RISK FACTORS
Investing in our common stock involves a high degree of risk. Before purchasing our common stock, you should
carefully consider each of the following risk factors as well as the other information contained in this prospectus supplement and the accompanying base prospectus and the documents incorporated by
reference, including our consolidated financial statements and the related notes. Each of these risk factors, either alone or taken together, could adversely affect our business, operating results and
financial condition, as well as adversely affect the value of an investment in our common stock. The risks described below are not the only ones we face. Additional risks of which we are not presently
aware or that we currently believe are immaterial which may also impair our business operations and financial position. If any of the events described below were to occur, our financial condition, our
ability to access capital resources, our results of operations and/or our future growth prospects could be materially and adversely affected and the market price of our common stock could decline. As
a result, you could lose some or all of any investment you may have made or may make in our common stock. In assessing these risks, you should also refer to the other information contained or
incorporated by reference in this prospectus.
RISKS RELATED TO OUR BUSINESS
We have historically incurred losses and may continue to incur losses.
Since the inception of our business in 2000, we have only experienced one fiscal year (2006) with profitable results. In order to
regain profitability, or to achieve and sustain positive cash flows from operations in the future, we must reduce operating expenses and/or increase our revenues and gross margins. Although we have in
the past engaged in a series of cost reduction actions, and believe that we could reduce our current level of expenses through elimination or reduction of strategic initiatives, such expense
reductions alone may not make us profitable or allow us to sustain profitability if it is achieved and eliminating or reducing strategic initiatives could limit our opportunities and prospects. Our
ability to achieve profitability will depend on increased revenue growth from, among other things, monetization of our intellectual property, increased demand for our memory subsystems and other
product offerings, as well as our ability to expand into new and emerging markets. We may not be successful in achieving the necessary revenue growth or the expected expense reductions. Moreover, we
may be unable to sustain past or expected future expense reductions in subsequent periods. We may not achieve profitability or sustain such profitability, if achieved, on a quarterly or annual basis
in the future.
Any
failure to achieve profitability could result in increased capital requirements and pressure on our liquidity position. We believe our future capital requirements will depend on many
factors, including our levels of net product sales and any additional NRE or other revenues we may receive, the timing and extent of expenditures to support product sales and marketing, research and
development activities, the expansion of manufacturing capacity both domestically and internationally, market acceptance of our products, intellectual property enforcement activities and strategic
collaborations or other transactions. Our capital requirements could result in our having to, or otherwise choosing to, seek additional funding through public or private equity offerings or debt
financings. Such funding may not be available when needed, on terms acceptable to us or at all, any of which could result in our inability to meet our financial obligations and other related
commitments.
We may not have sufficient working capital to fund our planned operations, and, as a result, we may
need to raise additional capital in the future in order to continue operating our business and developing new products and technologies, which capital may not be available when needed, on acceptable
terms or at all.
We believe that, taking into account our planned activities, we have sufficient cash resources to satisfy our capital needs for at
least the next twelve months. However, our estimates of our operating expenses and working capital requirements could be incorrect, and we may use our cash resources
S-11
Table of Contents
faster
than we presently anticipate. Further, some or all of our ongoing or planned investments may not be successful and could result in further losses. In addition, irrespective of our cash
resources, we may be contractually or legally obligated to make certain investments which cannot be postponed.
Our
capital requirements will depend on many factors, including, among others:
-
-
the acceptance of, and demand for, our products;
-
-
our success and that of our strategic partners in developing and selling products derived from our technology;
-
-
our continued listing on The NASDAQ Capital Market;
-
-
the costs of further developing our existing, and developing new, products or technologies;
-
-
the extent to which we invest in new technology, testing and product development;
-
-
costs associated with defending and enforcing our intellectual property rights;
-
-
the timing of vendor payments and the collection of receivables, among other factors affecting our working capital;
-
-
the exercise of outstanding options or warrants to acquire our common stock;
-
-
the number and timing of acquisitions and other strategic transactions in which we participate, if any; and
-
-
the costs associated with the continued operation, and any future growth, of our business.
We
expect to rely in the near term on funds raised pursuant to this offering and other recent public and private placement offerings of debt and equity securities. However, until we can
generate a sufficient amount of revenue to finance our cash requirements, which we may never do, we may need to increase our liquidity and capital resources by one or more measures, which may include,
among others, reducing operating expenses, restructuring our balance sheet by negotiating with creditors and vendors, entering into strategic partnerships or alliances, raising additional financing
through the
issuance of debt, equity, or convertible securities and working to increase revenue growth through new product sales. There is no guarantee that we will be able to obtain capital when needed, on terms
acceptable to us, or at all.
Insufficient
funds would have a material adverse effect on our business and operations and could cause us to fail to execute our business plan, fail to take advantage of future
opportunities or fail to respond to competitive pressures or customer requirements, and further may require us to significantly modify our business model and/or reduce our operations, which could
include delaying, scaling back or eliminating some or all of our ongoing and planned investments in corporate infrastructure, research and development projects, regulatory submissions, business
development initiatives, and sales and marketing activities, among other investments. Modification of our business model and operations could result in an impairment of assets, the effects of which
cannot be determined. Furthermore, if we continue to issue equity or convertible debt securities to raise additional funds, our existing stockholders may experience significant dilution, and the new
equity or debt securities may have rights, preferences and privileges that are superior to those of our existing stockholders. If we incur additional debt, it may increase our leverage relative to our
earnings or to our equity capitalization.
We have incurred a material amount of indebtedness to fund our operations, the terms of which
require that we pledge substantially all of our assets as security. Our level of indebtedness and the terms of such indebtedness, could adversely affect our operations and liquidity.
We have incurred debt secured by all of our assets under our convertible note with SVIC and our credit facility with Silicon Valley
Bank ("SVB"). Our convertible promissory note issued to SVIC is
S-12
Table of Contents
secured
by a first-priority security interest in our patent portfolio and a second priority security interest in substantially all of our other assets. Our credit facility with SVB is secured by a
first priority security interest in all of our assets other than our patent portfolio, to which SVB has a second priority security interest. The SVIC and SVB debt instruments contain customary
representations, warranties and indemnification provisions, as well as affirmative and negative covenants that, among other things restrict our ability
to:
-
-
incur additional indebtedness or guarantees;
-
-
incur liens;
-
-
make investments, loans and acquisitions;
-
-
consolidate or merge
-
-
sell or exclusively license assets, including capital stock of subsidiaries;
-
-
alter our business;
-
-
change any provision of our organizational documents;
-
-
engage in transactions with affiliates; and
-
-
pay dividends or make distributions.
The
SVIC and SVB debt instruments also include events of default, including, among other things, payment defaults, breaches of representations, warranties or covenants, certain
bankruptcy events, and certain material adverse changes. If we were to default under either debt instrument and were unable to obtain a waiver for such a default, among other remedies, the lenders
could accelerate our obligations under the debt instruments and exercise their rights to foreclose on their security interests, which would cause substantial harm to our business and prospects.
Incurrence
and maintenance of this debt could have material consequences, such as:
-
-
requiring us to dedicate a portion of our cash flow from operations and other capital resources to debt service, thereby reducing our
ability to fund working capital, capital expenditures, and other cash requirements;
-
-
increasing our vulnerability to adverse economic and industry conditions;
-
-
limiting our flexibility in planning for, or reacting to, changes and opportunities in, our business and industry, which may place us
at a competitive disadvantage; and
-
-
limiting our ability to incur additional debt on acceptable terms, if at all.
We are involved in and expect to continue to be involved in costly legal and administrative
proceedings to defend against claims that we infringe the intellectual property rights of others or to enforce or protect our intellectual property rights.
As is common in the semiconductor industry, we have experienced substantial litigation regarding patent and other intellectual property
rights. Lawsuits claiming that we are infringing others' intellectual property rights have been and may in the future be brought against us, and we are currently defending against claims of invalidity
in the USPTO.
The
process of obtaining and protecting patents is inherently uncertain. In addition to the patent issuance process established by law and the procedures of the USPTO, we must comply
with JEDEC administrative procedures in protecting our intellectual property within its industry standard setting process. These procedures evolve over time, are subject to variability in their
application, and may be
S-13
Table of Contents
inconsistent
with each other. Failure to comply with JEDEC's administrative procedures could jeopardize our ability to claim that our patents have been infringed.
By
making use of new technologies and entering new markets there is an increased likelihood that others might allege that our products infringe on their intellectual property rights.
Litigation is inherently uncertain, and an adverse outcome in existing or any future litigation could subject us to significant liability for damages or invalidate our proprietary rights. An adverse
outcome also could force us to take specific actions, including causing us to:
-
-
cease manufacturing and/or selling products, or using certain processes, that are claimed to be infringing a third party's
intellectual property;
-
-
pay damages (which in some instances may be three times actual damages), including royalties on past or future sales;
-
-
seek a license from the third party intellectual property owner to use their technology in our products, which license may not be
available on reasonable terms, or at all; or
-
-
redesign those products that are claimed to be infringing a third party's intellectual property.
