Relational Amends Counterclaim to Block Delay of Sovereign's Annual Meeting; Calls Sovereign's Motives Transparently Destructive
January 05 2006 - 6:30AM
Business Wire
Relational Investors LLC today said that Sovereign Bancorp, Inc.'s
(NYSE: SOV) announcement that it would postpone its annual
shareholder meeting by over four months represents still another
egregious assault on the rights of its shareholders. In
Relational's view, Sovereign's board has now lost any remaining
modicum of credibility. In order to preserve its rights and the
rights of all shareholders, Relational today amended its
counterclaim in the existing litigation in the Southern District of
New York to request that the court block what Relational believes
is a destruction of fundamental shareholder rights. As part of its
claim, Relational asserted that it believed that the sole purpose
for Sovereign's recent actions was to ensure that current
shareholders' votes were diluted in the face of Relational's effort
to elect two directors and remove Sovereign's board. Relational
believes that Sovereign purposefully sought to avoid putting the
proposed Independence Community Bank (Nasdaq: ICBC) and Santander
(NYSE: STD) transactions to a shareholder vote because it feared
that shareholders would reject them. If Sovereign can delay the
annual meeting long enough to close the Santander transaction,
existing shareholders' voting power at the annual meeting will be
diluted by at least 20%. In addition, Sovereign recently repudiated
13 years of public disclosure to shareholders regarding their right
to remove directors at any annual meeting without cause, claiming
that such statements were made "in error." Sovereign justifies
postponing the shareholders' meeting because "it is essential for
management to focus its full attention on (Sovereign's proposed
acquisition of Independence Community Bank) and integration..."
This is disingenuous, particularly considering Sovereign's
announcement in October that it intended to close the Independence
and Santander transactions around July 1, more than two months
after the originally scheduled annual meeting, its multiple
statements about its ability to integrate Independence and its
commitment to superior shareholder rights and proper corporate
governance. Moreover, in our view Sovereign's claim that the
meeting needed to be postponed because of "the potential confusion
created by Relational Investors' recent statement that it would
seek to remove the entire Board without cause" fails even to meet
the straight face test. The only "confusion" on this point -- if
there be any -- is the result of Sovereign repudiating 13 years of
public disclosure concerning shareholders' right to remove
directors at any annual meeting without cause. Ralph Whitworth,
Principal of Relational, said: "Sovereign's board continues to
march forward on its cynical campaign to deprive its shareholders,
at their expense, of the right to vote on transformational
transactions and vote on the very directors they are entitled to
elect. We are confident that neither our legal system nor our free
market system will allow these machinations to prevail over the
owners of the company. We will respond to these actions vigorously
and relentlessly and seek every available remedy under the law."
About Relational Investors Relational Investors LLC is a registered
investment advisor and asset management firm located in San Diego,
California managing $6.1 billion. Additional information about
Relational is available on their website at www.rillc.com. Further
Information About Relational's SEC Filings On October 20, 2005,
Relational, together with a number of affiliated persons and
entities that may be deemed "participants" for purposes of the
solicitation rules of the Securities and Exchange Commission
("SEC"), filed a preliminary proxy statement on Schedule 14A with
the SEC relating to a possible solicitation of proxies from the
shareholders of Sovereign Bancorp, Inc. ("Sovereign") in connection
with Relational's nomination of Ralph Whitworth and David
Batchelder for election to Sovereign's board of directors at
Sovereign's 2006 Annual Meeting of shareholders. On December 13,
2005, Relational filed with the SEC a revised preliminary proxy
statement. Relational will prepare and file with the SEC a
definitive proxy statement relating to their nomination of Messrs.
Whitworth and Batchelder and may file other proxy solicitation
materials. RELATIONAL ANTICIPATES THAT IT WILL FURTHER REVISE AND
FILE THE PRELIMINARY PROXY STATEMENT AND SHAREHOLDERS ARE URGED TO
READ THE PRELIMINARY PROXY STATEMENT AS REVISED (AND THE DEFINITIVE
PROXY STATEMENT, WHEN IT BECOMES AVAILABLE) BECAUSE IT CONTAINS
IMPORTANT INFORMATION REGARDING RELATIONAL'S NOMINATION OF MESSRS.
WHITWORTH AND BATCHELDER FOR ELECTION AS DIRECTORS. The preliminary
proxy statement is, and the revised preliminary proxy statement and
the definitive proxy statement (when they become available) will
be, available for free at www.sec.gov, along with any other
relevant documents. You may also obtain a free copy of the
preliminary proxy statement, or the definitive proxy statement
(when it becomes available), by contacting Maudie Holland of
Relational at (858) 704-3321, or by sending an email to
maudie@rillc.com. Information regarding the names, affiliation, and
interests of persons who may be deemed to be participants in our
solicitation of proxies of Sovereign's shareholders is available in
the preliminary proxy statement filed with the SEC on October 20,
2005 and the revised preliminary proxy statement filed on December
13, 2005.
Independence Community Bank (NASDAQ:ICBC)
Historical Stock Chart
From Feb 2025 to Mar 2025
Independence Community Bank (NASDAQ:ICBC)
Historical Stock Chart
From Mar 2024 to Mar 2025