Tesla Crash Victim's Family Seeks Court Probe
September 20 2016 - 3:40PM
Dow Jones News
SHANGHAI—A Chinese man whose son was killed while driving a
Tesla Motors Inc. vehicle applied to a local Beijing court to
investigate whether the car's Autopilot driving system was
engaged.
In January, 23-year-old Gao Yaning died in a crash in the
northeastern province of Hebei while driving a Tesla Model S. Six
months later his father, Gao Jubin, filed a lawsuit accusing Tesla
of exaggerating Autopilot's capabilities. At a court hearing
Tuesday, he asked for an independent investigation of the cause of
the crash.
"The family insists the investigation should be done by a third
party, rather than Tesla," said Cui Qiuna, a lawyer for the Gao
family. The court will study the family's request.
The family believes the car was in Autopilot mode when it
collided with a road sweeper, Ms. Cui said.
Tesla said the collision damage makes it impossible to
determine, and that the family hasn't provided it with any
additional information to allow it to investigate, despite repeated
requests.
Tesla said in a statement after the hearing that even if
Autopilot was engaged, it wasn't the cause of the collision. When
the system is turned on it warns the driver to keep hands on the
steering wheel, the car maker said, reinforced by repeated warnings
to "be prepared to take over at any time." In this case, it said,
the driver took no action even though the road sweeper "was visible
for nearly 20 seconds."
Mr. Gao's traffic fatality was first reported last week by state
broadcaster China Central Television, which said video footage
taken by a camera inside the car showed the vehicle maintaining its
speed as it crashed into the road sweeper. The report also quoted
Chinese police as saying there was no evidence that the brakes had
been applied.
In court Tuesday, Gao's family called on Tesla to admit its
salespeople had exaggerated Autopilot's capabilities and publicly
apologize for false advertising, said the family's lawyers. In
addition, the family is seeking 10,000 yuan ($1,500) as
compensation for the grief they have suffered because of the son's
death.
The court in Beijing's Chaoqyang District didn't give a verdict
on Tuesday, said the lawyers, who added it will hold another
hearing on the family's request for an independent
investigation.
Tesla revised the marketing of its Autopilot feature in China
since mid-August, after a Beijing driver who sideswiped a parked
car when the system was engaged accused the auto maker of
overplaying its capabilities. There were no injuries.
It scaled back its description of Autopilot on its website and
in other marketing materials from zi dong jia shi, meaning the car
can drive itself, to zi dong fu zhu jia shi, meaning it is a
driver-assist system. Tesla's China-based sales staff was told to
make the system's limitations clear.
Scrutiny of the semiautonomous-driving option has risen since
Tesla disclosed in June that a Model S using the system hadÂ
crashed in Florida, killing the driver. The U.S. National Highway
Traffic Safety Administration has said it would investigate the
crash, one of a handful linked to the Autopilot system, which made
its debut nearly a year ago and was designed to help drivers change
lanes, maintain a safe speed and find parking spaces.
Several driverless-car advocates have criticized Autopilot for
lulling drivers into believing the car is in control—as evidenced
by videos that drivers have posted online showing themselves
reading or even sitting in the back seat while the car drove
itself—when in fact it requires them to remain alert.
Earlier this month Tesla Chief Executive Elon Musk announced
plans to update the Autopilot software with changes, including
making it rely more on the car's radar system, that he said likely
would have prevented the Florida crash.
Rose Yu
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
September 20, 2016 15:25 ET (19:25 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2016 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
Tesla (NASDAQ:TSLA)
Historical Stock Chart
From Aug 2024 to Sep 2024
Tesla (NASDAQ:TSLA)
Historical Stock Chart
From Sep 2023 to Sep 2024