A growing number of Bank of America Corp. investors are pressing
for broader changes to the company's board as a contentious
shareholder vote approaches on Chairman and Chief Executive Brian
Moynihan's combined roles.
With the Sept. 22 vote about a week away, several large
shareholders have pressed for changes to the bank's board beyond
the question of whether Mr. Moynihan should continue to serve in
both roles.
Some investors would like the longest-tenured directors on the
board to leave. Others would rather see more financial experts or
new blood on the board's governance committee, which led the
controversial decision last year to combine the CEO and chairman
roles under Mr. Moynihan despite a 2009 shareholder vote to
separate those positions.
The way Bank of America's directors handled that process
"indicates that they need to get fresh eyes," said Jonas Kron, who
runs shareholder engagement at Trillium Asset Management. Trillium,
which often favors separate chairmen and CEOs at its holdings,
voted its 400,000 shares against the bank's proposal, which asks
for shareholders' blessing to let directors structure the roles as
they see fit.
Korea Investment Corp., South Korea's sovereign-wealth fund and
a top-20 shareholder of Bank of America according to FactSet, also
plans to vote against the proposal, in part due to concerns about
the bank's recent dividends and a share price that has trailed
peers, a person familiar with the $85 billion fund said. Bank of
America's share price is down about 10% so far this year, compared
with a 4% decline in the KBW Bank Index.
Bank of America has defended its board and its handling of the
chairman issue, noting that the 2009 vote to separate the jobs took
place during the financial crisis under a different CEO.
"Shareholders can speak now," said Gary Lynch, the bank's
general counsel, referring to the coming vote in an interview. "You
tell us what you want us to do, and the board is going to abide by
that."
In recent meetings with investors, some bank officials have said
the vote could go either way, according to people familiar with the
situation.
Some investors' concerns about the board go deeper, however.
Jonathan Finger, a partner at Finger Interests Ltd., said he would
like to see some directors who have been on the board since before
the financial crisis make room for someone new.
"It's unnatural to have people on the board for over 10 years,"
said Mr. Finger, who has already voted the firm's approximately
900,000 shares against the bank's proposal.
It isn't clear if discontent over the board will boil over into
next week's vote or if director changes are likely any time soon.
One official at a large Bank of America shareholder said it asked
bank officials about changing some directors at a meeting this
summer, but bank representatives including lead director Jack
Bovender made no commitments, the official said.
Some investors have speculated the bank could make a director
change, either in response to a vote or before one in an effort to
generate more "yes" tallies. The bank declined to comment on its
plans.
Some big investors will likely vote in the bank's favor despite
some misgivings about the board's action last year. That is because
some institutional investors will probably decide based on what is
best for the bank's share price; the stock price could fall if Bank
of America loses the vote.
Other, more activist investors are likely to vote against the
bank as a matter of principle, believing that having someone
besides the CEO as board chairman makes the board more willing to
challenge the CEO.
In 2009, before Mr. Moynihan became CEO, regulators ordered the
bank to add more board members with regulatory and banking
experience because of a perceived paucity of that expertise.
Bank of America added financial experts to the board, but some
of them have since left. The bank says its board has evolved
appropriately as it has moved further away from the financial
crisis. In a presentation it sent to investors last week, it also
said that board candidates are reviewed by regulators.
Mr. Moynihan said in a speech this month that Bank of America
had "a very strong board with a very good skill set." He also
praised several board members including Mr. Bovender, who aren't
banking experts but bring knowledge of different industries such as
cruise lines, hospitals and pharmaceuticals.
"They're never going to experience running a company with $100
billion in revenue and 200,000 employees and the fifth most
valuable company in financial services in the world, but what they
have is experience from other dimensions," Mr. Moynihan said.
Tom Brown, who runs the hedge fund Second Curve Capital, said he
would vote for the bank's proposal, echoing statements supportive
of Mr. Moynihan from Berkshire Hathaway Inc. CEO Warren Buffett.
Mr. Brown described the board as "very active," and said that Mr.
Moynihan has enough experience that he no longer needs a separate
chairman.
Still, some said the bank, a major player in a highly regulated
industry, should be held to particularly high standards.
"This is not Joe Bob's Machine Shop," said William Atwood,
executive director of the Illinois State Board of Investment. The
fund, which manages 10.3 million shares, will vote against the
bank's proposal. The fund usually tends to vote for separating the
roles, but Bank of America directors in particular haven't "cloaked
themselves in glory" with their handling of the chairman-CEO issue,
he added.
Several investors including Mr. Atwood didn't have specific
suggestions on how the board should be changed, though CtW
Investment Group, which works with union pension funds that hold
about 21 million shares, says it thinks the head of the bank's
governance committee, Thomas May, should step down, since that
committee led the decision to make Mr. Moynihan the chairman.
An official of another institutional investor predicted the bank
could clinch this month's vote if Mr. May steps down from the board
before then. Mr. May received only 67% approval at the bank's
annual meeting this year.
Mr. May, through representatives, declined to comment.
Shasha Dai contributed to this article.
Write to Christina Rexrode at christina.rexrode@wsj.com and
Joann S. Lublin at joann.lublin@wsj.com
Subscribe to WSJ: http://online.wsj.com?mod=djnwires
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
September 14, 2015 07:55 ET (11:55 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2015 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
Bank of America (NYSE:BAC)
Historical Stock Chart
From Apr 2024 to May 2024
Bank of America (NYSE:BAC)
Historical Stock Chart
From May 2023 to May 2024