3rd UPDATE:NYSE Euronext Swings To $182 Million 2Q Loss;Knocks Flash
July 30 2009 - 11:14AM
Dow Jones News
The head of NYSE Euronext (NYX) on Thursday criticized new
trading techniques used by some rivals as a "giant step backwards"
for an industry under increasing regulatory scrutiny.
Duncan Niederauer, chief executive, said the use of so-called
"flash" order types "tilts the playing field toward a select group
of participants," and said they mirrored practices that NYSE
Euronext itself has ended.
His comments came as the transatlantic exchange operator
reported a second-quarter loss thanks to a $355 million charge
related to its new U.K. clearing business, though the company
boosted its full-year forecast for cost savings.
Shares were recently 3.3% higher at $27.90.
NYSE Euronext is the only major U.S. equities platform not to
use flash order types, which display stock orders to off-exchange
liquidity pools before they're sent out to the broader market.
Niederauer has been critical of the practice in recent weeks and
acknowledged on a conference call that NYSE Euronext gave up "a
percentage point or two" of market share by not following
competitors' lead. But, he said, "we felt it was the right decision
to make."
Flash orders have come under fire because they're perceived as
giving an information advantage to certain traders. Niederauer
acknowledged comparisons to the Big Board's old market model, in
which specialists were criticized for the same reason.
"It's a little ironic that some of the same people who insisted
we eliminate those information advantages" have now adopted flash
orders, he said.
Rivals Nasdaq OMX Group Inc. (NDAQ) and BATS Exchange
implemented their versions of flash orders in June, in response to
the success of upstart Direct Edge, which has grown to become the
third-largest U.S. equities market operator thanks in part to the
practice.
NYSE Euronext has seen its market share in U.S. cash equities
drop to about 28% in July from 33% at the beginning of the year,
partially due to the rise of flash order types, Niederauer said
Thursday.
Niederauer expressed confidence that the Securities and Exchange
Commission, which has been reviewing the practice, will address the
issue appropriately and that any action won't affect overall market
liquidity.
If regulators crack down on flash orders, NYSE Euronext will
likely see a bump in its market share, Chief Financial Officer
Michael Geltzeiler told Dow Jones Newswires.
Charges Hit 2Q
A modest rise in revenue from the prior quarter and lower
expenses year-on-year for NYSE Euronext were wiped out by the $355
million paid to LCH.Clearnet Group Ltd. under a deal that sees the
stock market and derivatives exchange operator taking more of its
clearing in-house.
The clearing move is seen adding more than $100 million in
annual revenues and is anticipated to be accretive in 2009, while
staffing reductions will contribute further cost savings.
The cost of staff cuts in the U.S. and Europe also weighed on
the quarter, though earnings were ahead of consensus excluding
special charges, and the company said it would beat its target of
extracting $100 million in synergies this year from the acquisition
of the American Stock Exchange.
The reported net loss of $182 million, or 70 cents a share,
compared with a $195 million profit in the second quarter of 2008.
Excluding one-off charges, a 51-cent surplus in the latest quarter
was ahead of the 45-cent consensus among analysts.
NYSE Euronext, like rivals, has been paring expenses to counter
intensifying competition in the cash equities business and a slide
in volume of some its core derivatives products, its largest
business segment by revenue.
The company is cutting almost 300 staff, a move that helped cut
fixed costs by 6% compared with a year ago.
Revenue rose to $1.125 billion from $1.03 billion a year ago and
$1.1 billion in the prior quarter, with the company citing the
positive impact of pricing changes for the sequential
improvement.
NYSE Euronext said its U.S. futures platform is expected to see
an operating loss of $25 million to $30 million this year as the
company works to build trading activity and secure equity partners
for the venture.
It also plans to launch new futures contracts based on MSCI
indexes in the third quarter, as well as fixed-income derivatives
following a new clearing partnership with Depository Trust and
Clearing Corp.
-By Jacob Bunge, Dow Jones Newswires; 312-750-4117;
jacob.bunge@dowjones.com
(Doug Cameron and A.H. Mooradian contributed to this
article)