New York City Moves to Restrict Panhandlers in Times Square
April 08 2016 - 1:20AM
Dow Jones News
The New York City Council approved a bill Thursday that
supporters hope will bring order to Times Square, curbing
aggressive panhandling that has been at the center of a yearslong
political and cultural tug of war.
The measure comes after complaints jumped last summer about the
growing ranks of costumed characters and topless women who seek
tips from tourists in exchange for posing in photographs.
"They get into fights with each other. They grope people and
they get arrested for assault and battery at an increasing rate,"
Councilman Daniel Garodnick said.
The legislation gives the city Department of Transportation the
power to restrict the panhandlers—and more conventional users of
Time Square—to defined zones across the bustling plaza.
The council acted as a small group of costumed panhandlers sat
in the balcony and looked on. All were disappointed, and at least
one was defiant. Abdel Amine Elkhezzani, dressed as Spider-Man,
said the bill would put him and others out of business.
"I won't be placed in a zone," said Mr. Elkhezzani, 37 years
old. "I'll be the first one arrested."
The transportation department now has the job creating the
so-called special commercial zones. A report compiled last fall by
Manhattan elected officials, community-board members and Times
Square business owners suggested the area be divided into three
legally-defined public spaces.
One would have so-called civic zones for free-speech activities,
approved concessions and permitted events. A second space would
accommodate those soliciting passersby. A third zone would allow
the free flow of pedestrians.
The measure grew out of a task force created by New York City
Mayor Bill de Blasio. Some panhandlers dressed up as children's
cartoon characters and others had been arrested for aggressive
behavior, including assault.
Mr. de Blasio said last summer the tip-seekers should be
regulated. He also initiated a crackdown on aggressive
behavior.
"The women in Times Square, or the furry creatures in Times
Square, are engaged in a business," he said in August. "I believe
that opens the door for us to enforce the way we would with any
other business."
A succession of New York mayors has worked to put their imprints
on Times Square, where more than 300,000 tourists now visit
daily.
Former Mayor Ed Koch used eminent domain to help rid it of peep
shows; David Dinkins wooed companies such as Walt Disney Co. to
move into the plaza, a transformative effort Rudolph Giuliani
continued. Michael Bloomberg made the area into a pedestrian plaza,
complete with movable tables and chairs, by rerouting Midtown
traffic.
Mr. de Blasio sought to make his mark last summer after women,
some wearing little other than body paint, began posing with
tourists for tips. It is legal for women to be topless in New York
City.
"As a human being and a parent, I don't think it's appropriate
in the middle of one of the busiest squares in New York City that
women should display themselves that way," he said in August.
The bill wasn't aimed at the topless women, said Councilman
Corey Johnson, a Manhattan Democrat and co-sponsor of the measure.
"They can be topless anywhere they want in public," Mr. Johnson
said. "And this bill does not seek to limit that in any way."
Tim Tompkins, president of the Times Square Alliance, which
backed the measure, said the area is an economic engine for the
city. "If people repeatedly have negative experiences that are
literally repeated with billions of media impressions then that
hurts the tourism economy," he said.
The council voted 42-1 for the bill. Five members abstained.
"The council's legislation goes a long way toward making the
experience better and more enjoyable for New Yorkers and tourists
alike," said a spokeswoman for the mayor. Mr. de Blasio is expected
to sign the legislation by the end of May.
Councilman Robert Cornegy, who voted against the bill, said city
government shouldn't make it more difficult for low-wage workers to
make ends meet. "Don't knock the hustle," he said.
Write to Mara Gay at mara.gay@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
April 08, 2016 01:05 ET (05:05 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2016 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
Walt Disney (NYSE:DIS)
Historical Stock Chart
From Mar 2024 to Apr 2024
Walt Disney (NYSE:DIS)
Historical Stock Chart
From Apr 2023 to Apr 2024