios. The Company is though dependent on contracted lease
payments paid on time and in full.
Mindful of the significant
challenges which could still impact the airline industry, Thai
Airways in particular and the Company, the Company has extended its
viability period to June 2025 assuming Thai Airways continue to
meet its lease payment obligations and certain service providers
(Asset Manager, Broker and Directors) continue to defer some of
their fees as agreed. The Board also proposes an additional capital
raise in 2024 as stated in going concern section on page
31.
The Group is required to present a
plan for refinancing or similar to the lenders before the expiry of
the current loan facilities in the last quarter of 2026. The
Directors are currently assessing this keeping in mind that they
have to act in the best interest of the Group.
Continuing and foremost amongst
the near-term risks faced by the Group, is the successful emergence
from restructuring of Thai Airways and the recovery from Covid
related restrictions to Thai's tourist economy. So far, the news
from Thai Airways has been positive. The Directors note that whilst
they believe that Thai Airways is currently in a good position to
exit rehabilitation, there is no guarantee of this. The Directors
continue to monitor the developments of the rehabilitation process
and the impact on the Group. The Directors regularly consider and
assess the viability of the Company and take into account the
Company's current position and the potential impact of the
principal risks outlined below. The Directors have considered the
impact of the Russian invasion of Ukraine on the Group and other
emerging conflicts and have concluded that to date there has been
no material impact on the operations of the Group save for indirect
impacts such as rising fuel costs. Of note is that the Company's
aircraft currently operate in the Indo-Pacific region where there
are at present no overfly or other restrictions.
The Directors continue to consider
that an investment in the Company should be regarded as long term
in nature and is suitable only for sophisticated investors,
investment professionals, high net worth bodies corporate,
unincorporated associations and partnerships and trustees of high
value trusts and private clients (all of whom will invest through
brokers), in each case, who can bear the economic risk of a
substantial or entire loss of their investment and who can accept
that there may be limited liquidity in the shares.
The Directors consider that the
Notes to the Financial Statements are integral to the support of
the Viability Statement.
DIRECTORS' REPORT (CONTINUED)
Annual General
Meeting
The next AGM of the Company will
be held in Guernsey at a date that will be communicated in the
future at East Wing, Trafalgar Court, Les Banques, St Peter
Port, Guernsey. The meeting will be held to, inter alia; receive
the Annual Report and Audited Consolidated Financial Statements;
elect and re-elect Directors; propose the reappointment of the
auditor; authorise the Directors to determine the auditor's
remuneration; approve the Directors' remuneration policy; authorise
the Company to issue and allot new shares and approve a partial
disapplication of the pre-emption rights to allow the Company to
issue new shares by way of tap issues. Shareholders are encouraged
to vote in advance by proxy. The formal notice of AGM will be
issued to shareholders in due course.
The Board continues to welcome
engagement with its shareholders and those who have questions
relating directly to the business of the AGM can forward their
questions to the Company Secretary by email to DPA@aztecgroup.co.uk
by no later than one week before the AGM. A Q&A reflecting the
questions received and responses provided will be made available on
the Company's website at www.dpaircraft.com as soon as practicable
following the AGM.
On 19 September 2023 at the
Company's last AGM, the following percentages of total votes cast
were cast against resolutions:
o 32.16% against resolution 2, (to approve the re-election of
Harald Brauns);
o 36.65% against resolution 4, (to approve the Directors'
remuneration report);
o 73.21% against resolution 5, (to approve the Directors'
remuneration policy);
o 32.27% against resolution 7, (to authorise Directors to allot
and issue up to 10% of ordinary shares in issue); and
o 32.27% against resolution 8, (to authorise Directors to allot
and issue a further 10% of ordinary shares in issue).
The Company noted it would reflect
and continue to consult with shareholders in this
respect.
The Company has subsequently
discussed the matter with shareholders who wished to engage further
and following discussions with those shareholders, the matters
raised had been satisfactorily clarified and
resolved.
The Board is thankful to all
shareholders for their continuous support.
Corporate Governance
The Company is not required to
comply with any particular corporate governance codes in the UK or
Guernsey, but the Directors take corporate governance seriously and
will have regard to relevant corporate governance standards in
determining the Company's governance policies including without
limitation in relation to corporate reporting, risk management and
internal control procedures.
The Directors intend to comply,
and ensure that the Company complies, with any obligations under
the Companies (Guernsey) Law, 2008 and the Articles to treat
shareholders fairly as between themselves.
Directors' Share Dealings
The Board has agreed to adopt and
implement the Market Abuse Regulation for Directors' dealings. The
Board will be responsible for taking all proper and reasonable
steps to ensure compliance with the Market Abuse
Regulation.
DIRECTORS' REPORT (CONTINUED)
Board Committees
The Board of Directors has
established an audit committee, which operates under detailed terms
of reference, copies of which are available on request from the
Company Secretary. Details of the Company Secretary are included
within the Company information on page 79.
The Board have established a
Management Engagement Committee which reviewed the performance of
the Asset Manager and the key service providers at least annually
and this review includes a consideration of the service providers'
internal controls, risk management, operational management,
information technology and their effectiveness.
Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive
('AIFMD')
In July 2013 the European
Alternative Investment Fund Management Directive ('AIFMD') came
into effect with transitional provisions until July 2014. The
Company has been determined to be a 'self-managed' Guernsey
Alternative Investment Fund ('AIF') and as such will be treated as
a non-EU AIFM for the purposes of the Directive. The Company has
registered with the Financial Conduct Authority (and notified the
Guernsey Financial Services Commission) under the AIFMD (Marketing)
Rules, 2013.
For a non-EU AIFM that has over
EUR 100 million (equivalent to US$ 107 million at 31 December 2023)
of net assets under management and also utilises leverage, certain
Annual Investor Disclosures are required.
For the purpose of AIFMD, the
Company is a Self-Managed Alternative Investment Fund Manager with
assets above the EUR 100 million (equivalent to US$ 107 million at
31 December 2023), with leverage, threshold.
AIFMD does not prescribe use of
any one particular accounting standard. However, the financial
statements must be audited by an auditor empowered by law to audit
the accounts in accordance with the EU Statutory Audit
Directive.
The required disclosures for
investors are contained within the Financial Conduct Authority
checklist and the Company's compliance therewith can be found in
Appendix 1 to these financial statements.
Environmental, social and governance
(ESG)
The Group recognises the Paris
Agreement on climate change. The Group operates NTA ('New
Technology Aircraft'); specifically Boeing 787-8's equipped with
Rolls Royce Trent-1000 engines which are 20% more fuel efficient on
a revenue-per-kilometre basis than similar comparable current
technology legacy aircraft. The Board continue to implement steps
to reduce its own travelling and maximises the use of virtual
meetings within the Board and with all its key service
providers.
Jonathan Bridel
Jeremy Thompson
Director
Director
25 April
2024
25 April 2024
REPORT OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE
On the following pages, we present
the Audit Committee (the 'Committee') Report for 2023, setting out
the Committee's structure and composition, principal duties and key
activities during the year. The Committee has reviewed the
Company's financial reporting, the independence and effectiveness
of the independent auditor (the 'auditor') and the internal control
and risk management systems of service providers.
The Board is satisfied that for
the period under review and thereafter the Committee has recent and
relevant commercial and financial knowledge sufficient to satisfy
the requirements of the Committee's remit.
Structure and Composition
The Committee is chaired by Mr
Thompson and its other members are Mr Bridel and Mr
Brauns.
The Committee conducts formal
meetings not less than three times a year. There were four meetings
during the period under review and multiple ad-hoc meetings. All
Directors were present and forming part of the quorum. The auditor
is invited to attend those meetings at which the annual and interim
reports are considered.
Principal Duties
The role of the Committee
includes:
·
Monitoring the integrity of the published
financial statements of the Group;
·
Keeping under review the consistency and
appropriateness of accounting policies on a year to
year basis;
·
Satisfying itself that the annual financial
statements, the interim statement of financial results and any
other major financial statements issued by the Group follow
International Financial Reporting Standards and give a true and
fair view of the Group and its subsidiaries' affairs; matters
raised by the external auditors about any aspect of the financial
statements or of the Group's internal control, are appropriately
considered and, if necessary, brought to the attention of the
Board, for resolution;
·
Monitoring and reviewing the quality and
effectiveness of the auditor and their independence;
·
Considering and making recommendations to the
Board on the appointment, reappointment, replacement and
remuneration of the Group's auditor;
·
Monitoring and reviewing the internal control and
risk management systems of the service providers; and
·
Considering at least once a year whether there is
a need for an internal audit function.
The complete details of the
Committee's formal duties and responsibilities are set out in the
Committee's terms of reference, a copy of which can be obtained
from the Secretary.
Independent Auditor
The Committee is also the forum
through which the auditor reports to the Board of Directors. The
Committee reviews the scope and results of the audit, its cost
effectiveness and the independence and objectivity of the auditor,
with particular regard to the terms under which it is appointed to
perform non-audit services including fees. The Committee has
established pre-approval policies and procedures for the engagement
of KPMG Channel Islands Limited ('KPMG') to provide non-audit
services.
In order to align the Company's
auditing arrangements with the location of its business, the Board
have changed the KPMG entity which undertakes the Company's audit
during the year. As a consequence, KPMG Channel Islands Limited has
assumed the role of independent auditor for the year ended 31
December 2023 and has replaced KPMG Ireland.
REPORT OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE (CONTINUED)
Independent Auditor
The audit fees proposed by the
auditor each year are reviewed by the Committee taking into account
the Group's structure, operations and other requirements during the
year and the Committee make appropriate recommendations to the
Board. The Committee considers KPMG Channel Islands Limited to be
independent of the Company. The Committee also met with the
external auditors without the Asset Manager or Administrator being
present so as to provide a forum to raise any matters of concern in
confidence.
Evaluations or Assessments made during the
year
The following sections discuss the
assessments made by the Committee during the year:
Significant Areas of Focus
for the Financial Statements
The Committee's review of the
interim and annual financial statements focused on:
·
Valuation of the Company's Assets (more detail in
relation to the approach is in note 3);
·
Assessing straight lining lease asset for
impairment;
·
Considering the accounting treatment of the loan
modification and its associated adjustment;
·
The financial statements giving a true and fair
view and being prepared in accordance with International Financial
Reporting Standards and the Companies (Guernsey) Law, 2008;
and
·
Going concern and the viability statement
review.
Effectiveness of the
Audit
The Committee had formal meetings
with KPMG during the period under review:
·
Before the start of the audit to discuss formal
planning, discuss any potential issues and agree the scope that
will be covered; and
·
After the audit work was concluded to discuss any
significant matters such as those stated above.
·
The Board considered the effectiveness and
independence of KPMG by using a number of measures, including but
not limited to:
·
The audit plan presented to them before the start
of the audit;
·
The audit results report;
·
Changes to audit personnel;
·
The auditor's own internal procedures to identify
threats to independence; and
·
Feedback from both the Asset Manager and
Administrator.
Internal
Audit
There is no internal audit
function. As all of the Directors are non-executive and all of the
Company's administration functions have been delegated to
independent third parties, the Audit Committee considers that there
is no need for the Company to have an internal audit function.
However, this matter is reviewed periodically.
Conclusion and Recommendation
After reviewing various reports
such as the operation and risk management framework and performance
reports from the Directors and the Asset Manager and assessing the
significant areas of focus for the financial statements listed on
pages 49 to 52, the Committee is satisfied that the financial
statements appropriately address the critical judgements and key
estimates (both in respect to the amounts reported and the
disclosures).
REPORT OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE (CONTINUED)
Conclusion and Recommendation (continued)
The Committee is also satisfied
that the significant assumptions used for assessing going concern
and, determining the value of assets and liabilities have been
appropriately scrutinised, challenged and are sufficiently robust.
The independent auditor reported to the Committee that no material
misstatements were found in the course of its work. Furthermore,
the Administrator confirmed to the Committee that they were not
aware of any material misstatements including matters relating to
presentation. The Committee confirms that it is satisfied that the
independent auditor has fulfilled its responsibilities with
diligence and professional scepticism. Following the completion of
the financial statements review process on the effectiveness of the
independent audit and the review of audit services, the Committee
will recommend that KPMG be reappointed at the next Annual General
Meeting.
For any questions on the
activities of the Committee not addressed in the foregoing, a
member of the Committee will attend each Annual General Meeting to
respond to such questions.
By order of the Audit
Committee
Jeremy Thompson
Audit Committee Chairman
25 April 2024
STATEMENT OF PRINCIPAL RISKS AND
UNCERTAINTIES
Geopolitical and economic risks
The Company leases aircraft to a
customer in Thailand exposing it to (i) Thailand's varying
economic, social, legal and geopolitical risks, (ii) instability of
Thailand markets and (iii) the impact of global health pandemics
and other global market disruptions. Exposure to Thailand's
jurisdiction may adversely affect the Company's future performance,
position and growth potential if Thailand's economy does not
perform well or if laws and regulations that have an adverse impact
on the aviation industry are passed in Thailand. The adequacy and
timeliness of the Company's response to emerging risks in this
jurisdiction is of critical importance to the mitigation of their
potential impact on the Company.
