By Juro Osawa And Gillian Wong
Alibaba Group Holding Ltd.'s first earnings report as a listed
company showed both the strong business growth investors have been
hoping for and the many factors weighing on profit.
The Chinese e-commerce giant said Tuesday that its earnings for
the quarter ended in September fell 39% from a year earlier to $494
million, largely because of stock awards to employees and
executives. Those awards were handed out before Alibaba's record
$25 billion initial public offering of stock in September, in an
attempt to hold on to staff and reward them for good performance,
the company said.
Outside of that one-time expense, Alibaba said its operations
grew strongly. Revenue for the quarter rose 54% to $2.74 billion,
as more business flowed through the company's online shopping
sites.
Alibaba said it had more users than ever, that an increasing
number were shopping over their smartphones, and that it was
earning more money from mobile services.
"We're one of the very few companies in China that has generated
substantial revenues from mobile and clearly disclosed it," Alibaba
Executive Vice Chairman Joseph Tsai said during an analyst call
after the earnings announcement. He added that during the past
quarter, Alibaba added more mobile users--29 million--than the
population of Texas.
Increased expenses aimed at getting and serving those mobile
customers, as well as the cost of integrating two Chinese Internet
firms, combined with the stock-award expenses to push down
Alibaba's relatively high operating-profit margins to 25.8% in the
quarter from 47.9% a year earlier.
The results are "lacking the wow factor for an upgrade," said
Tony Chu, a portfolio manager based in Hong Kong for U.S.
asset-management company RS Investments. Mr. Chu also said he was
disappointed that Alibaba didn't provide an earnings outlook. RS
Investments bought Alibaba shares in the September IPO.
Others were impressed by the results. "A lot more people bought
a lot more stuff. These are the key metrics, and the rest are
details," said Sanford Bernstein analyst Carlos Kirjner. "On
balance, it was a very positive quarter."
Alibaba shares rose about 3.2% by midday in New York, and they
touched a new all-time high of $104.96.
Investors are counting on Alibaba's robust growth in the coming
years as China's e-commerce market expands into small cities and
rural areas. Hangzhou-based Alibaba, which operates the Taobao and
Tmall marketplaces, accounts for about 80% of China's online
transactions, according to analysts.
Merchants on Taobao and Tmall did business totaling $90.5
billion in the latest quarter, up 49% from a year earlier, Alibaba
said. Taobao, which hosts millions of small merchants, accounted
for about two-thirds that total, while Tmall, where large global
brands such as Apple Inc. and Nike Inc. set up shop, accounted for
the rest.
The results also showed that more of Alibaba's e-commerce
transactions are coming through smartphones and tablet computers.
Mobile transactions accounted for 36% of overall transactions on
Taobao and Tmall in the quarter, up from 15% a year earlier. The
number of active users on Alibaba's mobile platforms increased to
217 million in September from 188 million in June.
The increase in mobile users and transactions shows Alibaba is
quickly adapting to an environment in which more Chinese consumers
access online services through smartphones.
Yet that shift to mobile commerce also has weighed on earnings.
That is because the bulk of Alibaba's revenue--a little more than
half during the business year ended in March--came from advertising
and marketing services such as those it offers to merchants on
Taobao. And Taobao vendors pay Alibaba less for mobile advertising
than on personal computers, the company has said.
The latest quarterly results showed Alibaba's progress with its
mobile traffic. In the three months through September, the company
took in revenue equal to 1.9% of the business transacted through
its mobile services, versus 1.5% the previous quarter. That still
isn't as high as the 2.5% Alibaba gets from customers buying
through computers.
"The Street is beginning to focus on mobile," said Vince Rivers,
a senior portfolio manager at JO Hambro Capital Management. "The
stock's strength today is warranted, because the company beat
expectations for the number of mobile users and the mobile
monetization rate. They're getting more dollars of revenue for
dollars of transactions they generate."
Alibaba executives also stressed that the company's mobile
e-commerce services are ahead of those of other Chinese rivals.
Although the executives didn't name any company, chief among
Alibaba's competitors is Tencent Holdings Ltd., which dominates
online games and mobile messaging in China, and is expanding into
e-commerce.
Mr. Tsai said Alibaba will continue working on its own
smartphone operating system--dubbed Yun OS--despite a setback in
2012, when Google Inc. kept computer maker Acer Inc. from selling a
new handset that used it.
Mr. Tsai said Alibaba's operating system is for smartphones as
well as other devices, and is part of the company's long-term
strategy in China, where many Google services are unavailable.
Alibaba can put its services, such as e-commerce, on top of its
operating system, he said.
"The dominant player today may not be dominant tomorrow. That's
why we continue to invest in our OS," Mr. Tsai said.
Some investors shrugged off the increased spending on mobile
commerce, even though it resulted in lower-than-hoped-for profit
margins.
"The new strategic initiatives have yet to ramp up. So they're
getting a pass [on margins] because revenue growth is still huge,
and they're standing in front of what's seasonally their strongest
quarter," said Jim O'Donnell, chief investment officer at Forward
Management LLC, a $6 billion fund and Alibaba shareholder. He was
referring in part to the coming Nov. 11 Singles Day holiday in
China, which has historically been Alibaba's biggest sales day.
Excluding certain costs, such as those related to the IPO,
Alibaba had earnings of 45 cents a share for the September quarter,
in line with the average analyst estimate on Thomson Reuters. The
company's revenue surpassed the average estimate of $2.61
billion.
Alibaba said that on its China retail marketplaces, gross
merchandise volume for the quarter increased 49% and annual active
buyers increased 52% year-over-year.
Telis Demos contributed to this article.
Write to Juro Osawa at juro.osawa@wsj.com and Gillian Wong at
gillian.wong@wsj.com