One the world's top investment banks today lowered their forecasts
for global GDP by 30 basis points and 70 basis points for this year
and next, respectively. Here are Morgan Stanley’s revisions to
prior projections:
2011: Global GDP forecast of 3.9%, down from
4.2%
2012: Global GDP forecast of 3.8%, down from
4.5%
This is exactly what I have been saying to expect
since July 29 when we got final -- and abysmal -- GDP revisions for
the US economy for the previous three quarters. When the first half
clocked in at a dismal 0.8% growth, I said stocks would go lower as
large investors priced in a probable recession even before they
could prove it was coming.
What proof were they looking for? Visibility on
corporate earnings and domestic demand, which is essentially GDP
since 45% of the S&P 500 earnings are from abroad and a large
part of this is not part of the domestic math.
Proof was needed because of these new concerns:
China trying to cool its red-hot pace of growth
Europe on the verge a systemic banking crisis
Weak manufacturing and consumer data in the US
Philly Fed Drops a Bomb
And the other dose of data we got Thursday that can
be put in the "confirms a coming recession" camp was the Philly Fed
Survey. How serious is it that this one came in at -30.7 when the
market was looking for something closer to zero?
The Philadelphia Federal Reserve Survey of business
conditions tracks sentiment and trends among industrial
manufacturers in that district, including data for orders,
shipments, employment, and prices. Its correlation to the national
industrial production data is strong and it is considered a
relatively solid leading indicator for the rest of the country.
There was concern in June when the Philly Fed
dropped below the zero line to a minus 7.7 reading. July saw it
peek its head back above zero, so it looked like we could have a
repeat of last August to October in this data, where a sub-zero
mark was quickly erased by a surge above 40.
But given the other "slowdown is here" data and the
tone of the Federal Reserve after both its June and August FOMC
meetings, manufacturers may have begun pricing in the recession
just as quickly.
The significance of the -30 reading is that it
brings us right back to where we were during the 2008-09 recession
when industrial production measures were hitting anywhere from -2%
to -4%. That's scary territory for stocks.
Are the Philly Fed district manufacturers right? Is
the slowdown more severe than most investors had imagined? We shall
have to wait for more data to know for sure. Meanwhile, the stock
market ecology remains unstable...
Sell First, Investigate Later
The month of August so far has been a classic
example of "shoot first and ask questions later." In this case,
good stocks are being shot while the recession gets discounted.
Morgan Stanley will not be the last investment or
research house to downgrade growth. We still await the Fed to
revise its GDP projections as I wrote about in these two
articles...
QE3 and the Probability of Recession, August
10
Bernanke: I See Unemployed People, August
9
Where it will get really interesting is when we get
specific calls on US GDP. Surely, many strategists are at work
formulating their revisions based on an overall analysis of the
global economy since Emerging Markets are such a driver of US
economic growth.
Does Philly Fed in Recession Territory Make it a
Done Deal?
Thursday's market meltdown is driven as much by the
fears in Europe and Morgan Stanley's downcast view as by the
depressing Philadelphia Fed survey.
This puts Federal Reserve leaders in new light,
especially with three dissenters on the last FOMC vote and dovish
Dudley out there already this week explaining the necessity of
continued extraordinary monetary accommodation.
Even though I said on Bloomberg TV Thursday that I
had moved my recession probability from 40% to 50% based on Philly
Fed, I still wait for more confirming data. I hope this doesn't
become a self-fulfilling recession as I wrote about last week.
And I trust that monetary accommodation can beat
the threat of deflation. In the meantime, I won't be afraid to take
positions in my favorite stocks on these fear-driven sell-off
days.
Plus, in addition to my thesis from Wednesday that
there is extreme fundamental value in the S&P 500 around 1,100,
I saw two barometers of risk appetite holding up well on Thursday:
copper and the euro.
If the recession were a done deal, copper would be
selling off more dramatically. It continues to stay close to $4. I
still like my current long holding in Southern Copper (SCCO)
here, especially near its 52-week lows and kicking out an 8%
dividend yield.
And if Europe's banking system were going to
implode, the euro would not be holding on above $1.43 so well. The
crude oil market, conversely, is definitely taking it on the chin,
so I have reasons to worry about my energy stocks like
Suncor (SU) and National Oilwell Varco (NOV), as well
as my industrial names like Cummins (CMI) and Eaton
(ETN).
But I also don't think Philly Fed spells a certain
recession. And I look forward to seeing what opportunities the next
few weeks bring.
To see why I think the market is getting very close
to a screaming buy again, just like the correction of 2010, see
"S&P 1,100: Extreme Value Area?"
Kevin Cook is a Senior Stock Strategist for
Zacks.com
CUMMINS INC (CMI): Free Stock Analysis Report
EATON CORP (ETN): Free Stock Analysis Report
NATL OILWELL VR (NOV): Free Stock Analysis Report
SOUTHERN COPPER (SCCO): Free Stock Analysis Report
SUNCOR ENERGY (SU): Free Stock Analysis Report
Zacks Investment Research
Eaton (NYSE:ETN)
Historical Stock Chart
From May 2024 to Jun 2024
Eaton (NYSE:ETN)
Historical Stock Chart
From Jun 2023 to Jun 2024