Salesforce Battles Microsoft, LinkedIn -- WSJ
September 30 2016 - 3:03AM
Dow Jones News
By Rachael King
Salesforce.com Inc. said it would press regulators in the U.S.
and Europe to block Microsoft Corp.'s $26.2 billion acquisition of
LinkedIn Corp., arguing the deal would hurt competition by giving
its business-software rival too much control over the
social-networking company's vast pool of data.
Salesforce's public broadside against the deal on Thursday came
three months after it lost a bidding war for LinkedIn to Microsoft.
Both companies' interest in LinkedIn centers on data generated by
its members, who typically maintain career résumés on the site.
LinkedIn claims 450 million members in more than 200 countries,
including 106 million monthly active uses.
Burke Norton, Salesforce's chief legal officer, said owning
LinkedIn would give Microsoft an unfair competitive advantage
because it could block rivals' access to the data on its
membership. He said the deal also raises "data privacy issues" that
Salesforce thinks U.S. and European Union authorities should
scrutinize.
"Microsoft's proposed acquisition of LinkedIn threatens the
future of innovation and competition," Mr. Norton said in a
statement.
Microsoft responded by pointing out that the deal had already
passed regulatory muster in some countries, and that it is
Salesforce, not Microsoft, that dominates the market for software
that handles customer relationship management, or CRM -- a market
in which LinkedIn's data may help Microsoft compete against
Salesforce.
"Salesforce may not be aware, but the deal has already been
cleared to close in the United States, Canada, and Brazil," said
Brad Smith, Microsoft's chief legal officer. "We're committed to
continuing to work to bring price competition to a CRM market in
which Salesforce is the dominant participant charging customers
higher prices today."
Antitrust issues arising from the acquisition of immense data
sets have been raised in technology mergers in both the EU and the
U.S., but no merger has been derailed on those grounds, according
to Michael Carrier, a professor at Rutgers Law School who
specializes in antitrust issues. European regulators examined the
competitive and privacy implications of Google's acquisition of
DoubleClick and Facebook Inc.'s purchase of WhatsApp. The EU
regulators ultimately approved them.
The European Union antitrust watchdog signaled Thursday that big
data will continue to play a role in assessing merger deals. In a
speech, the EU's competition chief, Margrethe Vestager, said she
would "keep a close eye on how companies use that data."
The EU's review of Microsoft's purchase of LinkedIn likely will
focus on whether the professional network's data "has a very long
durability or might constitute a barrier for others," Ms. Vestager
told Bloomberg after the merger was announced.
Salesforce's argument could work against it if the company were
to acquire the social network Twitter Inc., as The Wall Street
Journal and others have reported it is trying to do. Moreover,
Salesforce's contention that Microsoft might deny competitors
access to LinkedIn's data would have applied equally to Salesforce
if it had been successful in its effort to acquire the network.
People familiar with the matter noted that no outside entity
currently has unlimited access to LinkedIn trove of data.
LinkedIn's data is potentially valuable because large data sets
are critical to the development of artificial intelligence, a
technology that both Microsoft and Salesforce have said they are
counting on to drive growth.
Salesforce hasn't filed a formal complaint against Microsoft in
connection with its purchase of LinkedIn, according to people
familiar with the matter. However, the company filled out a
questionnaire sent by the European Commission, which solicits
information from companies potentially affected by mergers and
acquisitions as part of its normal preregistration process.
Microsoft hasn't yet registered the deal with EU authorities.
Nonetheless, Salesforce's announcement of its intention to fight
the deal is an unusually proactive and public stance so early in
the acquisition process. Generally, competitors hold their
opposition until a merger has been registered with regulators.
"We intend to work closely with regulators, lawmakers and other
stakeholders to make the case that this merger is anticompetitive,"
Mr. Norton said.
Salesforce tried to outbid Microsoft for LinkedIn, according to
people familiar with the effort. However, Salesforce continued to
submit bids after Microsoft and LinkedIn entered into an exclusive
deal, according to those people and regulatory filings.
Chief Executive Marc Benioff later sent an email to LinkedIn CEO
Jeff Weiner and LinkedIn Chairman Reid Hoffman after reading a July
1 regulatory filing that detailed events leading up to the deal.
Mr. Benioff wrote in the email that he would have offered a "much
higher" price had LinkedIn continued talks with him after its call
for final offers, according to a July 22 company filing.
--Jay Greene, Natalia Drozdiak and Deepa Seetharaman contributed
to this article.
Write to Rachael King at rachael.king@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
September 30, 2016 02:48 ET (06:48 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2016 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
Microsoft (NASDAQ:MSFT)
Historical Stock Chart
From Mar 2024 to Apr 2024
Microsoft (NASDAQ:MSFT)
Historical Stock Chart
From Apr 2023 to Apr 2024