The Geopolitical risk surrounding
the Russian invasion of Ukraine and ongoing conflict in the Middle
East and the subsequent consequences have the potential to
impact travel and/or travellers' willingness to travel which in
turn could affect the volume of traffic to and from Thailand. The
Thai government led by PM Thavisin and the return from exile of
former PM Thaksin provides an unknown backdrop in terms of
political stability. However, it is clear though that tourism is a
major part of the Thai economy.
Exposure to the commercial airline industry
As a supplier to and partner of
the airline industry, the Group is exposed to the financial
condition of the airline industry as it leases its aircraft to
commercial airline customers. The financial condition of the
airline industry is affected by, among other things, geopolitical
events, outbreaks of communicable pandemic diseases and natural
disasters, fuel costs and the demand for air travel. To the extent
that any of these factors adversely affect the airline industry
they may result in (i) downward pressure on lease rates and
aircraft values, (ii) higher incidences of lessee defaults,
restructuring, and repossessions and (iii) inability to lease
aircraft on commercially acceptable terms.
Thai Airways
Thai went into debt rehabilitation
on 27 May 2020, and the business rehabilitation plan was approved
on 15 June 2021, by the Central Bankruptcy Court of Thailand. There
is risk that the business rehabilitation plan does not achieve the
desired results, and this could have an adverse impact on the
entity's lease arrangements, with Thai Airways which is the core
source of income for the Group.
Thai is under the contractual
obligation to return the aircraft in full life condition. The
additional requirement to cash collateralize the obligation by
payment of Maintenance Reserves was waived in the novated lease
agreement.
This leaves the company with the
risk that in case of a Thai default under the lease the aircraft
may not be returned in a full life status.
In addition, the continuing impact
of COVID-19 and the conflict between Russia and Ukraine has the
potential to impact Thai's business rehabilitation plan and
adversely impact the Group. This is particularly relevant for the
Group given the aircraft leased to Thai Airways are the sole source
of income for the Group.
Asset risk
The Company's Assets as at year
end comprise of two Boeing 787-8 aircraft. The Group bears the risk
of selling or re-leasing the aircraft in its fleet at the end of
their lease terms or if the lease is terminated. If demand for
aircraft decreases market lease rates may fall, and should such
conditions continue for an extended period, it could affect the
market value of aircraft in the fleet and may result in an
impairment charge. The Directors have engaged an asset manager with
appropriate experience of the aviation industry to manage the fleet
and remarket or sell aircraft as required to reduce and address
this risk. Any lasting impact of the COVID-19 situation on both
aircraft demand and lease rates are at present unknown.
STATEMENT OF PRINCIPAL RISKS AND UNCERTAINTIES
(CONTINUED)
Asset risk (continued)
The Company's Assets as at year
end comprise of two Boeing 787-8 aircraft. The Group bears the risk
of selling or re-leasing the aircraft in its fleet at the end of
their lease terms or if the lease is terminated. If demand for
aircraft decreases market lease rates may fall, and should such
conditions continue for an extended period, it could affect the
market value of aircraft in the fleet and may result in an
impairment charge. The Directors have engaged an asset manager with
appropriate experience of the aviation industry to manage the fleet
and remarket or sell aircraft as required to reduce and address
this risk. Any lasting impact of the COVID-19 situation on both
aircraft demand and lease rates are at present unknown.
There is no guarantee that, upon
expiry or cessation of the leases, the Assets could be sold or
re-leased for an amount that would enable shareholders to realise a
capital profit on their investment or to avoid a loss. Costs
regarding any future re-leasing of the assets would depend upon
various economic factors and would be determinable only upon an
individual re-leasing event. Potential reconfiguration costs could
in certain circumstances be substantial.
Key personnel risk
The ability of the Company to
achieve its investment objective is significantly dependent upon
the advice of certain key personnel at its Asset Manager DS
Aviation GmbH & Co. KG; there is no guarantee that such
personnel will be available to provide services to the Company for
the scheduled term of the Leases or following the termination of
the Lease. However, Key Man clauses within the Asset Management
agreement do provide a base line level of protection against this
risk.
Credit risk & Counterparty risk
Credit risk is the risk that a
significant counterparty will default on its contractual
obligations. The Group's most significant counterparty is Thai
Airways as lessee and provider of income and DekaBank Deutsche
Girozentrale ('DekaBank') as holder of the Group's cash and
restricted cash. The lessee does not maintain a credit rating. Thai
Airways is currently in the early stages of implementing a
rehabilitation plan. The Moody's credit rating of DekaBank is Aa2
(2022: Aa2).
There is no guarantee that the
business rehabilitation process of Thai Airways will continue to be
successful even though developments to date have been positive.
Failure of any material part of the business rehabilitation plan
may have an adverse impact on Thai's ability to comply with its
obligations under the LOI entered into during March 2021 and the
subsequent amended lease agreement entered into in 2022.
Any failure by Thai Airways to pay
any amounts when due could have an adverse effect on the Group's
ability to comply with its obligations under the DekaBank loan
agreements and could result in the lenders enforcing their security
and selling the relevant Assets on the market, potentially
negatively impacting the returns to investors. Thai Airways is
however an international full-service carrier and is important to
Thailand's economy and as such it is unlikely that the government
will not provide it with the necessary support to see it through
its restructure. There is no guarantee and hence a significant risk
remains.
Refinancing risk
The Group is required to present a
plan for refinancing or similar to the lenders before the expiry of
the current loan facilities in the last quarter of 2026. There is a
risk that the Group will not be able to replace the DekaBank debt
obligation with new debt before the expiry of the current loan
facilities. If not able to refinance, the Group would have to
dispose the aircraft to settle the loan and there is no guarantee
that the Assets could be sold for an amount that would enable
shareholders to realise a capital profit on their investment or to
avoid a loss.
STATEMENT OF PRINCIPAL RISKS AND UNCERTAINTIES
(CONTINUED)
Liquidity risk
In order to finance the purchase
of the Assets, the Group entered into loan agreements. Pursuant to
the loan agreements, the lenders are given first ranking security
over the Assets. Under the provisions of each of the loan
agreements, the Borrowers are required to comply with loan
covenants and undertakings. A failure to comply with such covenants
or undertakings may result in the relevant lenders recalling the
relevant loan. In such circumstances, the Group may be required to
remarket the relevant Asset (either sell or enter into a subsequent
lease) to repay the outstanding relevant loan and/or re-negotiate
the loan terms with the relevant lender. With respect to working
capital, the Company intends to raise additional finance in Q3 2024
as stated in the going concern section on page 31.
Cyber risk
The Group relies on its key third
party service providers' cyber security measures including
firewalls, encryption protocols, employee training programs and
regular security assessments to safeguard the Group's data and
records from unauthorized access and harmful exploitations. The
Management Engagement Committee receives annual confirmation from
all its third parties service providers to ensure that controls
over cyber security and IT infrastructure are in place.
Boeing
The Company is exposed to Boeing
being able to resolve any identified 787 related problems which the
FAA or other regulatory bodies designate as restricting commercial
operations. At present no such restrictions exist. The 787 is
considered a latest generation aircraft type which has pioneered
areas including the extensive use of carbon fibre in its fuselage
and wing construction.
Rolls Royce
The Company has exposure to Rolls
Royce as suppliers of the Trent 1000 engines in terms of ongoing
support. Announcements by RR have implied that the low-pressure
turbine (LPT) and other known previous engine performance issues
have been resolved. The Trent 1000 is a highly fuel-efficient
engine, representing the latest engine technology. As such the
Company is exposed to any future as yet unknown performance issues.
This situation is partially mitigated by Thai using Rolls Royce
Total Care and by the Asset Manager having oversight of performance
issues from both physical and desktop checks.
STATEMENT OF DIRECTORS' RESPONSIBILITIES
Statement of directors' responsibilities
The directors are responsible for
preparing the Directors' Annual Report and the financial statements
in accordance with applicable law and regulations.
Company law requires the directors
to prepare financial statements for each financial year. Under that
law they have elected to prepare the financial statements in
accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards as
issued by the IASB and applicable law.
The financial statements are
required by law to give a true and fair view of the state of
affairs of the Group and of the profit or loss of the Group for
that period.
In preparing these financial
statements, the directors are required to:
Under company law the directors
must not approve the financial statements unless they are satisfied
that they give a true and fair view of the state of affairs of the
Group and of its profit or loss for that period. In preparing
these financial statements, the directors are required
to:
§ select
suitable accounting policies and then apply them
consistently;
§ make
judgements and estimates that are reasonable, relevant and
reliable; and prudent;
§ state
whether applicable accounting standards have been followed, subject
to any material departures disclosed and explained in the financial
statements;
§ assess
the Group's ability to continue as a going concern, disclosing, as
applicable, matters related to going concern; and
§ use the
going concern basis of accounting unless they either intend to
liquidate the Group or to cease operations or have no realistic
alternative but to do so.
The directors are responsible for
keeping proper accounting records that are sufficient to show and
explain the Group's transactions and disclose with reasonable
accuracy at any time the financial position of the Group and enable
them to ensure that its financial statements comply with the
Companies (Guernsey) Law, 2008. which disclose with reasonable
accuracy at any time the financial position of the Group and enable
them to ensure that the financial statements comply with the
Companies (Guernsey) Law, 2008. They are responsible for such
internal control as they determine is necessary to enable the
preparation of financial statements that are free from material
misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, and have general
responsibility for taking such steps as are reasonably open to them
to safeguard the assets of the Group and to prevent and detect
fraud and other irregularities.
The directors are responsible for
the maintenance and integrity of the corporate and financial
information included on the Group's website, and for the
preparation and dissemination of financial statements. Legislation
in Guernsey governing the preparation and dissemination of
financial statements may differ from legislation in other
jurisdictions.
STATEMENT OF DIRECTORS' RESPONSIBILITIES
(CONTINUED)
Statement of directors' responsibilities
(Continued)
The Directors who hold office at
the date of approval of this Director's Report confirm that so far
as they are aware, there is no relevant audit information of which
the Group's auditor is unaware, and that each Director
has taken all the steps he ought
to have taken as a director to make himself aware of any relevant
audit information and to establish that the Group's auditor is
aware of that information.
Responsibility statement of the directors in respect of the
annual financial report
We confirm that to the best of our
knowledge:
•
the financial statements, prepared in accordance with the
applicable set of accounting standards, give a true and fair view
of the assets, liabilities, financial position and profit or loss
of the Group; and
•
the annual report includes a fair review of the development and
performance of the business and the position of the issuer,
together with a description of the principal risks and
uncertainties that they face.
Signed on behalf of the Board
by
Jonathan Bridel
Jeremy Thompson
Director
Director
25 April
2024
25 April 2024
INDEPENDENT AUDITOR'S REPORT TO THE MEMBERS OF DP AIRCRAFT I
LIMITED
Our opinion is
unmodified
We have audited the
consolidated financial statements of DP Aircraft I
Limited (the "Company") and its subsidiaries (together, the
"Group"), which comprise the consolidated statement of financial
position as at 31 December 2023, the consolidated statements
of comprehensive income, changes in equity and cash flows for the
year then ended, and notes, comprising material accounting policies
and other explanatory information.
In our opinion, the accompanying
consolidated financial statements:
·
give a true and fair view of the financial
position of the Group as at 31 December 2023, and of the Group's
financial performance and cash flows for the year then
ended;
·
are prepared in accordance
with International Financial Reporting Standards ("IFRS");
and
·
comply with the Companies (Guernsey) Law,
2008.
Basis for opinion
We conducted our audit in
accordance with International Standards on Auditing (UK) ("ISAs
(UK)") and applicable law. Our responsibilities are described
below. We have fulfilled our ethical responsibilities under, and
are independent of the Company and Group in accordance with,
UK ethical requirements including the FRC Ethical Standard as
required by the Crown Dependencies' Audit Rules and Guidance. We
believe that the audit evidence we have obtained is a sufficient
and appropriate basis for our opinion.
Material uncertainty relating to
going concern
Going concern
|
The risk
|
Our response
|
We draw
attention to note 2a to the consolidated financial statements which
indicates that the Group's current cash flow forecasts demonstrate
that the Group has sufficient cash to cover operating costs for a
period of at least twelve months from the date of approval of the
Group's consolidated financial statements. Should a plausible
downside scenario occur, additional finance will be required to
provide sufficient funding to the Group's operating activities.
Therefore the Company will look to raise additional capital in Q3
2024 (the "capital raise").
These events and conditions, along
with the other matters explained in note 2a, constitute a material
uncertainty that may cast significant doubt on the Group's ability
to continue as a going concern.
|
Disclosure quality
The
consolidated financial statements explain how the Board has formed
a judgement that it is appropriate to adopt the going concern basis
of preparation for the Group.
That
judgement is based on an evaluation of the inherent risks to the
Group's business model and how those risks might affect the Group's
financial resources or ability to continue operations over a period
of at least twelve months from the date of approval of the Group's
financial statements, in particular in relation to the extent of
additional funding that may be required in order to meet
obligations as they fall due.
The risk
for our audit is whether such judgements amounted to a material
uncertainty that may cast significant doubt on the ability of the
Group to continue as a going concern. If so, that fact is required
to be disclosed (as has been done) and along with a description of
the circumstances, is a key financial statement
disclosure.
|
Our audit
procedures included but were not limited too:
Review of
the Group's going concern assessment:
We
evaluated the Group's going concern assessment and performed
inquiries of the Board of Directors to understand the key
judgements made.
