CORRECT:Equities Clearing,Order Types To Boost Nasdaq Market Share
May 15 2009 - 6:00PM
Dow Jones News
Nasdaq OMX Group (NDAQ) may forgo profits on a planned new
equity clearing service in an effort to arrest the fall in its
share of U.S. stock trading, an executive said Friday.
The move is among a raft of measures planned after Nasdaq OMX
Group's share of U.S. equity trading fell below 20% on some days in
May, despite cutting prices to fend off the challenge of new
electronic platforms.
The operator of the Nasdaq Stock Market also plans to introduce
new order types that can route orders through private pools of
liquidity, an approach that resembles rival platforms operated by
Direct Edge ECN LLC and BATS Exchange Inc.
Nasdaq OMX's planned clearing service would rival a similar
near-cost pricing structure offered by the Depository Trust and
Clearing Corp., and is contingent on the move boosting its share of
trading volume, according to Brian Hyndman, senior vice president
of Nasdaq Transaction Services.
Its willingness to clear stock trades at cost follows a U.S.
Treasury-backed plan, announced this week, that would mandate
clearing of standardized over-the-counter derivatives, a boon to
derivatives exchanges like CME Group Inc. (CME) and
IntercontinentalExchange Inc. (ICE) that are set up to handle such
trades.
Nasdaq OMX itself has sought inroads to the OTC markets through
its International Derivatives Clearing Group venture, which clears
interest-rate swap trades, but the focus remains on its U.S.
equities-market share, which has dropped to 22% from 27% since
January, according to a Raymond James report.
Nasdaq Clearing Corp., slated to launch in the fourth quarter,
aims to be cheaper than the DTCC; despite the latter's status as a
non-profit, member-owned utility, the company carries a substantial
amount of overhead that keeps the overall price higher than it
needs to be, Hyndman said.
A streamlined alternative from Nasdaq OMX should bring in more
trade, according to Hyndman.
"If we're delivering value to our customers, we should see a
bigger portion of that volume and market share come to us."
Order Types A New Focus
Nasdaq OMX also is experimenting with new order types that
change the way stock orders are directed through its markets,
looking to draw more traders with faster and cheaper
executions.
On May 1, the exchange introduced a strategy nicknamed "Thrifty"
that routes orders from the Nasdaq Stock Exchange to Nasdaq OMX BX,
a handful of private liquidity pools, and the New York Stock
Exchange, at a price that is lower than other public exchanges,
according to Hyndman.
And starting in June, Nasdaq OMX will introduce an order type
known as "Flash," which will check stock orders first against the
Nasdaq Stock Exchange before routing them through an internal feed
viewable only by Nasdaq OMX customers, which "should offer a more
aggressive price" before going out to the public market, Hyndman
said.
It isn't quite a dark pool, but Hyndman acknowledged it is
similar to the approach of Direct Edge, which checks orders against
its main book and then, if the order isn't filled, sends orders to
a dark pool accessible by about 25 participants before it goes out
to other markets.
Dark pools are private markets where large equity orders are
transacted anonymously.
At Direct Edge, officials said clients must opt in to have their
orders routed through the dark pool, but Hyndman said Nasdaq's
"Flash" order type will route orders via the internal feed by
default.
Customer feedback has been positive so far, Hyndman said, and
more varieties of the "Flash" order are in the works.
The fusion of off-exchange liquidity pools and open markets is
gaining traction among equities platforms.
BATS Exchange earlier this month debuted a new strategy called
Dark Scan, which flows orders through dark pools before they hit
the main order book, in exchange for a rebate of 1 cent per 100
shares traded.
The practice has drawn criticism from some who take issue with
routing trades through dark pools by default, forcing clients to
opt out.
Another argument is that liquidity on other exchanges could
disappear while a stock order makes its way through various dark
pools.
Joseph Mecane, chief administrative officer at NYSE Euronext
(NYX), said Friday that the exchange plans to file a comment letter
with the Securities and Exchange Commission opposing some of these
practices.
-By Jacob Bunge, Dow Jones Newswires; 312-750-4117;
jacob.bunge@dowjones.com