Brazil Miner Vale Steps Up Spot Ore Sales To China
April 16 2009 - 11:53AM
Dow Jones News
Brazilian mining giant Companhia Vale do Rio Doce (RIO), or
Vale, is aggressively offering "undercover" discounts to Chinese
iron ore spot market buyers through cheaper freight charges, a
former Vale executive told Dow Jones Newswires on Thursday.
The former executive, who wished to remain anonymous, confirmed
a Citigroup note Wednesday that stated Vale was "aggressively"
selling the commodity at spot market prices to China.
Contacted by Dow Jones Newswires, a spokeswoman for Vale
declined to comment on the company's sales strategy.
The former Vale executive said the discounting was putting
Chinese iron ore miners in a difficult situation as they cannot
match the price or the quality of Brazilian imports.
Vale has been selling iron ore fines from its Carajas mine at
$70-$75 a metric ton in recent weeks, signing new long-term
contracts with small and medium-sized mills, according to
Citigroup.
Iron ore spot prices in China have come down in recent weeks to
$64 per ton due to Vale's aggressive entry into the market.
According to the former Vale executive, Chinese steel mills were
opportunistically buying the cheaper iron ore on offer but the
steel industry has not completely recovered yet, and so stocks are
growing.
Chinese port stocks have risen 10 million tons to around 68
million tons, with March iron ore imports reaching a record high of
52.1 million tons, up 46% on the year.
"On the negative side, greater inventories may mean lower iron
ore demand later in the year, and a continuing fall in prices, but
in compensation Vale may gain greater market share," said the
former executive.
A New York-based mining sector analyst, who also wished to
remain anonymous, said, "The fact Vale has been practicing large
spot market discounts is old news and nothing new to those in the
loop. What's most interesting to investors at the moment is the
likelihood of a price settlement between miners and Japanese
mills."
Japan's Sankei Shimbun reported Thursday that BHP Billiton Ltd.
(BHP) and other iron ore miners were about to sign a supply
agreement with major local steelmakers at a 30% discount on 2008
prices.
A Vale spokesman told Dow Jones Newswires on Thursday the
company would not comment on how it was selling its iron ore or on
negotiations with steel mills.
-By John Kolodziejski, Dow Jones Newswires; 55-21-2586-6086;
John.Kolodziejski@dowjones.com