By Deborah Levine
Investors may have to consider how various sectors of the bond
market will be affected by whether Barack Obama or Mitt Romney wins
the election next month, because different types of bonds are seen
are expected to strengthen or weaken.
The biggest factor that the president will determine is who will
replace Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke, because the biggest
influence on markets is the expectation of low interest rates for
the next few years.
"What the Fed is doing is overwhelming what the candidates can
do, because it's such a big presence in the bond market," said
Anthony Valeri, fixed-income investment strategist for LPL
Financial. "If Romney got one of his own people who said the
stimulus isn't helping and we don't need it, all bets are off on
keeping rates low. We'd have to factor in earlier rate hikes and
the impact on the bond market would be higher yields."
Still, municipal bonds and some industries in the corporate-bond
market might do better because of anticipated regulation changes,
while longer-term Treasury yields are seen rising.
How investors see the president tackling the so-called fiscal
cliff just after the election, and how the stock market reacts,
also play into investment decisions. Tuesday's debate will be
watched more closely after the first debate last week threw a
wrench into expectations that Obama would win handily.
The Fed's "lower for longer" benchmark-rate policy is still a
huge influence on markets, keeping yields low as the Fed buys bonds
and driving investors out of risk-free assets and into stocks and
commodities.
Mr. Bernanke's term as chairman ends in January 2014, and many
believe he will leave the central bank. The president appoints the
Fed chairman. But that's still a couple of years off, and the
president (or any politician, for that matter) doesn't have the
power to force him out sooner.
"Romney would appoint a new Fed chairman who is more hawkish
than Bernanke, which puts into question their pledge to keep rates
low until mid-2015," said John Briggs, a U.S. Treasury strategist
at RBS Securities.
Still, the Fed traditionally focuses on its dual mandate: trying
to keep inflation low and stable, while achieving maximum
employment. So what the Fed does should be driven primarily by how
the economy is doing at that time -- whether it's growing slowly,
more quickly or not at all.
"The Fed is very committed to keeping rates low as long as
necessary, and I think that's going to be longer than people think
under either president," said Bill Hornbarger, chief investment
strategist at Moneta Group.
One factor that may blunt the impact of a new Fed chairman is
that monetary policy is set by committee, on which votes and
positions rotate very gradually, according to Lee Munson, chief
investment officer at Portfolio Inc. in Albuquerque.
"The Fed moves too slow for the next president to alter monetary
policy so much that it's going to change bond rates," he said.
Municipal Bonds
Guessing about the Fed aside, what sectors of the bond market
are poised to do best under Obama and which under Romney?
Municipal bonds are one of the prime assets to buy if you expect
income taxes to go up, because the majority of them offer interest
payments exempt from federal taxes. "Obama has suggested increasing
taxes on upper earners, so municipal bonds are a potential
beneficiary because that makes the tax exemption more valuable,"
Mr. Valeri said.
A 10-year, tax-exempt municipal bond rated AA currently yields,
on average, 1.94%, or equivalent to 2.98% for buyers in the 35% tax
bracket, according to Thomson Reuters MMD. That's almost the same
as AA-rated corporate bonds maturing in 10 years, which yield
2.96%, and more than 10-year Treasury yields of 1.65%.
The caveat is that in an effort to tackle the federal deficit,
both candidates have said that the tax exemption may be ended, or
maybe only for taxpayers above a certain income level, though most
analysts say there's a slim likelihood of that.
Corporate Bonds
These bonds have been the darling for many fund managers for
some time, but different sectors of the debt market may get a small
boost if they're expected to do better -- either get more support
or less regulation -- under the next president.
"If Romney wins, defense, aerospace, energy, financials, coal,
rails, mining and metals are all sectors that should do well
because he'd make those industries more secure and more profitable,
which is good for their bonds," said Mark MacQueen, co-founder of
Sage Advisory Services, which oversees $11 billion in assets.
Under Mr. Obama, infrastructure-related and alternative-energy
companies should do better, he added.
As for health care, it's a bit of a toss-up, according to Mr.
MacQueen. Some health-care providers could be better off without
so-called Obamacare, while companies that improve efficiency in
things like medical records and drug delivery may do better under a
Democratic leadership.
Analysts also noted that higher-rated corporate debt will
continue to act like Treasurys, while lower-rated investment-grade
debt and speculative-grade bonds are more likely to track
stocks.
A better way for individual investors to try that strategy would
be to buy bond exchange-traded funds instead of individual company
names, Mr. Munson said.
That's especially true for high-yield bonds, so look at ETFs
like iShares iBoxx $ High Yield Corporate Bond Fund (HYG) and SPDR
Barclays Capital High Yield Bond ETF (JNK).
Among the biggest investment-grade bond ETFs are the iShares
Barclays Aggregate Bond Fund (AGG) and Vanguard Total Bond Market
ETF (BND).
Treasury yield Curve
As for what Treasury yields will do, analysts have said they
would rise as the economy improves (if it does, and as the
flight-to-quality demand fades if Europe gets its debt crisis under
control).
However, short-term rates are expected to stay pinned to the
federal funds rate. Longer-term yields may rise more, driven by
growth and related inflation expectations. That would widen the gap
between short-term and long-term yields, steepening the yield curve
which charts the spread.
Another concern that may push longer-term yields up is the
perception of how hard fiscal policy makers in the White House and
Congress will work to reduce the country's wide deficits over the
longer term. That's related to the shorter-term tax and spending
measures expiring at the end of the year, known as the fiscal
cliff.
"Under both candidates, the yield increase will be modest
because the fiscal cliff is going to retard economic growth," Mr.
Valeri of LPL said. How much depends on which measures are allowed
to expire, or get temporarily extended until the spring after newly
elected lawmakers are sworn in.
However, the perception is that "Obama won't tackle the fiscal
cliff and keep spending roughly on its current track, so the
government's credibility to reduce the deficit would come into
question," he added.
Benchmark 10-year Treasury yields , which he already expects to
rise toward 2% this year from 1.69% currently, could rise to 2.25%
to 2.50% under that scenario, Mr. Valeri commented.
Mr. Romney is generally perceived as more pro-business, but the
question for bondholders is whether anything he can do will so
quickly get money moving in the economy -- something the Fed barely
has been able to do with about $2.3 trillion -- that it will send
inflation up, Mr. Munson of Portfolio said. That's hard to see
happening soon.
Also, just like many throughout the country, a lot of bond
investors have very low expectations of lawmakers dealing with the
fiscal cliff at all, affecting the economic outlook that's central
to Fed policy and bond yields. "They'll keep kicking the can down
the road because there won't be enough of a mandate for either
party to dig in and solve the problem," Mr. Hornbarger of Moneta
said.
Also watching stocks
As for shorter-term moves, bond traders are generally watching
for how stocks react to the next debate and the election itself.
"Markets now expect Obama to win, so that's priced in," Mr. Briggs
at RBS said. "But if Romney wins, that's a surprise, then stocks
rally and the yield curve steepens."
Still, who becomes president is far from the only factor in
making investment decisions, and strategists and investors
emphasized all this is only one part of their decision process.
"Personally, I don't think one man can start growth in this
country," Mr. Munson acknowledged. "I wouldn't be selling your bond
portfolio with a Romney victory."
The biggest factor remains what the Federal Reserve is doing
right now.
"The thing that will impact financial markets more than anything
is zero interest rates," Mr. Hornbarger said. "As long as there's a
zero-rate policy, it will be supportive of risk assets and keep
longer-term bond yields lower, though they may creep up a bit."
-Write to Deborah Levine at dlevine@marketwatch.com