Benefit Gains Exceed Wage Growth, New Labor Data Show -- Update
September 18 2018 - 5:32PM
Dow Jones News
By Eric Morath
Americans' compensation is growing, but workers might not notice
it in their regular pay.
The value of benefits -- including bonuses and vacation time --
grew at a faster rate in the 12 months ended in June than wages and
salaries, according to data the Labor Department released
Tuesday.
That extended a long-running but slow shift in compensation
toward benefits and away from wages.
The cost of benefits for private-sector employers rose 3% in
June from a year earlier, while the cost of wages and salaries
advanced 2.7%.
The benefit gain was driven by a nearly 12% increase in bonuses
and other forms of supplemental pay. Paid leave, including vacation
time, rose 4% in June from a year earlier.
The improved perks point to a job market that has shifted in the
workers' favor. The unemployment rate, at 3.9% last month, is
holding just above a 18-year low, employers have added jobs for
95-straight months and the number of job openings exceed the number
of unemployed Americans actively looking for work.
"Bonuses and supplemental pay speak to labor market conditions,
and workers are in a good spot to get a little more," said Ryan
Sutton, a district president for staffing agency Robert Half.
"Companies are still reluctant to move base wages up too much. It's
a lot harder to take that away than bonuses."
The increase in bonus compensation in part reflects lump sum
payments that many large companies, including AT&T Inc. and
Comcast Corp., gave to employees after Congress approved a package
of tax cuts.
Mr. Sutton said bonuses are closely tied to corporate profits,
and while the tax cuts likely improved bottom lines for many
companies, profits have been growing at a strong clip for several
years.
President Trump's economic advisers argued in a recent paper
that growth in overall compensation is a better measure of how
workers are faring than wages alone.
Overall compensation has grown faster than wages at least since
the recession ended in 2009.
"Bonuses and paid leave are the ones growing fastest lately,"
said Kevin Hassett, chairman of the president's Council of Economic
Advisers, earlier this month. "Employees appreciate such benefits
just as much as cash, and that's why we look at the sum, rather
than one in isolation."
Growth in bonuses has been more pronounced in the past year than
earlier in the expansion, and has accelerated since 2015. Bonus
payments were unchanged in June from March, the last time the data
were collected. The data aren't seasonally adjusted, making monthly
comparisons potentially misleading, but the lack of movement could
suggest that at least some of those payments may not be
repeated.
Lawrence Mishel, an economist at the Economic Policy Institute
who formerly worked for several labor unions, said the bonus and
benefit growth are more reflective of several years of falling
unemployment than recent tax cuts.
"Overall wage and compensation growth does not provide much in
the way of bragging rights for tax cutters," he said. "Especially
given the expectation of rising wages and compensation amid low
unemployment."
Increased bonus payments could also indicate firms are using
one-time payments to recruit or retain workers.
Tuesday's report showed the cost of health-care coverage and
other insurance rose 2.3% from a year earlier. The cost of
retirement and savings benefits fell slightly from a year earlier
in June.
The Employer Costs for Employee Compensation report is among
several Labor Department measures of earnings. Most show a modest
acceleration in average pay this year, but with growth relatively
subdued compared with other periods of extremely low
unemployment.
Average hourly earnings for private-sector workers rose 2.9% in
August from a year earlier, according to the department's
employment report released earlier this month. That measure comes
from a different survey.
Due to its methodology, the Labor Department cautions against
reading too much into trends over time found in the compensation
report. But it is still of interest to economists because it
provides specific details on the cost of various types of benefits
not found in other reports.
Write to Eric Morath at eric.morath@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
September 18, 2018 17:17 ET (21:17 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2018 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.