If
any adverse ruling in any such matter occurs, any resulting limitations in our ability to market our products, or delays and costs associated with redesigning our products or payments
of license fees to third parties, or any failure by us to develop or license a substitute technology on commercially reasonable terms could have a material adverse effect on our business, financial
condition and results of operations.
There
is a limited pool of experienced technical personnel that we can draw upon to meet our hiring needs. As a result, a number of our existing employees have worked for our existing or
potential competitors at some point during their careers, and we anticipate that a number of our future employees will have similar work histories. In the past, some of these competitors have claimed
that our employees misappropriated their trade secrets or violated non-competition or non-solicitation agreements. Some of our competitors may threaten or bring legal action involving similar claims
against us or our existing employees or make such claims in the future to prevent us from hiring qualified candidates. Lawsuits of this type may be brought, even if there is no merit to the claim,
simply as a strategy to drain our financial resources and divert management's attention away from our business.
Our
business strategy also includes litigating claims against others, including our competitors, customers and former employees, to enforce our intellectual property, contractual and
commercial rights including, in particular, our trade secrets, as well as to challenge the validity and scope of the proprietary rights of others. We could become subject to counterclaims or
countersuits against us as a result of this litigation. Moreover, any legal disputes with customers could cause them to cease buying or using our products or delay their purchase of our products and
could substantially damage our relationship with them.
Any
litigation, regardless of its outcome, would be time consuming and costly to resolve, divert our management's time and attention and negatively impact our results of operations. As a
result, any current or future infringement claims by or against third parties or claims for indemnification by customers or end users of our products resulting from infringement claims could
materially adversely affect our business, financial condition or results of operations.
As
a result of an unfavorable outcome at the PTAB in connection with a decision on appeal in the reexaminations of U.S. Pat. No. 7,619,912 ("'912 Patent"), which covers important
features of DDR3 LRIDIMM designs, and U.S. Pat. No. 7,864,627 ("'627 Patent"), we may expend significant resources to continue to pursue valid positions in the '912 and '627 reexaminations,
which may not be resolved in a timely manner and may not yield a more favorable outcome.
S-14
Table of Contents
We are involved in and expect to continue to be involved in legal proceedings at the ITC to stop
infringing SK hynix RDIMM and LRDIMM products from entering the U.S. and in district court to seek damages for patent infringement against SK hynix.
On September 1, 2016, we took action to safeguard our innovations by filing legal proceedings for patent infringement against SK
hynix in the ITC and the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California. We are seeking an exclusion order in the ITC that directs U.S. Customs and Border Protection to stop infringing SK
hynix RDIMM and LRDIMM products from entering the United States. ITC investigations proceed on an expedited basis, typically advancing to trial within a year from the filing of the complaint and a
final decision issued a few months later, but there can be no guarantee that the rendering of a final decision will follow such a timeline. In the district court proceedings, we are primarily seeking
damages though we expect this action will likely remain stayed until the ITC reaches conclusion.
Intellectual
property litigation is expensive and time-consuming, regardless of the merits of any claim, and could divert our management's attention from operating the business. In
addition, lawsuits in the ITC and in district courts are subject to inherent uncertainties due to the complexity of the technical issues involved, and we cannot be assured that we will be successful
in our actions. Moreover, if we are counter-sued by Sk hynix and lose the suit, we could be required to pay substantial damages. Furthermore, we may not be able to reach a settlement with Sk hynix to
license our patent portfolio on terms acceptable to us, and even if we are able to reach a settlement, the terms of the licensing arrangement may not be as favorable as we anticipated. Any of the
foregoing could cause us to incur significant costs and prevent us from selling our products and materially adversely affect our business, financial condition or results of operations.
Our revenues and results of operations have been substantially dependent on NVvault in historical
periods and we may be unable to replace revenue lost from the rapid decline in NVvault sales.
For the six months ended July 2, 2016 and June 27, 2015, our NVvault non-volatile DIMM used in cache-protection and data
logging applications, including our NVvault battery-free, the flash-based cache system, accounted for approximately 1% and 38% of total net product sales, respectively. We have experienced a steady
decline in NVvault sales in recent years, due in large part to our loss of our former most significant NVvault customer, Dell, beginning in 2012. We recognized no NVvault sales to Dell in the six
months ended July 2, 2016 and June 27, 2015. We expect
no future demand from Dell for our NVvault products. In order to leverage our NVvault technology and diversify our customer base, and to secure one or more new key customers, we continue to pursue
additional qualifications of NVvault with other OEMs and to target new customer applications such as online transaction processing, virtualization, big data analytics, high speed transaction
processing, high-performance database, and in-memory database applications. We also introduced EXPRESSvault in March 2011 and the next generation of EXPRESSvault (EV3) in July 2015 and we continue to
pursue qualification of the next generation DDR4 NVvault with customers. Our future operating results will depend on our ability to commercialize these NVvault product extensions, as well as other
products such as HybriDIMM and other high-density and high-performance solutions. HybriDIMM is still under development and may require substantial additional investment and the services and attention
of key employees who have competing demands on their available time. Although we believe that our JDLA with Samsung entered into in November 2015 may advance the development of this product and that
Samsung may prove to be an important strategic partner that can facilitate getting this technology to market, our partnership with Samsung and any other steps we take to further the development of
this or any other products in development could fail. If we are not be successful in expanding our qualifications or marketing any new or enhanced products, we will be unable to secure revenues
sufficient to replace lost NVvault revenue and our results of operations and prospects could be materially harmed.
S-15
Table of Contents
We are subject to risks relating to our focus on developing our HybriDIMM and NVvault products and
lack of market diversification.
We have historically derived a substantial portion of our net sales from sales of our high-performance memory subsystems for use in the
server market. We expect these memory subsystems to continue to account for a portion of our net sales in the near term. We believe that market acceptance of these products or derivative products that
incorporate our core memory subsystem technology for use in servers is critical to our success.
We
have invested a significant portion of our research and development budget into the design of application-specific integrated circuits ("ASIC") and hybrid devices, including our
NVvault family of products and most recently our next generation HybriDIMM memory subsystem. These products are subject to increased risks as compared to our legacy products. For
example:
-
-
we are dependent on a limited number of suppliers for both the DRAM ICs and the ASIC devices that are essential to the functionality
of our products, and in the past we have experienced supply chain disruptions and shortages of DRAM and NAND flash required to create our NVvault products as a result of business issues that are
specific to our suppliers or the industry as a whole;
-
-
we may be unable to achieve new qualifications or customer or market acceptance of our memory subsystem, NVvault products or other new
products such as HybriDIMM, or achieve such acceptance in a timely manner;
-
-
the NVvault products or other new products such as HybriDIMM may contain currently undiscovered flaws, the correction of which would
result in increased costs and time to market; and
-
-
we are required to demonstrate the quality and reliability of our products to our customers, and are required to qualify these
products with our customers, which requires a significant investment of time and resources prior to the receipt of any revenue from such customers.
Additionally,
if the demand for servers deteriorates or if the demand for our products to be incorporated in servers declines, our operating results would be adversely affected, and we
would be forced to diversify our product portfolio and our target markets. We may not be able to achieve this diversification, and our inability to do so may adversely affect our business.
We use a small number of FPGAs, DRAM ICs and NAND flash suppliers and are subject to risks of
disruption in the supply of FPGAs, DRAM ICs and NAND.
Our ability to fulfill customer orders or produce qualification samples is dependent on a sufficient supply of field-programmable gate
arrays ("FPGAs"), DRAM ICs and NAND flash, which are essential components of our memory subsystems. There are a relatively small number of suppliers of FPGAs, DRAM ICs and NAND flash, and we purchase
from only a subset of these suppliers. We have no long-term FPGA, DRAM or NAND flash supply contracts.
From
time to time, shortages in DRAM ICs and NAND flash have required some suppliers to limit the supply of their DRAM ICs and NAND flash. We have experienced supply chain disruptions
and shortages of DRAM and flash required to create our HyperCloud, NVvault and Planar X VLP products, and we are continually working to secure adequate supplies of DRAM and NAND flash necessary to
fill customers' orders for our products in a timely manner. If we are unable to obtain a sufficient supply of DRAM ICs or NAND flash to meet our customers' requirements, these customers may reduce
future orders for our products or not purchase our products at all, which would cause our net sales to decline and harm our operating results. In addition, our reputation could be harmed and,
S-16
Table of Contents
even
assuming we are successful in resolving supply chain disruptions, we may not be able to replace any lost business with new customers, and we may lose market share to our competitors.
Our
dependence on a small number of suppliers and the lack of any guaranteed sources of FPGAs, DRAM and NAND flash supply expose us to several risks, including the inability to obtain an
adequate supply of these important components, price increases, delivery delays and poor quality.
