By Anna Wilde Mathews and Melanie Evans
HCA Healthcare Inc., one of the nation's largest hospital
operators, has closed clinics and outpatient facilities and cut
employees' hours. A family-medicine practice in Dallas furloughed a
third of its staff. A major 48-hospital nonprofit system will put
700 workers on temporary leave.
Amid a pandemic that has sickened thousands in the U.S., many
hospitals and doctors are grappling with an unexpected side effect:
a financial squeeze that could deplete the health-care resources
needed to meet local surges in cases and threatens the operations
of some financially struggling hospitals.
Coronavirus patients are overwhelming hospitals in cities
including New York, New Orleans and Detroit. As others brace for
similar spikes, they are also seeing sharp drop-offs in regular
doctor visits, emergency-room arrivals and the lucrative surgeries
that are vital to most hospitals' bottom lines.
Hospitals are burning through cash even as nonprofit operators
have seen their reserves in investment portfolios dented, spurring
credit agencies to put the sector on a negative outlook -- despite
an expected influx of money from a newly passed federal aid
package.
"There's this waiting period for the wave to hit that a lot of
hospitals aren't prepared to weather," said Chas Roades, chief
executive of Gist Healthcare, a consulting firm. "Because the
revenue has gone way down, they're having to cut expenses in a way
that might make them less prepared when the wave does hit."
Governors in at least 17 states have halted or urged hospitals
to stop elective procedures in recent weeks. Hospitals themselves
have canceled surgeries to clear space for expected coronavirus
patients and preserve scarce protective equipment. Many patients
have decided to avoid medical settings and obey government
stay-at-home orders.
Williamson, W.Va., is at risk of losing its facility, Williamson
Memorial Hospital, just as the virus is expected to spread. The
hospital said Monday it would close its doors in April, after
revenue dropped about 45% in March. Visits to its emergency room
fell by about a third, while inpatient days dropped by around
two-thirds, said Gene Preston, interim chief executive of the
76-bed hospital.
The hospital is operating in bankruptcy but had secured
financing intended to keep it open until a buyer took over, but the
new pressure meant that money wouldn't be enough, he said.
Williamson Memorial hasn't yet treated any patients with
Covid-19 -- the respiratory illness caused by the novel coronavirus
-- but Mr. Preston said he is worried that if it shuts, local
residents who are infected with it might delay seeking treatment or
need to be transferred to a hospital farther away.
On Wednesday, Williamson Health & Wellness Center, a local
clinic, said it would buy the hospital, aiming to close the deal on
April 30. Donovan Beckett, chief executive of the clinic, said it
hopes to keep the hospital operating without a gap, but "it's too
soon to tell" if that will be possible.
Bigger operators are also under pressure. Bon Secours Mercy
Health, a nonprofit with hospitals in seven states, said it would
furlough 700 administrative workers and freeze wages for
administrative staff. "We're facing hard decisions over the short
term," Bon Secours said in a statement.
HCA Healthcare says it is seeking to avoid layoffs or furloughs,
curbing expenses and putting off capital projects. It is moving
idled workers to other jobs. The company will pay those who can't
be redeployed 70% of their base pay for up to seven weeks.
"It's important to us to keep our workforce," said Chief
Executive Sam Hazen. More than 40,000 full- and part-time workers
would be eligible for paid downtime. Top executives will also see
pay cut by 30% through the pandemic, the company said, and Mr.
Hazen will donate two months' pay to a hardship fund for
workers.
The revenue loss comes as spending is soaring on supplies that
are in shortage, extra workforce and other preparations for an
expected -- and in some cases realized -- surge of Covid-19
patients, hospital executives said. That has put hospitals in "an
economic vise," Mr. Hazen said.
A $2 trillion federal stimulus package signed into law last
Friday is set to deliver aid, including a $100 billion fund for
hospitals and other health-care providers. Hospitals say they don't
know how the money will be divvied up or how quickly it will get to
hospitals.
Tuesday, the American Hospital Association asked the Trump
administration to immediately push out about $23 billion by sending
hospitals $25,000 for each of their beds, with more for those in
coronavirus hot spots. Wrapping in all parts of the bill, the AHA
estimates hospitals could end up receiving $120 billion in federal
aid.