We
assessed the Group's cash-flow forecast and agreed inputs to
supporting documentation, as appropriate. We assessed the level of
forecast expenses against expenses historically incurred. This cash
flow forecast takes into consideration the deferral of Asset
Manager fees, broker fees and Directors' fees. We have obtained
confirmation to support the deferral of these fees.
Since the
Group also relies on the timely receipt of lease rental income from
Thai Airways, we held inquiries with the Asset Manager and the
Board of Directors to assess the likelihood that Thai Airways
continues to meet the contractually agreed rental payments on time.
We inspected correspondence received by the Group from Thai
Airways. We agreed the payments made by Thai Airways during the
year and post year end to the Group's bank statements.
Assessing
disclosures:
We considered whether adequate
disclosures have been made in relation to material uncertainties
relating to going concern included in note 2a to the consolidated
financial statements, including the identified risks and
dependencies.
|
INDEPENDENT AUDITOR'S REPORT TO THE MEMBERS OF DP AIRCRAFT I
LIMITED (CONTINUED)
Key audit matters: our assessment
of the risks of material misstatement
Key audit matters are those matters
that, in our professional judgment, were of most significance in
the audit of the consolidated financial statements and include
the most significant assessed risks of material misstatement
(whether or not due to fraud) identified by us, including those
which had the greatest effect on: the overall audit strategy; the
allocation of resources in the audit; and directing the efforts of
the engagement team. Going concern is a significant key audit
matter and is described in the 'Material uncertainty relating to
going concern' section of our report. These matters were addressed
in the context of our audit of the consolidated financial
statements as a whole, and in forming our opinion thereon, and we
do not provide a separate opinion on these matters. In
arriving at our audit opinion above, the other key
audit matter was as follows (unchanged from 2022):
|
The risk
|
Our response
|
Valuation
of PPE - Aircraft & Related Components (the
"Assets")
$124.1
million (2022: $125.5 million)
Refer to
pages 38-39 of the Audit Committee, note 2c accounting policy and
notes 3 and 9 disclosures
|
Basis:
IAS 36
'Impairment of Assets' requires that assets are assessed for
impairment on at least an annual basis including management's
estimate of the recoverable amount.
The
standard requires that for all assets in scope at the end of the
reporting period, an entity assess whether there is any indication
that an asset may be impaired and, where such indications exist,
the recoverable amount of the asset is estimated.
Risk:
The
carrying value of the Assets, due to the estimation uncertainty
involved, and their magnitude in the context of the consolidated
financial statements as a whole, is considered to be the area which
has the greatest effect on our overall strategy and allocation of
resources in planning and completing the audit.
|
Our audit
procedures included but were not limited to:
Internal
Controls:
We
assessed the design and implementation of the key control over the
Assets' valuation.
Challenging management's method, assumptions and
inputs:
We
assessed the consistency of the method applied in the Group's
impairment assessment with the approach outlined in the Group's
accounting policy and the requirements of IFRS.
With
regard to the reports of the two independent professional
appraisers engaged by the Group (the "Appraisers"), we
· assessed the
reasonableness of the current market values included in the
impairment assessment by obtaining and inspecting the reports of
the Appraisers;
· assessed the
Appraisers' competence, capabilities and objectivity;
· performed
inquiries with the Appraisers and management to understand key
judgements made;
· compared the
current market values included in the impairment assessment to the
reports prepared by the Appraisers.
We
recalculated the carrying value of the Assets and compared to the
recoverable amount in the impairment assessment prepared by
management.
Assessing
Disclosures:
We also
considered the Group's disclosures (see notes 3 and note 9) in
relation to the use of judgements and estimates regarding the
determination of the carrying value of the Assets and the Group's
measurement policies adopted in note 2c for compliance with
IFRS.
|
INDEPENDENT AUDITOR'S REPORT TO THE MEMBERS OF DP AIRCRAFT I
LIMITED (CONTINUED)
Our application of materiality and an
overview of the scope of our audit
Materiality for
the consolidated financial statements as a whole was set at
$1,150,000, determined with reference to a benchmark of group total
assets of $150,864,020, of which it represents approximately
0.75% (2022: 0.75%).
In line with our audit methodology,
our procedures on individual account balances and disclosures were
performed to a lower threshold, performance materiality, so as to
reduce to an acceptable level the risk that individually immaterial
misstatements in individual account balances add up to a material
amount across the consolidated financial statements as a whole.
Performance materiality for the Group was set at 75% (2022: 75%) of
materiality for the consolidated financial statements as a whole,
which equates to $862,000. We applied this percentage in our
determination of performance materiality because we did not
identify any factors indicating an elevated level of
risk.
We reported to the Audit Committee
any corrected or uncorrected identified misstatements exceeding
$57,500, in addition to other identified misstatements that
warranted reporting on qualitative grounds.
Our audit of the Group was
undertaken to the materiality level specified above, which has
informed our identification of significant risks of material
misstatement and the associated audit procedures performed in those
areas as detailed above.
The group team performed the audit
of the Group as if it was a single aggregated set of financial
information. The audit was performed using the materiality level
set out above and covered 100% of total group revenue, total group
profit before tax, and total group assets and
liabilities.
Going concern
The directors have prepared the
consolidated financial statements on the going concern basis as
they do not intend to liquidate the Group or the Company or to
cease their operations, and as they have concluded that the Group
and the Company's financial position means that this is realistic.
They have concluded that there are material uncertainties that
could have cast significant doubt over their ability to continue as
a going concern for at least a year from the date of approval of
the consolidated financial statements (the "going concern
period").
An explanation of how we evaluated
management's assessment of going concern is set out in the
"Material uncertainty relating to going concern" section of our
report.
Our conclusions based on this
work:
·
we consider that the directors' use of the going
concern basis of accounting in the preparation of the consolidated
financial statements is appropriate; and
·
we have nothing material to add or draw attention
to in relation to the directors' statement in note 2a to the
consolidated financial statements on the use of the going concern
basis of accounting, and their identification therein of a material
uncertainty over the Group's ability to continue to use that basis
for the going concern period, and found the going concern
disclosure in note 2a to be acceptable.
However, as we cannot predict all
future events or conditions and as subsequent events may result in
outcomes that are inconsistent with judgements that were reasonable
at the time they were made, the above conclusions are not a
guarantee that the Group and the Company will continue in
operation.
INDEPENDENT AUDITOR'S REPORT TO THE MEMBERS OF DP AIRCRAFT I
LIMITED (CONTINUED)
Fraud and breaches of laws and regulations -
ability to detect
Identifying and responding to risks of
material misstatement due to fraud
To identify risks of material
misstatement due to fraud ("fraud risks") we assessed events or
conditions that could indicate an incentive or pressure to commit
fraud or provide an opportunity to commit fraud. Our risk
assessment procedures included:
·
enquiring of management as to the Group's
policies and procedures to prevent and detect fraud as well as
enquiring whether management have knowledge of any actual,
suspected or alleged fraud;
·
reading minutes of meetings of those charged with
governance; and
·
using analytical procedures to identify any
unusual or unexpected relationships.
As required by auditing standards,
we perform procedures to address the risk of management override of
controls, in particular the risk that management may be in a
position to make inappropriate accounting entries. On this audit we
do not believe there is a fraud risk related to revenue recognition
because the Group's revenue streams are simple in nature with
respect to accounting policy choice, and are easily verifiable to
external data sources or agreements with little or no requirement
for estimation from management. We did not identify any additional
fraud risks.
We performed procedures
including
·
Identifying journal entries and other adjustments
to test based on risk criteria and comparing any identified entries
to supporting documentation; and
·
incorporating an element of unpredictability in
our audit procedures.
Identifying and responding to risks of
material misstatement due to non-compliance with laws and
regulations
We identified areas of laws and
regulations that could reasonably be expected to have a material
effect on the consolidated financial statements from our sector
experience and through discussion with management (as required by
auditing standards), and from inspection of the Group's regulatory
and legal correspondence, if any,
and discussed with management the
policies and procedures regarding compliance with laws and
regulations. As the Group is regulated, our assessment of risks
involved gaining an understanding of the control environment
including the entity's procedures for complying with regulatory
requirements.
The Group is subject to laws and
regulations that directly affect the consolidated financial
statements including financial reporting legislation and taxation
legislation and we assessed the extent of compliance with these
laws and regulations as part of our procedures on the related
financial statement items.
The Group is subject to other laws
and regulations where the consequences of non-compliance could have
a material effect on amounts or disclosures in the consolidated
financial statements, for instance through the imposition of fines
or litigation or impacts on the Group and the Company's ability to
operate. We identified financial services regulation as being the
area most likely to have such an effect, recognising the regulated
nature of the Group's activities and its legal form. Auditing
standards limit the required audit procedures to identify
non-compliance with these laws and regulations to enquiry of
management and inspection of regulatory and legal correspondence,
if any. Therefore if a breach of operational regulations is not
disclosed to us or evident from relevant correspondence, an audit
will not detect that breach.
INDEPENDENT AUDITOR'S REPORT TO THE MEMBERS OF DP AIRCRAFT I
LIMITED (CONTINUED)
Context of the ability of the audit to detect
fraud or breaches of law or regulation
Owing to the inherent limitations
of an audit, there is an unavoidable risk that we may not have
detected some material misstatements in the consolidated financial
statements, even though we have properly planned and performed our
audit in accordance with auditing standards. For example, the
further removed non-compliance with laws and regulations is from
the events and transactions reflected in the consolidated financial
statements, the less likely the inherently limited procedures
required by auditing standards would identify it.
In addition, as with any audit,
there remains a higher risk of non-detection of fraud, as this may
involve collusion, forgery, intentional omissions,
misrepresentations, or the override of internal controls. Our audit
procedures are designed to detect material misstatement. We are not
responsible for preventing non-compliance or fraud and cannot be
expected to detect non-compliance with all laws and
regulations.
Other information
The directors are responsible
for the other information. The other information comprises the
information included in the Annual Report but does not
include the consolidated financial statements and our
auditor's report thereon. Our opinion on the consolidated financial
statements does not cover the other information and we do not
express an audit opinion or any form of assurance conclusion
thereon.
In connection with our audit of
the consolidated financial statements, our responsibility is
to read the other information and, in doing so, consider whether
the other information is materially inconsistent with the
consolidated financial statements or our knowledge obtained in
the audit, or otherwise appears to be materially
misstated. If, based on the work we have performed, we
conclude that there is a material misstatement of this other
information, we are required to report that fact. We have nothing
to report in this regard.
We have nothing to report on other matters on
which we are required to report by exception
We have nothing to report in
respect of the following matters where the Companies (Guernsey)
Law, 2008 requires us to report to you if, in our
opinion:
·
the Company has not kept proper accounting
records; or
·
the consolidated financial statements are
not in agreement with the accounting records; or
·
we have not received all the information and
explanations, which to the best of our knowledge and belief are
necessary for the purpose of our audit.
Respective responsibilities
Directors' responsibilities
As explained more fully in their
statement set out on pages 41 and 42, the directors are
responsible for: the preparation of the consolidated financial
statements including being satisfied that they give a true and fair
view; such internal control as they determine is necessary to
enable the preparation of consolidated financial statements
that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or
error; assessing the Group and Company's ability to continue as a
going concern, disclosing, as applicable, matters related to going
concern; and using the going concern basis of accounting unless
they either intend to liquidate the Group or the Company or to
cease operations, or have no realistic alternative but to do
so.
INDEPENDENT AUDITOR'S REPORT TO THE MEMBERS OF DP AIRCRAFT I
LIMITED (CONTINUED)
Auditor's responsibilities
Our objectives are to obtain
reasonable assurance about whether the consolidated financial
statements as a whole are free from material misstatement, whether
due to fraud or error, and to issue our opinion in an auditor's
report. Reasonable assurance is a high level of assurance, but does
not guarantee that an audit conducted in accordance with ISAs (UK)
will always detect a material misstatement when it exists.
Misstatements can arise from fraud or error and are considered
material if, individually or in aggregate, they could reasonably be
expected to influence the economic decisions of users taken on the
basis of the consolidated financial statements.
A fuller
description of our responsibilities is provided on the FRC's
website at www.frc.org.uk/auditorsresponsibilities.
The purpose of this report and restrictions
on its use by persons other than the Company's members, as a
body
This report is made solely to the
Company's members, as a body, in accordance with section 262 of the
Companies (Guernsey) Law, 2008. Our audit work has been
undertaken so that we might state to the Company's members
those matters we are required to state to them in an auditor's
report and for no other purpose. To the fullest extent permitted by
law, we do not accept or assume responsibility to anyone other than
the Company and the Company's members, as a body, for our
audit work, for this report, or for the opinions we have
formed.
