By Laurence Norman
BRUSSELS -- European finance ministers worked through deep
differences to agree to a package of measures totaling half a
trillion euros aimed at blunting the impact of the coronavirus on
the fragile economy, officials said. But a bigger conflict over
whether to share the costs of the health crisis was deferred.
The agreement late Thursday provided a moment of unity in what
has been a bruising fight among European Union members over the
response to the crisis, which has slammed some countries still
recovering from the financial crisis a decade ago. Finance
ministers had spent more than 15 hours Tuesday night trying to
reach an accord without success.
"This response contains bold and ambitious proposals that would
have been unthinkable just a few weeks ago. We can all remember the
response to the financial crisis of the last decade when Europe did
too little, too late," said Mario Centeno, president of the
Eurogroup of finance ministers. "This time around, it is
different."
The deal, however, provided only a temporary truce among
hard-hit members, including Italy and Spain, and wealthier northern
countries, like Germany and the Netherlands, over whether the 19
members of the common currency bloc should issue common eurozone
debt to finance recovery efforts from the crisis.
Over coming months, the steps agreed to should offer businesses
additional liquidity, help governments fund job programs and
provide credit lines, with relatively few strings attached, to
European governments that face difficulties accessing financial
markets, according to a final text of the deal.
But southern countries say immediate guarantees of common debt
issuance are crucial to allow them to spend what they need to
handle the coronavirus crisis. Without that promise, governments in
the hardest hit countries may constrain stimulus now to avoid high
debt level spiraling further and sparking a sovereign debt crisis
as the bloc looks toward an economic recovery.
EU leaders had given finance ministers two weeks to come up with
measures, a deadline that ended Thursday. They are expected to hold
a teleconference next week to sign off the recommendations.
Under the deal, member states will be able to receive
precautionary credit lines from the region's bailout fund amounting
to at least 2% of a country's economic output, or some EUR240
billion ($262 billion) of the available credit in the region's
bailout fund, known as the European Stability Mechanism.
Finance ministers said they would try and set up access to the
ESM within two weeks. The funding could help pay health costs
directly related to the crisis. Non-euro EU countries will have
access to the EU's balance of payments financial assistance.
While there are few initial conditions on the use of the money,
over time countries would "remain committed to strengthen economic
and financial fundamentals," the text of the deal said, a demand of
the Netherlands in particular.
Borrowing from the ESM has become a no-go in Italy, because of
heavy conditions attached to the fund's money under the financial
crisis. Opposition leader Matteo Salvini has spearheaded a campaign
against Italy signing up to the fund.
The finance ministers also backed a program extending up to
EUR200 billion in loans to EU businesses, underwritten by EUR25
billion in member state guarantees for the European Investment
Bank, the bloc's finance arm.
They gave the go-ahead for a EUR100 billion jobs support program
proposed last week by the European Commission. Once set up, that
will see the EU's executive body borrow directly in the markets,
with guarantees provided by member states, to help governments fund
programs that prevent companies laying off workers.
The ministers also committed to establishing a large-scale
recovery fund to help the region emerge from the crisis. However,
they left key questions open about the size, timing and financing
of the fund for the bloc's leaders to come back to.
The text said the fund would need to be temporary and targeted,
and didn't mention eurozone bonds, reflecting the division within
the bloc over the instruments. It said only that discussions on
financing the fund would include "innovative financial instruments,
consistent with EU Treaties."
The Netherlands, Germany, Finland and others have long opposed
Eurobonds, saying they would turn the eurozone into a financial
transfer union and are inconsistent with EU and domestic laws.
"With this package we will help countries in need on the short
term while also building resilient economies on the long-term,"
said Dutch Finance Minister Wopke Hoekstra. "This is a powerful and
sensible sign of European solidarity."
Carsten Brzeski, Chief Economist, Eurozone and Global Head of
Macro at ING, said that given the disagreements, he doubts the
recovery fund will "fly any time soon."
"This aid package...leaves the question whether any of the
countries will be satisfied," he said. "As so often in eurozone
decision making, small historic steps have been taken toward more
integration, but many would argue this isn't yet enough."
Write to Laurence Norman at laurence.norman@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
April 09, 2020 18:43 ET (22:43 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2020 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.