Consumers Bore Cost for U.S. Tariffs on Washing Machines, Paper Finds
April 22 2019 - 9:01AM
Dow Jones News
By David Harrison
President Trump's tariffs on imported washing machines cost U.S.
consumers about $1.5 billion a year, according to new research.
The paper released Monday found the tariffs raised the price of
washing machines by 12%.
The prices of dryers, which weren't subject to the tariffs but
are often sold together with washers, also rose about the same
amount, according to the research by Aaron Flaaen, a Federal
Reserve economist; Ali Hortaçsu and Felix Tintelnot, both of the
University of Chicago.
Saying he was "committed to defending American companies," Mr.
Trump in January 2018 announced a 20% tariff on the first 1.2
million washing machines imported into the U.S. each year and a 50%
tariff on all subsequent units.
Administration officials touted the tariffs as a response to
unfair trade practices by foreign producers that were harming U.S.
manufacturers. The administration also has announced broader
tariffs on around $250 billion of Chinese goods and has announced
it is planning to impose tariffs on around $11 billion in imports
from the European Union.
But the researchers' conclusions suggest tariffs can have
unintended effects.
Mr. Tintelnot said in an interview the washing machine tariffs
also raised prices on dryers because vendors preferred to spread
out the full cost increase over both items since washers and dryers
are frequently sold in a bundle.
"You would have seen near double the price increase for washers,
if there was not this other good," he said.
Foreign appliance makers such as Samsung Electronics Co. and LG
Electronics Inc. responded to the tariffs by announcing plans to
boost production in the U.S. and hire up to 1,600 new workers.
Whirlpool Corp., a domestic manufacturer, said it would also hire
an extra 200 workers.
The tariffs also produced $82.2 million in new government
revenue between February 2018 and January 2019, according to the
study.
But consumers paid the price, the research found. After taking
into account the additional government revenue, each of those new
jobs cost $817,000, the researchers found.
The White House had no comment.
Last year's tariffs weren't the first to be imposed on washing
machine producers. In 2012, the U.S. levied duties on washers from
South Korea and Mexico saying they were undercutting prices from
domestic manufacturers. In response, imports of Chinese washers
rose.
But instead of pushing up prices, the duties lowered them
because it was cheaper to make a washing machine in China than in
South Korea.
In 2016 under the Obama administration, Washington imposed
tariffs on Chinese-made washing machines, which at the time made up
about 80% of washers imported into the U.S. Prices rose briefly
until production shifted again, this time to Vietnam and Thailand,
Mr. Tintelnot said.
In 2018, by contrast, tariffs were levied on all imports,
regardless of their origin, pushing up prices.
"Tariffs applied globally against many countries are much more
costly for consumers than tariffs applied against one or two
particular countries," he said.
Write to David Harrison at david.harrison@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
April 22, 2019 08:46 ET (12:46 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2019 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.