Fiona Babbe
For and on behalf of KPMG Channel
Islands Limited
Chartered Accountants and
Recognised Auditors
Guernsey
25 April 2024
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF COMPREHENSIVE
INCOME
For the year ended 31 December
2023
|
|
Year ended
|
Year ended
|
|
|
31 Dec
2023
|
31 Dec
2022
|
|
Notes
|
US$
|
US$
|
Income
|
|
|
|
Lease rental income
|
4
|
8,714,249
|
16,462,372
|
Expenses
|
|
|
|
Asset management fees
|
22
|
(450,890)
|
(471,590)
|
General and administrative
expenses
|
5
|
(1,129,640)
|
(1,094,587)
|
Expected credit gain/(loss) on
straight lining lease
asset
|
11
|
383,199
|
(1,486,453)
|
Expected credit loss write
off
|
11
|
-
|
(105,063)
|
Depreciation
|
9
|
(1,343,498)
|
(958,760)
|
|
|
(2,540,829)
|
(4,116,453)
|
|
|
|
|
Operating profit
|
|
6,173,420
|
12,345,919
|
|
|
|
|
Finance costs
|
6
|
(9,551,675)
|
(4,860,305)
|
Other Income
|
|
8,138
|
1,552
|
Finance income
|
|
860,827
|
194,906
|
Net
finance costs
|
|
(8,682,710)
|
(4,663,847)
|
|
|
|
|
(Loss)/profit before tax
|
|
(2,509,290)
|
7,682,072
|
|
|
|
|
Taxation
|
7
|
3,603
|
(21,249)
|
(Loss)/profit for the year
|
|
(2,505,687)
|
7,660,823
|
|
|
|
|
Total Comprehensive (Loss)/Income for the
year
|
|
(2,505,687)
|
7,660,823
|
|
|
|
|
(Loss)/Earnings per Share for the year - basic and
diluted
|
8
|
(0.01047)
|
0.03429
|
All income is attributable to the
Ordinary Shares of the Company.
The notes on pages 53 to 78 form
an integral part of these financial statements.
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL
POSITION
As at 31 December 2023
|
31 Dec
2023
|
31 Dec
2022
|
|
Notes
|
US$
|
US$
|
NON-CURRENT ASSETS
|
|
|
|
PPE- Aircraft & Related
Components
|
9
|
124,122,582
|
125,466,080
|
Trade and other
receivables
|
11
|
5,853,206
|
8,935,454
|
Restricted Cash
|
10
|
15,735,805
|
14,979,197
|
Total non-current assets
|
|
145,711,593
|
149,380,731
|
|
|
|
|
CURRENT ASSETS
|
|
|
|
Trade and other
receivables
|
11
|
3,144,163
|
3,857,514
|
Restricted cash
|
10
|
1,093,759
|
4,175,280
|
Cash and cash equivalents -
available for use
|
|
914,505
|
1,479,541
|
Total current assets
|
|
5,152,427
|
9,512,335
|
|
|
|
|
TOTAL ASSETS
|
|
150,864,020
|
158,893,066
|
|
|
|
|
EQUITY
|
|
|
|
Share Capital
|
15
|
211,279,828
|
211,279,828
|
Accumulated losses
|
16
|
(169,049,394)
|
(166,543,707)
|
TOTAL EQUITY
|
|
42,230,434
|
44,736,121
|
|
|
|
|
NON-CURRENT LIABILITIES
|
|
|
|
Bank borrowings
|
14
|
85,027,721
|
80,779,172
|
Maintenance provision
|
12
|
14,829,296
|
14,829,296
|
Total non-current liabilities
|
|
99,857,017
|
95,608,468
|
|
|
|
|
CURRENT LIABILITIES
|
|
|
|
Bank borrowings
|
14
|
7,684,502
|
17,707,184
|
Trade and other
payables
|
13
|
1,092,067
|
841,293
|
Total current liabilities
|
|
8,776,569
|
18,548,477
|
|
|
|
|
TOTAL LIABILITIES
|
|
108,633,586
|
114,156,945
|
|
|
|
|
TOTAL EQUITY AND LIABILITIES
|
150,864,020
|
158,893,066
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The financial statements on pages
49 to 78 were approved by the Board of Directors and were
authorised for issue on 25 April 2024. They were signed on its
behalf by:
The notes on pages 53 to 78 form
an integral part of these financial statements.
Jonathan Bridel
Jeremy
Thompson
Chairman
Director
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS
For the year ended 31 December
2023
|
|
Year ended
|
Year ended
|
|
Notes
|
31 Dec
2023
|
31 Dec
2022
|
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
|
|
|
|
(Loss)/profit for the
year
|
|
(2,505,687)
|
7,660,823
|
|
|
|
|
Adjusted for:
|
|
|
|
Depreciation and
amortisation
|
9
|
1,343,498
|
958,760
|
Finance costs
|
6
|
9,551,675
|
4,860,305
|
Taxation
|
7
|
(3,603)
|
21,249
|
Movement in straight lining lease
asset
|
11
|
3,486,794
|
(8,753,206)
|
Lease receivable written
off
|
11
|
-
|
105,063
|
Movement in expected credit loss on
straight lining lease
assset
|
11
|
(383,199)
|
1,486,453
|
Tax-paid
|
|
(11,086)
|
-
|
Changes in:
|
|
|
|
Increase in maintenance
reserves
|
12
|
-
|
368,614
|
Increase in trade and other
payables
|
13
|
265,462
|
192,312
|
Decrease/(increase) in trade and
other receivables
|
11
|
692,004
|
(607,766)
|
NET
CASH FLOW FROM OPERATING ACTIVITIES
|
12,435,858
|
6,292,607
|
|
|
|
|
INVESTING ACTIVITIES
|
|
|
|
Restricted cash
|
|
2,324,913
|
(1,900,631)
|
NET
CASH FLOW FROM / (USED IN) INVESTING ACTIVITIES
|
2,324,913
|
(1,900,631)
|
|
|
|
|
FINANCING ACTIVITIES
|
|
|
|
Share issue proceeds
Share issue costs
|
|
-
-
|
750,000
(26,824)
|
Bank loan principal
repaid
|
14
|
(9,556,363)
|
-
|
Bank loan interest paid
|
14
|
(5,769,445)
|
(4,814,822)
|
NET
CASH FLOW USED IN FINANCING ACTIVITIES
|
|
(15,325,808)
|
(4,091,646)
|
|
|
|
|
CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS AT BEGINNING OF
YEAR
|
|
1,479,541
|
1,179,211
|
(Decrease)/increase in cash and cash
equivalents
|
|
(565,036)
|
300,330
|
CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS AT END OF YEAR
|
|
914,505
|
1,479,541
|
The notes on pages 53 to 78 form
an integral part of these financial statements.
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN EQUITY
For the year ended 31 December
2023
|
|
|
Accumulated
|
Total
|
|
|
Share capital
|
losses
|
Equity
|
|
Note
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
|
|
|
|
|
As at 1 January 2023
|
15
|
211,279,828
|
(166,543,707)
|
44,736,121
|
Total comprehensive expenses for the year
|
|
|
|
Loss for the year
|
|
-
|
(2,505,687)
|
(2,505,687)
|
Total comprehensive expense
|
|
-
|
(2,505,687)
|
(2,505,687)
|
|
|
|
|
|
As
at 31 December 2023
|
|
211,279,828
|
(169,049,394)
|
42,230,434
|
|
|
|
|
|
As at 1 January 2022
|
|
210,556,652
|
(174,204,530)
|
36,352,122
|
|
|
|
|
|
Total comprehensive income for the year
|
|
|
|
Profit for the year
|
|
|
7,660,823
|
7,660,823
|
Total comprehensive income
|
|
-
|
7,660,823
|
7,660,823
|
Transactions with owners
Issue of ordinary shares
Share issue costs paid
|
15
|
750,000
(26,824)
|
-
-
|
750,000
(26,824)
|
As
at 31 December 2022
|
|
211,279,828
|
(166,543,707)
|
44,736,121
|
The notes on pages 53 to 78 form
an integral part of these financial statements.
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL
STATEMENTS
For the year ended 31 December
2023
1) GENERAL
INFORMATION
The consolidated audited financial
statements ('financial statements') incorporate the results of DP
Aircraft I Limited (the "Company") and that of wholly owned
subsidiary entities, DP Aircraft Guernsey III Limited, DP Aircraft
Guernsey IV Limited (collectively and hereinafter, the
'Borrowers'), each being a Guernsey incorporated company limited by
shares and one intermediate lessor company, DP Aircraft UK Limited
(the 'Lessor'), a UK incorporated private limited company
respectively. The Company and its subsidiaries (the Borrowers and
the Lessor) comprise together the "Group".
The Company was incorporated on 5
July 2013 with registered number 56941. The Company is admitted to
trading on the Specialist Fund Segment of the London Stock
Exchange.
The Company's investment objective
is to obtain income and capital returns for its shareholders by
acquiring, leasing and then, when the Board considers it
appropriate, selling aircraft.
The financial statements were
approved by the Board of Directors and authorised for issue on 25
April 2024.
2) MATERIAL ACCOUNTING POLICY
INFORMATION
a)
Basis of
preparation
These financial statements are
prepared in accordance with International Financial Reporting
Standards, International Accounting Standards and Interpretations
('IFRS') issued by the International Accounting Standards Board
('IASB') and the Disclosure Guidance and Transparency Rules (the
'DTRs') of the UK's Financial Conduct Authority (the
'FCA').
The preparation of financial
statements in accordance with IFRS requires the use of certain
critical accounting estimates. It also requires the Directors to
exercise judgement in applying the Company's accounting policies.
The areas where significant judgements and estimates have been made
in preparing the financial statements and their effect are
disclosed in note 3.
The financial statements are
presented in United States Dollars (US$) which is also the
functional currency of the Company and its subsidiaries.
Material uncertainty
relating to going concern
The Directors believe that it is
appropriate to prepare these consolidated financial statements on a
going concern basis as the current cash flow forecasts demonstrate
that the Group, with continued deferral of fees, as outlined below,
from some service providers, has sufficient cash to cover operating
costs for a period of at least twelve months from the signing of
the consolidated financial statements (the "going concern
period").
Should a plausible downside
scenario occur additional finance will be required to provide
sufficient funding to fund the Group's activities to cover any
negotiations with the lenders as further detailed below. In this
respect the Company believes it is therefore prudent to raise
additional capital in Q3 2024. The Board will consult with its
broker regarding a proposed capital raise and its uptake. However,
the outcome is currently uncertain.
The Board therefore concludes that
to sufficiently cover off all going concern scenarios, there is a
material uncertainty, however it remains appropriate to prepare the
financial statements on a going concern basis.
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
2) MATERIAL ACCOUNTING POLICY
INFORMATION (CONTINUED)
a) Basis of preparation
(continued)
Material uncertainty
relating to going concern (continued)
In making this conclusion, the
Board have taken into consideration:
·
that Thai Airways have made monthly fixed lease
rental payments on time and in full from the start of the revised
fixed rental period commencing in January 2023. Further that Thai
Airways have reported a consistent return to profitability and have
projected that they will exit their formal rehabilitation Period in
Q4 2024;
·
that given Thai Airways improved performance the
Company will continue to receive US$ 35,000 per aircraft per month
as a contribution towards its operating costs with the rest going
towards the pay down of the Group's outstanding loan
arrangements;
·
the continued deferral of some fees by the Board,
the Asset Manager and the Broker as noted in note 13;
·
successfully raising up to US$ 1m in Q3 2024 to
allow the Group to trade beyond the going concern period to
facilitate negotiating (i) an extension to the current loan
maturities beyond the expiring loan terms in Q4 2026 with the
Lenders, and (ii) an enhancement of the terms and conditions of the
leases with Thai Airways, noting that negotiations with the lenders
will commence in late 2024; and
·
as a matter of prudence, the Company will need to
consider costs associated with the winding up of the Group should
it be required.
New standards,
interpretation and amendments from 1 January 2023
The Group adopted Disclosure of
Accounting Policies (Amendments to IAS 1 and IFRS Practice
Statement 2) from 1 January 2023. The amendments require the
disclosure of 'material' rather than 'significant' accounting
policies. Although the amendments did not result in any changes to
the accounting policies themselves, they impacted the accounting
policy information disclosed (in this note) in certain
instances.
New and amended accounting
standards and interpretations.
At the date of authorisation of
these financial statements, the following amendments to Standards
and Interpretations were assessed to be relevant and are all
effective for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2024
and thereafter:
- IAS 1 Amendments (Classification
of Liabilities as Current or Non-Current)
- IAS 1 Amendments (Disclosure of
Accounting Policies and IFRS Practice Statement 2)
- IAS 1 Amendments (Non-current
Liabilities with Covenants)
- IAS 8 Amendments (Definition of
Accounting Estimates)
- IAS 12 Amendments (Deferred Tax
and OECD Pillar 2 Taxes)
- IAS 12 Amendments (Deferred Tax
related to Assets and Liabilities arising from a Single
Transaction)
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
2) MATERIAL ACCOUNTING POLICY
INFORMATION (CONTINUED)
a) Basis of preparation
(continued)
New and amended accounting
standards and interpretations (Continued)
The Group intends to adopt the
Standards and Interpretations in the reporting period when they
become effective and the Board does not anticipate that the
adoption of these Standards and Interpretations in future
periods will materially impact the Group's financial results in the
period of initial application although there may be revised
presentations to the Financial Statements and additional
disclosures.
b)
Basis of
consolidation
The financial statements
incorporate the financial statements of the Company and the
subsidiary undertakings controlled by the Company made up to 31
December each year. Control is achieved where the Company has power
over the investee, exposure or rights to variable returns from its
involvement with the investee and the ability to use its power to
affect the amount of the investor's returns.
