By Yuliya Chernova
American startups, especially consumer-hardware makers, are
facing difficult choices as they cope with escalating trade
tensions.
The U.S. government has been implementing wave after wave of
tariffs on Chinese goods since last summer. During a new round in
May, President Trump threatened to impose duties on potentially all
imports from China.
Venture-backed companies, including makers of educational
robots, at-home health devices and electronic scooters, have seen
significant cost increases as many rely heavily on Chinese
manufacturers.
"It's all cost, friction, and additional overhead," Brad Feld,
partner at Boulder, Colo. venture firm Foundry Group, and an
investor in numerous hardware startups, told WSJ Pro.
Startups are responding by increasing prices, changing their
sales strategy, and evaluating new production locations.
"It's forcing us to raise our prices and, ultimately, it'll
force us to sell fewer units, which means lower revenue," said Paul
Berberian, chief executive of Sphero Inc., known for its
programmable rolling robot toys, which are made in China.
One of Sphero's products -- app-enabled musical rings called
Specdrums -- was slapped with an import tariff last year. The
company increased the price to $64.99 from the planned $49, and
decided to drop a cheaper version that was in development, Mr.
Berberian said.
"We sell to kids. It seems kind of bad to tax kids," Mr.
Berberian said.
Big companies are switching manufacturing locations or
reallocating resources to other products and revenue sources. Apple
Inc., for instance, is asking suppliers to study shifting final
assembly of some products out of China as it considers diversifying
its supply chain, The Wall Street Journal reported.
Startups don't typically have that luxury.
"There's no Plan B," said Nisan Lerea, co-founder and chief
executive of Wazer Inc., a startup that sells precision-cutting
tools which it makes in the Brooklyn Navy Yard using Chinese parts.
"We need to stay the course because we are not going to say, 'Oh,
now I'll do something differently, the company doesn't have the
scope."
Wazer was forced to increase its price for its desktop waterjet,
passing on its costs to the American manufacturers that buy its
product, Mr. Lerea said.
Even without extra costs, hardware startups face high failure
rates. Several well-funded venture-backed companies, such as
robotics startups Anki Inc. and Jibo Inc., have gone out of
business in the past few months for reasons other than tariffs. But
costs stemming from tariffs are straining companies that already
operate on low margins.
"Incremental tariffs are not something that we modeled into our
business model," said Kal Vepuri, founder and CEO of Hero Health
Inc., a New York maker of electronic-medication dispensers for home
use. Hero Health raised $12 million in Series A funding last year
before seeing tariff-related cost increases on many of the
components it imports from China.
Bad timing
Tariffs are hitting a broad swath of venture portfolios, in part
because firms have been ramping up investments in hardware startups
such as Bird Rides Inc., which imports scooters from China.
Venture-backed consumer electronics startups in the U.S., raised
about $19.39 billion in capital in the past five years, according
to Dow Jones VentureSource.
The U.S. in May raised tariffs on $200 billion worth of Chinese
goods to 25% from 10%, increasing the toll on more businesses.
Robotics Inc., which has a few dozen employees, found out that
its programmable robot, Misty II, would be subject to a 25% tariff
after some of its customers had already preordered the robot for
$1,699 via a crowdfunding campaign. Misty decided against changing
the price for those customers, and will be delivering it for less
than its cost, said Tim Enwall, founder and head of Misty
Robotics.
"That alone will cost us half a month's payroll," Mr. Enwall
said.
New customers would have to pay $2,400 if they preorder, making
these robots less competitive on pricing.
"All that means is that the Japanese and the French robots are
more affordable," Mr. Enwall said.
Hardware startups also are considering shifting production out
of China. But it comes at a cost that most early-stage startups
can't afford, said David Pakman, partner at venture firm
Venrock.
Primarily, the U.S. isn't a suitable location for many of these
companies seeking a low-cost location. Prohibitive costs and a lack
of manufacturing facilities for low-volume electronics make
shifting production to the U.S. untenable, Mr. Enwall said.
In the case of Hero Health Inc., the maker of the pill dispenser
that displays a "Made in U.S.A." label on its website, its
executives are considering a plan to move the assembly from
California to China, Mr. Vepuri said. The current tariff regime is
such that while Hero's components are taxed extra, the Hero machine
itself could be imported without an additional duty, at least for
now, Mr. Vepuri said.
As the trade talks remain in limbo, entrepreneurs are
increasingly fretful.
"I don't know if our company could survive in a full-on tariff
regime," Sphero's Mr. Berberian said.
Write to Yuliya Chernova at yuliya.chernova@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
June 21, 2019 12:37 ET (16:37 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2019 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.