Historical
declines in customer demand and our revenues caused us to reduce our purchases of DRAM ICs and NAND flash. Such fluctuations could continue in the future. If we fail to
maintain sufficient purchase levels with some suppliers, our ability to obtain supplies of raw materials may be impaired due to the practice of some suppliers to allocate their products to customers
with the highest regular demand.
Our
customers qualify the FPGAs, DRAM ICs and NAND flash of our suppliers for use in their systems. If one of our suppliers should experience quality control problems, it may be
disqualified by one or more of our customers. This would disrupt our supplies of FPGAs, DRAM ICs and NAND flash and reduce the number of suppliers available to us, and may require that we qualify a
new supplier. If our suppliers are unable to produce qualification samples on a timely basis or at all, we could experience delays in the qualification process, which could have a significant impact
on our ability to sell that product.
We may be unsuccessful in establishing and operating a licensing business.
Although we intend to pursue an intellectual property-based licensing business in order to monetize our intellectual property rights,
we are currently operating based on a products-based business model and we may never be successful in developing any licensing business. Although we may pursue an agreement with Samsung in the future
to grant Samsung a commercial license to our NVDIMM-P technology pursuant to the terms of our JDLA with Samsung, we may never successfully enter into any such agreement with Samsung or any other third
party. Further, the terms of any such agreements that we may reach with third party licensees are uncertain and may not provide significant royalty or other licensing revenues to us to justify our
costs of developing and maintaining the licensed intellectual property or may otherwise include terms that are not favorable to us. Additionally, the pursuit of a licensing business would require by
its nature that we relinquish certain of our rights to our technologies and intellectual property that we license to third parties, which could limit our ability to base our own products on such
technologies or could reduce the economic value that we receive from such technologies and intellectual property. Additionally, the establishment of this new business may be more difficult or costly
than expected and require additional personnel, investments and may be a significant distraction for management. In connection with any licensing business we may develop, our licenses and royalty
revenue may be uncertain from period to period and we may be unable to attract sufficient licensing customers, which would materially and adversely affect our results of operations. Our ability to
maintain or increase our license revenue will depend on a variety of factors, including novelty, utility, performance, quality, breadth and depth of our current and future intellectual property and
technology, all as compared to that of our competitors, as well as our sales and marketing capabilities. Once secured, license revenue may be negatively affected by factors within and outside our
control, including reductions in our customers' sales prices, sales volumes and the terms of such license arrangements. If we are not successful in achieving a licensing business, we may never recoup
the costs associated with developing, maintaining, defending and enforcing our intellectual property portfolio and our financial condition would be harmed.
S-17
Table of Contents
We may lose our competitive position if we are unable to timely and cost-effectively develop new or
enhanced products that meet our customers' requirements and achieve market acceptance or technologies that we can monetize through licensing arrangements or otherwise.
Our industry is characterized by intense competition, rapid technological change, evolving industry standards and rapid product
obsolescence. Evolving industry standards and technological change or new, competitive technologies could render our existing products and technologies obsolete. Accordingly, our ability to compete in
the future will depend in large part on our ability to identify and develop new or enhanced products and technologies on a timely and cost-effective basis, and to respond to changing customer
requirements. In order to develop and introduce new or enhanced products and technologies, we need to:
-
-
identify and adjust to the changing requirements of our current and potential customers;
-
-
identify and adapt to emerging technological trends and evolving industry standards in our markets;
-
-
design and introduce cost-effective, innovative and performance-enhancing features that differentiate our products and technologies
from those of our competitors;
-
-
develop relationships with potential suppliers of components required for these new or enhanced products and technologies;
-
-
qualify these products for use in our customers' products; and
-
-
develop and maintain effective marketing strategies.
Our
product development efforts are costly and inherently risky. It is difficult to foresee changes or developments in technology or anticipate the adoption of new standards. Moreover,
once these changes or developments are identified, if at all, we will need to hire the appropriate technical personnel or retain third-party designers, develop the product, identify and eliminate
design flaws, and manufacture the product in production quantities either in-house or through third-party manufacturers. As a result, we may not be able to successfully develop new or enhanced
products or we may experience delays in the development and introduction of new or enhanced products. Delays in product development and introduction could result in the loss of, or delays in
generating, net sales or other revenues and the loss of market share, as well as damage to our reputation. Even if we develop new or enhanced products or technologies, they may not meet our customers'
requirements or gain market acceptance.
Our customers require that our products undergo a lengthy and expensive qualification process
without any assurance of net sales.
Our prospective customers generally make a significant commitment of resources to test and evaluate our memory subsystems prior to
purchasing our products and integrating them into their systems. This extensive qualification process involves rigorous reliability testing and evaluation of our products, which may continue for nine
months or longer and is often subject to delays. In addition to qualification of specific products, some of our customers may also require us to undergo a technology qualification if our product
designs incorporate innovative technologies that the customer has not previously encountered. Such technology qualifications often take substantially longer than product qualifications and can take
over a year to complete. Qualification by a prospective customer does not ensure any sales to that prospective customer. Even after successful qualification and sales of our products to a customer,
changes in our products, our manufacturing facilities, our production processes or our component suppliers may require a new qualification process, which may result in additional delays.
S-18
Table of Contents
In
addition, because the qualification process is both product specific and platform specific, our existing customers sometimes require us to re-qualify our products, or to qualify our
new products, for use in new platforms or applications. For example, as our OEM customers transition from prior generation architectures to current generation architectures, we must design and qualify
new products for use by those customers. In the past, the process of design and qualification has taken up to nine months to complete, during which time our net sales to those customers declined
significantly. After our products are qualified, it can take several months before the customer begins production and we begin to generate net sales from such customer.
Likewise,
when our memory and NAND flash component vendors discontinue production of components, it may be necessary for us to design and qualify new products for our customers. Such
customers may require of us or we may decide to purchase an estimated quantity of discontinued memory components necessary to ensure a steady supply of existing products until products with new
components can be qualified. Purchases of this nature may affect our liquidity. Additionally, our estimation of quantities required during the transition may be incorrect, which could adversely impact
our results of operations through lost revenue opportunities or charges related to excess and obsolete inventory.
We
must devote substantial resources, including design, engineering, sales, marketing and management efforts, to qualify our products with prospective customers in anticipation of sales.
Significant delays in
the qualification process could result in an inability to keep up with rapid technology change or new, competitive technologies. If we delay or do not succeed in qualifying a product with an existing
or prospective customer, we will not be able to sell that product to that customer, which may result in our holding excess and obsolete inventory and harm our operating results and business.
Sales to a limited number of customers represent a significant portion of our net sales and the loss
of, or a significant reduction in sales to, any one of these customers could materially harm our business.
Sales to certain of our OEM customers have historically represented a substantial majority of our net product sales. Approximately 35%
and 12% of our net product sales in the six months ended July 2, 2016 were to two customers, the largest of which was a new customer in 2016. Approximately 27% and 16% of our net product sales
in the six months ended June 27, 2015 were to two customers, the largest of which has purchased few products and contributed only a small portion of our revenues during 2016 to date. The
composition of major customers and their respective contributions to our net product sales have varied and will likely continue to vary from period to period as OEMs progress through the life
cycle of the products they produce and sell. We do not have long-term agreements with any of our customers and, as such, any or all of them could decide at any time to discontinue, decrease or delay
their purchase of our products. In addition, the prices that these customers pay for our products could change at any time. Further, we may not be able to sell some products developed for one customer
to a different customer because our products are often designed to address specific customer requirements, and even if we are able to sell these products to another customer, our margin on such
products may be reduced. Additionally, while we may not be contractually obligated to accept returned products, we may determine that it is in our best interest to accept returns from certain large or
key customers in order to maintain good relations with them, and such additional returns could negatively impact our operating results. Moreover, because a few customers account for a substantial
portion of our net sales, the failure of any one of these customers to pay on a timely basis would negatively impact our cash flow. As a result, the loss of any of our customers, or a significant
reduction in sales to difficulties in collecting payment from any of them, could significantly reduce our net sales and adversely affect our operating results.
Our
ability to maintain or increase our net sales to our key customers depends on a variety of factors, many of which are beyond our control. These factors include our customers'
continued sales of
S-19
Table of Contents
servers
and other computing systems that incorporate our memory subsystems and our customers' continued incorporation of our products into their systems. Because of these and other factors, net sales
to these customers may not continue and the amount of such net sales may not reach or exceed historical levels in any future period.
A limited number of relatively large potential customers dominate the markets for our products.
Our target markets are characterized by a limited number of large companies. Consolidation in one or more of our target markets may
further increase this industry concentration. As a result, we anticipate that sales of our products will continue to be concentrated among a limited number of large customers in the foreseeable
future. We believe that our financial results will depend in significant part on our success in establishing and maintaining relationships with, and effecting substantial sales to, these potential
customers. Even if we establish and successfully maintain these relationships, our financial results will be largely dependent on these customers' sales and business results.
