PROPOSAL No. 4: APPROVAL OF AN AMENDMENT TO THE AMENDED AND
RESTATED LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY AGREEMENT OF OUR WHOLLY-OWNED SUBSIDIARY, OFFICE DEPOT, LLC, TO ELIMINATE THE PASS-THROUGH PROVISION
As previously announced, on June 30, 2020, we
implemented a holding company reorganization under Section 251(g) of the General Corporation Law of the State of Delaware (the DGCL), whereby a newly-formed Delaware corporation (The ODP Corporation) became the parent public
company, and the former parent public company became a wholly-owned subsidiary of the Company. Specifically, in connection with this reorganization, Office Depot, Inc., a Delaware corporation and the former parent public company (ODI),
merged with and into an indirect wholly-owned subsidiary of the Company, Office Depot, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (OD LLC). OD LLC is a wholly-owned subsidiary of ODP Investment, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company
(ODPI), which is a wholly-owned subsidiary of the Company.
As required by Section 251(g) of the DGCL, OD LLCs limited liability company
Agreement was amended in connection with the Reorganization (as so amended and restated, the LLC Agreement), to provide that (i) any act or transaction by or involving OD LLC, other than the election or removal of managers, that
would require the approval of ODPI as OD LLCs sole shareholder, if OD LLC were a corporation subject to the DGCL rather than a limited liability company, will also require the approval of the Companys shareholders, and (ii) any
amendment to the LLC Agreement that would, if adopted by a corporation subject to the DGCL, be required to be included in the certificate of incorporation of such corporation, will require, by specific reference to Section 251(g) of the DGCL
and in addition to the approval of ODPI as the sole member of OD LLC, the approval of the Companys shareholders by the same vote as is required by the DGCL and/or by the LLC Agreement (the Pass-Through Provision). Accordingly, the
Pass-Through Provision gives the Companys public shareholders direct voting rights with respect to matters affecting the Companys indirect wholly-owned subsidiary, OD LLC, that would otherwise only require the approval of ODPI, a direct
wholly-owned subsidiary of the Company, as sole member. Absent a provision like the Pass-Through Provision, there is no general requirement under Delaware law that shareholders of a parent entity vote on transactions involving the parent
entitys wholly-owned subsidiaries.
The Board of Directors seeks approval from the Companys shareholders to amend the LLC Agreement in order to remove
the Pass-Through Provision, which is an unusual requirement and a limitation on the Companys administrative and operational flexibility. Among other things, the removal of the Pass-Through Provision would allow The ODP Corporation, through its
wholly-owned subsidiary ODPI acting as the sole member of OD LLC, to approve certain corporate acts relating to its indirect wholly-owned subsidiary OD LLC, without requiring the additional approval of the Companys shareholders. There are no
similar pass-through voting provisions in the governing documents of the Companys other subsidiaries, nor does Delaware law generally require that the shareholders of a parent company vote on these types of matters involving the parents
wholly-owned subsidiaries.
The following provisions will be removed from Section 15 of the LLC Agreement of OD LLC if this Proposal 4 is approved by the
Companys shareholders:
(b) Stockholder Consent. Notwithstanding anything in this Agreement to the
contrary, the approval of the stockholders of New Parent must be obtained for any act or transaction by or involving the Company, other than the election or removal of Managers, that would require the approval of the stockholders of the Company if
the Company were a corporation subject to the General Corporation Law rather than a limited liability company.
(c) Amendments. Notwithstanding anything herein to the contrary, any amendment to this Agreement that would, if adopted
by a corporation subject to the General Corporation Law, be required to be included in the certificate of incorporation of such corporation, shall, by specific reference to Section 251(g) of the General Corporation Law, require, in addition to
the approval of the Member as set forth herein, the approval of the stockholders of New Parent (or any successor of New Parent by merger), by the same vote as is required by the General Corporation Law and/or by this Agreement.
A complete copy of the proposed amendment is attached to this proxy statement as Appendix A.
Board Rationale
The removal of the Pass-Through Provision will put
the Company in the same position as substantially all other public holding companies that operate through multiple subsidiaries. It is uncommon for the shareholders of such public
● ● ●
81