Congress Plans to Reverse Ban on Gun-Violence Research -- Update
March 21 2018 - 8:37PM
Dow Jones News
By Michelle Hackman
WASHINGTON -- Congress paved the way for a resumption of
public-health research into gun violence by the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention, one of several measures inserted in a broad
spending bill to address the Parkland, Fla., school shooting.
In a victory for Democrats, the provision will partially alter
the 1996 ban, known as the "Dickey Amendment," which the CDC has
interpreted as a blanket prohibition on gun-violence research. The
legislation will explicitly allow the agency to conduct
public-health research on gun use, though it would still be barred
from advocating tighter gun control.
Supporters of the Dickey provision say it ensures that the
federal government doesn't become enmeshed in a contentious
political issue. But Democrats and some centrist Republicans
contend that the amendment has had a chilling effect on scientific
research into the issue, interfering with a greater understanding
of the causes of gun violence.
A senior Republican aide said the measure doesn't reverse the
Dickey Amendment, but rather clarifies that it allows research to
continue.
The change is one of several gun measures Congress will include
in its spending package, which it must pass by Friday night to
avoid a partial federal shutdown. Lawmakers have also agreed to
include a bipartisan measure strengthening federal background
checks and boosting funding for school security and mental
health.
The moves were applauded by education advocates and school
districts, which have spent years lobbying for increased federal
dollars to supplement dwindling school budgets.
But the measures will likely do little to quell continued calls
from advocates for greater gun control -- including vocal Parkland
students -- who hoped to see stronger measures that they say are
key to preventing future mass shootings.
Congressional leaders also agreed to include legislation from
Sens. John Cornyn (R., Texas) and Chris Murphy (D., Conn.) dubbed
"Fix NICS," which encourages state and federal agencies to submit
conviction records to the FBI's National Instant Criminal
Background Check System, or NICS.
Most other gun-safety proposals supported by Democrats --
including expanded background checks, a higher minimum age for
rifle purchases and a ban on assault-style weapons -- face an
uphill battle in Congress, where nearly all Republicans and some
red-state Democrats oppose them.
The bill will also include $1.1 billion this year to help pay
for mental-health and school safety programs, including hiring
school psychologists or counselors.
It will also authorize up to $100 million a year on other
initiatives, such as violence-prevention training for teachers and
students. That funding can't be spent on arming teachers, a measure
the Trump administration had sought but had caused bipartisan
unease.
"The fact that schools are going to get a meaningful amount of
money -- that's significant," said Kelly Vaillancourt, director of
government relations at the National Association of School
Psychologists. But, she added, "we don't want Congress to now wipe
their hands and say, 'We've addressed school safety.' "
The package reflects the sustained pressure from activists,
particularly students and parents from Marjory Stoneman Douglas
High School in Parkland, Fla., whose organizing has prompted a
renewed national discussion of school violence and gun safety. Last
week, more than a million students across the country walked out of
their schools in a coordinated gesture to protest government
inaction on gun control.
On Saturday -- the date by which Congress must pass its spending
bill to avoid a partial government shutdown -- hundreds of
thousands of people are expected to come to Washington to attend a
rally that organizers have called the "March for Our Lives."
Gun-rights activists, however, say the emotional reaction to the
Parkland shooting shouldn't lead to laws that deprive responsible
gun owners of their rights. A better response, they say, is greater
attention to mental health, school-security funding, and
enforcement of existing gun laws.
Earlier this week, Education Secretary Betsy DeVos announced the
composition of a federal commission on school safety that President
Donald Trump formed as part of his administration's response to the
Parkland massacre. The commission, which will meet for the first
time next month, will comprise secretaries from the Departments of
Justice, Health and Human Services and Homeland Security.
Education activists have accused Mrs. DeVos of reneging on a
promise to involve educators and other school-safety experts.
Write to Michelle Hackman at Michelle.Hackman@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
March 21, 2018 20:22 ET (00:22 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2018 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.