UPDATE: Companies Call For Broader Access To OTC Clearing
June 09 2009 - 5:42PM
Dow Jones News
Exchanges and market participants pressed members of Congress on
Tuesday to ensure clearinghouses for over-the-counter derivatives
can be accessed by more than Wall Street banks.
The companies made their case as Congress gears up to enact
major new regulations of derivatives markets that will likely force
many types of over-the-counter derivatives to be processed through
clearinghouses, which guarantee trades and cushion the market in
the event of a default.
The calls for broader participation come as the only active U.S.
clearinghouse for credit derivatives, the bank-backed ICE Trust
platform, has cleared more than $800 billion in trades since
launching in early March.
Membership in ICE Trust, operated by Atlanta-based
IntercontinentalExchange Inc. (ICE), is essentially limited to the
biggest dealer banks for the time being by virtue of a $5 billion
minimum net worth and a $20 million contribution to the guaranty
fund.
Major financial firms like JP Morgan (JPM) and Goldman Sachs
(GS) that participate in the clearinghouse are also financial
stakeholders in the clearing effort.
"The use of central counterparties by all market participants,
including end users...should be encouraged by providing open and
fair access to key infrastructure components," said Standard Credit
Group Chief Executive Donald Fewer in testimony before the House of
Representatives' Financial Services Subcommittee on Capital
Markets.
At issue is when broker-dealers, hedge funds and other buy-side
participants will be allowed to join the clearinghouse as members,
or have collateral posted with banks on over-the-counter trades
protected by the clearinghouse's guarantee fund.
The financial crisis has created momentum for the creation of
clearinghouses for credit-default swaps and other exotic
over-the-counter instruments, which some blame for contributing to
the crisis.
The private sector, including ICE and CME Group Inc. (CME), have
worked with regulators to develop clearing platforms for
credit-default swaps, although CME has had trouble launching its
platform as the big banks have preferred to clear through ICE Trust
instead.
In addition, the Obama administration has called for drastic new
reforms for the over-the-counter derivatives markets, including
plans to mandate clearing for standardized products. The plan also
goes a step further than some companies and Republican lawmakers
may like by requiring exchange-trading of all standard
over-the-counter products.
Brokers Looking For Entry
Executives from brokerage firms Newedge Group and MF Global Ltd.
(MF) have also called on ICE to broaden membership in the ICE Trust
clearinghouse.
"When you look at the guarantee pool supporting any product, you
want diversity ... small, medium and large companies trading
different asset classes; that's what creates protection," said
Bernard Dan, chief executive of MF Global, in a recent interview
with Dow Jones Newswires.
"With ICE Trust, because the participation is very limited and
it's a single product, that diversity is not there yet."
The CEO of Nasdaq OMX's (NDAQ) new interest rate swap
clearinghouse, the International Derivatives Clearing Group, which
stands to gain financially from the Obama proposal, also voiced
concerns about clearinghouse membership Tuesday, although he didn't
explicitly mention ICE.
"Any new clearing system must protect the smallest eligible
market participant in a manner that is consistent with the largest
market participant with the same rules and same level of access;
otherwise the system will fail again," said Chris Edmonds.
ICE Chief Executive Jeffrey Sprecher told Dow Jones Newswires on
Tuesday that ICE's credit derivatives clearinghouse will be
operationally ready to extend clearing protection to cover member
banks' customers in "weeks."
Sprecher said ICE has been working with the Federal Reserve and
the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. on firming up the process,
similar to segregation of customer funds in futures markets.
However, banks have targeted Dec. 15 as the date by which they
plan to offer segregated funds, according to a recent letter to the
New York Federal Reserve.
Sprecher said ICE will maintain its high membership standards
for the time being because of the "extreme risk" particularly
associated with single-name credit derivatives.
CME has said that its credit derivatives clearing service,
developed with hedge fund firm Citadel Investment Group, will be
open to buy-side participants at launch and will provide for
segregation of customer funds.
CME Executive Chairman Terry Duffy told Dow Jones Newswires that
the Chicago-based exchange operator hopes to launch its
credit-default swap clearing platform by the end of the year.
-By Jacob Bunge, Dow Jones Newswires; 312-750-4117;
jacob.bunge@dowjones.com
-By Sarah N. Lynch, Dow Jones Newswires; 202-862-6634;
sarah.lynch@dowjones.com