By Tim Higgins
Elon Musk has long cast Tesla Inc. as a tech company, but the
coronavirus pandemic -- and his battle to resume production -- show
that the Silicon Valley car maker still has at least as much in
common with Detroit as it does with the tech giants down the
The Tesla chief's decision to disobey California authorities and
resume some work at the electric-vehicle maker's lone U.S. assembly
plant has become the highest-profile standoff between business and
government as the country debates how and whether to reopen the
Mr. Musk has been on the floor of the San Francisco Bay Area
factory this week to welcome workers back. He has dared authorities
to arrest him or halt production. So far, they haven't.
Tensions between Mr. Musk and California officials have been
steadily rising since Michigan Gretchen Whitmer last week said she
was allowing factory work to resume. Ms. Whitmer's move cleared the
way for General Motors Co., Ford Motor Co. and Fiat Chrysler
Automobiles NV to bring back some employees this week and ready
their North American factories with the stated goal of resuming
vehicle production starting May 18.
When local authorities outside of San Francisco said Tesla's
factory, idled since March 23, should remain closed, Mr. Musk grew
defiant. It meant Tesla would be the only U.S. auto maker unable to
get back to building cars. He called that disparity "insane."
For Tesla, one of the competitive risks from remaining shut
while Detroit and others reopen is being able to quickly satisfy
demand in an economic rebound. Rivals would be able to stock
dealerships with new vehicles while Tesla rebuilt inventory.
The episode shows how companies that compete across state or
national borders can be affected by governments' decisions about
what can reopen and when.
This week GM is restarting parts-distribution centers, two
engine factories and an upstate New York plant that makes radiators
and other components, a spokesman said. Competitors in Europe have
already begun resuming production.
Daimler AG's Mercedes-Benz factory in Alabama was the first
major auto maker in the U.S. to return to work, on April 27,
followed by BMW AG, Hyundai Motor Co., and Kia Motors Corp. plants
in South Carolina, Alabama and Georgia, respectively, which started
assembly lines at limited capacities on May 4.
Over the weekend, Mr. Musk launched a campaign to restart Tesla
production amid a lockdown in Fremont, threatening to move
headquarters out of state, and filing suit in federal court for
clearance to reopen. On Monday, Mr. Musk said on Twitter that Tesla
would resume production in defiance of lockdown orders -- creating
a standoff with authorities who have given little indication how
they plan to resolve it.
Politics have figured into the national debate over reopening.
President Trump has lashed out at some states, such as Michigan,
for their Democratic governors' handling of the coronavirus crisis.
On Tuesday he voiced his support for Mr. Musk, posting on Twitter:
"California should let Tesla & @elonmusk open the plant, NOW.
It can be done Fast & Safely!"
Some of Tesla's corporate neighbors appear to be in no rush to
get back to the office, partly because many of their employees can
work remotely. Facebook Inc. and Google-parent Alphabet Inc. told
workers last week they could continue working from home for the
rest of the year, and Twitter Inc. said its employees could
possibly do so indefinitely.
Tesla, however, needs an army of workers on an assembly line --
often working in physical proximity -- to build its cars. Tesla
employs more than 10,000 people at the Fremont factory where it
makes the hot-selling Model 3 compact car and other vehicles.
Before Mr. Musk's surprise reopening push, Tesla executives had
been working with Alameda County, home to the Fremont factory, on a
plan to restart manufacturing. Scott Haggerty, a county supervisor
involved in the talks, said he thought the two sides were in
agreement that vehicle assembly work could resume Monday, May 18 --
the same day other U.S. auto makers are set to resume
That timeline would still have left Tesla somewhat behind its
Detroit rivals, since it would still have to perform some of the
preparatory work for car assembly, which the other manufacturers
are trying to accomplish this week. Tesla pushed to open a section
of the plant where car components are stamped ahead of assembly,
according to Mr. Haggerty.
To build its cars, Tesla takes delivery of rolled steel that is
laid flat, cut into pieces and stamped into shapes with giant
presses to create hoods, side panels and other parts. Most auto
makers in the U.S. house stamping operations in separate factories
from those where they assemble vehicles. Tesla does all that in the
limited confines of the Fremont plant, which gives the company a
big incentive to complete the preparations early and speed its
ability to get cars out the door.
Alameda County, which has a population of nearly 1.7 million,
has recorded 75 Covid-19-linked fatalities, according to state
data, and is among the Bay Area's hardest-hit sections. Mr. Musk
has publicly questioned the risks posed by the novel
Tesla buses in many workers from other counties, and local
health officials were concerned such an influx could lead to more
infections, Mr. Haggerty said, adding that the county was looking
for ways to screen employees before they arrived on site. "There
was a whole nuance of just trying to make sure that we could open
the plant and not see a spike in cases or deaths," he said.
Tesla didn't respond to requests for comment about the
Talks between Tesla and county officials were thrown into
disarray when Mr. Musk began recalling workers last Friday and then
filed the lawsuit Saturday.
In a letter sent on Monday, the county urged the company to
cease work. "We hope that Tesla -- like other businesses who have
been notified of non-compliance -- comes into compliance with the
order without the need for additional enforcement measures,"
Colleen Chawla, director of the county's health-care services
Late Tuesday, the county said it was reviewing Tesla's plan for
reopening and was seeking additional steps. The county said once
conditions are met, Tesla could conduct minimum operations to
prepare for reopening "as soon as next week" -- without addressing
the fact that Mr. Musk had said production has already resumed.
Tesla's workers are closely following the company's fight,
several told The Wall Street Journal. In early April, the company
furloughed without pay those whose jobs couldn't be done from home.
Workers have been recalled in recent days, and a Tesla
human-resources executive informed employees that operations would
begin with limited staff, saying workers with concerns about coming
back on the job wouldn't be penalized.
Some hourly employees were split on returning; one likened the
shutdown to "economic suicide," while another expressed concern
about how safe the car maker can keep its workers. Some workers
worried of retaliation if they declined to show up for work. Others
raised concerns about the pressure they'll face to make up for
weeks of lost production to meet Mr. Musk's goals of boosting
deliveries more than 36% this year.
Tesla has said it has added partitions and barriers to separate
work areas and is screening employees for fevers at plant
entrances. Start times might be staggered to space out worker
arrivals. Before Saturday, a company memo said Tesla wouldn't let
workers in if they have a temperature of 100.4 degrees or
Asked how things went at the factory, on Tuesday Mr. Musk
responded on Twitter: "Great."
--Mike Colias and Ben Foldy contributed to this article.
Write to Tim Higgins at Tim.Higgins@WSJ.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
May 13, 2020 14:28 ET (18:28 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
Historical Stock Chart
From Jul 2020 to Aug 2020
Historical Stock Chart
From Aug 2019 to Aug 2020