When control of a subsidiary
undertaking is lost, the assets and liabilities of that subsidiary
are deconsolidated at the date of loss of control and a resulting
loss or gain on loss of control is reported in profit or
loss.
The results of subsidiary
undertakings acquired or disposed of during the year are included
in the consolidated statement of comprehensive income from the
effective date of acquisition or up to the effective date of
disposal as appropriate. All intra-group transactions, balances,
income and expenses are eliminated on consolidation.
c) Property, Plant
and Equipment (PPE) - Aircraft and Related
Components
Upon delivery, aircraft (the
'Assets') are initially recognised at cost plus initial direct
costs which may be capitalised under IAS 16. In accounting for
property, plant and equipment, the Group makes estimates about the
expected useful lives, the fair value of attached leases and the
estimated residual value of aircraft. In estimating useful lives,
fair value of leases and residual value of aircraft, the Group
relies upon actual industry experience, supported by estimates
received from independent appraisers.
Items of PPE are measured at cost
less accumulated depreciation and any accumulated impairment
losses. If significant parts of an item of PPE have different
useful lives, then they are accounted for as separate items of
PPE.
d)
Depreciation
Depreciation is calculated to
write off the cost of items of PPE less their residual values under
the straight-line method over their estimated useful lives and is
generally recognised in profit or loss.
Depreciation methods, useful lives
and residual values are reviewed at each reporting date and
adjusted if appropriate.
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
2) MATERIAL ACCOUNTING POLICY
INFORMATION (CONTINUED)
e)
Lease
When an aircraft is acquired with
a lease attached, an evaluation of whether the lease is at fair
value is undertaken. A lease premium is recognised when it is
determined that the acquired lease terms are above fair
value. Lease premiums are recognised as a component of
aircraft and are amortised to profit or loss on a straight-line
basis over the term of the lease.
The two aircraft leased to Thai
Airways International were acquired in 2015 and had a useful
economic lease life of 12 years at acquisition. The useful economic
lease life since acquisition of 12 years is unchanged as at year
end.
The Group's policy is to
depreciate the Assets over their remaining lease life (given the
intention to sell the Assets at the end of each respective lease)
to an appraised residual value at the end of the lease. Residual
values are reviewed annually at the beginning of each year, and
such estimates are supported by future values determined by two
external valuations and discounted by the inflation rate
incorporated into those valuations, see note 3 for further
details.
f) Operating lease - Group as
lessor
At inception of a contract, the
Group assesses whether a contract is, or contains, a lease. A
contract is, or contains, a lease if the contract conveys the right
to control the use of an identified asset for a period of time in
exchange for consideration.
When the Group acts as a lessor,
it determines at lease inception whether each lease is a finance
lease or an operating lease.
The Group makes an overall
assessment of whether the lease transfers substantially all of the
risks and rewards incidental to ownership of the underlying
asset. If this is the case, then the lease is a finance
lease; if not, it is an operating lease.
g)
Lease rental
income
Leases relating to the Aircraft
are classified as operating leases where the terms of the lease do
not transfer substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership
to the lessee. Fixed rental income from operating leases is
recognised on a straight-line basis over the term of the lease.
Variable rental income is accounted for on an accrual basis. Any
modifications to operating leases are accounted for as a new lease
from the effective date of the modification, considering any
prepaid or accrued lease payments relating to the original lease as
part of the lease payments for the new lease.
Initial direct costs incurred in
setting up a lease are capitalised to Property, Plant and Equipment
and amortised over the lease term.
h) Bank Borrowings and
interest expense
Bank borrowings are recognised
initially at fair value, net of transaction costs incurred. Bank
borrowings are subsequently measured at amortised cost; any
difference between the proceeds (net of transaction costs) and the
redemption value is recognised through profit or loss in the
consolidated statement of comprehensive income over the period of
borrowing using the effective interest rate method. Bank borrowings
are classified as current liabilities unless the Group has an
unconditional right to defer settlement of the liability for at
least one year after the reporting date.
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
2) MATERIAL ACCOUNTING POLICY
INFORMATION (CONTINUED)
h) Bank Borrowings and
interest expense (Continued)
Initial direct costs related to
bank borrowings are capitalised, presented net against the bank
borrowings in the consolidated statement of financial position and
amortised to the consolidated statement of comprehensive income
over the period of the related loan as part of the effective
interest rate.
Where loans are modified, the
modification is assessed in line with IFRS 9 to determine whether
the modification is substantial. Where the modification is
substantial, the existing loan is derecognised and the
new loan is recognised at fair
value. Where the modification is not substantial, the existing loan
is not derecognised. Any difference arising on modification is
recognised as a gain or loss within the consolidated statement of
comprehensive income regardless of whether the modification is
substantial or not.
Interest expense is calculated
using the effective interest rate method. The effective interest
method is a method of calculating the amortised cost of a financial
liability and of allocating interest expense over the relevant
period.
The effective interest rate is the
rate that exactly discounts estimated future cash receipts or
payments (including all fees or amounts paid or received that form
an integral part of the effective interest rate, including
transaction costs and other premiums or discounts) through the
expected life of the financial asset
or liability.
i) Restricted
Cash
Restricted cash comprises cash
held by the Group, but which is ring-fenced or used as security for
specific financing arrangements, and to which the Group does not
have unfettered access. Restricted cash includes monies received in
relation to maintenance provisions and security
deposits.
j) Maintenance
Reserves Provision
Maintenance reserves are lessee
contributions to a retention account held by the lessor which are
calculated by reference to the budgeted cost of maintenance and
overhaul events (the 'supplemental rentals'). They are intended to
ensure that at all times the lessor holds sufficient funds to cover
the proportionate cost of maintenance and overhaul of the Asset
relating to the life used on the airframe, engines and parts since
new or since the last overhaul. During the term of the lease, all
maintenance is required to be carried out at the cost of the
lessee, and maintenance provisions are required to be released only
upon receipt of satisfactory evidence that the relevant qualifying
maintenance or overhaul has been completed.
Maintenance reserves are recorded
in the consolidated statement of financial position during the term
of the lease as a liability. Reimbursements will be charged against
this liability as qualifying maintenance work is performed.
Maintenance reserves are restricted and not distributable until, at
the end of the lease, the Group is released from the obligation to
make any further reimbursements in relation to the aircraft, and
the remaining balance of maintenance provisions, if any, is
released through profit or loss as lease related income. On
termination of the lease maintenance reserves balance is also
released to profit or loss as lease related income.
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
2) MATERIAL ACCOUNTING POLICY
INFORMATION (CONTINUED)
k) Segmental
reporting
The Directors are of the opinion
that the Group is engaged in a single segment of business, being
acquiring, leasing and subsequent selling of aircraft. All
significant operating decisions are based upon analysis of the
Group as one segment. The financial results from this segment are
equivalent to the financial statements of the Group as a
whole.
3) USE OF JUDGEMENTS AND
ESTIMATES
The preparation of financial
statements in conformity with IFRS requires that the Directors make
judgements and estimates about the future, that affect the
application of the Group's accounting policies and reported amounts
of assets and liabilities, income and expenses. Actual results may
differ from these estimates.
Information about assumptions and
estimation uncertainty at 31 December 2023 that have a significant
effect of resulting in a material adjustment to the carrying
amounts of assets and liabilities in the next financial year
are:
Assumptions and estimation uncertainties in the impairment testing
of PPE and key assumptions underlying recoverable amounts cost of
disposal.
Impairment of property,
plant and equipment
An impairment is recognised if the
carrying amount of an asset exceeds its recoverable amount.
Impairment losses are recognised in profit or loss.
At each reporting, the Group
reviews the carrying amounts of its PPE to determine whether there
is any indication of impairment. If any such indication exists,
then the assets' recoverable amount is estimated. The recoverable
amount of an asset is the higher of the value in use and fair value
less cost to disposal. In considering the impairment of the Thai
aircraft, the Board concluded that the fair value less costs of
disposal was the recoverable amount. The fair value less costs of
disposal used in the assessment is based on the full-life market
value of each aircraft as determined by 2 independent appraisers
given the aircraft have a lease with a full-life return condition
attached to them.
The Board considered all possible
valuation ranges and concluded that the Thai aircraft were not
impaired as at 31 December 2023 given the fair value less costs of
disposal was greater than the book value of the aircraft. 2
independent appraisers determined that the full life market value
of the aircraft as at 31 December 2023 ranges from US$ 59.8m to US$
74.5m. Note, every appraiser has its own opinion of the market and
how the market will develop. On a specific aircraft type one
appraiser might be more favourable compared to another firm and
vice versa. In addition, appraisers obtain their market information
from different sources and use different calculation models. This
has an influence on future and current market values hence the wide
range. In order to eliminate peaks in one or the other
direction the Board take the average of the 2 appraisers in
determining market values for the aircraft. This approach is
consistent with the approach adopted by other market participants
(lessors, lenders, etc) and is consistent with prior periods. Given
the nature and life of the aircraft this approach is considered to
be reasonable. The average market value less selling costs for each
aircraft is more than each aircraft's carrying value.
Therefore, no impairment loss has been recognised during the
financial year ended 31 December 2023 ( 2022: US$ nil).
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
3) USE OF JUDGEMENTS AND
ESTIMATES (CONTINUED)
Impairment of property,
plant and equipment (Continued)
The Board also considered if there
was any indication that the accumulated impairment recognised in
previous years on Thai aircraft of US$ 58,839,697 had reversed
partially or in full. The Board has concluded that based on the
possible ranges of the aircraft valuations, there was no reversal
during the year ended 31 December 2023.
The aircraft are currently in a
half-life state which means the airframe, engines, landing gear and
other major time/cycle limited components are halfway through their
various overhaul and /or life cycles. Note that the aircraft will
be returned in a full-life condition on termination of the leases
hence full-life market value was used in the impairment
assessment.
Depreciation of
aircraft
As described in note 2, the Group
depreciates the Assets on a straight-line basis over the remaining
lease life and taking into consideration the estimated residual
value at the end of the lease term. The Group engages independent
expert valuers (appraisers) each year to provide a valuation of the
Assets and take into account the average of the valuations
provided.
Residual value estimates of the
Aircraft were determined by the full life inflated base values at
the end of the leases from external valuations and discounted by
the inflation rate incorporated into those valuations.
The full life inflated base value
is the appraiser's opinion of the underlying economic value of the
aircraft in an open, unrestricted, stable market environment with a
reasonable balance of supply and demand and assumes full
consideration of its 'highest and best use'. The full life inflated
values used within the financial statements match up the two lease
termination dates (October 2026 and December 2026) and have been
discounted by the inflation rate incorporated into the valuations.
The residual value of the aircraft does not represent the current
fair value of the aircraft.
The residual value estimates at
the end of each year are used to determine the aircraft
depreciation of future periods. The residual value estimates for
aircraft as at 31 December 2023 was US$ 122,852,389 (2022: US$
120,247,838), carrying value as at 31 December 2023 was US$
124,122,582 (2022: US$ 125,466,080).
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
4) LEASE RENTAL
INCOME
|
|
|
|
2023
|
2022
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
Variable rental (PBH rent)
income
|
-
|
7,709,166
|
Straight lining rental
income
|
8,714,249
|
8,753,206
|
Total lease rental income
|
8,714,249
|
16,462,372
|
|
|
|
|
All lease rental income was
derived from Thai Airways and the related two Boeing 787-8 aircraft
leased to them.
Until 31 December 2022 the lease
terms provided for a power by the hour ('PBH') arrangement (i.e.,
rent was payable by reference to actual monthly utilisation of the
Thai aircraft). After 31 December 2022, lease payments are fixed at
US$ 510,000 per month until October and December 2026 respectively
for each lease.
The lease term may be extended by
three years to October 2029 for aircraft MSN 36110 and December
2029 for aircraft MSN 35320 (the "Extension Period") with further
scaled back monthly lease payments starting from November 2026 and
January 2027 respectively. The Extension Period is however subject
to agreement with the Group after consulting the Lenders. The lease
term has been determined to be the period to October 2026 and
December 2026 which is the non-cancellable term of each aircraft
lease.
The contracted cash lease rental
payments to be received under non-cancellable operating leases at
the reporting date are:
|
Boeing
787-8
|
Boeing
787-8
|
|
|
Serial No:
35320
|
Serial No:
36110
|
Total
|
31
Dec 2023
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
2024
|
6,120,000
|
6,120,000
|
12,240,000
|
2025
|
6,120,000
|
6,120,000
|
12,240,000
|
2026
|
5,758,065
|
5,067,097
|
10,825,162
|
|
17,998,065
|
17,307,097
|
35,305,162
|
31
Dec 2022
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
2023
|
6,120,000
|
6,120,000
|
12,240,000
|
2024
|
6,120,000
|
6,120,000
|
12,240,000
|
2025
|
6,120,000
|
6,120,000
|
12,240,000
|
2026
|
5,758,065
|
5,067,097
|
10,825,162
|
|
24,118,065
|
23,427,097
|
47,545,162
|
US$ 10,038,709 (2022: US$
13,525,502) of the future contracted lease rental payments are
recognised as a straight lining lease asset as at year
end.
