("Sunoco Deal Indicates Tough Refiner Selling Market," published
at 12:17 p.m. EDT, incorrectly stated the name of Western Refining.
The corrected version follows.)
DOW JONES NEWSWIRES
Sunoco Inc.'s (SUN) agreement to sell its Tulsa, Okla., oil
refinery to Holly Corp. (HOC) for $65 million won't affect its
investment-grade credit ratings, Fitch Ratings said, but the low
price indicates refineries will face a tough environment to sell
sites.
Fitch's comments came a day after Sunoco's deal was announced,
and the credit rater said sellers of brownfield refineries are
facing a depressed economic environment, especially for sellers of
smaller facilities with limited conversion capacity and significant
capital expenditure requirements.
Sunoco put the 85,000-barrel-a-day refinery up for sale in 2008
and in December disclosed that it would convert the facility into
an oil product terminal if it couldn't find a buyer. The agreed
upon price tag represents a steep decline in asset values amid an
industry slump.
Skyrocketing crude oil prices, which are refiners' biggest cost,
and weakening demand for products such as gasoline and diesel hit
the sector's earnings after several years of high returns.
The $65 million transaction equates to a sales price of just
$745 a barrel of refining capacity, according to Fitch. This is
sharply lower than recent refinery sales, including the
$3,920-a-barrel sale of Valero Energy Corp.'s (VLO)
85,000-barrel-a-day Krotz Springs, La., refinery sold to Alon USA
Energy Inc. (ALJ) last July and the $11,875-a-barrel sale of the
160,000-barrel-a-day Lima, Ohio, refinery sold to Husky Energy Inc.
(HUSKF).
Fitch on Friday affirmed its issuer default and senior unsecured
credit ratings on Sunoco at BBB, or two notches above junk
territory.
A key motivation for the sale of the Tulsa refinery was Sunoco's
desire to avoid $400 million in capital costs required to bring the
site into compliance with the Environmental Protection Agency's
off-road diesel requirements.
But finding a buyer was tough in the recession, as a steep drop
in share prices across the energy sector has also diluted the value
of stock as a deal currency for now, further limiting the ability
of would-be buyers to finance purchases.
The low price of the Tulsa sale doesn't bode well for
independent refiners or integrated oil companies looking to the
sale of marginal refineries as a source of cash, Fitch said. Other
refineries that are on the block or are expected to be put out for
sale in the near term include Valero's refinery in Aruba and
Western Refining Inc.'s (WNR) Yorktown, Va., refinery.
But those deals are also showing signs of trouble. Western
Refining said last month it doesn't expect to find a buyer for its
Virginia refinery in the near future and last week, Russian oil
company OAO Lukoil Holdings (LKOH.RS) said it didn't have any
immediate interest in buying Valero's Aruba refinery, which has
been on the block for 17 months.
Sunoco's shares were down 0.8% to $28.10 in recent trading. The
company's stock is off 43% from September.
-By John Kell, Dow Jones Newswires, 201-938-5285,
john.kell@dowjones.com