By Tom Fairless
BRUSSELS--A cache of secret tax documents released Tuesday shed
further light on how Luxembourg has helped multinational companies
to lower their tax bills, in a second major leak that could
intensify pressure on the Grand Duchy to alter its tax
practices.
The latest documents, disclosed by the Washington-based
International Consortium of Investigative Journalists at late
evening local time in Brussels, show how 35 major companies,
including Walt Disney Co. and Koch Industries Inc., used complex
financial structures to funnel profits through subsidiaries in
Luxembourg, potentially avoiding taxes in other jurisdictions.
In a statement Wednesday, Luxembourg's finance ministry said tax
avoidance by multinational companies couldn't be blamed on one
country alone, and criticized the "highly questionable" way in
which the documents were acquired.
"Luxembourg agrees that the legitimacy of certain mechanisms,
which are compliant with international and national law, can be put
in doubt from an ethical point of view," the ministry said. "The
analysis of this situation calls for a broad perspective, and
cannot be limited to one country's regulatory framework."
One Disney subsidiary reported a pretax profit in Luxembourg of
more than EUR1 billion ($1.2 billion) over four years, but it paid
just EUR2.8 million of tax, according to the ICIJ, a tax rate of
about 0.25%.
A spokeswoman for Disney called the disclosures "deliberately
misleading, " adding that "Disney's global tax rate has averaged
34% over the past five years." She said the Luxembourg arrangement
hadn't "meaningfully affected the taxes we pay in any jurisdiction
globally."
The ICIJ said the centerpiece of privately held Koch's tax
arrangements was an internal bank called Arteva Europe, which
managed the cash flows of the conglomerate's European operations
through Luxembourg. A Koch subsidiary paid $6.4 million in taxes on
$269 million in profits from 2010 through 2013, the group said.
Koch representatives couldn't be reached for comment.
The disclosures come amid a determined push by governments,
particularly in Europe, to put an end to financial maneuvers that
allow multinational companies to shift profits to tax havens from
the higher-tax jurisdictions in which they are earned. But previous
efforts to curb tax avoidance and evasion have made painfully slow
progress, in part because all European Union governments must sign
off on changes to the bloc's tax legislation.
The first set of leaked Luxembourg tax documents, published a
month ago, revealed details of deals negotiated by accounting firm
PricewaterhouseCoopers for more than 340 of the world's biggest
companies, including package-delivery company FedEx Corp. and
food-and-beverage giant PepsiCo Inc.
At the time FedEx and PepsiCo defended their practices, saying
they did nothing improper.
The latest batch of documents show that the other so-called "Big
Four" accounting firms--Ernst & Young, Deloitte and
KPMG--negotiated similarly aggressive tax deals in the Grand
Duchy.
Other companies that appear this time include Hong Kong-based
conglomerate Hutchison Whampoa Ltd.
Ernst & Young and PwC both said their tax advice was in
accordance with applicable laws, and that they couldn't comment on
individual cases because of client confidentiality. PwC said the
reports on its tax advice were "based on partial, incomplete
information, which was illegally obtained." Deloitte and KPMG
couldn't be reached.
At issue are advance tax agreements, or so-called comfort
letters, from Luxembourg authorities that provide certainty to
companies about how much tax they must pay. Such deals are legal
provided they don't offer special treatment to some companies and
not others.
The European Commission, the EU's executive arm, in recent
months has opened investigations into tax deals struck by four
multinational companies that it says received special treatment--
Apple Inc. in Ireland, Amazon.com Inc. and Fiat SpA in Luxembourg,
and Starbucks Corp. in the Netherlands. Those companies have denied
receiving special treatment.
The latest leak is likely to put fresh pressure on recently
appointed European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker, who
was Luxembourg's prime minister when most of these agreements were
struck.
Mr. Juncker survived a no-confidence vote by the European
Parliament last month over his involvement in Luxembourg's
controversial tax practices after the two main political blocs
stood behind him.
"By continuing to do pretty much nothing, European leaders seem
content to allow billions in tax revenue to slip through their
fingers," said Natalia Alonso, a deputy director of campaigns at
the humanitarian group Oxfam, which lobbies against tax avoidance.
"Europe cannot wait any longer."
The EU's new competition commissioner, Margrethe Vestager has
said she would pursue the tax investigations as a matter of
priority. Her role it is to scrutinize tax deals that are deemed to
represent government aid that favors some companies over their
rivals.
Ms. Vestager said last month that she considered the first batch
of Luxembourg documents as "market information" that she could
potentially use to launch further probes.
Mr. Juncker, who also served as Luxembourg's finance minister
for two decades, has played down his role in overseeing
Luxembourg's tax system. "The tax administration doesn't have to
report to the finance minister," he said in November.
Write to Tom Fairless at tom.fairless@wsj.com
Access Investor Kit for Hutchison Whampoa Ltd.
Visit
http://www.companyspotlight.com/partner?cp_code=P479&isin=HK0013000119
Access Investor Kit for The Walt Disney Co.
Visit
http://www.companyspotlight.com/partner?cp_code=P479&isin=US2546871060
Access Investor Kit for FedEx Corp.
Visit
http://www.companyspotlight.com/partner?cp_code=P479&isin=US31428X1063
Access Investor Kit for Hutchison Whampoa Ltd.
Visit
http://www.companyspotlight.com/partner?cp_code=P479&isin=US4484152081
Access Investor Kit for PepsiCo, Inc.
Visit
http://www.companyspotlight.com/partner?cp_code=P479&isin=US7134481081
Subscribe to WSJ: http://online.wsj.com?mod=djnwires