(Updates comment from dealers, other details.)
By Sharon Terlep and John Stoll
Of DOW JONES
General Motors Co. said Wednesday that it would wind down its
loss-making Saturn brand after the last-minute collapse of plans to
sell the niche brand to Penske Automotive Group Inc. (PAG).
Penske, which runs a network of U.S. auto dealers, said a deal
to source cars for sale under the Saturn brand after GM ceased
production had been rejected by its prospective manufacturing
partner, which people familiar with the situation identified as
Renault SA (RNO.FR).
"We were running 300 miles an hour about three hours ago to get
to get this done, and then we hit a wall," GM spokesman John
McDonald said. "This is disappointing."
Roger Penske, the former race-car driver who heads the group,
had pursued what the industry viewed as a bold experiment in
outsourcing manufacturing.
Without the deal, the line GM launched 19 years ago as a way to
fend off competition from Asian imports will end no later than
October 2010.
The collapse is a setback as well for Penske, who had hoped to
expand his auto empire. Under the arrangement, he was to buy
Saturn's brands, service and parts and distribution operations, but
not its manufacturing operations.
Shares in Penske were down 10% recently in after-hours trading
at $17.27.
Saturn will wind down by October 2010 under agreements already
made with the brand's dealers. Had the Penske deal gone through,
the dealers would have needed to ink new contracts with Penske to
stay in business. GM's McDonald said many of the dealerships are
expected to close before next year's deadline.
Saturn is one of four brands - alongside Saab, Hummer and
Pontiac - earmarked for closure or disposal in GM's post-bankruptcy
restructuring plan. The company is in talks to sell Saab and
Hummer, and also is winding down Pontiac. GM said earlier this year
that the Saturn, Hummer and Saab brands generated an average annual
pretax loss of $1.1 billion.
GM said existing Saturn owners would be able to have their
vehicles serviced at GM dealers.
People familiar with the situation said a deal had been due to
be announced as soon as Thursday, and Penske had already
distributed new franchise agreements to dealers. The chance of
another manufacturer stepping in is "remote," a person familiar
with the situation said.
No 'Plan B'
The Penske announcement came as a "huge surprise" to dealers, GM
and Treasury Department officials, all of whom were watching
developments closely, according to people familiar with the matter.
"We're out of luck," one dealer said. "I don't think there is a
Plan B."
Saturn of Oak Lawn, Ill., sales manager Marty Mollway said the
dealer was disappointed by the news. "I don't know where this puts
us. I don't know where we go from here."
Scott Davies, owner of Saturn of Wichita, Kan., said as of late
Wednesday afternoon he hadn't been contacted by Saturn or Penske.
"We'll just have to deal with it."
Up until earlier Wednesday, Saturn dealers were being told that
the sale of the unit would be complete "in the next few days," a
person familiar with the matter said. These dealers were asked to
rush to complete several initiatives needed for the closing,
including submitting customer-service information and inventory
data.
The proposed deal called for Penske to initially acquire
vehicles from GM but eventually branch out to sell products from
Renault SA and its Samsung Motors unit, which is based in South
Korea.
Penske Auto said Wednesday that it negotiated a supply agreement
with "another manufacturer," but that company's board rejected the
deal.
"Without that agreement, the company has determined that the
risks and uncertainties related to the availability of future
products prohibit the company from moving forward with this
transaction," said Penske Auto.
Renault couldn't immediately be reached for comment.
Saturn has 350 dealers and the Penske deal was seen saving some
13,000 jobs. The dealers had pressed GM to seek a sale after the
auto maker initially planned to phase out production.
-By Sharon Terlep and John Stoll, 248-204-5532;
sharon.terlep@dowjones.com (Doug Cameron and Kevin Kingsbury
contributed to this article).