If a standardized memory solution that addresses the demands of our customers is developed, our net
sales and market share may decline.
Many of our memory subsystems are specifically designed for our OEM customers' high-performance systems. In a drive to reduce costs and
assure supply of their memory module demand, our OEM customers may endeavor to design Joint Electron Device Engineering Council ("JEDEC") standard DRAM modules into their new products. Although we
also manufacture JEDEC modules, this trend could reduce the demand for our higher priced customized memory solutions, which would have a negative impact on our financial results. In addition, the
adoption of a JEDEC standard module instead of a previously custom module might allow new competitors to participate in a share of our customers' memory module business that previously belonged to us.
If
our OEM customers were to adopt JEDEC standard modules, our future business may be limited to identifying the next generation of high-performance memory demands of OEM customers and
developing solutions that address such demands. Until fully implemented, any next generation of products may constitute a significantly smaller market, which would reduce our net sales and market
share.
We may not be able to maintain our competitive position because of the intense competition in our
targeted markets.
Our products are primarily targeted for the server, high-performance computing and communications markets. These markets are intensely
competitive, as numerous companies vie for business opportunities at a limited number of large OEMs. We face competition from
DRAM suppliers, memory module providers and logic suppliers for many of our products, including NVvault and HyperCloud. Additionally, if and to the extent we enter new markets or pursue licensing
arrangements to monetize our technologies and intellectual property portfolio, we may face competition from a large number of competitors that produce solutions utilizing similar or competing
technologies.
Some
of our customers and suppliers may have proprietary products or technologies that are competitive with our products, or could develop internal solutions or enter into strategic
relationships with, or acquire, existing high-density memory module providers. Any of these actions could reduce our customers' demand for our products. Some of our significant suppliers of memory
integrated circuits may be able to manufacture competitive products at lower costs by leveraging internal efficiencies, or could choose to reduce our supply of memory integrated circuits, adversely
affecting our ability to manufacture our memory subsystems on a timely basis, if at all.
Certain
of our competitors have substantially greater financial, technical, marketing, distribution and other resources, broader product lines, lower cost structures, greater brand
recognition and longer
S-20
Table of Contents
standing
relationships with customers and suppliers. Some of our competitors may also have a greater ability to influence industry standards than we do, as well as more extensive patent portfolios.
Our
ability to compete in our current target markets and in future markets will depend in large part on our ability to successfully develop, introduce and sell new and enhanced products
or technologies on a timely and cost-effective basis and to respond to changing market requirements. We expect our competitors to continue to improve the performance of their current products, reduce
their prices and introduce new or enhanced technologies that may offer greater performance and improved pricing. If we are unable to match or exceed the improvements made by our competitors, our
market position would deteriorate and our net sales would decline. In addition, our competitors may develop future generations and enhancements of competitive products that may render our technologies
obsolete or uncompetitive.
If we fail to protect our proprietary rights, our customers or our competitors might gain access to
our proprietary designs, processes and technologies, which could adversely affect our operating results.
We rely on a combination of patent protection, trade secret laws and restrictions on disclosure to protect our intellectual property
rights. We have submitted a number of
patent applications regarding our proprietary processes and technology. It is not certain when or if any of the claims in the remaining applications will be allowed. As of July 2, 2016, we had
63 U.S. and foreign patents issued and over 38 pending applications worldwide. We intend to continue filing patent applications with respect to most of the new processes and technologies that we
develop. However, patent protection may not be available for some of these processes or technologies.
It
is possible that our efforts to protect our intellectual property rights may not:
-
-
prevent challenges to, or the invalidation or circumvention of, our existing intellectual property rights;
-
-
prevent our competitors from independently developing similar products or technologies, duplicating our products or technologies or
designing around any patents that may be issued to us;
-
-
prevent disputes with third parties regarding ownership of our intellectual property rights;
-
-
prevent disclosure of our trade secrets and know-how to third parties or into the public domain;
-
-
result in valid patents, including international patents, from any of our pending or future applications; or
-
-
otherwise adequately protect our intellectual property rights.
Others
may attempt to reverse engineer, copy or otherwise obtain and use our proprietary technologies without our consent. Monitoring the unauthorized use of our technologies is
difficult. We cannot be certain that the steps we have taken will prevent the unauthorized use of our technologies. This is particularly true in foreign countries, such as the People's Republic of
China ("PRC"), where we have established a manufacturing facility and where the laws may not protect our proprietary rights to the same extent as applicable U.S. laws.
If
some or all of the claims in our patent applications are not allowed, or if any of our intellectual property protections are limited in scope by the USPTO or our foreign patents being
subjected to invalidation proceedings with their respective authorities, or by a court or circumvented by others, we could face increased competition with regard to our products and be unable to
execute on our strategy of monetizing our intellectual property. Increased competition or an inability to monetize our intellectual property could significantly harm our business, our operating
results and prospects. Currently four of our patents are the subject of
Inter Partes
Reexamination proceedings with the
S-21
Table of Contents
USPTO,
or appeals therefrom, and we cannot assure you that any of these proceedings will result in an outcome favorable to us.
Our operating results may be adversely impacted by worldwide economic and political uncertainties
and specific conditions in the markets we address, including the cyclical nature of and volatility in the memory market and semiconductor industry.
Adverse changes in domestic and global economic and political conditions have made it extremely difficult for our customers, our
vendors and us to accurately forecast and plan future business activities, and these conditions have caused and could continue to cause U.S. and foreign businesses to slow spending on our products and
services, which would further delay and lengthen sales cycles. In addition, sales of our products are dependent upon demand in the computing, networking, communications, printer, storage and
industrial markets. These markets have been cyclical and are characterized by wide fluctuations in product supply and demand. These markets have also experienced significant downturns, often connected
with, or in anticipation of, maturing product cycles, reductions in technology spending and declines in general economic conditions. These downturns have been characterized by diminished product
demand, production overcapacity, high inventory levels and the erosion of average selling prices and may result in reduced willingness of potential licensees to enter into license agreements with us.
We
may experience substantial period-to-period fluctuations in operating results due to factors affecting the computing, networking, communications, printers, storage and industrial
markets. A decline or significant shortfall in demand in any one of these markets could have a material adverse effect on the demand for our products and as a result, our sales would likely decline.
In addition, because many of our costs and operating expenses are relatively fixed, if we are unable to control our expenses adequately in response to reduced sales, our gross margins, operating
income and cash flow would be negatively impacted.
During
challenging economic times our customers may face issues gaining timely access to sufficient credit, which could impair their ability to make timely payments to us. If that were
to occur, we may be required to increase our allowance for doubtful accounts and our ability to timely collect payments would be negatively impacted. Furthermore, our vendors may face similar issues
gaining access to credit, which may limit their ability to supply components or provide trade credit to us. We cannot predict the timing, strength or duration of any economic slowdown or subsequent
economic recovery, either worldwide or in the memory market and related semiconductor industry. If the economy or markets in which we operate do not improve or if conditions worsen, our business,
financial condition and results of operations will likely be materially and adversely affected. Additionally, the combination of our lengthy sales cycle coupled with challenging macroeconomic
conditions could compound the negative impact on the results of our operations.
Our lack of a significant backlog of unfilled orders, and the difficulty inherent in estimating
customer demand, makes it difficult to forecast our short-term production requirements to meet that demand, and any failure to optimally calibrate our production capacity and inventory levels to meet
customer demand could adversely affect our revenues, gross margins and earnings.
We make significant decisions regarding the levels of business that we will seek and accept, production schedules, component
procurement commitments, personnel needs and other resource requirements based on our estimates of customer requirements. We do not have long-term purchase agreements with any of our customers.
Instead, our customers often place purchase orders no more than two weeks in advance of their desired delivery date, and these purchase orders generally have no cancellation or rescheduling penalty
provisions. The short-term nature of commitments by many of our customers, the fact that our customers may cancel or defer purchase orders for any reason, and the possibility of unexpected changes in
demand for our customers' products each reduce our ability to
S-22
Table of Contents
accurately
estimate future customer requirements for our products. This fact, combined with the quick turn-around times that apply to each order, makes it difficult to forecast our production needs
and
allocate production capacity efficiently. As a result, we attempt to forecast the demand for the DRAM ICs, NAND flash and other components needed to manufacture our products, but any such forecasts
could turn out to be wrong. Further, lead times for components vary significantly and depend on various factors, such as the specific supplier and the demand and supply for a component at a given
time.
Our
production expense and component purchase levels are based in part on our forecasts of our customers' future product requirements and to a large extent are fixed in the short term.