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
5) GENERAL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE EXPENSES
|
2023
|
|
2022
|
|
US$
|
|
US$
|
Administration fees
|
227,569
|
|
259,437
|
External accounting
services
|
21,726
|
|
36,810
|
Aircraft agency fees
|
5,523
|
|
12,033
|
Aircraft valuation fees
|
13,266
|
|
9,092
|
Aircraft security trustee
fees
|
25,079
|
|
12,000
|
Audit fees
|
123,398
|
|
69,895
|
Interim audit fees
|
-
|
|
12,810
|
Company broker fees
|
167,899
|
|
167,902
|
Directors' fees and
expenses
|
196,520
|
|
212,593
|
Insurance costs, including
directors' insurance
|
89,249
|
|
100,873
|
Foreign exchange
|
26,095
|
|
4,974
|
IT and printing costs
|
19,036
|
|
22,378
|
Legal fees
|
8,194
|
|
3,157
|
Miscellaneous costs
|
12,911
|
|
8,399
|
Registrar fees
|
26,016
|
|
28,738
|
Other expenses
|
14,213
|
|
20,725
|
Total ongoing costs
|
976,694
|
|
981,816
|
|
|
|
|
Restructuring fees
|
152,946
|
|
112,771
|
|
|
|
|
Total general and administrative expenses
|
1,129,640
|
|
1,094,587
|
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
6) FINANCE
COSTS
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
2023
|
2022
|
|
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
Loan interest
|
|
|
4,494,653
|
4,860,305
|
Loan Modification
adjustment
Loan arrangement fee
|
|
5,042,029
14,993
|
-
-
|
Total finance costs
|
|
|
9,551,675
|
4,860,305
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
During the period there was a
restructure of the loans advanced by DekaBank. Management, in line
with IFRS 9, assessed whether the modification was substantial or
not. The assessment was done on a quantitative basis and compared
the net present value of the modified cash flows per the amended
loan terms including any fees payable or receivable, discounted at
the original effective interest rate, against the carrying value of
the loans prior to the modification. A difference of 10% or more
would have been considered substantial as is advised in IFRS 9.
Management concluded that the modification was not substantial, and
a modification adjustment, being the difference between the net
present value of the cash flows under the revised terms discounted
at the original agreement's effective interest rate and the
carrying value of the loans immediately prior to the modification,
was made to the existing loan in line with IFRS 9. This totalled
US$ 5,042,029 and increased both finance costs and the loans
payable at the point of modification. This adjustment essentially
recognises a loss now due to the less favourable terms (primarily
interest rate increases) under the modified terms compared to the
original terms. As a result of this adjustment, interest will be
recognised at the lower original effective interest rate as opposed
to the higher modified interest rate going forward.
7)
TAXATION
With the exception of DP Aircraft
UK Limited, all companies within the Group are exempt from taxation
in Guernsey and are charged an annual exemption fee of £1,600 each
(2022: £1,200).
DP Aircraft UK Limited are subject
to taxation at the applicable rate in the United Kingdom. They
recorded a tax benefit of US$3,603 during the year compared to a
tax expense of US$21,249 in 2022. The Directors do not expect the
taxation payable to be material to the Group.
A tax reconciliation has not been
presented in these Financial Statements as the effective tax rate
is not material and the reconciliation is not relevant to the
understanding of the Company's results for the year end.
8) EARNINGS PER
SHARE
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
2023
|
2022
|
|
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
(Loss)/Profit for the
year
|
|
(2,505,687)
|
7,660,823
|
Weighted average number of
shares
|
|
239,333,333
|
223,388,128
|
(Loss)/Earnings per Share
|
|
(0.01047)
|
0.03429
|
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
9) PROPERTY, PLANT &
EQUIPMENT - AIRCRAFT & RELATED COMPONENTS
|
Aircraft
|
Lease
Premium
|
Total
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
COST
|
|
|
|
As at 1 January 2023 and 31 December 2023
|
238,731,161
|
17,398,493
|
256,129,654
|
|
|
|
|
ACCUMULATED DEPRECIATION / AMORTISATION
|
|
|
|
As at 1 January 2023
|
54,425,384
|
8,200,047
|
62,625,431
|
Charge for the year
|
1,343,498
|
-
|
1,343,498
|
As at 31 December 2023
|
55,768,882
|
8,200,047
|
63,968,929
|
|
|
|
|
IMPAIRMENT
|
|
|
|
As at 1 January 2023
|
58,839,697
|
9,198,446
|
68,038,143
|
Charge for the year
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
As at 31 December 2023
|
58,839,697
|
9,198,446
|
68,038,143
|
|
|
|
|
CARRYING AMOUNT
|
|
|
|
As at 31 December 2023
|
124,122,582
|
-
|
124,122,582
|
|
Aircraft
|
Lease
Premium
|
Total
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
COST
|
|
|
|
As at 1 January 2022 and 31 December 2022
|
238,731,161
|
17,398,493
|
256,129,654
|
|
|
|
|
ACCUMULATED DEPRECIATION / AMORTISATION
|
|
|
|
As at 1 January 2022
|
53,466,624
|
8,200,047
|
61,666,671
|
Charge for the year
|
958,760
|
-
|
958,760
|
As at 31 December 2022
|
54,425,384
|
8,200,047
|
62,625,431
|
|
|
|
|
IMPAIRMENT
|
|
|
|
As at 1 January 2022
|
58,839,697
|
9,198,446
|
68,038,143
|
Charge for the year
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
As at 31 December 2022
|
58,839,697
|
9,198,446
|
68,038,143
|
|
|
|
|
CARRYING AMOUNT
|
|
|
|
As at 31 December 2022
|
125,466,080
|
-
|
125,466,080
|
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
9) PROPERTY, PLANT &
EQUIPMENT - AIRCRAFT & RELATED COMPONENTS
(CONTINUED)
As at year end PPE is comprised of
two aircraft leased to Thai Airways under an operating lease. Under
the terms of the leases that existed during the year, the cost of
repair and maintenance of the Assets is to be borne by Thai Airways
and Thai Airways has an obligation to return the Assets in a full
life condition. However, after expiry or termination of the leases
with Thai, the cost of repair and maintenance will fall upon the
Group. Therefore, after expiry or termination of the Thai leases,
the Group may bear higher costs and the terms of any subsequent
leasing arrangements (including terms for repair, maintenance and
insurance costs relative to those agreed under the leases) may be
less favourable, which could reduce the overall distributions paid
to the shareholders.
Refer to note 3 for details
regarding residual value estimates. The Group depreciates the
aircraft on a straight-line basis over the remaining lease term.
The lease term has been determined to end in 2026.
As detailed in note 3, as at 31
December 2023 there is no impairment to the aircraft and there are
no indications of reversal of prior year impairment either. Refer
to note 3 for further details.
The loans entered into by the
Group to complete the purchase of the two Thai aircraft are cross
collateralised. Each of the loans are secured by way of security
taken over each of the two aircraft.
10) RESTRICTED CASH
|
|
|
2023
|
2022
|
Current assets
|
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
Security deposit
accounts
|
|
|
97
|
91
|
Lease rental accounts
|
|
|
1,093,662
|
4,175,189
|
|
|
|
1,093,759
|
4,175,280
|
Non-current assets
|
|
|
|
|
Maintenance reserves
accounts
|
|
15,735,805
|
14,979,197
|
Total restricted cash
|
|
|
16,829,564
|
19,154,477
|
Maintenance reserves held at
reporting date, are to be used solely to cover costs related to the
maintenance of the two aircraft. Effective 15 June 2021, the Group
no longer receives maintenance reserves contributions from the
lessee in line with the updated lease terms.
The majority of security deposits
were transferred to Lease Rental Accounts during the prior period
and are being used to service loan payments due to DekaBank in
accordance with the DekaBank financing arrangements. Monies
received into the Lease Rental Accounts during the fixed rent
period are to be transferred into Borrower Rental Accounts and
applied in a specific manner as agreed between DekaBank and the
Group. Access to the Lease Rental Accounts, Security deposit
accounts and Maintenance reserves accounts is physically restricted
by DekaBank therefore these monies are classified as restricted
cash.
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
11) TRADE AND OTHER
RECEIVABLES
|
|
|
2023
|
2022
|
|
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
Prepayments
|
|
|
61,914
|
82,333
|
Rent receivable
|
|
|
-
|
671,585
|
Straight-lining lease
asset
|
|
|
10,038,709
|
13,525,503
|
Total trade and other receivables
|
|
|
10,100,623
|
14,279,421
|
Less:
Expected credit loss on straight lining lease asset
|
(1,103,254)
|
(1,486,453)
|
Net trade and other receivables
|
|
|
8,997,369
|
12,792,968
|
Current and non-current split as
at year end is as follows:
|
|
|
2023
|
2022
|
Current assets
|
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
Prepayments
|
|
|
61,914
|
82,333
|
Rent receivable
|
|
|
-
|
671,586
|
Straight-lining lease
asset
|
|
|
3,082,249
|
3,103,595
|
|
|
|
3,144,163
|
3,857,514
|
Non-current assets
|
|
|
|
|
Straight-lining lease
asset
|
|
|
5,853,206
|
8,935,454
|
Trade and other receivables
|
|
|
8,997,369
|
12,792,968
|
The Group has assessed the straight-lining lease asset for
impairment. This balance represents the result of straight lining
of future fixed Thai lease payments over the lease term. The Group
has performed an assessment on the straight-lining lease asset
taking into account current and future information relating to the
airline industry as well as the lessee specifically and concluded
that the expected credit loss provision as at 31 December 2023 is
US$ 1,103,254 (2022: US$ 1,486,453). For the remaining receivables,
the Group has concluded that these are not material thus any
provision, if any, would also be immaterial and so no further
assessment is necessary.
Movements in the impairment provision for trade
receivables is as follows:
|
|
|
2023
|
2022
|
|
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
Opening provision
|
|
|
1,486,453
|
-
|
Expected credit loss on straight
lining lease asset
|
|
|
(383,199)
|
1,486,453
|
Expected credit loss on lease
receivable
|
|
|
-
|
105,063
|
Lease receivable written
off
|
|
|
-
|
(105,063)
|
Closing provision
|
|
|
1,103,254
|
1,486,453
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
12) MAINTENANCE
PROVISION
The maintenance reserves
liability relates to funds received from Thai
Airways reserved for covering the cost of maintenance. Effective 15
June 2021, the Group no longer receives maintenance reserves
contributions from the lessee in line with the updated lease
terms.
13) TRADE AND OTHER
PAYABLES
|
2023
|
2022
|
Current
|
US$
|
US$
|
Accruals and other
payables
|
255,581
|
221,749
|
Asset Manager fees payable (note
22)
|
283,011
|
218,033
|
Broker fees payable
|
321,809
|
167,902
|
Director fees payable (note
21)
|
225,105
|
212,360
|
Taxation payable
|
6,560
|
21,249
|
Total trade and other payables
|
1,092,066
|
841,293
|
All directors, brokers fees and most
of the asset manager fees have been classified as current
liabilities under IFRS but these creditors have agreed the amounts
are not payable within twelve months unless there is an asset
sale.
14) BANK BORROWINGS
|
2023
US$
|
2022
US$
|
Current liabilities: Bank interest
payable and Bank borrowings
|
(7,684,502)
|
17,707,184
|
Non-current liabilities: Bank
borrowings
|
(85,027,721)
|
80,779,172
|
Total liabilities
|
(92,712,223)
|
98,486,356
|
|
|
|
The borrowings are repayable as follows:
|
|
|
Interest payable
|
183,992
|
181,493
|
Within one year
|
7,500,510
|
17,525,691
|
In two to five years
|
85,027,721
|
80,779,172
|
Total Bank borrowings
|
92,712,223
|
98,486,356
|
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
14) BANK BORROWINGS
(CONTINUED)
The table below analyses the
movements in the Group's bank borrowings:
|
2023
|
2022
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
Opening balance
|
98,304,863
|
98,304,863
|
Loan modification adjustment (note
6)
|
5,042,029
|
-
|
Repayment of loan
|
(9,556,363)
|
-
|
Amortisation payable
|
(1,262,298)
|
-
|
Principal Bank borrowings
|
92,528,231
|
98,304,863
|
Interest payable
|
183,992
|
181,493
|
Total Bank borrowings
|
92,712,223
|
98,486,356
|
The table below sets out an
analysis of net debt and the movements in net debt for the year
ended 31 December 2023
|
|
Cash and cash
equivalents
|
Principal
|
Interest
|
Net Debt
|
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
At 1 January 2023
|
|
1,479,541
|
(98,304,863)
|
(181,493)
|
(97,006,815)
|
Cash flows
|
|
(565,036)
|
9,556,363
|
5,769,445
|
14,760,772
|
Non cash: -
|
|
|
|
|
|
Modification adjustment
|
|
-
|
(5,042,029)
|
-
|
(5,042,029)
|
Amortisation adjustment
|
|
-
|
1,262,298
|
(1,262,298)
|
-
|
Interest charge
Loan arrangement fee
|
|
-
-
|
-
-
|
(4,494,653)
(14,993)
|
(4,494,653)
(14,993)
|
At 31 December 2023
|
|
914,505
|
(92,528,231)
|
(183,992)
|
(91,797,718)
|
|
|
Cash and cash
equivalents
|
Principal
|
Interest
|
Net Debt
|
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
At 1 January 2022
|
|
1,179,211
|
(98,304,863)
|
(136,010)
|
(97,261,662)
|
Cash flows
|
|
300,330
|
-
|
4,814,822
|
5,115,152
|
Non cash: -
|
|
|
|
|
|
Interest charge
|
|
-
|
-
|
(4,860,305)
|
(4,860,305)
|
At 31 December 2022
|
|
1,479,541
|
(98,304,863)
|
(181,493)
|
(97,006,815)
|
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
14) BANK BORROWINGS
(CONTINUED)
DekaBank
On 6 May 2021, subsequent to the
LOI being entered into by the Group and Thai as described in the
summary in page 4, the Group and DekaBank amended and restated the
existing loan facility agreements in respect of the Thai aircraft
to accommodate the new lease terms, First Amendment and Restatement
to the Loan Agreements. Repayments of principal were deferred until
after the end of the PBH arrangement (31 December 2022), and a new
repayment schedule was to be renegotiated close to the end of the
PBH arrangement.
