Federal Court Finds DuPont is Not Licensed to Use Monsanto's Roundup Ready(R) Trait in Combination With the DuPont Optimum(R) GA
January 19 2010 - 8:00AM
PR Newswire (US)
ST. LOUIS, Jan. 19, 2010 /PRNewswire-FirstCall/ -- Monsanto Company
(NYSE: MON) welcomed the St. Louis Federal Court's ruling that
DuPont was not licensed to combine the Roundup Ready® trait with
the Optimum® GAT® (OGAT) trait in corn or soybeans. The ruling
means that DuPont is not authorized to use the Roundup Ready trait
to mask the "unacceptable risks to farmers" posed by DuPont's OGAT
trait. "The Court ruled that the Monsanto-DuPont license agreements
'are unambiguous and do not grant Pioneer the right to stack' the
Roundup Ready trait with the Optimum GAT trait," said Scott
Partridge, chief deputy general counsel for Monsanto. "DuPont
negotiated and signed a contract with a specific set of rights, at
the financial terms they preferred, and the rights did not include
making this stacked combination. This was DuPont's business
decision." "The court record further highlights that DuPont was
authorized to create any stacked trait product with our Roundup
Ready technology other than one such as OGAT, a conscious business
decision that they made at the time the contract was negotiated and
signed," said Partridge. "DuPont has always had the rights to
create a stacked product such as Roundup Ready with its Plenish(TM)
High Oleic soybean oil product, or adding a second herbicide
tolerance mode like its proprietary ALS-herbicide-tolerance
combined with Roundup Ready." "Importantly, the court's ruling
follows well-established patent and contract law by recognizing the
rights of the technology developer and reinforcing that contractual
rights should be respected," said Partridge. "Now that the
fundamental issue in this case has been decided, we look forward to
rapidly concluding the balance of this litigation." A Demonstrated
Track Record of Reasonable Business Solutions, Enabling Competition
"Monsanto has always and continues to remain open to reasonable
business solutions that create value for farmers," Partridge said.
"This is exemplified by the wide array of seed products which
contain a combination of intellectual property from Monsanto and
other companies." As the first company to broadly license traits
technologies to hundreds of independent seed companies, including
its major trait competitors, Monsanto remains committed to and has
a demonstrated track record of actively working with companies to
offer cutting-edge technologies. This includes creating and
licensing stacked trait products which incorporate Monsanto's
traits and competitive trait technologies. This approach, which is
highlighted through multiple corn and cotton trait offerings,
ensures that farmers can purchase trait technologies from the seed
companies they prefer to do business with. Monsanto also recently
confirmed that Roundup Ready soybeans would remain available after
patent expiry and would be royalty-free to farmers beginning in the
2015 season. The technology represents the first widespread
biotechnology trait to come off patent in the middle of this
decade. Monsanto also confirmed that it would not use variety
patents against U.S. farmers who save varieties with the technology
on their own farms after the expiration of the patent. Additional
Background Monsanto originally filed suit against E.I. du Pont de
Nemours and Company and its wholly owned subsidiary, Pioneer
Hi-Bred International, Inc., in May 2009. The lawsuit sought to
prevent the unlicensed combination of Monsanto's proprietary
Roundup Ready® herbicide tolerant technologies in soybeans and corn
with DuPont's problem plagued OGAT. In 2006, DuPont stated it would
replace the Roundup Ready gene in its line to improve performance.
The company later changed its story describing Roundup Ready as
"essential" upon learning its own glyphosate tolerance gene in OGAT
created "unacceptable risk to farmers." Interested parties who
would like to learn more about the evolution of DuPont's comments
on OGAT are encouraged to visit
http://www.monsanto.com/dupontlawsuit/timeline. Monsanto filed an
early motion for judgment on the pleadings in the case in October.
This ruling eliminates the need for a trial in this case about how
the two companies' license agreement is interpreted. More
information about this litigation as well as a copy of the Federal
Court's ruling is available on Monsanto's website at:
http://www.monsanto.com/dupontlawsuit. This represents the third
time that a court has ruled that DuPont has violated a trait
licensing agreement with Monsanto, and the second time that a court
has found DuPont did so by using Monsanto's technology in a way
that was not authorized. Over the last several months, since
Monsanto filed this suit, DuPont has leveled a campaign of
misinformation against Monsanto's business. As media reports have
highlighted, some of DuPont's efforts included funding
organizations such as the American Antitrust Institute (AAI) and
the Organization for Competitive Markets (OCM) - groups which have,
in turn, released reports with misleading information about
Monsanto's business practices. About Monsanto Company Monsanto
Company is a leading global provider of technology-based solutions
and agricultural products that improve farm productivity and food
quality. Monsanto remains focused on enabling both small-holder and
large-scale farmers to produce more from their land while
conserving more of our world's natural resources such as water and
energy. To learn more about our business and our commitments,
please visit: http://www.monsanto.com/ . Follow our business on
Twitter at http://www.twitter.com/MonsantoCo on Facebook at
http://www.facebook.com/MonsantoCo, or subscribe to our News
Release RSS Feed . Editor's Note: Roundup Ready and Monsanto and
the Vine Design are trademarks of Monsanto Technology LLC. Optimum®
GAT® and Plenish(TM) are registered trademarks or trademarks of
DuPont or its affiliates. CONTACT Lee Quarles, 314-694-2330 Kelli
Powers, 314-694-4003 DATASOURCE: Monsanto Company CONTACT: Lee
Quarles, +1-314-694-2330, or Kelli Powers, +1-314-694-4003, both of
Monsanto Web Site: http://www.monsanto.com/
Copyright