As a result, we likely would be unable to adjust spending on a timely basis to compensate for any unexpected shortfall in customer orders. If we overestimate customer demand, we may have excess raw
material inventory of DRAM ICs and NAND flash. If there is a subsequent decline in the prices of DRAM ICs or NAND flash, the value of our inventory will fall. As a result, we may need to write-down
the value of our DRAM IC or NAND flash inventory, which may result in a significant decrease in our gross margin and financial condition. Also, to the extent that we manufacture products in
anticipation of future demand that does not materialize, or in the event a customer cancels or reduces outstanding orders, we could experience an unanticipated increase in our finished goods
inventory. In the past, we have had to write-down inventory due to obsolescence, excess quantities and declines in market value below our costs. Any significant shortfall of customer orders in
relation to our expectations could hurt our operating results, cash flows and financial condition.
Also,
any rapid increases in production required by our customers could strain our resources and reduce our margins. If we underestimate customer demand, we may not have sufficient
inventory of DRAM ICs and NAND flash on hand to manufacture enough product to meet that demand. We also may not have sufficient manufacturing capacity at any given time to meet our customers' demands
for rapid increases in production. These shortages of inventory and capacity would lead to delays in the delivery of our products, and we could forego sales opportunities, lose market share and damage
our customer relationships.
In
addition, we recently agreed to resell certain Samsung products to end customers who Samsung does not reach in their distribution model. This includes small to medium storage
customers, appliance customers, system builders, and cloud and datacenter customers. However, there is no guarantee that there is sufficient demand from end customers for these products, and the lack
of sales of these products may adversely impact our financial conditions and results of operations. Furthermore, these products generally carry lower gross margin than our own products, therefore a
substantial increase in the resale of these products may reduce our overall gross profit margins.
Declines in our average sales prices, driven by volatile prices for DRAM ICs and NAND flash, among
other factors, may result in declines in our revenues and gross profit.
Our industry is competitive and historically has been characterized by declines in average sales price, based in part on the market
price of DRAM ICs and NAND flash, which have historically constituted a substantial portion of the total cost of our memory subsystems.
Our average sales prices may decline due to several factors, including overcapacity in the worldwide supply of DRAM and NAND flash memory components as a result of worldwide economic conditions,
increased manufacturing efficiencies, implementation of new manufacturing processes and expansion of manufacturing capacity by component suppliers.
Once
our prices with a customer are negotiated, we are generally unable to revise pricing with that customer until our next regularly scheduled price adjustment. Consequently, we are
exposed to the risks associated with the volatility of the price of DRAM ICs and NAND flash during that period. If the market prices for DRAM ICs and NAND flash increase, we generally cannot pass the
price increases
S-23
Table of Contents
on
to our customers for products purchased under an existing purchase order. As a result, our cost of sales could increase and our gross margins could decrease. Alternatively, if there are declines in
the price of DRAM ICs and NAND flash, we may need to reduce our selling prices for subsequent purchase orders, which may result in a decline in our expected net sales.
In
addition, since a large percentage of our sales are to a small number of customers that are primarily distributors and large OEMs, these customers have exerted, and we expect they
will continue to exert, pressure on us to make price concessions. If not offset by increases in volume of sales or the sales of newly-developed products with higher margins, decreases in average sales
prices would likely have a material adverse effect on our business and operating results.
If the supply of component materials used to manufacture our products is interrupted or if our
inventory becomes obsolete, our results of operations and financial condition could be adversely affected.
We use consumables and other components, including PCBs to manufacture our memory subsystems. We sometimes procure PCBs and other
components from single or limited sources to take advantage of volume pricing discounts. Material shortages or transportation problems could interrupt the manufacture of our products. These delays in
manufacturing could adversely affect our results of operations.
Frequent
technology changes and the introduction of next-generation products also may result in the obsolescence of other items of inventory, such as our custom-built PCBs, which could
reduce our net sales and gross margin and adversely affect our operating performance and financial condition.
A prolonged disruption of our manufacturing facility could have a material adverse effect on our
business, financial condition and results of operations.
We maintain a manufacturing facility in the PRC for producing most of our products, which allows us to utilize our materials and
processes, protect our intellectual property and develop the technology for manufacturing. A prolonged disruption or material malfunction of, interruption in or the loss of operations at our
manufacturing facility or the failure to maintain a sufficient labor force at such facility could require us to rely on third parties for our manufacturing needs, which generally increases our
manufacturing costs and decreases our profit margins and could limit our capacity to meet customer demand and delay new product development until a replacement facility and equipment, if necessary,
were secured. The replacement of the manufacturing facility could take an extended amount of time before manufacturing operations could restart. The potential delays and costs resulting from these
steps could have a material adverse effect on our business, financial condition and results of operations.
If we are unable to manufacture our products efficiently, our operating results could suffer.
We must continuously review and improve our manufacturing processes in an effort to maintain satisfactory manufacturing yields and
product performance, to lower our costs and to otherwise remain competitive. As we manufacture more complex products, the risk of encountering delays or difficulties increases. The start-up costs
associated with implementing new manufacturing technologies, methods and processes, including the purchase of new equipment, and any resulting manufacturing delays and inefficiencies, could negatively
impact our results of operations.
If
we need to add manufacturing capacity, an expansion of our existing manufacturing facility or establishment of a new facility could be subject to factory audits by our customers. Any
delays or unexpected costs resulting from this audit process could adversely affect our net sales and results of operations. In addition, we cannot be certain that we would be able to increase our
manufacturing capacity on a timely basis or meet the standards of any applicable factory audits.
S-24
Table of Contents
We depend on third-parties to design and manufacture custom components for some of our products.
Significant customized components, such as ASICs, that are used in HyperCloud and some of our other products are designed and
manufactured by third parties. The ability and willingness of such third parties to perform in accordance with their agreements with us is largely outside of our control. If one or more of our design
or manufacturing partners fails to perform its obligations in a timely manner or at satisfactory quality levels, our ability to bring products to market or deliver products to our customers, as well
as our reputation, could suffer. In the event of any such failures, we may have no readily available alternative source of supply for such products, since, in our experience, the lead time needed to
establish a relationship with a new design and/or manufacturing partner is at least 12 months, and the estimated time for our OEM customers to re-qualify our product with components from a new
vendor ranges from four to nine months. If we need to replace one of our manufacturers, we may not be able to redesign, or cause to have redesigned, our customized components to be manufactured by the
new manufacturer in a timely manner, and we could infringe on the intellectual property of our current design or manufacturing partner when we redesign the custom components or cause such components
to be redesigned by the new manufacturer. A manufacturing disruption experienced by our manufacturing partners, the failure of our manufacturing partners to dedicate adequate resources to the
production of our products, the financial instability of our manufacturing or design partners, or any other failure of our design or manufacturing partners to perform according to their agreements
with us would have a material adverse effect on our business, financial condition and results of operations.
We
have many other risks due to our dependence on third-party manufacturers, including: reduced control over delivery schedules, quality, manufacturing yields and cost; the potential
lack of adequate capacity during periods of excess demand; limited warranties on products supplied to us; and potential misappropriation of our intellectual property. We are dependent on our
manufacturing partners to manufacture products with acceptable quality and manufacturing yields, to deliver those products to us on a timely basis and to allocate a portion of their manufacturing
capacity sufficient to meet our needs. Although our products are designed using the process design rules of the particular manufacturers, our manufacturing partners may not be able to achieve or
maintain acceptable yields or deliver sufficient quantities of components on a timely basis or at an acceptable cost. Additionally, our manufacturing partners may not continue to devote adequate
resources to produce our products or continue to advance the process design technologies on which the qualification and manufacturing of our products are based.
If our products do not meet the quality standards of our customers, we may be forced to stop
shipments of products until the quality issues are resolved.
Our customers require our products to meet strict quality standards. Should our products not meet such standards, our customers may
discontinue purchases from us until we are able to resolve the quality issues that are causing us to not meet the standards. Such "quality holds" could have a significant adverse impact on our
revenues and operating results.
If our products are defective or are used in defective systems, we may be subject to warranty,
product recalls or product liability claims.
If our products are defectively manufactured, contain defective components or are used in defective or malfunctioning systems, we could
be subject to warranty and product liability claims and product recalls, safety alerts or advisory notices. While we have product liability insurance coverage, it may not be adequate to satisfy claims
made against us. We also may be unable to obtain insurance in the future at satisfactory rates or in adequate amounts.
S-25
Table of Contents
Although we generally attempt to contractually limit our exposure to incidental and consequential damages, if these contract provisions are not enforced or are
unenforceable or if liabilities arise that are not effectively limited, we could incur substantial costs in defending or settling product liability claims.
Warranty
and product liability claims or product recalls, regardless of their ultimate outcome, could have an adverse effect on our business, financial condition and reputation, and on
our ability to attract and retain customers. In addition, we may determine that it is in our best interest to accept product returns in circumstances where we are not contractually obligated to do so
in order to maintain good relations with our customers. Accepting product returns may negatively impact our operating results.
We may become involved in non-patent related litigation and administrative proceedings that may
materially adversely affect us.