On 7 February 2023, the Group and
DekaBank entered into a Second Amendment and Restatement to the
Loan Agreement in which the parties agreed on the following main
terms:
·
The total loan amount outstanding was split into
two tranches:
o Facility A loan of US$ 61,144,842, made up of MSN 35320 loan
of US$ 31,099,453 and MSN 36110 loan of
US$ 30,045,389. The Facility A loan amortizes to a combined balloon
of US$ 33,947,878 and represents the scheduled debt.
o Facility B loan of US$ 35,504,024 (non-amortizing), made up
of MSN 35320 loan of US$ 17,366,650 and
MSN 36110 loan of US$ 18,137,374. The Facility B loan will be
settled as a balloon payment at the end of the loan term in
2026.
·
USD 2.36m of surplus cash generated under the PBH
period was used to immediately repay debt on the amortizing
Facility A loan in February 2023, while an agreed cash reserve of
US$ 500,000 per aircraft will be retained to cover unforeseen costs
going forward.
·
the interest rate swap in place for the scheduled
debt was dissolved at no net gain or loss.
·
the MSN 35320 and MSN 36110 Facility A loans bear
fixed interest rates of 6.61% and 6.89% respectively.
·
the MSN 35320 and MSN 36110 Facility B loans bear
fixed interest rates of 5.26% and 5.42% respectively.
·
From the monthly fixed lease rental of US$
510,000 per aircraft (which denotes the maximum amount the Company
can earn in operations per month), US$ 475,000 is legally
restricted so that those funds are only payable to the lenders,
while the remaining US$ 35,000 per aircraft can be retained by the
company to contribute towards ongoing fixed costs of the
Company.
The MSN 35320 loan and the MSN
36110 loan have a final maturity date of 9 December 2026 and 29
October 2026 respectively.
Due to the limited liquidity
position of the Group, restructuring fees associated with the
second amendment and restatement will be paid after the eventual
remarketing of the aircraft, subject to surplus sales proceeds
being realised.While there are covenants attached to the loans,
there has been no issues of non-compliance within the
period.
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
15) SHARE CAPITAL
Company's authorised share capital
is unlimited.
Year ended 31 December 2023
|
Subordinated
|
|
|
|
Administrative
|
Ordinary
|
|
|
Share
|
Shares
|
Total
|
Issued and fully paid (no par value
shares):
|
Number
|
Number
|
Number
|
|
|
|
|
Shares as at 1 January 2023
|
1
|
239,333,333
|
239,333,334
|
Shares
as at 31 December 2023
|
1
|
239,333,333
|
239,333,334
|
|
|
|
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
Share capital as at 1 January
2023
|
-
|
211,279,828
|
211,279,828
|
Share capital as at 31 December 2023
|
-
|
211,279,828
|
211,279,828
|
|
|
|
|
Year ended 31 December 2022
|
Subordinated
|
|
|
|
Administrative
|
Ordinary
|
|
|
Share
|
Shares
|
Total
|
Issued and fully paid (no par value
shares):
|
Number
|
Number
|
Number
|
|
|
|
|
Shares as at 1 January 2022
|
1
|
209,333,333
|
209,333,334
|
Share issued during the
year
|
-
|
30,000,000
|
30,000,000
|
Shares
as at 31 December 2022
|
1
|
239,333,333
|
239,333,334
|
|
|
|
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
Share capital as at 1 January
2022
|
-
|
210,556,652
|
210,556,652
|
Proceeds from issue of
shares
|
|
750,000
|
750,000
|
Issue cost paid
|
-
|
(26,824)
|
(26,824)
|
Share capital as at 31 December 2022
|
-
|
211,279,828
|
211,279,828
|
Subject to the applicable company
law and the Company's Articles of Incorporation, the Company may
issue an unlimited number of shares of par value and/or no par
value or a combination of both.
The Subordinated Administrative
Share is held by DS Aviation GmbH & Co. KG, (the Asset
Manager).
Holders of Subordinated
Administrative Shares are not entitled to participate in any
dividends and other distributions of the Company. On a winding up
of the Company the holders of the Subordinated Administrative
Shares are entitled to an amount out of the surplus assets
available for distribution equal to the amount paid up, or credited
as paid up, on such shares after payment of an amount equal to the
amount paid up, or credited as paid up, on the Ordinary Shares to
the Shareholders. Holders of Subordinated Administrative Shares
shall not have the right to receive notice of and have no right to
attend, speak and vote at general meetings of the Company except if
there are no Ordinary Shares in existence.
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
15) SHARE CAPITAL
(CONTINUED)
The Directors are entitled to
issue and allot C Shares. No C Shares have been issued since the
Company was incorporated.
On 13 July 2022 the Company raised
gross proceeds of $750,000 through the issue of 30,000,000 new
ordinary shares in the capital of the Company at a price of
US$0.025 per new ordinary share.
16) ACCUMULATED LOSSES
The movements in the Group's
accumulated losses are shown on page 52.
Accumulated losses comprise
accumulated profits and losses over time.
17) DIVIDENDS
The dividends declared and paid
during the year ended 31 December 2023 are US$ nil (2022: US$
nil).
On 3 April 2020, the Company
announced a suspension of dividends until further notice due to the
impact of Covid-19 in global aviation and especially with long haul
operations. The suspension is continuing and as noted in Summary
report on pages 4 to 6, there is no realistic prospect of the
Company's shareholders receiving a dividend or other
distribution.
18) INVESTMENT IN SUBSIDIARY
UNDERTAKINGS
The Company's investments in
subsidiaries, all of which have been included in these consolidated
financial statements, are as follows:
|
|
|
Proportion
of
|
|
Date of
|
Country of
|
ownership
interest
|
Name
|
Incorporation
|
Incorporation
|
at 31 December
2023
|
DP Aircraft Guernsey III
Limited
|
21 May
2015
|
Guernsey
|
100%
|
DP Aircraft Guernsey IV
Limited
|
21 May
2015
|
Guernsey
|
100%
|
DP Aircraft UK Limited
|
14 April
2015
|
United
Kingdom
|
100%
|
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
19) FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS AND RISK
MANAGEMENT
The following table details the
categories of financial instruments held by the Group at the
reporting date:
|
2023
|
2022
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
Cash and cash
equivalents
|
914,505
|
1,479,541
|
Restricted cash
|
16,829,564
|
19,154,477
|
Trade and other receivables
(excluding prepayments and straight-lining lease asset)
|
-
|
671,586
|
Financial assets measured at amortised cost
|
17,744,069
|
21,305,604
|
|
|
|
Financial liabilities
|
|
|
Bank borrowings
|
92,712,223
|
98,486,356
|
Maintenance provision
|
14,829,296
|
14,829,296
|
Trade and other payables
(excluding tax)
|
1,092,066
|
841,293
|
Financial liabilities measured at amortised
cost
|
108,633,585
|
114,156,945
|
The primary risks arising from the
Group's financial instruments are capital management, credit risk,
market risk and liquidity risk. The principal nature of such risks
is summarised below. The Group's main financial instruments as at
year end comprised of cash and cash equivalents, restricted cash,
maintenance reserves payable and bank loans.
Capital
Management
The capital managed by the Group
comprises the ordinary shares and the subordinated administrative
shares. The Company is not subject to externally imposed capital
requirements.
Until COVID-19 and the impact on
the aircraft industry and the lessees, income distributions were
generally made quarterly, subject to compliance with Applicable Law
and regulations, in February, May, August and November of each
year. The Company aimed to make a distribution to investors of US$
0.0225 per share per quarter. As a result of the COVID-19 pandemic
impact on global aviation and especially its lessees, the Group has
suspended dividends until further notice to help preserve
liquidity.
Credit
risk
Credit risk is the risk that a
significant counterparty will default on its contractual
obligations. The Group's main counterparty during the year was Thai
Airways as lessee and provider of income. The Group, through the Asset Manager, mitigates credit risk
related to Thai Airways through regular monitoring of Thai's use of
the aircraft, review of Thai's financial position, performance, and
prospects and through a general review of the performance of the
airline market.
The Group assesses the probability
of Thai defaulting under different scenarios and the losses that
would be incurred under those different scenarios. The probability
of each default scenario occurring and the related loss that would
be incurred under that scenario is determined taking into account
Thai's historic financial position, performance and future
prospects. The general performance of the Thai economy and the
overall airline industry is also considered in the
assessment.
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
19) FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS AND RISK
MANAGEMENT (CONTINUED)
Credit risk
(continued)
There are gross lease rentals
receivable from Thai at 31 December 2023, US$ nil (2022: US$
671,586). A full lifetime ECL was recognised for the lease rentals
receivable from Thai in the prior year however no ECL has been
recognised for the balance due as at year end (see note 11).
Furthermore, the Group has also recognised a gross straight lining
lease asset as at 31 December 2023 of US$ 10,038,709 (2022: US$
13,525,502). A provision is recognised against this straight lining
lease asset as at 31 December 2023 of US$ 1,103,254 (2022: US$
1,486,453). Refer to note 11 for further details.
Whilst the Board expect that the
approved Thai rehabilitation plan will succeed, the final outcome
of these proceedings is unknown, refer to the Asset Manager Report
on pages 11 to 23 for more details regarding the rehabilitation
process. Failure of any material part of
the rehabilitation plan may have an adverse impact on its ability
to comply with its obligations under the lease (see note 4 for
details re obligations of lessee).
Cash and restricted cash are all
held at DekaBank. The credit rating of DekaBank by Moody' is Aa2
(2022: Aa2). The lessees do not maintain a credit
rating.
The carrying amount of financial
assets measured at amortised cost recorded in the financial
statements represents the Group's maximum exposure to credit risk.
The Group holds no collateral as security or any other credit
enhancements.
Market risk - interest rate
risk
Interest rate risk arises on the
Group's various interest-bearing assets and liabilities from
changes in the general economic conditions of the market from time
to time. The bank borrowings have the most significant interest
impact on the Group. As detailed in note 14, the Group's bank
borrowings were amended and restated. As part of the amendment and
restatement, interest rates were set at fixed rates. Therefore, the
Group's interest rate exposure is currently limited only to the
restricted cash and bank balances which earn an immaterial amount
of interest. As a result, the Group has no material exposure to
interest rate risk subsequent to year end.
A 0.25% increase or decrease in
interest rates on all interest-bearing financial instruments would
result in an increase or decrease in net finance costs for the year
of US$ 186,960 (2022: US$ 194,177).
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
19) FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS AND RISK
MANAGEMENT (CONTINUED)
The following table details the
Group's exposure to interest rate risk as at year end:
|
|
|
Non-interest
|
|
|
Fixed rate
|
Variable
rate
|
bearing
|
|
31 December 2023
|
instruments
|
instruments
|
instruments
|
Total
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
Restricted cash
|
-
|
16,829,564
|
-
|
16,829,564
|
Trade and other receivables
(excluding prepayments and
straight-lining lease asset)
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
Cash and cash
equivalents
|
-
|
914,505
|
-
|
914,505
|
Total financial assets
|
-
|
17,744,069
|
-
|
17,744,069
|
|
|
|
|
|
Trade and other
payables
|
-
|
-
|
(1,092,066)
|
(1,092,066)
|
Maintenance reserves
|
-
|
-
|
(14,829,296)
|
(14,829,296)
|
Bank borrowings*
|
(92,528,231)
|
-
|
(183,992)
|
(92,712,222)
|
Total financial liabilities
|
(92,528,231)
|
-
|
(16,105,354)
|
(108,633,585)
|
Total interest rate sensitivity gap
|
(92,528,231)
|
17,744,069
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
*Interest is charged on the
deferred portion of the loan based on a variable rate and a fixed
rate for the loan portion not deferred.
|
|
|
Non-interest
|
|
|
Fixed rate
|
Variable
rate
|
bearing
|
|
31 December 2022
|
instruments
|
instruments
|
instruments
|
Total
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
Restricted cash
|
-
|
19,154,477
|
-
|
19,154,477
|
Trade and other receivables
(excluding prepayments and
straight-lining lease asset)
|
-
|
-
|
671,586
|
671,586
|
Cash and cash
equivalents
|
-
|
1,479,541
|
-
|
1,479,541
|
Total financial assets
|
-
|
20,634,018
|
671,586
|
21,305,604
|
|
|
|
|
|
Trade and other
payables
|
-
|
-
|
(820,044)
|
(820,044)
|
Maintenance reserves
|
-
|
-
|
(14,829,296)
|
(14,829,296)
|
Bank borrowings
|
(62,800,839)
|
(35,504,024)
|
(181,493)
|
(98,486,356)
|
Total financial liabilities
|
(62,800,839)
|
(35,504,024)
|
(15,830,833)
|
(114,135,696)
|
Total interest rate sensitivity gap
|
(62,800,839)
|
(14,870,006)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Market risk - foreign
currency risk
The Group's exposure to foreign
currency risk is not significant as its cash flows are
predominantly in US$ which is the functional currency of the
company and subsidiaries, and presentation currency of the
Group.
