Alexa Can Do Many Things But Won't Call 911
November 06 2018 - 5:59AM
Dow Jones News
By Sarah Krouse
Americans regularly ask their Amazon Echo and Google Home
devices to play music, share the weather and call friends. Yet most
still can't ask their smart speakers to call 911.
Technology giants such as Amazon.com Inc. and Alphabet Inc.'s
Google that sell popular internet-connected speakers have largely
stopped short of making them conduits for emergency calls, even as
the devices have evolved to ring cellphones and landlines. Such
devices are now used in 20 million U.S. homes, roughly double the
number a year earlier, according to ComScore Inc.
There are regulatory and technical reasons why the devices
aren't always able to make emergency calls. Internet reliability is
a potential problem, as is the need to transmit accurate location
data and a callback number to emergency call takers, emergency
communications professionals say.
Most speakers only offer one-way calling and don't have the same
real-time GPS data that smartphones do. Even sending 911 caller
location data from cellphones has proved challenging because much
of the nation's 911 infrastructure developed around landline
phones.
Creating the ability to call 911 from a smart speaker would
require an additional monthly 911 surcharge that customers or the
technology companies would have to pay to support emergency call
infrastructure. Current monthly 911 surcharges vary by state or
county, but typically range from $0.25 to $3.00 and are included in
consumers' wireless and landline phone bills.
A regulatory exemption that spares certain calling services such
as Skype from having to reach local emergency call centers has to
date shielded smart-speaker makers from having to overcome those
hurdles.
The Federal Communications Commission is in the early stages of
considering -- and asking the telecommunications industry --
whether it should pass more stringent rules akin to those for
cellphone or landline 911 calls for services such as mobile apps or
senior monitoring devices that can call 911. It is unclear if any
such new rules would apply to smart speakers because many don't
currently connect to the system.
A spokeswoman for Amazon said customers can use the company's
Echo Connect, a device that can be linked to landlines or other
home phone services, to make emergency calls. The standard Amazon
Echo and Echo Dot cannot make emergency calls. "I can't speculate
on our future plans," she said.
"There are a number of technical and regulatory guidelines
involved in enabling 911 calls," said a Google spokeswoman, adding
that customers can use the Google Assistant app on their cellphones
to dial 911.
Dan Henry, director of government affairs at 911 industry group
the National Emergency Number Association, supports adding
emergency calling to such smart speakers as long as they provide
location information and a callback number.
"We're of the opinion that 911 needs to evolve," Mr. Henry said,
"and that the mechanisms that arise should be able to take up the
mantle and connect to 911."
Bridget Taylor, a 62-year-old in Jonesboro, Ark., fell getting
out of her bathtub this spring, but she didn't have her cellphone
with her to call for help.
"As soon as I was pulling myself up, I thought, 'Alexa is within
my voice and I wish I could just yell -- call 911'," she said. Ms.
Taylor, who pays about $40 a month for her elderly mother's
emergency help button, said she hopes smart speakers like the Echo
one day eliminate the need for her to buy one for herself.
It is important to tell children the limitations of smart
speakers, said David Hill, chair of the American Academy of
Pediatrics' council on communications and media.
Children eight and younger, in particular, might believe the
device is able to do tasks that adults know are beyond the gadget's
capabilities or that there is a little person inside, Dr. Hill
said.
"As part of your family safety meeting," Dr. Hill said, "you
want to talk about how to call 911 and make sure the kids know that
Alexa won't do it for you."
Write to Sarah Krouse at sarah.krouse@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
November 06, 2018 05:44 ET (10:44 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2018 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
Alphabet (NASDAQ:GOOG)
Historical Stock Chart
From Aug 2024 to Sep 2024
Alphabet (NASDAQ:GOOG)
Historical Stock Chart
From Sep 2023 to Sep 2024