HSBC Shareholders Likely to Reject Special Spinoff, Dividend Resolutions -- AGM Preview
May 04 2023 - 12:18PM
Dow Jones News
By Elena Vardon
HSBC Holdings shareholders will gather for the bank's annual
general meeting on Friday to vote on 18 resolutions, including
special resolutions requested by shareholders.
The meeting comes as Chinese insurer Ping An--a majority
shareholder with a stake of more than 8% in the bank and which has
support of some Hong-Kong-based retail investors--has recently been
vocal about reforming the lender and suggested restructuring
options to enhance shareholder value. HSBC responded by saying that
spinning off its Asian business would result in high costs and be
value destructive.
The meeting will take place days after HSBC published
first-quarter results where it reported better-than-expected
profits, even after one-time gains, and said it has established a
50% dividend payout ratio for 2023 and 2024 as it is confident it
will return to prepandemic dividend levels.
There is further evidence that the integrated business and
capital returns that HSBC is proposing are exceptionally high
numbers, said analyst Alastair Ryan of Bank of America Securities,
which forecasts it to return a quarter of its market
capitalization, or $34 billion, to shareholders over the next two
years.
A group represented by Ken Lui Yu Kin, who leads the 'Spin Off
HSBC Asia Concern Group', has proposed two resolutions which the
bank has advised shareholders to vote against as it considers them
not to be in the best interests of the company or shareholders.
Analysts expect both special resolutions 17 and 18 not to be
voted through by shareholders as no support from institutional
investors has been seen.
Here's what you need to know:
RESOLUTION 17: It proposes the creation and implementation of a
quarterly strategy review of structural reforms aimed at the bank's
Asia business, which would include its spinoff and strategic
reorganization and restructuring.
"We do not expect shareholder proposals seeking to restructure
HSBC to receive support, given the value of HSBC's connected global
businesses. Improved shareholder returns also reduce the perceived
need to create shareholder value through restructuring," Berenberg
analyst Peter Richardson wrote in a note.
The push to isolate the Asian business to unlock further value
"remains contrary to HSBC's tradition of a globally interconnected
bank and one which it fully intends to continue to resist,"
Interactive Investor's head of markets Richard Hunter said in a
note, adding that the turmoil in the sector has enabled HSBC to
flex its financial muscles and reiterate its power.
The request to carve out a still integrated but separately
identified entity is a very particular request and it has seen
little institutional support, BofA's Ryan said.
"In my view, Ping An's objective remains the partial listing of
the Hong Kong subsidiary, not to create value but to ringfence
depositors against the impact of U.S. sanctions (what Ping An
refers as geopolitical risk in its statement)," AlphaValue analyst
David Grinsztajn said.
RESOLUTION 18: A dividend policy was proposed through which the
bank would commit to distribute quarterly payouts that amount to no
less than $0.51 a year, its prepandemic level.
The resolution is asking for something that the company already
intends to deliver, Ryan said. HSBC is now in a position in which
it can restore its distribution to its traditionally high levels on
a recurring basis, he noted. With the current share buybacks,
planned special dividend from the disposal of its Canadian business
and the final 2023 dividend---which BofA estimates at $0.55 a
share--the bank can significantly catch up on total capital
distributions that were missed since the decision to cancel
quarterly dividends during the pandemic, he said.
"I think that requesting management to commit to a minimum
payout ratio does not make sense especially since the regulator as
a final say on capital distribution," AlphaValue's Grinsztajn
said.
The proposal is likely to be rejected as the bank declared its
first quarterly dividend since 2019 at 1Q results and will likely
to want to retain its flexibility over dividend distribution.
Write to Elena Vardon at elena.vardon@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
May 04, 2023 12:03 ET (16:03 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2023 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
Hsbc (LSE:HSBA)
Historical Stock Chart
From Sep 2024 to Oct 2024
Hsbc (LSE:HSBA)
Historical Stock Chart
From Oct 2023 to Oct 2024