By Esther Fung and Inti Pacheco
U.S. apparel companies are bracing for squeezed profits and
potential store closures as a result of the Trump administration's
pledge to extend tariffs on Chinese imports.
President Trump last week walked back some of his tariff threat,
agreeing to delay new duties on toys, cellphones and other
electronics until December. But a majority of apparel and much of
the footwear imported from China are still subject to tariffs
starting Sept. 1.
About 40% of all clothing and 70% of shoes sold in the U.S. are
made in China, according to the American Apparel and Footwear
Association. After China became a member of the World Trade
Organization in 2001, U.S. retailers increasingly relied on
manufacturing their goods there because of cheaper labor and
production costs.
In all, about $33 billion in apparel, shoes and hats are among
the items subject to a 10% tariff on Chinese imports beginning
Sept. 1, according to a Wall Street Journal analysis of data from
the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative and the Census
Bureau.
As fall approaches, the apparel that will be hit by the tariffs
includes gloves, mittens, overcoats and sweaters. More than 60% of
U.S. stockings and socks are made in China, and $250 million of
them face tariffs in less than two weeks.
Many apparel companies have already been cutting prices to fend
off heightened competition from discount chains, Amazon.com Inc.
and other online retailers. That has left them operating on such
thin margins that absorbing even a portion of any costs associated
with the new tariffs would be painful.
The tariffs would come not long before the start of the holiday
shopping season, which retailers count on for most of their annual
sales.
"Tariffs could wipe out their profits," said Wade Miquelon,
chief executive officer of Joann Fabric and Craft Stores, in a
recent press call.
Jay Sole, a retail and department store analyst at UBS,
estimated that if the administration raised tariffs on China to
25%, it could lead to as many as 12,000 stores closing, about 10%
of the stores among the 524 retailers UBS tracks. Even the proposed
10% tariff would pressure hundreds of stores throughout the U.S.,
he added.
Some retail landlords are less pessimistic. They suggest it
could take years before tariffs siphon enough cash flow to threaten
rent payments of most retailers.
"It's a little far down the line," said Charles Lanier, director
of real estate at Plaza Associates Inc., a private
commercial-property landlord that runs Crabtree Valley Mall in
Raleigh, N.C.
The administration has already imposed 25% tariffs on $250
billion worth of Chinese goods. With plans for new duties on
additional Chinese products, virtually all imports from China would
be subject to tariffs by year's end.
Most apparel companies are expected to absorb the cost increase
themselves or negotiate ways to cut expenses with their Chinese
manufacturers to avoid antagonizing customers with higher
prices.
Macy's Inc., which raised prices on some luggage, housewares and
furniture when tariffs on such items rose to 25% in May, said it
was unlikely to repeat that approach for apparel subject to new
tariffs.
"We learned from that experience that the customer had very
little appetite for those cost increases," CEO Jeffrey Gennette
said during the company's earnings call last week. Instead, he
said, Macy's would work with its Chinese partners to absorb the
extra costs.
Many apparel companies would find it painful to do the same.
Fifteen publicly traded clothing, footwear and accessories
retailers tracked by UBS have margins of less than 3%. These
companies represent $42 billion in sales, and they operate more
than 12,000 stores, UBS said.
Still, not all apparel companies would suffer equally. Some
brands have already taken steps to mitigate the potential impact of
new China tariffs, or even to benefit from them.
Weyco Group Inc., which sells Florsheim and Stacy Adams shoes,
said it increased imports from China in the spring to stay ahead of
tariffs that would affect apparel and footwear.
"In May, when the threat again became evident, we had
discussions with all the factories in China and just tried to pull
everything for that we could," Weyco CEO Thomas W. Florsheim Jr.
said during an earnings call this month.
Columbia Sportswear Co. said it may stop offering some products
made in China. "When there's uncertainty, that's the enemy of
investment," said Peter Bragdon, Columbia Sportswear's executive
vice president.
At least a few retailers already facing tariffs have been able
to raise prices without much consumer backlash. In May, Home Depot
said it managed to pass the tariff costs on imported washing
machines to its customers. Sales initially sagged, then
recovered.
Steven Madden Ltd., a shoe and fashion-accessory company, said
it has already moved some production out of China. If any
competitors feel compelled to raise prices after the China tariffs,
the company would view that as an opportunity to gain market
share.
"We're making a good chunk of the Steve Madden-branded products
in Mexico for fall," CEO Edward Rosenfeld said on a recent earnings
call. He added that some production was moved to Cambodia "and a
number of other countries."
But shifting suppliers isn't an easy option for most apparel
companies. It takes years to build relationships and establish new
supply chains. Retailers have built quality-control systems in
Chinese factories that can't be dismantled and reassembled in
another country overnight.
China's currency depreciation earlier this month, when officials
reduced the value of the yuan against the dollar by around 2.5%,
helps a bit by making Chinese products cheaper in dollar terms. Yet
many expenses tied to importing products including gasoline and
materials such as cotton, are dollar-based.
Joann Fabric and Craft Stores, which has 850 stores across 49
states, faces tariffs on artificial-floral supplies and plans to
hold prices steady this year and absorb any losses for now, rather
than risk alienating customers with higher prices or closing down
stores.
"We don't want to cut hours or give up good properties," said
Mr. Miquelon.
Write to Esther Fung at esther.fung@wsj.com and Inti Pacheco at
inti.pacheco@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
August 20, 2019 05:44 ET (09:44 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2019 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.