From time to time, we may become involved in various legal proceedings relating to matters incidental to the ordinary course of our
business, including commercial, product liability, employment, class action, whistleblower and other litigation and claims, and governmental and other regulatory investigations and proceedings. Such
matters can be time-consuming, divert management's attention and resources and cause us to incur significant expenses. Furthermore, because litigation is inherently unpredictable, the results of these
actions could have a material adverse effect on our business, results of operations and financial condition.
If we are required to obtain licenses to use third-party intellectual property and we fail to do so,
our business could be harmed.
Although some of the components used in our final products contain the intellectual property of third parties, we believe that our
suppliers bear the sole responsibility to obtain any rights and licenses to such third-party intellectual property. While we have no knowledge that any third-party licensor disputes our belief, we
cannot assure you that disputes will not arise in the future. The operation of our business and our ability to compete successfully depends significantly on our continued operation without claims of
infringement or demands resulting from such claims, including demands for payments of money in the form of, for example, ongoing licensing fees.
We
are also developing new products that we intend to launch in new customer markets. Similar to our current products, we may use components in these new products that contain the
intellectual property of third parties. While we plan to exercise precautions to avoid infringing on the intellectual property rights of third parties, disputes regarding intellectual property
ownership could arise.
If
it is determined that we are required to obtain inbound licenses and we fail to obtain licenses, or if such licenses are not available on economically feasible terms, then we would be
forced to redesign the applicable product without the infringing component, which may be costly or not possible, or we may be forced to cease all manufacture and sales of the applicable product. Any
such outcome would harm our business, operating results and financial condition.
The flash memory market is constantly evolving and competitive, and we may not have rights to
manufacture and sell certain types of products utilizing emerging flash formats, or we may be required to pay a royalty to sell products utilizing these formats.
The flash-based storage market is constantly undergoing rapid technological change and evolving industry standards. Many consumer
devices, such as digital cameras, PDAs and smartphones, are transitioning to emerging flash memory formats, such as the Memory Stick and xD Picture Card formats, which we do not currently manufacture
and do not have rights to manufacture. Although we do not currently serve the consumer flash market, it is possible that certain OEMs may choose to adopt
S-26
Table of Contents
these
higher-volume, lower-cost formats. This could result in a decline in demand, on a relative basis, for other products that we manufacture, such as CompactFlash, SD and embedded USB drives. If we
decide to manufacture flash memory products utilizing emerging formats, we would be required to secure licenses to give us the right to manufacture such products that may not be available at
reasonable rates or at all. If we are not able to supply flash card formats at competitive prices or if we were to have product shortages, our net sales could be adversely impacted and our customers
would likely cancel orders or seek other suppliers to replace us.
Our indemnification obligations for the infringement by our products of the intellectual property
rights of others could require us to pay substantial damages.
As is common in our industry, we have in effect a number of agreements in which we have agreed to defend, indemnify and hold harmless
our customers and suppliers from damages and costs that may arise from the infringement by our products of third-party patents, trademarks or other proprietary rights. The scope of such indemnity
varies, but may, in some instances, include indemnification for damages and expenses, including attorneys' fees. Our insurance does not cover intellectual property infringement. The term of these
indemnification agreements is generally perpetual after execution of the applicable agreement. The maximum potential amount of future payments we could be required to make under these indemnification
agreements is unlimited. We may periodically have to respond to claims and litigate these types of indemnification obligations. Although our suppliers may bear responsibility for the intellectual
property inherent in the components they sell to us, they may lack the financial ability to stand behind such indemnities. Additionally, it may be costly to enforce any indemnifications that they have
granted to us. Accordingly, any indemnification claims by customers could require us to incur significant legal fees and could potentially result in the payment
of substantial damages, either of which could result in a material adverse effect on our business and results of operations.
We depend on a few key employees, and if we lose the services of any of these employees or are
unable to attract and retain other qualified personnel, our business could be harmed.
To date, we have been highly dependent on the experience, relationships and technical knowledge of certain key employees. We believe
that our future success will be dependent on our ability to retain the services of these key employees, develop their successors, reduce our reliance on them, and properly manage the transition of
their roles should departures occur. The loss of these key employees or their inability to provide their services could delay the development and introduction of, and negatively impact our ability to
sell, our products and otherwise harm our business. We do not have employment agreements with any of these key employees other than Chun K. Hong, our President, Chief Executive Officer and Chairman of
the Board. We maintain "Key Man" life insurance on Chun K. Hong; however, we do not carry "Key Man" life insurance on any of our other key employees.
Our
future success also depends on our ability to attract, retain and motivate highly skilled engineering, manufacturing, and other technical and sales personnel. Competition for
experienced personnel is intense. We may not be successful in attracting new engineers or other technical personnel or in retaining or motivating our existing personnel. If we are unable to hire and
retain engineers with the skills necessary to keep pace with the evolving technologies in our markets, our ability to continue to provide our current products and to develop new or enhanced products
will be negatively impacted, which would harm our business. In addition, a general shortage of experienced engineers could lead to increased recruiting, relocation and compensation costs for such
engineers, which may exceed our expectations and resources. These increased costs may make hiring new engineers difficult or may increase our operating expenses.
Historically,
a significant portion of our workforce has consisted of contract personnel. We invest considerable time and expense in training these contract employees. We may experience
high turnover
S-27
Table of Contents
rates
in our contract employee workforce, which may require us to expend additional resources in the future. If we convert any of these contract employees into permanent employees, we may have to pay
finder's fees to the contract agency.
We rely on third-party manufacturers' representatives to sell our products and the failure of these
manufacturers' representatives to perform as expected could reduce our sales.
We sell some of our products to customers through manufacturers' representatives. We are unable to predict the extent to which our
manufacturers' representatives will be successful in marketing and selling our products. Moreover, many of our manufacturers' representatives also market and sell other, potentially competing
products. Our representatives may terminate their relationships with us at any time. Our future performance will also depend, in part, on our ability to attract additional manufacturers'
representatives that will be able to market and support our products effectively, especially in markets in which we have not previously distributed our products. If we cannot retain our current
manufacturers' representatives or recruit additional or replacement manufacturers' representatives, our sales and operating results will be harmed.
Economic, political and other risks associated with international sales and operations expose us to
significant risks.
Since 2009, most of our world-wide manufacturing production has been performed at our manufacturing facility in the PRC. Language and
cultural differences, as well as the geographic distance from our headquarters in Irvine, California, further compound the difficulties of running a manufacturing operation in the PRC. Our management
has limited experience in creating or overseeing foreign operations, and the ongoing management of our PRC facility may require our management team to divert substantial amounts of their time,
particularly if we encounter operational difficulties or manufacturing disruptions at our PRC facility. We may not be able to maintain control over product quality, delivery schedules, manufacturing
yields and costs. Furthermore, the costs related to having excess capacity have in the past and may in the future continue to have an adverse impact on our gross margins and operating results.
We
manage a local workforce that may subject us to regulatory uncertainties. Changes in the labor laws of the PRC could increase the cost of employing the local workforce. The increased
industrialization of the PRC, as well as general economic and political conditions in the PRC, could also increase the price of local labor. Any or all combination of these factors could negatively
impact the cost savings we currently enjoy from having our manufacturing facility in the PRC.
Economic, political and other risks associated with international sales and operations could
adversely affect our net sales.
Part of our growth strategy involves making sales to foreign corporations and delivering our products to facilities located in foreign
countries. To facilitate this process and to meet the long-term projected demand for our products, we have established a manufacturing facility in the PRC, which performs most of our worldwide
manufacturing production. Selling and manufacturing in foreign countries subjects us to additional risks not present with our domestic operations, as we are operating in business and regulatory
environments in which we have limited previous experience. Further, the geographic distance from our headquarters in Irvine, California, compounds the difficulties of running a manufacturing operation
in the PRC. We will need to continue to overcome language and cultural barriers to effectively conduct our operations in these environments. Changes in the labor laws of the PRC could increase the
cost of employing the local workforce. The increased industrialization of the PRC, as well as general economic and political conditions in the PRC, could also increase the price of local labor. Any of
these factors could negatively impact the cost savings we experience from locating our manufacturing facility in the PRC. Our management has limited experience creating or overseeing
S-28
Table of Contents
foreign
operations, and the ongoing management of our PRC facility may require our management team to divert substantial amounts of their time, particularly if we encounter operational difficulties or
manufacturing disruptions at our PRC facility. We may not be able to maintain control over product quality, delivery schedules, manufacturing yields and costs.
In
addition, the economies of the PRC and other countries have been highly volatile in the past, resulting in significant fluctuations in local currencies and other instabilities. These
instabilities affect a number of our customers and suppliers in addition to our own foreign operations.
