Minimum Volatility ETFs: Fact or Over-estimated Hype? - ETF News And Commentary
May 17 2013 - 7:17AM
Zacks
With the equity markets hovering near record high levels despite
weak domestic and global cues, all eyes are on the ongoing first
quarter earnings season. By now it should be a very well known fact
to the investor community that this quarter earnings are the wild
card for equities going forward. This is especially in order to
justify the sentiments with the fundamentals (see Retail Sales
Data: The Biggest Driver of Retail ETFs).
Whatever be the situation, safety preference has also been the
focus for many investors along with the optimism in equities. The
first quarter itself saw massive inflows in short term bond ETFs
which offers a safety play due to their low portfolio duration
(i.e. the sensitivity of bond prices to changes in interest rates),
given the fact that interest rates are in their record lows.
Speaking of safety, we have long mentioned in our articles the
importance of low volatility products which not only reduce the
overall portfolio volatility, but also go a long way in maximizing
returns (read Buy These ETFs for Higher Returns and Lower Risk).
Fortunately for investors, there are a number of options in the ETF
space which they can utilize to gain exposure in the low volatility
equity space. One of them is the iShares MSCI U.S. Minimum
Volatility ETF (USMV).
USMV in Focus
The ETF is a recent addition to the massive product portfolio of
iShares being launched in October of 2011. However, the reception
that the product got from the investors is way beyond just any new
launch. It has managed to amass an asset base of just a tad below
$3 billion and on an average trades close to 278K shares daily.
As its name suggests, the product seeks to reduce the overall
exposure to volatility and it does that by primarily employing a
strategy that selects stocks that exhibit lower volatility
characteristics. Furthermore in its attempt to reduce risk, it
selects from a universe of predominantly large cap stocks and also
weighs the components almost equally in order to avoid
concentration/stock specific risk.
The ETF has exposure to roughly 126 stocks and charges investors
15 basis points in fees and expenses—a pretty reasonable expense
ratio considering the competition and the purpose it serves (see
Small Cap Japan ETFs: Overlooked Winners?).
Naturally, the ETF is largely skewed towards the defensive
sectors like Healthcare and Consumer Staples. However, aggressive
sectors such as Financials and Information Technology are also
given a good amount of weighting. USMV also pays out 1.16% as
yields.
Fact or Over-estimated Hype
It is true that any investment avenue that limits exposure to
volatility and at the same time does not cap the upside potential
is a very lucrative option. Especially compared to a
‘non-low risk’ avenue, which might
provide similar returns, but in case of a downtrend, their
relatively high variance will cause them to plunge at a faster pace
(see 4 Ways to Short Gold with ETFs).
On the other hand, for the minimum variance products, even if
the broader market turns south, the products will eventually plunge
but at a much lower pace. This is primarily due to the low beta and
low variance that these products possess.
But do these theories work in real life? We seek to find the
answers with the following charts.
Chart 1: 30 Day Rolling Standard
Deviation
The above chart represents the comparitive 30 day rolling
Standard deviation (as a measure of volatility) of USMV and the
S&P 500. The time in consideration is since the inception of
USMV. As we can see, the ETF does justify its strategy as a minimum
volatility product as the volatility line of USMV is almost always
below the S&P 500 volatility line.
It can therefore be argued that the product well and truly
limits the exposure to volatility. But what about returns? Does it
significantly cap the returns potential too? The following chart
seeks the answer.
Chart 2: Cumulative Daily Returns (Since the
Inception of USMV)
The chart (the daily cumulative returns) suggests that the
answer is ‘No’. In fact most of the times the USMV is seen
outperforming the S&P 500 index. At the same time, investors
should note that the time period in consideration was not a bad one
for the broader equity markets either.
Therefore, for any investment avenue to establish a trend by
beating the S&P 500 index within this time frame would be an
excellent show. More so if the product exhibits lower realized
volatility than the index (see 4 Low-Volatility ETFs to Hedge Your
Portfolio).
Not only this, the product also goes a notch higher to establish
a pure play low volatility ETF and establishes a trend of low beta
value versus the S&P 500 index as indicated by the following
chart. As we can see the beta value has never crossed 1 since its
inception.
The Bottom Line
It is a fact that low volatility products have been very popular
among investors. This is not only during uncertain times, but also
when markets are surging. Also, another example of an ultra popular
choice within the low volatility ETF space is the
PowerShares S&P 500 Low Volatility ETF (SPLV).
The ETF was quite recently launched in May of 2011 and has
witnessed massive inflows in its asset base since inception.
At the time of writing, SPLV had an asset base of around $4.7
billion. With such enthusiasm surrounding the low volatility
products one thing becomes quite clear. Going forward these low
volatility ETFs will continue to be the darling of the investors
(read 3 ETF Strategies For Long Term Success).
And why not, because not only have they justified their
investment strategy to the full extent, but low volatility ETFs
have also given investors the opportunity to earn high returns
while keeping a limited view on its underlying volatility. It can
therefore be safe to argue that low volatility ETFs have well and
truly arrived, and are not just over-estimated hypes.
Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research?
Today, you can download 7
Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click
to get this free report >>
SPDR-SP 500 TR (SPY): ETF Research Reports
ISHARS-MS US MV (USMV): ETF Research Reports
To read this article on Zacks.com click here.
Zacks Investment Research
Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research?
Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click
to get this free report
iShares MSCI USA Min Vol... (AMEX:USMV)
Historical Stock Chart
From Nov 2024 to Dec 2024
iShares MSCI USA Min Vol... (AMEX:USMV)
Historical Stock Chart
From Dec 2023 to Dec 2024