By Nick Timiraos
Most Federal Reserve officials last month expected the central
bank could stop shrinking its $4 trillion asset portfolio later
this year and believed a plan to do so should be released soon.
Officials agreed "such an announcement would provide more
certainty about the process for completing the normalization of the
size of the Federal Reserve's balance sheet," according to the
minutes of the Jan. 29-30 meeting, released Wednesday.
Officials also agreed to signal a pause in interest-rate
increases until they could better judge the outcome of rising risks
to U.S. economic growth that had materialized since they raised
their benchmark short-term rate in December. "Many participants
suggested that it was not yet clear what adjustments to the target
range for the federal funds rate may be appropriate later this
year," the minutes said.
The written account of the meeting showed a split over whether
officials believed any interest-rate increases would be necessary
this year because of diverging views over the economy's likely
trajectory.
Several officials "argued that rate increases might prove
necessary only if inflation outcomes were higher than in their
baseline outlook," the minutes said. Others indicated, however,
that they expected another interest rate increase could be
justified given their outlook for solid growth later this year.
Officials have used the word "patient" to describe their current
stance of putting rate increases on hold, and some form of the word
appeared 14 times in Wednesday's minutes. Officials didn't see
significant risks to signaling they would move to the sidelines
after raising rates in quarterly intervals last year, the minutes
said.
But they also discussed contingency plans should they need to
return to raising interest rates. "Many participants observed that
if uncertainty abated, the committee would need to reassess the
characterization of monetary policy as 'patient' and might then use
different statement language," the minutes said.
In December, officials raised their benchmark rate by a
quarter-percentage point and signaled two more rate rises were
likely this year. At last month's meeting, officials delivered an
about-face from their policy stance six weeks earlier because the
economic outlook had turned cloudier.
Financial-market volatility had increased due to concerns over
slowing global growth, trade tensions between the U.S. and China,
and the Fed's plans to continue lifting rates. In addition, the
expiration of funding for parts of the federal government resulted
in a 35-day shutdown.
Tighter financial conditions and the prospect of muted inflation
convinced officials they no longer needed to raise rates with the
same urgency they had in 2018.
Several Fed officials at the January meeting said they had
slightly lowered their outlook for economic growth this year since
the December meeting, pointing to softer consumer and business
sentiment, downgrades in foreign economies' growth outlooks and
tighter financial conditions stemming from the year-end market
swoon, the minutes said.
While many of the crosscurrents officials cited last month for
justifying their policy pause had been building last fall, the
minutes provide a fuller account of why officials changed course
more convincingly after the December meeting.
Market volatility, for example, increased in the two weeks
following the December meeting. In addition, officials expressed
concern with the narrowing in spreads between short- and long-term
interest rates. Recessions tend to follow, by roughly one or two
years, after the spread turns negative.
Some officials also signaled worry that increases in corporate
borrowing costs could ultimately restrain economic growth.
The shift in the Fed's rate outlook reflects a broader stepping
back from the framework that has guided policy decisions in recent
years. The Fed operates under a framework that expects diminishing
slack in the labor market to ultimately fuel rising price pressures
across the economy, requiring pre-emptive rate increases to keep
inflation under control.
Even though unemployment has fallen to levels expected to
generate wage and price pressures, inflation has run below the
central bank's 2% target during most of the past three years in
which the Fed has raised interest rates.
The unemployment rate ticked up to a still-low 4% in January
from 3.7% last fall.
Inflation has been running near the Fed's 2% target since last
year, though measures of inflation that exclude volatile energy and
food prices have been running slightly below 2%.
At the January meeting, "several participants judged that risks
that could lead to higher-than-expected inflation had diminished
relative to downside risks," the minutes said.
Some officials said recent declines in oil prices, weaker growth
abroad, and a stronger dollar could continue to hold down inflation
this year.
Fed officials have signaled recently they see much less urgency
to pre-emptively tighten policy because interest rates have moved
closer to a neutral range expected to neither spur nor slow
growth.
Wednesday's minutes also spell out in greater detail how
discussions have unfolded around the Fed's asset portfolio. The
central bank began to shrink its balance sheet in 2017 by allowing
limited amounts of Treasury and mortgage securities to mature
without replacing them. The portfolio has fallen to $4 trillion
from around $4.5 trillion at its peak.
The Fed never said how long that runoff process would run. Fed
Chairman Jerome Powell declined to give any updated time frame
after last month's meeting.
While the Fed expanded its holdings from 2008 to 2014 to provide
more support to the economy, Mr. Powell said the central bank was
preparing to end the runoff for reasons unrelated to providing more
or less stimulus. Instead, the decision is being driven primarily
by a technical debate about the demand for reserves, or money banks
hold at the Fed.
Bank reserves have declined to around $1.6 trillion last month
from a peak of $2.8 trillion in 2014.
A staff briefing at the meeting last month suggested the decline
in reserves might reach an appropriate endpoint later this year,
and the Fed's staff presented options for slowing the process by
ending the asset runoff "at some point over the latter half of this
year."
After that, the Fed would hold its asset portfolio steady for
some time, before later allowing it to rise again as warranted by
demand for the Fed's liabilities, including currency and reserves.
At that point, the Fed would return to the market to buy
Treasurys.
Officials plan to continue shrinking their mortgage holdings
over time to return to a portfolio of primarily Treasurys.
Currently, the Fed is allowing up to $20 billion of its mortgage
bonds to mature every month, though the actual amounts have been
less than that because low refinancing activity has reduced
mortgage payoffs. Officials debated last month whether to maintain
the cap in mortgage-bond redemptions after the Fed stops shrinking
its Treasury holdings.
Officials haven't decided what types of Treasury securities they
will purchase when they are done running down the portfolio, and
Wednesday's minutes didn't yield new clues.
Write to Nick Timiraos at nick.timiraos@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
February 20, 2019 16:14 ET (21:14 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2019 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.