In
the future, some of our net sales may be denominated in Chinese Renminbi ("RMB"). The Chinese government controls the procedures by which RMB is converted into other currencies, and
conversion of RMB generally requires government consent. As a result, RMB may not be freely convertible into other currencies at all times. If the Chinese government institutes changes in currency
conversion procedures, or imposes restrictions on currency conversion, those actions may negatively impact our operations and could reduce our operating results. In addition, fluctuations in the
exchange rate between RMB and U.S. dollars may adversely affect our expenses and results of operations as well as the value of our assets and liabilities. These fluctuations may also adversely affect
the comparability of our period-to-period results. If we decide to declare dividends and repatriate funds from our Chinese operations, we will be required to comply with the procedures and regulations
of applicable Chinese law. Any changes to these procedures and regulations, or our failure to comply with these procedures and regulations, could prevent us from making dividends and repatriating
funds from our Chinese
operations, which could adversely affect our financial condition. If we are able to make dividends and repatriate funds from our Chinese operations, these dividends would be subject to U.S. corporate
income tax.
International
turmoil and the threat of future terrorist attacks, both domestically and internationally, have contributed to an uncertain political and economic climate, both in the
United States and globally, and have negatively impacted the worldwide economy. The occurrence of one or more of these instabilities could adversely affect our foreign operations and some of our
customers or suppliers, which could adversely affect our net sales. In addition, our failure to meet applicable regulatory requirements or overcome cultural barriers could result in production delays
and increased turn-around times, which would adversely affect our business.
Our
international sales are subject to other risks, including regulatory risks, tariffs and other trade barriers, timing and availability of export licenses, political and economic
instability, difficulties in accounts receivable collections, difficulties in managing distributors, lack of a significant local sales presence, difficulties in obtaining governmental approvals,
compliance with a wide variety of complex foreign laws and treaties and potentially adverse tax consequences. In addition, the United States or foreign countries may implement quotas, duties, taxes or
other charges or restrictions upon the importation or exportation of our products, leading to a reduction in sales and profitability in that country.
Our operations could be disrupted by power outages, natural disasters or other factors.
Due to the geographic concentration of our manufacturing operations in our PRC facility and the operations of certain of our suppliers,
a disruption resulting from equipment failure, power failures, quality control issues, human error, government intervention or natural disasters, including earthquakes and floods, could interrupt or
interfere with our manufacturing operations and consequently harm our business, financial condition and results of operations. Such disruptions would cause significant delays in shipments of our
products and adversely affect our operating results. In July 2014, our PRC facility suffered water damage as a result of heavy rain and floods, which forced us to temporarily halt manufacturing at the
facility while necessary repairs or replacements were made to the facility and to certain of our manufacturing equipment. This incident caused us to incur additional expenses as we
S-29
Table of Contents
shifted
our manufacturing activities to a third-party manufacturing facility in the PRC to enable us to mitigate the disruption in shipments to our customers. While we believe we have contained the
disruptions we expect that our relationships with our key customers could be materially harmed if we incur additional manufacturing disruptions in the future. While we were able to favorably resolve
our claim with our insurance carrier, similar events could occur in the future and, in such event, we may not be able to secure alternative manufacturing capabilities if manufacturing at our PRC
facility is disrupted.
Difficulties with our global information technology systems and/or unauthorized access to such
systems, could harm our business.
Any failure or malfunctioning of our global information technology system, errors or misuse by system users, difficulties in migrating
standalone systems to our centralized systems, or inadequacy of the system in addressing the needs of our operations could disrupt our ability to timely and accurately manufacture and ship products,
which could have a material adverse effect on our business, financial condition and results of operations. Any such failure, errors, misuse or inadequacy could also disrupt our ability to timely and
accurately process, report and evaluate key operations metrics and key components of our results of operations, financial position and cash flows. Any such disruptions would likely divert our
management and key employees' attention away from other business matters. Any disruptions or difficulties that may occur in connection with our global information technology system could also
adversely affect our ability to complete important business process, such as maintenance of our disclosure controls and procedures and evaluation of our internal control over financial reporting and
attestation activities pursuant to Section 404 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002.
In
connection with our daily business transactions, we store data about our business, including certain customer data, on our global information technology systems. While our systems are
designed with security measures to prevent unauthorized access, third parties may gain unauthorized access to our systems. This unauthorized access could be the result of intentional misconduct by
computer hackers, employee error, employee malfeasance or other causes. Additionally, third parties may attempt to fraudulently induce employees or customers into disclosing sensitive information such
as user names, passwords or other information in order to gain access to our information technology system for the purpose of sabotage or to access our data, including our and our customers'
intellectual property and other confidential business information. Because the techniques used to obtain unauthorized access to information technology systems evolve frequently and generally are not
recognized until successful, we may be unable to anticipate these techniques or to implement adequate preventative measures. Any security breach could result in disruption to our business,
misappropriation or loss of data, loss of confidence in us by our customers, damage to our reputation, legal liability and a negative impact on our sales.
Our failure to comply with environmental laws and regulations could subject us to significant fines
and liabilities or cause us to incur significant costs.
We are subject to various and frequently changing U.S. federal, state and local and foreign governmental laws and regulations relating
to the protection of the environment, including those governing the discharge of pollutants into the air and water, the management and disposal of hazardous substances and wastes, the cleanup of
contaminated sites and the maintenance of a safe workplace. In particular, some of our manufacturing processes may require us to handle and dispose of hazardous materials from time to time. For
example, in the past our manufacturing operations have used lead-based solder in the assembly of our products. Today, we use lead-free soldering technologies in our manufacturing processes, as this is
required for products entering the European Union. We could incur substantial costs, including clean-up costs, civil or criminal fines or sanctions and third-party claims for property damage or
personal injury as a result of violations of, or noncompliance with,
S-30
Table of Contents
environmental
laws and regulations. Although we have not incurred significant costs to date to comply with these laws and regulations, new laws or changes to current laws and regulations to make them
more stringent could require us to incur significant costs to remain in compliance.
Regulations related to "conflict minerals" may cause us to incur additional expenses and could limit
the supply and increase the cost of certain metals used in manufacturing our products.
In August 2012, the SEC adopted a rule requiring disclosure of specified minerals, known as conflict materials, that are necessary to
the functionality or production of products manufactured or contracted to be manufactured by public companies. The rule requires companies to verify and disclose whether or not such minerals originate
from the Democratic Republic of Congo or an adjoining country. To comply with this rule, we are required to conduct a reasonable country of origin inquiry each year and, depending on the results of
that inquiry, we may be required to exercise due diligence on the source and chain of custody of conflict minerals contained in our products. Such due diligence must conform to a nationally or
internationally recognized due diligence framework. We are required to file a disclosure report with the SEC in May of each year relating to the preceding calendar year.
The
due diligence activities required to determine the source and chain of custody of minerals contained in our products are time consuming and may result in significant costs. Due to
the size and complexity of our supply chain, we face significant challenges in verifying the origins of the minerals used in our products. Further, this rule could affect the availability in
sufficient quantities and at competitive prices of certain minerals used in the manufacture of our products, including tantalum, tin, gold and tungsten. There may be only limited number of sources of
"conflict-free" minerals, which could result in increased material and component costs, as well as additional costs associated with potential changes to our products, processes or sources of supply.
If
we are unable to sufficiently verify the origin of the minerals used in our products through the due diligence measures that we implement, or if we are unable to obtain an audit
report each year that concludes that our due diligence measures are in conformity with the criteria set forth in the relevant due diligence framework, our reputation could be harmed. In addition, we
may not be able to satisfy customers who require that our products be certified as "conflict-free," which could place us at a competitive disadvantage.
Our internal control over financial reporting may not be effective, which could have a significant
and adverse effect on our business.
Section 404 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 and the related rules and regulations of the SEC, which we collectively refer to
as Section 404, require us to evaluate our internal controls over financial reporting to allow management to report on these internal control as of the end of each year. Effective internal
controls are necessary for us to produce reliable financial reports and are important in our effort to prevent financial fraud. In the course of our Section 404 evaluations, we may identify
conditions that may result in significant deficiencies or material weaknesses and we may conclude that enhancements, modifications or changes to our internal controls are necessary or desirable.
Implementing any such changes would divert the attention of our management, could involve significant costs, and may negatively impact our results of operations.
We
note that there are inherent limitations on the effectiveness of internal controls, as they cannot prevent collusion, management override or failure of human judgment. If we fail to
maintain an effective system of internal controls or if management or our independent registered public accounting firm were to discover material weaknesses in our internal controls, we may be unable
to produce reliable financial reports or prevent fraud, which could harm our financial condition and results of operations, result in a loss of investor confidence and negatively impact our stock
price.
S-31
Table of Contents
If we do not effectively manage any future growth we may experience, our resources, systems and
controls may be strained and our results of operations may suffer.
Any future growth we may experience could strain our resources, management, information and telecommunication systems and operational
and financial controls. To manage future growth effectively, including any expansion of volume in our manufacturing facility in the PRC, we must be able to improve and expand our systems and controls.
We may not be able to do this in a timely or cost-effective manner, and our current systems and controls may not be adequate to support our future operations. In addition, our officers have relatively
limited experience in managing a rapidly growing business. As a result, they may not be able to provide the guidance necessary to manage future growth or maintain future market position. Any failure
to manage any growth we may experience or improve or expand our existing systems and controls, or unexpected difficulties in doing so, could harm our business.
