By Yoree Koh
Many education officials, public-health officials and parents
believe that vaccinating children against Covid-19 will play a key
role in resuming normal life in time for in-person learning in the
fall. That stance has led some parents to wonder: Will K-12
students be mandated to receive the vaccine to be allowed on campus
Children as young as 12 years old are now eligible to receive
the Covid-19 vaccine from Pfizer Inc. and BioNTech SE. Moderna Inc.
said Thursday it has asked U.S. health regulators to authorize the
use of its Covid-19 shot in adolescents ages 12 to 17, setting up
the potential availability of a second vaccine option for
About 23% of youths 12 to 15 years old have received at least
one dose of the Pfizer vaccine since U.S. health regulators cleared
it for use among that age group last month, according to the U.S.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
About 51% of people are in favor of mandating vaccines for
middle-school students, 56% for high-school students and 61% for
college students, according to a Gallup poll of more than 3,500
adults conducted in May.
About 53% of parents of children between the ages of 12 and 15
said they plan to have their child vaccinated. The same percentage
of parents of children under 12 said they planned to have their
children vaccinated once the green light is given.
State policies regarding vaccinations will play a key role in
whether schools can require Covid-19 vaccinations in a way similar
to how many require shots for infectious diseases such as
Can schools mandate Covid-19 vaccines?
Schools and school districts generally don't have the authority
to mandate student vaccines.
But other authorities can: namely, state legislatures or health
officials acting under legislative authority, said Dorit Rubinstein
Reiss, a public-health law professor at the University of
California Hastings College of the Law.
The one exception is New York City, where a 2018 court case over
flu vaccinations implies that city officials can likely require
student vaccines in addition to the ones authorized by the
"This is an area that is already simply pretty highly
regulated," said Ms. Reiss.
Some states such as California allow state health departments to
add other vaccines to those required by law. But the health
department has never exercised that allowance, said Ms. Reiss.
Every one of the 10 vaccines on California's approved list has been
added through the state legislature, she said.
Have state lawmakers shown an interest in mandating the Covid-19
vaccines for K-12 students?
Not really, and that isn't surprising, according to Ms. Reiss.
For starters, the vaccine has only been approved for use in
children 12 and up. So making an argument that a vaccine is
necessary might prove hard if only half the school population can
receive it, said Ms. Reiss. Lawmakers are unlikely to push for a
mandate until the vaccine is approved for use by all school-age
children. Another reason is that all three Covid-19 vaccines are
currently approved under an emergency-use authorization, said Ms.
Reiss. While that status doesn't necessarily preclude a mandate, it
does weaken the legal standing.
Oklahoma became the first state to pass legislation blocking
K-12 vaccine requirements. The bill, signed by Republic Gov. Kevin
Stitt late last month, also forbids schools from implementing a
mask mandate on unvaccinated students. Similar bills prohibiting
schools to require the vaccine are making their way through
Michigan and Pennsylvania legislatures.
Do school districts want the Covid-19 vaccine to be
Many are keeping quiet on the issue. New York City Mayor Bill de
Blasio, who has authority over schools, indicated last week that he
isn't keen on a vaccine mandate.
"I think when we get in the business of mandating, we create
conflict that we don't need in this," said Mr. de Blasio. He added
that increasing vaccinations by educating about their effectiveness
would be better.
Los Angeles Unified School District Superintendent Austin
Beutner said vaccines should be made mandatory once they have been
proven to be safe and effective.
"I would expect that in the not too distant future -- I don't
know if it's weeks, months or hopefully not years -- the state
would mandate it. Why would we treat Covid differently than we
treat measles and mumps? It doesn't make sense to me," said Mr.
Mr. Beutner, head of the country's second-largest school
district, said that he has discussed a potential mandate with state
legislators for months and that when the politics around the topic
are put aside, many agree that the vaccine should be required.
There are differing views on when would be the right time to
implement it, he said.
Mr. Beutner is stepping down from his job at the end of the
Nearly 50 urban school districts, including New York City, Los
Angeles, Cleveland and Detroit, are offering vaccinations to
students and families at school buildings, according to the Council
of the Great City Schools.
What do teachers say?
The National Education Association, the country's largest
teachers union, said it doesn't have a national position, and the
American Federation of Teachers, the second-largest teachers union,
said it isn't pushing for vaccination to be required. Randi
Weingarten, the group's president, has said it is important to
convince people of the vaccine's efficacy to overcome
How effective are the Covid-19 vaccines among children?
The results of a Pfizer-BioNTech study of 2,260 adolescents
found that the two-dose shot was 100% effective at protecting
against symptomatic Covid-19 in 12- to 15-year-olds.
So far, researchers haven't found evidence that the vaccines
pose any additional or different risks to children versus adults.
The most common side effects of the vaccine, according to the CDC,
are flulike symptoms, such as fever, muscle aches and chills.
Do school vaccine mandates work?
Yes, according to Dr. Paul Offit, director of the Vaccine
Education Center at Children's Hospital of Philadelphia. Take the
case of measles, the first vaccine to be mandated at schools in
some states. According to a 2003 paper in the American Medical
Association's Journal of Ethics, "Evidence showed that states with
school immunization laws had rates of measles 40-51% lower than
states without such laws."
Such findings led to more state mandates and strict
"Because of those mandates we ultimately eliminated measles from
this country" for a time, said Dr. Offit.
Every state requires children to be vaccinated to attend school,
with inoculations for mumps, measles and rubella, as well as polio
and diphtheria among the most common. But there are exemptions. Six
states -- West Virginia, Mississippi, New York, Maine, California
and Connecticut -- allow only medical exemptions.
Forty-four states and the District of Columbia grant religious
exemptions, and 15 states allow philosophical exemptions, according
to the National Conference of State Legislatures.
What about colleges?
Hundreds of colleges and universities -- both public and private
-- are requiring students to be vaccinated to participate in
on-campus learning this fall.
The legal restrictions that bind K-12 schools don't always apply
because most public universities have self-governing powers from
the state, and private universities generally aren't subject to
state regulations, said Ms. Reiss. But the self-governing powers of
public universities usually aren't strong enough to override state
legislation. If states say that public universities can't make the
Covid-19 vaccine a condition for attendance, such as in the case of
Oklahoma and Utah, then the universities' powers might be limited,
said Ms. Reiss.
Some public-health experts and pediatricians caution that it
might be prudent to wait until more data is available before making
the Covid-19 vaccine a requirement. Danny Benjamin, a professor of
pediatrics at Duke University, said he would want "maximum
information" on the vaccine's efficacy and mortality rates on a
much larger scale than provided through the initial trials. "We're
really early in the life cycle of mandating it," said Dr.
Dr. Benjamin, whose four children have all received the vaccine
including two who were part of the initial trials, said that given
the hesitancy regarding vaccines it is best not to rush to
mandates. Instead, encouraging vaccinations through incentives and
education would be better, he said.
Write to Yoree Koh at email@example.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
June 11, 2021 08:14 ET (12:14 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2021 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
Historical Stock Chart
From Jun 2021 to Jul 2021
Historical Stock Chart
From Jul 2020 to Jul 2021