U.S. Files Complaints With WTO Against Trading Partners
July 16 2018 - 3:28PM
Dow Jones News
By Vivian Salama
WASHINGTON -- The U.S. fired back at lawsuits other countries
have filed with the World Trade Organization over Trump steel and
aluminum tariffs, escalating a trade dispute with some of America's
closest allies.
The U.S. on Monday filed separate claims against China, the
European Union, Canada, Mexico and Turkey -- the latest stage in
tit-for-tat retaliations prompted by President Donald Trump's
decision to pursue tariffs earlier this year, citing
national-security interests and unfair trade practices.
"Instead of working with us to address a common problem, some of
our trading partners have elected to respond with retaliatory
tariffs designed to punish American workers, farmers and
companies," U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer said in a
statement Monday. "The United States will take all necessary
actions to protect our interests, and we urge our trading partners
to work constructively with us on the problems created by massive
and persistent excess capacity in the steel and aluminum
sectors."
Mr. Lighthizer's office said that the other countries'
retaliatory tariffs appear to breach commitments made by WTO
members, and added that the tariffs imposed by the U.S. "are
justified under international agreements the United States and its
trading partners have approved."
Trading partners argue that the U.S., by citing
national-security concerns, is using a phony rationale for imposing
tariffs affecting politically favored U.S. industries.
The Trump administration raised the prospect of a global trade
conflict earlier this year by imposing tariffs of 10% on aluminum
imports and 25% on steel imports from Canada, Mexico and the
EU.
Last week, the U.S. also expanded its continuing trade fight
with China, moving beyond industrial goods to impose tariffs on
$200 billion of Chinese consumer products. China is disputing those
tariffs in a WTO complaint also announced Monday.
Other nations hit by tariffs have launched countermeasures of
their own, which so far target $24 billion worth of American-made
goods -- a figure that is set to increase. Some of those tariffs
target industries heavily concentrated in states that supported Mr.
Trump, raising concern about their impact on Republican efforts to
maintain a majority in Congress in November's midterm
elections.
Mr. Trump has repeatedly raised the prospects of withdrawing
from the WTO, although this month he said that no withdrawal was
planned for now, adding that the organization is "treating us badly
and I hope they change their ways."
Beyond Mr. Trump's remarks, the White House has displayed its
dissatisfaction with the WTO by holding up appointments to the
organization's appeals court, hobbling its dispute-settlement
process.
Allies have said the action threatens the WTO.
Mr. Lighthizer said last year that the global commercial arbiter
is "losing its essential focus" and becoming "a litigation-centered
organization" that has failed to pay sufficient attention to
enforcing existing rules.
These lawsuits "send a signal that the Trump administration sees
some value in the WTO," said Chad Bown, a senior fellow at the
Peterson Institute for International Economics in Washington. "If
they weren't filing these cases and holding up appointment of
judges then the, sense would be that they just want the
organization to implode."
Tariff-related cases brought by countries to the WTO could take
as long as three years to resolve. The burden of these disputes may
weigh heavily on the 164-country body, observers warn.
If the U.S. loses the cases and doesn't remove tariffs, the
countries that brought the cases could be authorized by the WTO to
impose tariffs on U.S. goods -- essentially giving WTO imprimatur
to actions they are starting to take.
The U.S., by resorting to tariffs before getting WTO backing for
the actions, reflects disillusionment with the WTO, founded in 1995
as successor to the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, which
took effect in 1948. In 2001, the year China joined the WTO,
members launched talks to update and rewrite global trade rules but
those efforts died a decade ago.
"It is a bizarre world that we are living in when tariffs and
countertariffs come first and then the lawsuits follow," said Mr.
Bown.
Mr. Bown also said he worries that the U.S. is endangering the
WTO system by claiming a national-security rationale. "It opens the
potential for any country to impose tariffs in the name of national
security and that renders the rules of the WTO meaningless," he
said.
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
July 16, 2018 15:13 ET (19:13 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2018 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.