By Louise Radnofsky and Cassandra Sweet
WASHINGTON -- President Donald Trump Tuesday took steps to begin
unraveling the centerpiece of the Obama environmental agenda,
signing an order to reverse rules aimed at pushing U.S. utilities
to shift from coal plants to cleaner-burning fuels.
"My administration is putting an end to the war on coal," Mr.
Trump said ahead of the official signing at the Environmental
Protection Agency, repeating a campaign slogan he used to champion
policies he said would bring back mining jobs.
He said he was ending a "crushing attack on American industry"
and paring back regulations that impeded job creation, while still
ensuring clean air and water.
But while the moves are being billed as job savers, companies
and energy experts said the order is unlikely to reverse the U.S.
utility industry's shift to natural gas, solar and wind as leading
sources of electricity.
The order begins a formal review of President Barack Obama's
Clean Power Plan, which would have required utilities to reduce
power plant carbon-dioxide emissions to 32% below 2005 levels by
2030. It also initiates a review of a regulation that would impose
tougher missions requirements on new plants.
It further pulls back 2016 guidance from the Council on
Environmental Quality on climate change and official estimates of
the social cost of carbon, methane and nitrous oxide and rescinds a
temporary ban on new coal leases on federal lands, which Mr.
Obama's Interior Department issued early last year.
The moves are all but certain to trigger legal and political
pushback from environmentalists, and Democrats announced swift
opposition on Tuesday. The actual repeal could take years as the
litigation and rule-making process run their course. The White
House on Monday night acknowledged it would likely take "some
time."
"Ultimately, litigation will keep these agencies on course, but
this order is a big waste of time and effort, done to appease a
dirty industry and right-wing climate-denial fanatics," said Sen.
Sheldon Whitehouse, a Rhode Island Democrat.
The White House action is part of a broad push across the
government to rein in what Republicans and businesses say is a
burdensome and costly regulatory environment created under the
Democratic administration. It also gave the president an
opportunity to move beyond the difficult collapse of health-care
legislation in the House last week and hand a win to allies who
have fervently opposed the power plant rules.
Energy and environmental regulations have been among the Trump
team's highest priorities for review. The administration has given
the green light to two contentious oil pipelines, Dakota Access and
Keystone XL, and last month Mr. Trump ordered the EPA to begin the
process of repealing a regulation that brings more bodies of water
under federal jurisdiction as a means to protect drinking water
supplies. Federal courts temporarily blocked both the carbon and
water rules during the Obama administration.
The move also raises questions about what steps, if any, the
Trump administration might take to comply with a global pact to
address climate change that roughly 200 nations agreed to in Paris
in 2015.
The order Tuesday drew a rebuke from the European Union. "Now,
it remains to be seen by which other means the United States
intends to meet its commitments under the Paris Agreement," said
Miguel Arias Canete, climate action and energy chief at the
European Commission, the EU's executive arm.
A senior White House official said Monday that the Trump
administration hasn't reached a decision on how to proceed with the
Paris agreement.
While companies and energy experts said Tuesday's move may
extend the life of some aging coal-fired power plants, there are
other factors at work.
Many energy companies face state requirements to increase
renewable power generation and are under pressure from investors
such as pension funds and university endowments to clean up their
operations.
Cheap U.S. natural gas unlocked by hydraulic fracturing and
horizontal drilling has prompted many companies to scrap older coal
plants in favor of gas-fired plants, which require fewer workers to
operate.
Companies are also taking advantage of tax credits for renewable
power to build out solar and wind farms, which are becoming more
cost-competitive with fossil-fuel generation thanks to economies of
scale and advances in technology.
"Investors want to see companies that are moving away from coal,
to other energies," said Fiona Reynolds, managing director at
Principles for Responsible Investment, a London-based nonprofit
that helps funds figure out how to cut the carbon footprint of
their investments.
Nearly 700 institutions valued at more than $5 trillion have
pledged to divest themselves from fossil-fuel companies, according
to a December report by consulting firm Arabella Advisors.
And many utilities are already orienting themselves toward
cleaner fuels.
Duke Energy Corp. said it planned to invest $11 billion in
natural-gas and renewable power generation over the next 10 years,
as the company aims to cut its greenhouse-gas emissions by 35% from
2005 levels, by 2026.
That represents a long-term company strategy and isn't likely to
change, Duke Chief Executive Lynn Good said in a February
interview.
Southern Co. plans to invest at least $1 billion a year over the
next five years in new wind farms. It now uses natural gas to
generate 47% of its power. Coal provides 31%, nuclear 15%, and
hydropower, wind, solar and other renewable sources 7%.
"Going forward, we anticipate an increase in renewable
generation capacity and declining utilization of coal," said
Terrell McCollum, a spokesman for the Atlanta-based utility.
Still, the symbolism surrounding the action was important for
Mr. Trump and loyal constituencies in the mining industry, where
the power plant rules were viewed as a government betrayal for
regions whose mines had long provided steady employment.
At Tuesday's signing, Mr. Trump, flanked by coal miners, singled
out West Virginia Republican Sen. Shelley Moore Capito, who was one
of around two dozen members of Congress present, according to the
White House.
Ms. Capito said he "kept his promise to roll back one of the
most harmful acts of overreach by the Obama administration" and
that the Obama-era rules "would have completely decimated West
Virginia's vital coal industry while having no meaningful climate
impact."
In addition to the coal miners and lawmakers, the event included
Vice President Mike Pence, Energy Secretary Rick Perry, Interior
Secretary Ryan Zinke, and Environmental Protection Agency
Administrator Scott Pruitt.
Mr. Pruitt said the president was "rejecting the narrative that
this country cannot be pro-energy and pro-environment" and said
that under his leadership, "We're not going to allow regulations
here at the EPA to pick winners and losers."
Shares of some coal companies jumped on news of the order.
Peabody Energy Corp., the world's largest private-sector coal
company, which is in the process of exiting bankruptcy, rose 15.8%
to $2.20. Arch Coal Inc. rose 1.85% to $69. Environmental groups
blasted the order, saying it would lead to dirtier air and water
for Americans in addition to increasing greenhouse gases.
Emre Peker contributed to this article.
Write to Louise Radnofsky at louise.radnofsky@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
March 28, 2017 19:48 ET (23:48 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2017 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
Duke Energy (NYSE:DUK)
Historical Stock Chart
From Aug 2024 to Sep 2024
Duke Energy (NYSE:DUK)
Historical Stock Chart
From Sep 2023 to Sep 2024