New Jersey's Economic Development Authority to Change How It Makes Money
January 27 2020 - 10:38AM
Dow Jones News
By Joseph De Avila
New Jersey's Economic Development Authority said it plans to
tweak how the agency makes money after a state task force raised
concerns about a potential conflict of interest.
The EDA's lax oversight of the state's $11 billion corporate
tax-incentive program resulted in improperly awarded tax breaks,
according to a report released this month by a task force appointed
by Gov. Phil Murphy.
Businesses paid fees to the EDA for the tax credits, and the
greater the credit, the greater the fee.
"The EDA thus has a financial interest in the approval and award
of tax credits," the report said. "This presents the risk that the
EDA may have a natural incentive to administer the tax-incentives
programs in a manner that results in more, rather than fewer,
approved awards."
EDA staff told the task force that the fees didn't affect how
they determined awards, according to the report, and the task force
didn't find evidence to contradict that. But nevertheless the task
force said the fees presented "questions of the EDA's operations at
the systemic level."
New Jersey's EDA doesn't receive any funds from the state budget
unlike many other state economic-development agencies, including
those in New York and Connecticut. Instead, the EDA is entirely
self-funded through fees, rent from real-estate holdings and
interest earned from lending money to businesses.
In 2013, the EDA changed how it calculated fees, and they became
a larger component of funding for the authority. Fees for the tax
credits accounted for 36% of the EDA's revenue in 2017 and 29% in
2018, said Tim Sullivan, chief executive of the EDA.
That figure is expected to drop to about 10% and 12% for 2019,
he said.
"In a normal year, we should seek to break even, not make a
profit," Mr. Sullivan said in an interview. "We aren't here to
optimize the financial performance of the EDA."
New Jersey's tax-credit program expired in June, and the EDA is
no longer taking applications. Mr. Murphy, a Democrat, has called
for capping the amount of tax credits that can be awarded annually
to $340 million. The expired program had no cap.
Mr. Sullivan said Mr. Murphy's proposed cap would mitigate the
conflict of interest concerns raised by the task force because it
would also limit the amount of money the authority could collect
from fees.
The governor, however, hasn't reached an agreement with
lawmakers on how to move forward. Senate President Steve Sweeney, a
Democrat, has opposed a cap and said it puts the state at a
competitive disadvantage.
Mr. Sullivan said that whenever the governor and the legislature
reach an agreement, his team will make changes to the fees.
"We'll take a look at the fees side of it to make sure it's
calibrated the right way, balancing our need to support our
operations but also balancing the considerations outlined in the
task-force report," Mr. Sullivan said.
Write to Joseph De Avila at joseph.deavila@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
January 27, 2020 10:23 ET (15:23 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.