A spokeswoman for the Department of Health and Human Services
said the administration "is continuing to take quick and decisive
action to combat Covid-19 and protect Americans."
At Three Rivers Hospital, in Brewster, Wash., executives are
waiting for government aid to offset a 42% drop in revenue in
March, due to a slump in emergency-room traffic and primary-care
visits and halted elective procedures. Help from the state is
enabling Three Rivers to pay employees for the next few weeks,
while a potential advance from Medicare might fund another month of
operations. The hospital doesn't know how it will get a share of
the $100 billion federal relief fund.
For now, Three Rivers's books show about $900,000 in unpaid
bills, and executives have been putting off vendors.
"To have this happen, and to have this happen so rapidly, has
been devastating," said Scott Graham, chief executive of 25-bed
facility and another nearby hospital.
Beaumont Health, based in Southfield, Mich., operates eight
hospitals around Detroit and Southeast Michigan and is quickly
burning through cash, said John Fox, the nonprofit system's chief
executive. It needs about $12 million to finance daily operations
and had enough reserves before the pandemic to stay afloat for
about 200 days. Now Beaumont is losing about $70 million a month
after halting electives in March.
Meantime, the system has ramped up spending to respond to the
pandemic, he said. Tuesday afternoon, Beaumont had about 900
hospital patients with coronavirus infections.
Its cash reserves have been further depleted by tumbling
markets, Mr. Fox said. Nonprofits don't return cash to shareholders
and instead pour profits into capital projects and investment
portfolios. Beaumont's investment portfolio was down 10%
year-to-date as of March 27.
Fitch Ratings said Monday that markets had erased about 30 days
of operating cash for the median nonprofit-hospital borrower in its
credit portfolio. Many hospitals will likely violate terms for
debt-service coverage set by lenders in the municipal bond markets,
triggering a "soft" default in the first or second quarter, Fitch
hospital analyst Kevin Holloran said. Nonetheless, hospitals are
widely expected to pay bondholders on time, he said, avoiding a
"hard" default that could accelerate repayment.
Major credit-ratings firms lowered their outlook for hospitals
to negative in recent days, as efforts to fight the pandemic hurt
hospital profits and the overall economy.
The federal help will likely fall short of making up the
industry's full losses, said Gary Taylor, an analyst with JPMorgan
Chase & Co. Based on an informal survey of hospital owners last
week, Mr. Taylor estimated that revenues are down 40% to 60%, with
sharp drops in emergency-room visits and inpatient surgical
volumes.
"The overall level of activity is lower than we've ever seen,"
he said. "It's a really unprecedented situation." On the other
side, he added, health insurers could see a financial benefit from
the forgone procedures, as the cancellations save them money.
Though many might be rescheduled, the surgeries being canceled
are often those most essential to hospitals' earnings, including
hip and knee replacements, as well as other procedures performed on
patients with private insurance.
Coronavirus cases will often be less profitable, partly because
many Covid-19 patients will be on Medicare, which often pays less
than employer plans despite a newly enacted rate bump for such
patients, analysts said. Care required for coronavirus infections
can also be intensive and costly.
A recent survey by analysts at Barclays PLC found that doctors
were seeing visits drop by about 50% on average. Though some were
replaced by remote telehealth consultations, that might not be
enough to offset the decline, they wrote.
In Dallas, Chrisette Dharma, owner of Southwest Family Medicine
Associates, an eight-doctor family medicine practice, furloughed a
third of her 27-person staff last week, setting aside cash to help
them financially. The practice is now doing around 50 to 70 visits
a day, less than half its typical volume, leading revenue to drop
75%, she said.
Many of visits now occur remotely, and the insurer reimbursement
isn't yet clear. Dr. Dharma is looking at whether she can get help
through one of the new federal programs, she said: "We are
surviving on a prayer."
Write to Anna Wilde Mathews at anna.mathews@wsj.com and Melanie
Evans at Melanie.Evans@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
April 01, 2020 15:33 ET (19:33 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.