2
ISS and Glass Lewis both criticized Forest
Labs for deeply flawed corporate governance
The image of the CEO sitting in on the ostensibly
independent directors as they discuss whether or not to
support him is uncomfortably close to that of a show
trial: a
theatrical demonstration of power
, with a
pre-determined outcome, in which those with ostensible
authority must first and foremost demonstrate their
zealous personal loyalty to
the one who holds real
.
All the subsequent protestations about personal
integrity and independence
ring a little hollow
, when
the
right
course
of
action
calling
an
executive
session
to let the unaffiliated outside directors debate the issues
in private, without any undue influence from insiders
was both an
obvious and easy choice
. That the
meeting appears to have been
orchestrated from the
C-suite
the
General
Counsel,
rather
than
the
boards
own outside advisors, apparently prepared and
presented the materials which shaped the discussion
does not help matters.
If there was ever a moment for the independent
directors to take matters into their own hands, this was
it.
That
they
failed
to
do
so
and
perhaps
even
failed
to
recognize
their
own
responsibility
to
do
so
is
We believe that there are various aspects of the
Companys corporate governance that could suggest that
the
.
. . .we believe that Mr. Solomon and other Company
insiders
should have recused
themselves from the
board deliberations and actual voting on the matter.
. . .we note that the boards primary committees (audit,
compensation, and nominating and governance) have
historically been comprised of the boards longest
tenured directors, which we believe
may blunt the
impact
that
can
be
made
by
the
recently-appointed
directors.
. . .the appointment of Mr. Goodman as presiding
director leaves us feeling
highly dubious
of the boards
ability to enact truly positive corporate governance
reforms and only serves to drive home the Icahn Groups
argument that the Companys board is
filled with
.
ISS
Glass Lewis
Source: ISS, Glass Lewis
power
deeply worrisome
board
has
become
entrenched
entrenched directors
.
|