If we acquire businesses or technologies or pursue other strategic transactions in the future, these
transactions could disrupt our business and harm our operating results and financial condition.
We will evaluate opportunities to acquire businesses or technologies or pursue other strategic transactions, including collaboration or
joint development arrangements such as our JDLA with Samsung that might complement our current product offerings or enhance our intellectual property portfolio or technical capabilities. We have no
experience in acquiring other businesses or technologies. Acquisitions and other strategic transactions entail a number of risks that could adversely affect our business and operating results,
including, among others:
-
-
difficulties in integrating the operations, technologies or products of the acquired companies or working with third parties with
which we may partner on joint development or collaboration relationships;
-
-
the diversion of management's time and attention from the normal daily operations of the business;
-
-
insufficient increases in net sales to offset increased expenses associated with acquisitions or strategic transactions;
-
-
difficulties in retaining business relationships with suppliers and customers;
-
-
overestimation of potential synergies or a delay in realizing those synergies;
-
-
entering markets in which we have no or limited experience and in which competitors have stronger market positions; and
-
-
the potential loss of key employees of our or any acquired companies.
Future
acquisitions or other strategic transactions also could cause us to incur debt or be subject to contingent liabilities. In addition, acquisitions could cause us to issue equity or
debt securities that could dilute the ownership interests of our existing stockholders or increase our leverage relative to our earnings or to our equity capitalization. Furthermore, acquisitions or
other strategic transactions may result in material charges or adverse tax consequences, substantial depreciation, deferred compensation charges, in-process research and development charges, the
amortization of amounts related to deferred stock-based compensation expense and identifiable purchased intangible assets or impairment of goodwill, any or all of which could negatively affect our
results of operations.
S-32
Table of Contents
RISKS RELATED TO THIS OFFERING AND OUR COMMON STOCK
You will experience immediate dilution in the book value per share of the common stock you purchase.
Because the price per share of our common stock being offered is substantially higher than the book value per share of our common
stock, you will suffer substantial dilution in the net tangible book value of the common stock you purchase in this offering. If you purchase shares of common stock in this offering, you will suffer
immediate and substantial dilution of $1.58 per share in the net tangible book value of the common stock, based on an assumed offering price of $1.76 per share, the last reported sale price of our
common stock on the NASDAQ Capital Market on September 6, 2016. See the section entitled "Dilution" below for a more detailed discussion of the dilution you will incur if you purchase common
stock in this offering.
Our management will have broad discretion over the use of the net proceeds from this offering.
We currently anticipate using the net proceeds from this offering to accelerate our patent monetization campaign, to commercialize
HybriDIMM, and for general corporate purposes, including working capital and other general and administrative purposes. We have not reserved or allocated specific amounts for any of these purposes and
we cannot specify with certainty how we will use the net proceeds. Accordingly, our management will have considerable discretion in the application of the net proceeds and you will not have the
opportunity, as part of your investment decision, to assess whether the proceeds are being used appropriately. The net proceeds may also be used for corporate purposes that do not increase our
operating results or market value. Until the net proceeds are used, they may be placed in investments that do not produce income or that lose value.
Our results of operations fluctuate significantly and are difficult to predict, and any failure to
meet investor or analyst expectations of our performance could cause the price of our common stock to decline.
Our operating results have varied significantly in the past and will continue to fluctuate from quarter-to-quarter or year-to-year in
the future due to a variety of factors,
many of which are beyond our control. Factors relating to our business that may contribute to these quarterly and annual fluctuations include, among other, those described in the risk factors in this
prospectus. Due to the various factors described herein and others, the results of any prior quarterly or annual periods should not be relied upon as an indication of our future operating performance.
If our quarterly results of operations fall below the expectations of securities analysts or investors, the price of our common stock could decline substantially. As a result of the significant
fluctuations of our operating results in prior periods, period-to-period comparisons of our operating results may not be meaningful and investors in our common stock should not rely on the results of
any one quarter as an indicator of future performance.
Our principal stockholders have significant voting power and may take actions that may not be in the
best interest of our other stockholders.
As of September 6, 2016, approximately 10.91% of our outstanding common stock was held by our affiliates, including 9.74% held
by Chun K. Hong, our Chief Executive Officer and Chairman of our board of directors. As a result, Mr. Hong has the ability to exert substantial influence over all matters requiring approval by
our stockholders, including the election and removal of directors and any proposed merger, consolidation or sale of all or substantially all of our assets and other corporate transactions. This
concentration of control could be disadvantageous to other stockholders with interests different from those of Mr. Hong.
S-33
Table of Contents
Anti-takeover provisions under our charter documents and Delaware law could delay or prevent a
change of control and could also limit the market price of our stock.
Our certificate of incorporation and bylaws contain provisions that could delay or prevent a change of control of our company or
changes in our board of directors that our stockholders might consider favorable. In addition, these provisions could limit the price that investors would be willing to pay in the future for shares of
our common stock. The following are examples of provisions which are included in our certificate of incorporation and bylaws, each as amended:
-
-
our board of directors is authorized, without prior stockholder approval, to designate and issue preferred stock, commonly referred to
as "blank check" preferred stock, with rights senior to those of our common stock;
-
-
stockholder action by written consent is prohibited;
-
-
nominations for election to our board of directors and the submission of matters to be acted upon by stockholders at a meeting are
subject to advance notice requirements; and
-
-
our board of directors is expressly authorized to make, alter or repeal our bylaws.
In
addition, we are governed by the provisions of Section 203 of the Delaware General Corporation Law, which may prohibit certain business combinations with stockholders owning
15% or more of our outstanding voting stock. These and other provisions in our certificate of incorporation and bylaws and of Delaware law could make it more difficult for stockholders or potential
acquirers to obtain control of our board of directors or initiate actions that are opposed by the then-current board of directors, including delaying or impeding a merger, tender offer, or proxy
contest or other change of control transaction involving our company. Any delay or prevention of a change of control transaction or changes in our board of directors could prevent the consummation of
a transaction in which our stockholders could receive a substantial premium over the then-current market price for their shares.
The price of and volume in trading of our common stock has and may continue to fluctuate
significantly.
Our common stock has been publicly traded since November 2006. The price of our common stock and the trading volume of our shares are
volatile and have in the past fluctuated significantly. This volatility could continue and an active trading market in our common stock may never develop or be sustained. The market price at which our
common stock trades may be influenced by many factors, including, among others, the following:
-
-
our operating and financial performance and prospects, including our ability to achieve and sustain profitability in the future;
-
-
the financial projections we may provide to the public, any changes in these projections or our failure to meet these projections;
-
-
investor perception of us and the industry in which we operate;
-
-
the availability and level of research coverage of and market making in our common stock;
-
-
changes in earnings estimates or buy/sell recommendations by analysts;
-
-
announcement of significant partnership arrangement or legal proceedings, including patent infringement actions;
-
-
sales of our newly issued common stock or other securities associated with our shelf registration statement;
-
-
general financial and other market conditions; and
-
-
changing and recently volatile domestic and international economic conditions.
S-34
Table of Contents
In
addition, shares of our common stock and the public stock markets in general, have experienced, and may continue to experience, extreme price and trading volume volatility. These
fluctuations may adversely affect the market price of our common stock and a stockholder's ability to sell their shares into the market at the desired time or at the desired price.
In
2007, following a drop in the market price of our common stock, securities litigation was initiated against us. Given the historic volatility of our industry, we may become engaged in
this type of litigation in the future. Securities litigation, like other types of litigation that are discussed below is expensive and time-consuming and could subject us to unfavorable results.
We do not currently intend to pay dividends on our common stock, and any return to investors is
expected to come, if at all, only from potential increases in the price of our common stock.
We intend to use all available funds to finance our operations. Accordingly, while payment of dividends rests within the discretion of
our board of directors, no cash dividends on our common shares have been declared or paid by us in the past and we have no intention of paying any such dividends in the foreseeable future. Any return
to investors is expected to come, if at all, only from potential increases in the price of our common stock.
We may not be able to maintain our NASDAQ listing.
During 2015 and into early 2016, we experienced periods in which we were not compliant with the continued listing standards of The
NASDAQ Global Market. As a result of a compliance process, we transferred the listing of our common stock from The NASDAQ Global
Market tier to The NASDAQ Capital Market. On February 10, 2016, we received a compliance letter from The NASDAQ Stock Market notifying us that we had regained compliance with the applicable
requirements for continued listing on The NASDAQ Stock Market. Our common stock continues to trade on The NASDAQ Capital Market tier under the symbol "NLST." Notwithstanding our current compliance, we
may not be able to continue to comply with the applicable continued listing standards of The NASDAQ Capital Market. If we are delisted from The NASDAQ Capital Market, the liquidity of our common stock
may be impaired, which could reduce the trading value of our common stock.
S-35
Table of Contents