CWA Calls On FCC To Include Web Cos In Internet Rule
October 15 2009 - 5:24PM
Dow Jones News
The Communications Workers of America is calling on the Federal
Communications Commission to include Web companies like Google Inc.
(GOOG) in new Internet rules, signaling increasing pressure on
regulators to tread carefully in imposing the regulations.
The proposed open Internet rule is slated for an FCC vote next
week. The rule would prevent Internet companies such as Comcast
Corp. (CMCSA), Verizon Communications Inc. (VZ) or AT&T Inc.
(T) from selectively blocking or slowing certain Web content, and
would require providers to disclose how they manage their
networks.
In a letter sent to the FCC Thursday, CWA said the rule's
principles on competition and transparency should apply to all
Internet participants, "including network providers, application
and service providers, and content providers."
AT&T and other Internet service providers are concerned that
the "net neutrality" rules now circulating at the FCC will apply
only to them and not firms like Google.
CWA pointed out that Google employs 10 times fewer people than
AT&T and invests significantly less than AT&T in broadband
infrastructure.
CWA has some 300,000 members that are employees of telecom firms
like AT&T and Verizon as well as network manufacturers like
Alcatel-Lucent (ALU).
CWA Telecommunications Policy Director Debbie Goldman said the
union needed to get in front of the net neutrality debate before
the FCC rule becomes a hindrance to private investment.
"We began to get very concerned that it was going to have a
negative impact on investment, which in this industry means
hundreds of thousands of our members' jobs," Goldman said. "We need
a reasoned dialogue."
CWA wants to ensure that Internet service providers like
AT&T and Verizon have a level playing field against companies
like Google in terms of Internet regulation.
That could be a tall order. The FCC's jurisdiction over Web
companies like Google is debatable, and probably will be determined
in court, while its authority over Internet service providers is
more clear-cut.
Google's Washington Telecom and Media Counsel Richard Whitt said
it is "frightening" to argue that "all online software
applications, content, and viewpoints must be subject for the first
time to FCC regulation."
CWA's Goldman countered that the FCC has the authority to impose
rules on Internet applications because those products are
information services under telecom law.
CWA also says the new Internet rule should have "robust
carve-outs" for ISPs to manage their networks.
FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski has said the rule will allow
ISPs to manage their networks to ensure smooth performance during
peak traffic times, but network providers and manufacturers are
worried that any new regulations could hamper their activities.
Alcatel-Lucent and other manufacturers, including Cisco Systems
Inc. (CSCO) and Motorola Inc. (MOT), sent a separate letter to the
FCC Thursday saying new Internet regulations could "adversely
impact those of us who supply vital network services, networking
gear, and other devices and equipment used in building and
maintaining networks."
Major telecom associations sent the FCC a different letter
Thursday expressing concern that the draft proposal "apparently
contains highly controversial conclusions" about the broadband
market.
The letter, signed by USTelecom, CTIA-The Wireless Association,
The Telecommunications Industry Association, and the Independent
Telephone and Telecommunications Alliance, said Genachowski should
"develop consensus on the key issues and avoid conclusions that
would cause divisions inside and outside the Commission."
Based on earlier statements from the commissioners at the
five-member body, it is possible the Internet proposal could be
approved on a party-line vote.
-By Fawn Johnson, Dow Jones Newswires; 202-862-9263;
fawn.johnson@dowjones.com