4th UPDATE: NY AG: Some Banks Gave $1 Million Bonuses To Hundreds
July 30 2009 - 5:30PM
Dow Jones News
Several large, troubled banks that received U.S. government
assistance paid hundreds of employees bonuses of at least $1
million last year, according to New York Attorney General Andrew
Cuomo.
JPMorgan Chase & Co. (JPM) topped the list of banks that
gave large bonuses, with 1,626 people receiving $1 million or more,
including more than 200 people getting at least a $3-million
payment. Goldman Sachs Group Inc. (GS), which employs less than a
seventh of the number of people that JPMorgan does, paid 953 people
bonuses of $1 million or more, including 212 of them who received
$3 million or more.
Cuomo released the data in a report that criticized banks for
continuing to pay hefty bonuses, intended to reward good
performance, when the banks were reporting large losses or profit
declines during the financial crisis. As such, the report could fan
public indignation over bonuses paid on Wall Street.
The report provides a rare, numbers-based glimpse into the
secretive world of bonuses being paid by major banks. Shortly after
its release Thursday, employees of major Wall Street companies were
comparing notes about which companies paid the greatest number of
large bonuses.
Wall Street companies often allocate as much as half of the
revenue of certain units to pay bonuses to top-performing
employees. A few large banks were forced to accept money from the
U.S. Treasury Department's Troubled Asset Relief Program, or TARP.
Many have wanted to pay it back as soon as possible, largely
because of restrictions put on compensation that came with the
funds. Some key employees left to work for other companies not in
the spotlight of public anger over compensation.
Banks argue that they need to pay large bonuses to retain top
professionals. It is top talent that is keeping these companies
going, said Jeanne Branthover, head of the global financial
services practice at Boyden Global Executive Search. "Human capital
is now more important than ever," she said.
The Cuomo report said, "At many banks...compensation and
benefits steadily increased during the bull-market years between
2003 and 2006. However, when the subprime [mortgage] crisis emerged
in 2007, followed by the current recession, compensation and
benefits stayed at bull-market levels even though bank performance
plummeted."
Two of the first nine TARP recipients - Citigroup Inc. (C) and
Merrill Lynch - suffered huge losses of more than $27 billion
apiece last year. Citigroup received $45 billion from TARP, while
Merrill received $10 billion, but they paid out more than $5.3
billion and $3.6 billion in bonuses, respectively, the report
said.
At Citi, 738 got bonuses of $1 million or more, including 124
people who received bonuses of $3 million or more. At Merrill,
which was bought by Bank of America Corp. (BAC), 696 received
bonuses of $1 million or more, including 101 employees who received
$3 million or more in bonuses.
Bank of America paid 172 employees bonuses of $1 million or
more, including 28 who received $3 million or more.
Other banks, such as Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley (MS) and
JPMorgan, paid out more in bonuses than their profit for the year,
Cuomo's office said. Goldman Sachs, for example, earned $2.3
billion, paid out $4.8 billion in bonuses and received $10 billion
in TARP funding.
Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs, Bank of America and JPMorgan
declined to comment on the report. Citigroup didn't return a phone
call seeking comment.
The smallest number of big bonuses on the report's list of nine
banks was paid by State Street Corp. (STT), which paid 44 employees
a bonus of $1 million or more.
Bonuses have become a source of contention. At American
International Group Inc. (AIG), executives in one division were set
to get bonuses totaling $165 million, despite the company's federal
bailout and massive losses. Chief Executive Edward Liddy and other
executives received death threats over the issue and, in a March
congressional hearing, Liddy said he was concerned about the safety
of AIG employees. Some employees decided to return the bonuses.
The Cuomo report said some banks, including Merrill Lynch,
"severed the tie between paying based on performance" and paid
"based on what it expected its competitors would do."
A person close to Cuomo said the attorney general "decided not
to release the names of individual bonus recipients after weighing
the public's right to know with the personal privacy interest of
the individuals involved."
-By Kerry Grace Benn and Jessica Papini, Dow Jones Newswires;
212-416-2353; kerry.benn@dowjones.com