Critics Say New York Budget Being Crafted With 'Unprecedented Secrecy'
March 29 2020 - 7:29PM
Dow Jones News
By Jimmy Vielkind
Advocacy groups of all stripes are concerned they have been shut
out of the state budget negotiations set to conclude this week, a
deal one longtime watchdog said is taking shape in "unprecedented
secrecy."
The state Capitol in March normally teems with lobbyists,
citizens and officials from around the state pushing to be heard as
the budget comes together. State legislators' days are scheduled to
the minute, and people seeking their attention can be lucky to get
in a few moments during a chance encounter near the floor of the
chamber.
All that ceased when the building closed to visitors on March 15
as the coronavirus spread. Legislators voted on a handful of bills
on March 18, but remain scattered around the state. The traditional
avenues of influence adapted by necessity.
On Friday, Citizen Action of New York, a progressive advocacy
group, held a "car rally" where people honked on the street outside
the Capitol to protest any changes to the state's new bail law,
which eliminated cash bail for most misdemeanor and nonviolent
felony offenses.
For most of January and February, the group held weekly rallies
inside the building, arguing that the law -- which took effect Jan.
1 -- has reduced economic and racial disparities in the criminal
justice system.
Law-enforcement officials as well as elected leaders in both
parties, including New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio, believe the
bail law should be amended to let judges consider public safety
when deciding whether to detain someone before their trial.
"To roll back the bail law now or down the line is to set up for
devastation in the face of this pandemic," because it is difficult
to contain the virus in jails, said Erin George, the civil rights
campaign director for Citizen Action.
The Alliance for Quality Education, which advocates for greater
school funding, held a virtual news conference on Friday to urge
legislators to raise taxes on the wealthy rather than cut
services.
Brian Sampson, president of the Associated Builders and
Contractors, Empire State Chapter, said the contractors he
represents had to fall back on letter-writing and social-media
campaigns to lobby lawmakers. Contractors are battling against
building-trade unions over a provision that would broaden the
definition of public works that require a higher, prevailing wage
rate.
"It's obviously been very difficult. You're relying on phone
calls, text messages and emails, and you're hoping your message is
being heard," Mr. Sampson said.
Leaders of the state Senate and Assembly, both of which are
controlled by Democrats, didn't release their own draft budgets to
counter the $178 billion spending plan Gov. Andrew Cuomo unveiled
in January.
Instead, the Democratic governor has been talking directly with
Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie and Senate Majority Leader Andrea
Stewart-Cousins. This practice of three people in a room is common
in Albany, but without rank-and-file lawmakers close by, regular
briefings have been relegated to conference calls.
"Albany in the best of times is secretive," said Blair Horner, a
longtime leader of the New York Public Interest Research Group, a
watchdog organization. "We're now entering a black hole of
information where even light can't escape. It's as dark as dark can
be. Unless you're hiring the hot-wired lobbyists, it's hard to find
out what's going on."
Mr. Cuomo has appeared regularly in the Capitol to offer updates
on the state's response to the coronavirus outbreak, and he has
fielded some budget questions. The coronavirus has had big impacts
on the state economy and decreased revenue projections by around
15%.
"This is the easiest budget we've done," Mr. Cuomo joked to a
legislator recently and recounted during a public radio interview.
"We have no money."
THE QUESTION: New York's budget must be in place by April 1, but
lawmakers often miss the deadline. How many days late was the
tardiest budget, and who was governor when it was finally
adopted?
-- Know the answer? Leave a comment!
THE LAST ANSWER: Governors John Dix, William Marcy, William
Seward, Horatio Seymour and Silas Wright each have mountains named
after them in the Adirondack Park.
Write to Jimmy Vielkind at Jimmy.Vielkind@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
March 29, 2020 19:14 ET (23:14 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.