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
19) FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS AND RISK
MANAGEMENT (CONTINUED)
Liquidity
risk
Liquidity risk is the risk that
the Group will encounter difficulty in meeting its obligations in
respect of its financial liabilities. The Group's main financial
commitments are the loans due to DekaBank as well as meeting its
ongoing operating expenses.
Liquidity risk
management
In the event that the Leases are
terminated as a result of a default by Thai Airways, there is a
risk that the Group will not be able to remarket the Thai Assets
successfully within the remarketing period specified in the loan
agreements and that the Group will not have sufficient liquidity to
comply with its obligations under the Loan Agreements. This may
lead to a continued suspension in distributions paid on the shares
and/or a reduction in the value of the shares and have an adverse
effect on the Group and could ultimately result in the Dekabank
enforcing their security and selling the relevant Asset or Assets
on the market. There can be no guarantee that the Group will be
able to re-lease the Assets on terms equivalent to the existing
leases, which may have an adverse effect on the Group and its
ability to meet its investment objective and its dividend target.
Accordingly, were any or all of the Assets to be re-leased on less
favourable terms, this may have an adverse effect on the Group and
its share price. The Group monitors the impact of its obligations,
including the Dekabank loan, on liquidity through cash flow
forecasts which are prepared on a monthly basis.
As detailed in note 14, the Group
has successfully renegotiated an amendment to the Dekabank loans
and new terms were agreed. The new terms agreed change the
liquidity profile of the Group compared the analysis shown below.
Under the new terms, total loan repayments will be US$ 950,000 per
month (US$ 475,000 for each of the two loans), see note 14 for
further details.
The following table details the
contractual maturity analysis of the Group's financial liabilities
as at 31 December 2023. The amounts are contractual undiscounted
cash flows and therefore will not agree directly to the balances in
the consolidated statement of financial position as at 31 December
2023.
31 December 2023
|
Next 12
months
|
2-5 years
|
After 5
years
|
Total
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
Bank borrowings and
interest
|
(11,400,000)
|
(91,301,902)
|
-
|
(102,701,902)
|
Maintenance provision
|
-
|
(14,829,296)
|
-
|
(14,829,296)
|
Trade and other
payables
|
(1,092,066)
|
-
|
-
|
(1,092,066)
|
Total
|
(12,492,066)
|
(106,131,198)
|
-
|
(118,623,264)
|
31 December 2022
|
Next 12
months
|
2-5 years
|
After 5
years
|
Total
|
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
US$
|
Bank borrowings and
interest
|
(20,172,088)
|
(92,309,392)
|
-
|
(112,481,480)
|
Maintenance provision
|
-
|
(14,829,296)
|
-
|
(14,829,296)
|
Trade and other
payables
|
(841,293)
|
-
|
-
|
(841,293)
|
Total
|
(21,013,381)
|
(107,138,688)
|
-
|
(128,152,069)
|
In addition to the bank loans, the
Group may from time-to-time use borrowings. To this end the Group
may arrange an overdraft facility for efficient cash management.
The Directors intend to restrict borrowings other than the bank
loans to an amount not exceeding 15 percent of the net asset value
of the Group at the time of drawdown.
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
19) FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS AND RISK
MANAGEMENT (CONTINUED)
Liquidity risk
(continued)
Liquidity risk
management
Borrowing facilities will only be
drawn down with the approval of the Directors on a case-by- case
basis. The Directors may also draw down on an overdraft facility
for extraordinary expenses determined by them, on the advice of DS
Aviation, to be necessary to safeguard the overall investment
objective. With the exception of the loans, the Directors have no
intention, as at the date of this report, to use such borrowings or
overdraft facility for structural investment purposes.
No right of redemption or
repurchase
Shareholders have no right to have
their shares redeemed or repurchased by the Company at any time.
Shareholders wishing to realise their investment in the Company
would be required to dispose of their shares on the stock market.
Accordingly, the ability of shareholders to realise the Net Asset
Value of, or any value in respect of, their shares is mainly
dependent on the existence of a liquid market in the shares and the
market price of such shares.
Liquidity
Proposal
Although the Company does not have
a fixed life, the Articles require that the Directors convene a
Liquidity Proposal Meeting to be held no later than 30 June 2026 at
which a Liquidity Proposal in the form of an ordinary resolution
will be put forward proposing that the Company should proceed to an
orderly wind-up at the end of the term of the leases. In the event
the Liquidity Proposal is not passed, the Directors will consider
alternatives for the Company and shall propose such alternatives at
a general meeting of the shareholders, including re-leasing the
Assets, or selling the Assets and reinvesting the capital received
from the sale of the Assets in other aircraft.
20) FAIR VALUE
MEASUREMENT
The accounting policies and basis
of measurement in respect of financial instruments are detailed in
note 2.
Financial assets and financial liabilities at amortised
cost
The fair value of cash and cash
equivalents, trade and other receivables (excluding prepayment and
straight lining lease asset), restricted cash and interest payable
approximate their carrying amounts due to the short-term maturities
of these instruments.
21) RELATED PARTY
TRANSACTIONS
The Directors who served during
the year received the following remuneration:
|
2023
US$
|
2022
US$
|
Jonathan Bridel
(Chairman)
|
78,608
|
80,701
|
Jeremy Thompson (Chairman of the
Audit Committee and Senior Independent Director)
|
62,950
|
60,064
|
Harald Brauns (Chairman of the
Management Engagement Committee)
|
62,950
|
65,503
|
Total
|
204,508
|
206,268
|
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
21) RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS
(CONTINUED)
Up to 30 September 2022, 10% of
base fees and all extra fees were not paid by way of cash payments
but were deferred to be settled in the future or to be paid by way
of equity. There has been no settlement of director remuneration
via the issue of equity in the current year (2022:
US$ nil) and the
deferred fees remain outstanding as at 31 December 2023 (see note
13).
During the year, the total fees
and expenses for Directors amounted to £196,520 (2022: 212,593).
Due to the deferral of fees, the outstanding Directors' fees
payable at year end was 225,105 (2022:212,360).
Base annual fees are as
follows:
Annual Fees
|
Jan 23 to Dec
23
|
Oct
22 to Dec 22
|
Jan 22 to Sept
22
|
Jonathan Bridel
|
£61,750
|
£61,750
|
£66,000
|
Jeremy Thompson
|
£49,450
|
£49,450
|
£53,700
|
Harald Brauns
|
£49,450
|
£49,450
|
£53,800
|
*Note: Directors fees were agreed in GBP, the financial
statements are presented in USD
Director fees have been reduced by
10% which was the portion being deferred and possibly payable in
shares. The reduction in fees are effective 1 October
2022.
The Directors interests in the
shares of the Company as at 31 December 2023 are set out
below:
|
Number of
ordinary
shares
31 December
2023
|
Number of
ordinary
shares
31 December
2022
|
Connected parties of Jon
Bridel
|
90,000
|
90,000
|
Jeremy Thompson
|
15,000
|
15,000
|
Harald Brauns
|
-
|
-
|
There has been no distribution of
dividends to the directors during the year ended 31 December 2023
(2022:US$ nil)
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
22) MATERIAL CONTRACTS
Asset Management Agreement
The Asset Management Agreement
dated 19 September 2013, between the Group and DS Aviation was
initially amended on 5 June 2015 to reflect the acquisition of two
new aircraft. A second amendment via a side letter, effective 1
January 2021, was made to the Asset Management Agreement on 7 May
2021.
Disposal fee
The initial amendment provides a
calculation methodology for the disposal fee which will only become
payable when all four of the Assets (first two currently under
receivership and second two currently held by the Group) have been
sold after the expiry of the second Thai Airways lease in December
2026. The fee will be calculated as a percentage of the aggregate
net sale proceeds of the four assets, such percentage rate
depending upon the Initial Investor Total Asset Return per share
being the total amount distributed to an initial investor by way of
dividend, capital return or otherwise over the life of the Company.
If each of the Assets is sold subsequent to the expiry of their
respective leases, the percentage rate shall be:
·
Nil if the Initial Investor Total Asset Return
per Share is less than 205%;
·
1.5% if the Initial Total Asset Return per Share
equals or exceeds 205% but is less than 255%;
·
2% if the Initial Total Asset Return per Share
equals or exceeds 255% but is less than 305%; or
·
3% if the Initial Total Asset Return per Share
equals or exceeds 305%.
Management fees
In the event that any of the
Assets are sold prior to the expiry of its lease the percentage
hurdles set out above will be adjusted on the following
basis:
·
An amount will be deducted in respect of each
Asset sold prior to the expiry of its lease, equal to the net
present value of the aggregate amount of dividends per Share that
were targeted to be paid but were not paid as a result of the early
divestment of the relevant Asset; and
·
A further amount will be deducted, in respect of
each Asset sold prior to the expiry of its lease, equal to the
amount by which the proportion of the non-dividend component of the
relevant percentage hurdle attributable to the relevant Asset would
need to be reduced in order to meet its net present
value.
Per the second amendment, payment
of any Disposal Fee per above (if any) in connection with the sale
of any of the Assets that were under receivership is subordinated
to the DekaBank loans and will only become payable after the loans
(including the deferred element) have been repaid or prepaid in
full.
The disposal fee is a cash-settled
payment to the Asset Manager. There is no disposal fee expected to
be payable as at 31 December 2023 (2022: US$ nil).
The Asset Manager is paid a
monthly base fee of US$ 15,085 (US$ 16,666 up to 31 December 2020)
per asset in respect of the two Assets that are currently held by
the Group, increasing by 2.5 per cent per annum from May
2021.
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
(CONTINUED)
For the year ended 31 December
2023
22) MATERIAL CONTRACTS
(Continued)
Management fees (Continued)
As consideration for the Asset
Manager agreeing to a reduction of the monthly base fee in respect
of the two Assets that are currently held by the Group, the Company
agreed that, when permissible as advised by the corporate broker,
the Asset Manager shall receive an allocation of shares in the
Company determined to be of a value equivalent to the reduction in
the monthly base fee with respect to the two Assets. The share
allocation will be carried out using a share price for the
conversion which is fair and reasonable as advised by corporate
broker.
In the year ended 31 December 2023
Asset Management fees totalled US$ 450,890 (2022: US$ 471,590)
of which US$ 283,011 was due as at 31 December 2023 (2022: US$
218,033). As discussed in note 13, the amount due are not payable
within twelve months unless there is an asset sale.
Administration Agreement
The Administrator of the Company
is Aztec Financial Services (Guernsey) Limited. Aztec Financial
Services (Guernsey) Limited and Aztec Financial Services (UK)
Limited provide administration services to the Company's underlying
subsidiaries. These administrator companies are collectively known
as the "Administrators".
Total fees charged by the
Administrators during the year were US$ 249,295 (2022:US$ 305,896)
of which US$ 29,998 remained payable at 31 December 2023 (2022: US$
57,711).
The Administrators have the right
to be reimbursed from the Company for any reasonable out of pocket
expenses incurred in carrying out their
responsibilities.
Directors' fees
Details of the fees paid to the
Directors are included in note 21.
23) SUBSEQUENT EVENTS
There are no relevant subsequent
events to disclose in these annual financial statements.
COMPANY INFORMATION
Directors
|
Jonathan Bridel
|
|
Jeremy Thompson
|
|
Harald Brauns
|
|
|
Registered Office
|
East Wing
|
|
Trafalgar Court
|
|
Les Banques
|
|
St Peter Port
|
|
Guernsey
|
|
GY1 3PP, Channel
Islands
|
|
|
Asset Manager
|
DS Aviation GmbH & Co.
KG
|
|
Stockholmer Allee 53
|
|
44269 Dortmund
|
|
Germany
|
|
|
Solicitors to the Company
|
Norton Rose Fulbright
LLP
|
(as to English law)
|
3 More London Riverside
|
|
London
|
|
SE1 2AQ, United Kingdom
|
|
|
Advocates to the Company
|
Mourant
|
(as to Guernsey law)
|
Royal Chambers
|
|
St Julian's Avenue
|
|
St Peter Port
|
|
Guernsey
|
|
GY1 1HP, Channel
Islands
|
|
|
Auditor
|
KPMG Channel Islands Limited
|
|
Glategny Court
|
|
Glategny Esplanade
|
|
St Peter Port
|
|
Guernsey
|
|
GY1 1WR, Channel
Islands
|
|
|
Administrator and Company Secretary
|
Aztec Financial Services
(Guernsey) Limited
|
|
East Wing
|
|
Trafalgar Court
|
|
Les Banques
|
|
St Peter Port
|
|
Guernsey
|
|
GY1 3PP, Channel
Islands
|
|
|
Corporate Broker
|
Investec Bank plc
|
|
30 Gresham Street
|
|
London
|
|
EC2V 7QN, United
Kingdom
|
THE FOLLOWING PAGES DO NOT
FORM PART OF THE AUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS