Bank of America to Pay $42 Million to Settle New York AG Probe in Electronic Trading -- Update
March 23 2018 - 2:10PM
Dow Jones News
By Alexander Osipovich and Allison Prang
Bank of America Merrill Lynch will pay $42 million to New York
state to settle allegations that it routed client orders to
high-speed trading firms without telling the customers that it was
routinely doing so.
New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman said Friday that the
bank had secret agreements with certain firms, such as Citadel
Securities and Two Sigma Securities, to send them clients' orders
to buy and sell stocks.
Those agreements were kept concealed from clients over a
five-year period, the attorney general said.
Another one of the firms to which the bank sent orders was
Madoff Securities, the trading firm run by convicted Ponzi-scheme
operator Bernard L. Madoff, Mr. Schneiderman said.
Bank of America applied its "masking" strategy to more than 16
million client orders between 2008 and 2013, representing over 4
billion traded shares, the New York attorney general's office
said.
"Bank of America Merrill Lynch went to astonishing lengths to
defraud its own institutional clients about who was seeing and
filling their orders, who was trading in its dark pool, and the
capabilities of its electronic trading services," Mr. Schneiderman
said.
Bank of America admitted violating the Martin Act, a broad New
York state antifraud statute. A bank spokesman said the settlement
"primarily relates to conduct that occurred as long as 10 years
ago."
"At all times we met our obligation to deliver the best prices
to clients and about five years ago we addressed the issues
concerning communicating to clients about where their trades were
executed," the spokesman said.
Big investors like pension funds are often wary of letting
high-frequency trading, or HFT, firms see their orders, out of fear
that the traders will infer that a large buyer or seller is at work
in the markets. That can cause the speedy trader to adjust its
price quotes in response, resulting in the investor getting a worse
price for its trade.
The settlement order detailed various steps that Bank of America
employees allegedly took to reassure clients that HFT firms weren't
on the other side of their trades. One of them was systematically
changing electronic ID codes that would have revealed the bank to
be routing orders to venues run by high-speed traders, a practice
that was internally called "masking," the order said.
In one February 2013 email exchange cited in the order, an
unnamed bank employee asked colleagues how to respond to a client
who had requested a list of the trading venues where Bank of
America was routing orders. "[B]efore I send, is there anything you
want to streamline or eliminate (i.e. the HFT stuff at the end of
to whom do we route)?" the employee asked, according to the
order.
Later that day, the client received a list from which high-speed
traders had been deleted, the order said.
Bank of America also misled customers about how much trading
activity in its Instinct X dark pool was coming from retail
investors, claiming that retail investors accounted for 20% or 30%
of order flow in the dark pool, when in fact they were only about
5%, the order said.
Dark pools are off-exchange trading venues, often run by Wall
Street banks, in which big investors can attempt to buy or sell
large quantities of shares without tipping off the broader market
about their intentions.
The venues have come under scrutiny in recent years, after
regulators found that some banks had misled customers about the
degree of HFT activity in their dark pools.
In January 2016, Credit Suisse Group AG and Barclays PLC agreed
to pay a combined $154.3 million to the Securities and Exchange
Commission and the New York attorney general to settle
investigations into their dark pools. The Swiss bank neither
admitted nor denied wrongdoing, while Barclays admitted violating
federal securities laws as part of the deal.
Shares of Bank of America were down 2% in midday trading.
Write to Alexander Osipovich at alexander.osipovich@dowjones.com
and Allison Prang at allison.prang@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
March 23, 2018 13:55 ET (17:55 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2018 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
Bank of America (NYSE:BAC)
Historical Stock Chart
From Mar 2024 to Apr 2024
Bank of America (NYSE:BAC)
Historical Stock Chart
From Apr 2023 to Apr 2024